This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Willo
Ms Truss has only been PM since 6 September, accordingly it might be better advised to wait for the 'Hour glass' to flow further before forming a judgement. The passage of time might formulate a negative impression in my mind about her Premiership but at present I will allow events to unfold over a period of time before being judgemental. Two years is a protracted time in politics and I for one do not believe that electoral defeat for my party is an inevitability. Edited by Willo (10 Oct 2022 11.09am) Were you the captain of the Titanic in a past life? When you get warnings that your ship is going to sink unless you change direction immediately, you don't give the one holding the wheel more time. The MPs need to act now. Your lot need to tell them to do it and that you have made a mistake.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Were you the captain of the Titanic in a past life? When you get warnings that your ship is going to sink unless you change direction immediately, you don't give the one holding the wheel more time. The MPs need to act now. Your lot need to tell them to do it and that you have made a mistake. So what exactly did liz truss do wrong which she hasn’t put right. The 45% tax reduction hasn’t happened. A 1 p tax reduction for everyone and 1.25% NI hike has been stopped for everyone. So all who pay tax and NI are better off. So again what has she done so wrong in 6 weeks?
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
So what exactly did liz truss do wrong which she hasn’t put right. The 45% tax reduction hasn’t happened. A 1 p tax reduction for everyone and 1.25% NI hike has been stopped for everyone. So all who pay tax and NI are better off. So again what has she done so wrong in 6 weeks? That's because all those who pay tax and NI will not be better off! Tax cuts are no use at all if your costs exceed the benefit because of interest rates and inflation. Announcing tax cuts without any kind of detail on how they will be funded was bad enough. Knowing that money doesn't grow on trees and the 2+2 always equals 4 was enough for the markets to react as they did. This was a very, very stupid own goal. One that was not only completely avoidable but predicted. It's ideology dominating reason and common sense. These measures will have to be reversed, preferably sooner rather than austerity forcing it later. The only way this government can survive is to accept that it has made a mistake. Nothing in it's behaviour so far suggests it will, so now it's down to our MPs. This is a big test for them.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
So again what has she done so wrong in 6 weeks? Junked the country's creditworthiness resulting in higher mortgage rates which will probably end up with thousands of people who can no longer afford their mortgage payments to be made homeless. Completely misjudged the mood of the country and her own party. Managed to find someone more right wing than Pritti Patel to be Home Secretary. Excluded capable people from government if they hadn't backed her in the leadership election even going so far as to tell them that was the reason for them being replaced
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
Junked the country's creditworthiness resulting in higher mortgage rates which will probably end up with thousands of people who can no longer afford their mortgage payments to be made homeless. Completely misjudged the mood of the country and her own party. Managed to find someone more right wing than Pritti Patel to be Home Secretary. Excluded capable people from government if they hadn't backed her in the leadership election even going so far as to tell them that was the reason for them being replaced Higher mortgage rates are inevitable if you leave a fixed term. Many are in that position. You are aware that the whole world is in the middle of f***ed up city . Com atm. It’s not just little old UK. Some though reckon changing the PM will make it better.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
Junked the country's creditworthiness resulting in higher mortgage rates which will probably end up with thousands of people who can no longer afford their mortgage payments to be made homeless. Completely misjudged the mood of the country and her own party. Managed to find someone more right wing than Pritti Patel to be Home Secretary. Excluded capable people from government if they hadn't backed her in the leadership election even going so far as to tell them that was the reason for them being replaced The speech at Conference really resonated with me and many others, in fact I found I was nodding in agreement with every jot and tittle.The delivery was eloquent,cerebral and passionate.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
The speech at Conference really resonated with me and many others, in fact I found I was nodding in agreement with every jot and tittle. I noticed on the TV that many of the members were nodding but they seemed to be nodding off to sleep
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
I should be okay though so basically I don’t give a s*** Me too as I am mortgage free and have one year left on my fixed price energy deal but I do have kids that aren't quite so lucky in terms of their mortgages and didn't have the foresight to fix their energy deals despite me telling them for years to do so
|
|
| croydon proud |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
Junked the country's creditworthiness resulting in higher mortgage rates which will probably end up with thousands of people who can no longer afford their mortgage payments to be made homeless. Completely misjudged the mood of the country and her own party. Managed to find someone more right wing than Pritti Patel to be Home Secretary. Excluded capable people from government if they hadn't backed her in the leadership election even going so far as to tell them that was the reason for them being replaced
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
I noticed on the TV that many of the members were nodding but they seemed to be nodding off to sleep Wasn’t CP and WE on stage was it ?
|
|
|
Originally posted by croydon proud
It hasnt cost anyone billions at all. The BOE has taken the bonds at a reduced interest rate so still make a profit. Let’s hope they cash them in before labour get into power. Then they will be total junk .
|
|
| croydon proud |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
It hasnt cost anyone billions at all. The BOE has taken the bonds at a reduced interest rate so still make a profit. Let’s hope they cash them in before labour get into power. Then they will be total junk . Up to £ 300 billion I heard on the radio over the long term- oh well- you"re doing well lizzy dripping- keep it up!
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
It hasnt cost anyone billions at all. The BOE has taken the bonds at a reduced interest rate so still make a profit. Let’s hope they cash them in before labour get into power. Then they will be total junk .
