This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by europalace
"Tax on pensioners proposed to heal inter-generational divide" "It says that all young people should receive a £10,000 windfall at the age of 25 to help pay for a deposit on a home, start a business or improve their education or skills." Flawed solution to a real problem. Some pensioners continue to work because they are still paying off their mortgage or other debts including their children's. So they are to be penalised. Meanwhile some pensioners have a good income and don't need to work and they don't have to pay. It is the same flawed solution to making pensioners pay for their care by taxing their estate when they die. I am retired and have lots of friends who have no savings and live in rented accommodation. For them it was a lifestyle choice, they earned good money and chose to P*** it up against the wall. I choose to buy my home but now I will be penalised whilst they get a freebie. Don't kept me wrong I am willing to pay my share but so should other people unless you are poor. The only fair solution is to increase income tax so we all pay when we earn, after that we can save or spend as we see fit.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Flawed solution to a real problem. Some pensioners continue to work because they are still paying off their mortgage or other debts including their children's. So they are to be penalised. Meanwhile some pensioners have a good income and don't need to work and they don't have to pay. It is the same flawed solution to making pensioners pay for their care by taxing their estate when they die. I am retired and have lots of friends who have no savings and live in rented accommodation. For them it was a lifestyle choice, they earned good money and chose to P*** it up against the wall. I choose to buy my home but now I will be penalised whilst they get a freebie. Don't kept me wrong I am willing to pay my share but so should other people unless you are poor. The only fair solution is to increase income tax so we all pay when we earn, after that we can save or spend as we see fit. So, the only fair solution is to tax someone else? I’ve heard that one before. I have some sympathy with pensioners, it must be difficult knowing you’ve had your last pay packet, so it makes sense to want to protect your nest egg. But the fact remains there are many wealthy pensioners nowadays who should be paying more. I’d suggest we need much better means-testing to sort who should pay more.
Vive le Roy! |
|
|
Originally posted by the.universal
So, the only fair solution is to tax someone else? I’ve heard that one before. I have some sympathy with pensioners, it must be difficult knowing you’ve had your last pay packet, so it makes sense to want to protect your nest egg. But the fact remains there are many wealthy pensioners nowadays who should be paying more. I’d suggest we need much better means-testing to sort who should pay more. Why should they pay more? They've been paying all their lives.
|
|
|
Originally posted by the.universal
the fact remains there are many wealthy pensioners nowadays who should be paying more. I’d suggest we need much better means-testing to sort who should pay more. I guess that I come within your idea of a wealthy pensioner but a huge chunk of my income already goes to HMRC in the form of income tax. Do you expect me to pay even more?
|
|
|
Originally posted by aquickgame2
So I've worked all my life,paid into the system,saved a bit for my old age,now some fcker tells me I've got too much and there going to take more. Go fck yourself. Indeed ! I am a pensioner but in a fortunate position.There are vast swathes who just live off their monthly pension and find it hard to make ends meet.Ludicrous proposal and not likely to be Government policy. Edited by Willo (08 May 2018 9.25am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Cucking Funt
Why should they pay more? They've been paying all their lives. and?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
I guess that I come within your idea of a wealthy pensioner but a huge chunk of my income already goes to HMRC in the form of income tax. Do you expect me to pay even more? Fascist
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
and? By way of clarity, they have paid tax all their life and got public services back in return. Why should they now pay no tax but still enjoy the same services IF (big if) they can afford to pay as much as someone in the working population? What has chronology got do do with anything? As a PS, you are aware that recently the average income for pensioners passed the average income for the waged?
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
By way of clarity, they have paid tax all their life and got public services back in return. Why should they now pay no tax but still enjoy the same services IF (big if) they can afford to pay as much as someone in the working population? What has chronology got do do with anything? As a PS, you are aware that recently the average income for pensioners passed the average income for the waged? My point is that, having paid tax all their lives, it seems a ridiculous notion that they should now have to pay more just to stick ten grand in the back pockets of kids, a luxury they themselves were not afforded.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
I can't see this vote loser ever coming into being as whichever party introduces it will lose the next election. I'm also blowed if I am going to pay extra tax just so that some 25 year old knife wielding drug dealer can have a bonus courtesy of me On the basis that the Conservatives get the 'Lion's share' of the pensioners vote, it really would be electoral suicide for us to adopt the proposal as Government policy. This wouldn't be counter balanced by luring the young into voting Conservative.Firstly more of the older generation turn out to vote besides all the young will be conned by lavish Labour promises they either cannot keep or if they did so would bankrupt this country but this is another debate.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I do believe that there is some justification in the view that the balance isn't fair. If you look at pensioners through a Thatcher lens it doesn't look good for them. However, the current state over balance towards fiscal help to pensioners has been done for electoral purposes and so to see the Tories now publicly thinking about reducing it amuses me greatly. Talk about self harming. Still it's true that the balance of state fiscal assistance is overly favourable to pensioners. It's also very short sighted considering that this group is only going to increase in number.....but that's your Cameron types all over. Edited by Stirlingsays (08 May 2018 11.24am) Just a report into inter-generational fairness by 'The Research and policy organisation'. Not sure that the Conservative Party have or will give it serious consideration. To think the Chairman 'Lord Willetts' was once known as "Two brains" in recognition of his cerebral capacity !
|
|
|
Originally posted by Cucking Funt
My point is that, having paid tax all their lives, it seems a ridiculous notion that they should now have to pay more just to stick ten grand in the back pockets of kids, a luxury they themselves were not afforded. Really? Tuppeny-happeny houses, a far more generous welfare system, subsidised transport, jobs for life, final salary pensions, student grants... There are 2 things that really bother me [just so you know where to prod next time]: 1. In our day we scrimped and saved for a house. These days the young just blow their money and get into debt. 2. I've paid tax all my life; I've earned my time in the sun. You prodded number 2. On the £10k handout, it will simply be absorbed by debt and give their parents at best a year before they start bailing them out again. Useless. Better would be to means test the state pension; start to invest heavily in private halthcare; and then use the vast resources released to work towards equalising life between young and old. Both would be eminently fair; and political suicide. Thus, never gonna happen.
|
|
|
Originally posted by pefwin
Intergenerational equality is not a new idea. The problem is that we have had 40 years of short-term policies, skewed towards those liable to vote. It has meant that the old have got relatively wealthier whilst the young got poorer. People who retired say 10-20 years ago will be the most wealthy pensioners ever. A short-term fix will not work, or a society windfall tax, we need to look at society as a whole, how we pay for education, the housing market, IHT, and many more aspects.
The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World |
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
By way of clarity, they have paid tax all their life and got public services back in return. Why should they now pay no tax but still enjoy the same services IF (big if) they can afford to pay as much as someone in the working population? What has chronology got do do with anything? As a PS, you are aware that recently the average income for pensioners passed the average income for the waged? Really? Proof?
COYP |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.