This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by cryrst
And you constantly don’t read what I post. I have never denied climate change is happening, ever. My argument is how much is man made and how much is the earths doing, you know natural which would happen even if we were not here. If some of these scientists and governments had the bollox to tell us they know the kick back from most would be a WTF moment as ours is tiny. On the other hand if the earth is in imminent mortal danger from our carbon output and the only way to save it is to reduce drastically and quickly why do we have to pay. Surely money is pretty useless if you haven’t got a planet to spend it on. Do you understand why I’m cynical and I repeat all the models we are shown are worst case scenarios. Not the best or the mean or even the median, just the worst so f*** the dolphins Exactly.
hats off to palace, they were always gonna be louder, and hate to say it but they were impressive ALL bouncing and singing. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
It’s both our aging populations and the lower birthrate which is the issue. You cannot separate them, as they both contribute. For sure the Earth’s resources are ultimately finite but we are a very long way from needing to be overly concerned. New sources and more efficient methods of extraction are being found. New ways to use old materials are being discovered and previously disregarded materials being used. We are also recycling much more than in the past. Making sure that the third world get enough does not mean that we won’t or that our living standards will decline. The human race is pretty smart at finding ways. Things will continue to change, as they always have. Just at increased pace. That’s inevitable and should be embraced rather than imitating Canute. Our governments exist to serve us, but not be dictated to by us. This idea that they serve the “super rich” is nonsense. The super rich exist and can find ways around the controls of individual governments, but that doesn’t mean policy is designed for them. Ah yes. Everything will just magically work out. Your golden age will never arrive. At least, not for the vast majority of us. By the way. Canute did not think he could command the sea. It was the exact opposite. It was his subjects who foolishly thought he could. You know. The sort of dumbasses who believe in magic.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
And you constantly don’t read what I post. I have never denied climate change is happening, ever. My argument is how much is man made and how much is the earths doing, you know natural which would happen even if we were not here. If some of these scientists and governments had the bollox to tell us they know the kick back from most would be a WTF moment as ours is tiny. On the other hand if the earth is in imminent mortal danger from our carbon output and the only way to save it is to reduce drastically and quickly why do we have to pay. Surely money is pretty useless if you haven’t got a planet to spend it on. Do you understand why I’m cynical and I repeat all the models we are shown are worst case scenarios. Not the best or the mean or even the median, just the worst so f*** the dolphins OK, I should have precessed climate change with “man made”. For that I apologise. However everything else I said remains true. The contribution of natural climate change is well understood and takes place over much longer time periods. Always many centuries and often thousands of years. During which time we have been able to adjust and move. Man made has all occurred since the Industrial Revolution and there are vastly increased numbers of us now. Of course we look at worst case scenarios! Do you think they must be ignored? We must prepare for the worst, expect the median and hope for the best. Right now it’s looking as though the worst will be exceeded. Edited by Wisbech Eagle (14 Jul 2024 8.24am)
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Ah yes. Everything will just magically work out. Your golden age will never arrive. At least, not for the vast majority of us. By the way. Canute did not think he could command the sea. It was the exact opposite. It was his subjects who foolishly thought he could. You know. The sort of dumbasses who believe in magic. No magic, nor a golden age. Just a different one. Not involving us, but our children’s children who will wonder what on earth grandad was getting in a strop about. Just as we did with ours over some of their attitudes. They might though get cross about us being selfish and not tackling climate change because we didn’t want our cozy lifestyles disrupted.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
OK, I should have precessed climate change with “man made”. For that I apologise. However everything else I said remains true. The contribution of natural climate change is well understood and takes place over much longer time periods. Always many centuries and often thousands of years. During which time we have been able to adjust and move. Man made has all occurred since the Industrial Revolution and there are vastly increased numbers of us now. Of course we look at worst case scenarios! Do you think they must be ignored? We must prepare for the worst, expect the median and hope for the best. Right now it’s looking as though the worst will be exceeded. Edited by Wisbech Eagle (14 Jul 2024 8.24am) Ok then I accept your very rare acceptance of making a mistake and again ask why the % of natural to man made is never given. Some of these scientists must have calculated it so where are the figures. Probably tucked away with the instructions on a water driven car! Edited by cryrst (16 Jul 2024 10.14pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Ok then I accept your very rare acceptance of making a mistake and again ask why the % of natural to man made is never given. Some of these scientists must have calculated it so where are the figures. Probably tucked away with the instructions on a water driven car! Edited by cryrst (16 Jul 2024 10.14pm) Is there any other field of science where you feel you have a better grasp on the data and what is happening than the near-unanimous view of the scientific community? Or is it specific to climate change?