Are you seriously suggesting this is a good thing? I am no expert on the gilts market but, if my understanding is correct, these are debts due to be repaid in 30 years or more, at interest rates above the market. Our children and grandchildren's future is being mortgaged because of a stupid government, who have also saddled us all with the need to pay interest. It doesn't matter who is in power. They still need to be repaid. The markets don't react for fun. They react when what is happening affects them. They obviously don't believe what this government is doing adds up. Most knowledgeable seem to agree. You personally may not be affected as much as others. Nor will I. But we all are to some degree. That the world as a whole is also suffering doesn't excuse our government making things worse, rather than better.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Are you seriously suggesting this is a good thing? I am no expert on the gilts market but, if my understanding is correct, these are debts due to be repaid in 30 years or more, at interest rates above the market. Our children and grandchildren's future is being mortgaged because of a stupid government, who have also saddled us all with the need to pay interest. It doesn't matter who is in power. They still need to be repaid. The markets don't react for fun. They react when what is happening affects them. They obviously don't believe what this government is doing adds up. Most knowledgeable seem to agree. You personally may not be affected as much as others. Nor will I. But we all are to some degree. That the world as a whole is also suffering doesn't excuse our government making things worse, rather than better. Go on then give us some long term figures of what could have been and what will be.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Go on then give us some long term figures of what could have been and what will be. You need to ask a specialist economist for the detail. Having a long term aim to lower taxation and increase economic activity is the desire of almost every government. Doing it recklessly, without seemingly having either a clue how it will be paid for or caring too much, at a time when the country, and the whole world, is already struggling with the aftermaths of a pandemic and a war, and we have to cope with Brexit on top, is just irresponsible. Truss managed to convince her "electorate" about her "plan". More fool them. No-one else was convinced and expected the usual, "now we have looked at the books" reigning back and postponements until "the time is right". No-one expected them just to go ahead at 100 mph into a cul de sac. What was expected was a couple of morsels, to feed the prejudices of the Tories, but nothing on the scale that is proposed. It's unsustainable and will have to be reversed. Whether by this government, or a new one, remains to be seen. The idea that in the current climate cutting taxes will stimulate growth is nuts. People need their tax cut, and more, just to stay where they were. Businesses won't invest in an unstable economy. Any money saved on corporation tax will likely flow overseas. Trickle down economics is often seen by ambitious politicians as a way to stay popular. It has though been shown time and time again, not to work. It's a myth which has been firmly debunked. What happens long term depends a lot on what happens short term. If we reverse this stupidity we can recover quite quickly. If we go on digging it will take a long time.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
You need to ask a specialist economist for the detail. Having a long term aim to lower taxation and increase economic activity is the desire of almost every government. Doing it recklessly, without seemingly having either a clue how it will be paid for or caring too much, at a time when the country, and the whole world, is already struggling with the aftermaths of a pandemic and a war, and we have to cope with Brexit on top, is just irresponsible. Truss managed to convince her "electorate" about her "plan". More fool them. No-one else was convinced and expected the usual, "now we have looked at the books" reigning back and postponements until "the time is right". No-one expected them just to go ahead at 100 mph into a cul de sac. What was expected was a couple of morsels, to feed the prejudices of the Tories, but nothing on the scale that is proposed. It's unsustainable and will have to be reversed. Whether by this government, or a new one, remains to be seen. The idea that in the current climate cutting taxes will stimulate growth is nuts. People need their tax cut, and more, just to stay where they were. Businesses won't invest in an unstable economy. Any money saved on corporation tax will likely flow overseas. Trickle down economics is often seen by ambitious politicians as a way to stay popular. It has though been shown time and time again, not to work. It's a myth which has been firmly debunked. What happens long term depends a lot on what happens short term. If we reverse this stupidity we can recover quite quickly. If we go on digging it will take a long time. So you can’t put any meat on the bone then. It seemed that you were stating economic facts with your reply but you were just using supposition and guesses!
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
So you can’t put any meat on the bone then. It seemed that you were stating economic facts with your reply but you were just using supposition and guesses! Not at all. You asked for figures, and you need to be an economist to provide them. Which I am not. Others can provide the detail, on which there will be a range of opinions. All bad. You don't need though to be an expert to realise the folly of what has been done. Common sense tells you that, and listening to a multitude of people who are experts confirms it. You keep clinging to your straws! They won't be much use against an iceberg. In the meantime, let's hope that somebody does something before the ship sinks.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Not at all. You asked for figures, and you need to be an economist to provide them. Which I am not. Others can provide the detail, on which there will be a range of opinions. All bad. You don't need though to be an expert to realise the folly of what has been done. Common sense tells you that, and listening to a multitude of people who are experts confirms it. You keep clinging to your straws! They won't be much use against an iceberg. In the meantime, let's hope that somebody does something before the ship sinks. Here's a couple of questions for you. When was the last time an economist predicted anything correctly? Which financial crash, or boom, was predicted by an economist? I have more faith in meteorologists than economists. They are nothing more than chancers! [Link]
Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers |
|
|
Should be fun.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3751393] Here's a couple of questions for you. When was the last time an economist predicted anything correctly? Which financial crash, or boom, was predicted by an economist? I have more faith in meteorologists than economists. They are nothing more than chancers! [Link] I think that depends on what you mean by predict and the timescale involved. What's going on now aren't really predictions. They are interpretations of what the markets are saying.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.