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Is there any other field of science where you feel you have a better grasp on the data and what is happening than the near-unanimous view of the scientific community? Or is it specific to climate change? I’m asking a question about how much humans create compared to natural. Don’t you think that’s logical before we are all forced back into caves; and on the answers I may have a different opinion. Your opinion isn’t necessarily more accurate or correct than mine so are you a scientist alongside all the other skills you have !
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Is there any other field of science where you feel you have a better grasp on the data and what is happening than the near-unanimous view of the scientific community? Or is it specific to climate change? Oh and FYI gas is one of if not the cleanest fossil fuel. I know that !
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
I’m asking a question about how much humans create compared to natural. Don’t you think that’s logical before we are all forced back into caves; and on the answers I may have a different opinion. Your opinion isn’t necessarily more accurate or correct than mine so are you a scientist alongside all the other skills you have ! I'm not offering an opinion - I don't pretend you can just scratch your arse and decide an 'opinion' on a complicated science. I listen to people who are qualified to offer an opinion on these topics - their opinion is absolutely more accurate and correct than yours, yes. Again, are there any other scientific fields where you feel you know better than the people who study it, or just this one?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Climate change hysteria is very much a middle class and above phenomenon. They can afford the implications. I detect a lot of narcissism and general hubris within that movement. When you see the protests it's always the same kind of white liberal activists...mostly women or effeminate men. They largely ignore the tiny affect that the British isles has towards any climate change and instead insist that we become an example to the world in general and lead the way. Because in truth it's far less about any real affect it would have and has more to do with their saviour complex. Again, these people are a minority within the country who bully and dictate to others who never had anything to do with how we got here. It's an often made observation but the real 'polluters' aren't here but in China/India/US. If they were serious about tackling the issue they would direct all their resources into movements there. But again, that would mean they didn't get to display and virtue signal here....They say they want to save the earth, but that obviously doesn't mean moving to the countries where that change would be required. Pious, but not that pious. Not a fan of this take - who partakes in the public protest is hardly relevant to the issue - yes, wealthier demographics can afford to worry about bigger picture issues like this more than the poor can, and have the free time to engage with it - I'm not sure what that proves. Absolutely there are a tremendous amount of 'virtue signallers' in green movements, as you'll find in all moral causes - again, that does nothing to change the reality of what is actually happening. I think it's pretty obvious why someone in the UK focuses their efforts on UK policy - the idea that unless you're willing to relocate to India or China, you must not really care about this, is really weak.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Not a fan of this take - who partakes in the public protest is hardly relevant to the issue - yes, wealthier demographics can afford to worry about bigger picture issues like this more than the poor can, and have the free time to engage with it - I'm not sure what that proves. Absolutely there are a tremendous amount of 'virtue signallers' in green movements, as you'll find in all moral causes - again, that does nothing to change the reality of what is actually happening. I think it's pretty obvious why someone in the UK focuses their efforts on UK policy - the idea that unless you're willing to relocate to India or China, you must not really care about this, is really weak.
I'd argue against this. I think those who partake in such issues, and the manner in which they do so, is of high importance. Whether it be people with quite literally nothing better to do, narcissistically hijacking the green movement for some attention and feeling of importance in the world, or perhaps as an example a halfwit mob following Tommy Robinson around, they obfuscate sensible discussion and therefore conclusions drawn by the populous. With the green issue, it has become a political dog whistle, a fashionable hobby for the wealthy and an outlet for failures to equally attach themselves to. If people are ever going to engage with that which they're 'being told to do', they have to have some faith in the source of the sermon. Malnourished, unemployed malcontents, the wealthy or indeed politicians are not high up on the relatability and trust chart for the masses. Most will immediately just refuse to participate or engage, I'd suggest.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
I'd argue against this. I think those who partake in such issues, and the manner in which they do so, is of high importance. Whether it be people with quite literally nothing better to do, narcissistically hijacking the green movement for some attention and feeling of importance in the world, or perhaps as an example a halfwit mob following Tommy Robinson around, they obfuscate sensible discussion and therefore conclusions drawn by the populous. With the green issue, it has become a political dog whistle, a fashionable hobby for the wealthy and an outlet for failures to equally attach themselves to. If people are ever going to engage with that which they're 'being told to do', they have to have some faith in the source of the sermon. Malnourished, unemployed malcontents, the wealthy or indeed politicians are not high up on the relatability and trust chart for the masses. Most will immediately just refuse to participate or engage, I'd suggest. I don't really agree - it all just feels a bit shallow and more concerned with stereotyping than anything to do with the actual issue. The green movement tried the 'sensible' approach for decades and were mostly ignored. The political party have just performed very well at the GE which has been largely ignored by the media and political class. For all the talk of how much everyone hates ER and Just Stop Oil and the protests, these are movements which continue to gather support and momentum.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Not a fan of this take - who partakes in the public protest is hardly relevant to the issue - yes, wealthier demographics can afford to worry about bigger picture issues like this more than the poor can, and have the free time to engage with it - I'm not sure what that proves. Well, what I said it proves, it's a luxury belief (meaning they can afford the implications) that is more about virtue signalling and hubris than any practical effect on the world. There main affect is in the disruption of the lives of the poor and in insults to icons of cultural heritage for media exposure. It's very annoying. Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Absolutely there are a tremendous amount of 'virtue signallers' in green movements, as you'll find in all moral causes - again, that does nothing to change the reality of what is actually happening. Fair. Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
I think it's pretty obvious why someone in the UK focuses their efforts on UK policy - the idea that unless you're willing to relocate to India or China, you must not really care about this, is really weak. I disagree, the missionaries really believed in their cause and did exactly this all around the world.....frequently dying to, in their view, to save the souls of others. Real commitment that puts cause before ego. What you describe is purely a financial inconvenience, when there are definitely many, within a mainly middle class movement, who could actually afford it. Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
I think your line about being 'bullied and dictated to' is telling as to the real reason people resist a lot of green movements - they don't like being told what to do. Well yes, and if you accept all the climate change priors then there is also the practical situation of where the real pollution is happening and that illustrates where the real battle lies....and thus the anger with action here amongst the practically powerless. Edited by Stirlingsays (17 Jul 2024 11.12am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
Hopefully the King's Speech will have enough Tory policy to have the Corbynistas tearing their hair out. I expect is to be very Blairite, so we can expect an illegal war soon Blair's social policies, censorship and immigration near ruined the country when in office. But he won't be satisfied until he finishes it off.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
I don't really agree - it all just feels a bit shallow and more concerned with stereotyping than anything to do with the actual issue. The green movement tried the 'sensible' approach for decades and were mostly ignored. For all the talk of how much everyone hates ER and Just Stop Oil and the protests, these are movements which continue to gather support and momentum. Hardly.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Edited by Stirlingsays (17 Jul 2024 11.11am) Disagree re 'luxury belief' - it's about being able to 'afford' to take a long-term view on something which will not yield any immediate successes. Their main affect is continuing to grow a political movement and influence policy. You can't really believe that in order to truly support a cause you must be willing to relocate your whole life and die for it? It's a criteria near every movement in history would fail.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
I don't really agree - it all just feels a bit shallow and more concerned with stereotyping than anything to do with the actual issue. The green movement tried the 'sensible' approach for decades and were mostly ignored. The political party have just performed very well at the GE which has been largely ignored by the media and political class. For all the talk of how much everyone hates ER and Just Stop Oil and the protests, these are movements which continue to gather support and momentum. That is the point to which I am drawn, hence I used the word 'obfuscate' (ooh la la!). I'm quite ignorant of any 'sensible approach' so if there has been one and it's failed, point taken. However, I do not see the current approach as effective. The population, at large, will work off stereotypes. The stereotypes that exist around the green approach for me do therefore dilute and distort any message, regardless of the actual issue at hand.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.