You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Who is to blame?
November 21 2026 11.04pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Who is to blame?


Page 14 of 22 < 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 >
Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 17 Dec 19 2.31pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Robinson is 'hard right' when it comes to Islam.

Outside of that he's quite liberal and very pro Israel....and how 'hard right' is that?

People are just ignorant and believe what the left say.

For example, most people don't know that Richard Spencer endorses Bernie Sanders and supported Corbyn over Johnson......and also supported 'remain'.

It's quite amusing really.....it's like a cult which makes up its own reality.

This is becoming more evident by the week.

The question is whether the majority actually believe the lies or are a little smarter.
Recent electoral trends tend to suggest the latter.

 

Beanyboysmd Flag 17 Dec 19 2.49pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Robinson is 'hard right' when it comes to Islam.

Outside of that he's quite liberal and very pro Israel....and how 'hard right' is that?

People are just ignorant and believe what the left say.

For example, most people don't know that Richard Spencer endorses Bernie Sanders and supported Corbyn over Johnson......and also supported 'remain'.....it's all too far left for me.

It's quite amusing really.....it's like a cult which makes up its own reality.

Edited by Stirlingsays (17 Dec 2019 2.31pm)

I think we need to detach racism from political view. Robinson is racist, nobody is supporting him for his views on VAT rates. I honestly don't know how much weight there is on Labours "Anti-antisemitism" or the Tories "Anti-islam" but if true then racism and prejudice are common on both sides, neither are a left vs right political view.

If your view is a simple "We have too many foreigners for the infrastructure to cope" then that
is a reasonable right wing view, if your view is "Those people want to come over and rape our women" then...erm...fine I guess, but dont try to disguise that as a political debate (Not you specifically by the way!)

i miss 2010 when political debate consisted of debating how often bins should be collected or if women should be allowed to ref mens football, politics has become a genuinely unpleasant conversation now

Edited by Beanyboysmd (17 Dec 2019 2.50pm)

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 17 Dec 19 3.05pm

Originally posted by Beanyboysmd

I think we need to detach racism from political view. Robinson is racist, nobody is supporting him for his views on VAT rates. I honestly don't know how much weight there is on Labours "Anti-antisemitism" or the Tories "Anti-islam" but if true then racism and prejudice are common on both sides, neither are a left vs right political view.

If your view is a simple "We have too many foreigners for the infrastructure to cope" then that
is a reasonable right wing view, if your view is "Those people want to come over and rape our women"
then...erm...fine I guess, but dont try to disguise that as a political debate (Not you specifically by the way!)

i miss 2010 when political debate consisted of debating how often bins should be collected or if women should be allowed to ref mens football, politics has become a genuinely unpleasant conversation now

Edited by Beanyboysmd (17 Dec 2019 2.50pm)

I understand the reason of your argument but unfortunately, the elephant in the room is that some of those people have come over here and raped our women in large numbers.
It is just not acceptable to sweep that reality under the carpet just to support a particular narrative.

Does it really make someone a racist because they are angry about that or because they remind people that they warned them about allowing certain types of cultures into this country?
I see no relation to racism at all.
Life s just not about simple narratives and ideals. We live in a world where the various political tribes just want to promote a simple message and the truth is lost amongst the rhetoric.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 17 Dec 19 3.10pm

Originally posted by Beanyboysmd

I think we need to detach racism from political view. Robinson is racist, nobody is supporting him for his views on VAT rates. I honestly don't know how much weight there is on Labours "Anti-antisemitism" or the Tories "Anti-islam" but if true then racism and prejudice are common on both sides, neither are a left vs right political view.

If your view is a simple "We have too many foreigners for the infrastructure to cope" then that
is a reasonable right wing view, if your view is "Those people want to come over and rape our women" then...erm...fine I guess, but dont try to disguise that as a political debate (Not you specifically by the way!)

i miss 2010 when political debate consisted of debating how often bins should be collected or if women should be allowed to ref mens football, politics has become a genuinely unpleasant conversation now

Edited by Beanyboysmd (17 Dec 2019 2.50pm)

Racist?

There is no evidence that Robinson is 'racist' as you put it.

Islam is not a race and Robinson has non whites who support him. You are just repeating leftist propaganda.

The fact remains, the majority of Robinson's views aren't 'hard right'......and the reality of the 'hard right' is that they have more in common with the statist 'hard left' than people realise.

Edited by Stirlingsays (17 Dec 2019 3.10pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Beanyboysmd Flag 17 Dec 19 3.25pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

I understand the reason of your argument but unfortunately, the elephant in the room is that some of those people have come over here and raped our women in large numbers.
It is just not acceptable to sweep that reality under the carpet just to support a particular narrative.

Does it really make someone a racist because they are angry about that or because they remind people that they warned them about allowing certain types of cultures into this country?
I see no relation to racism at all.
Life s just not about simple narratives and ideals. We live in a world where the various political tribes just want to promote a simple message and the truth is lost amongst the rhetoric.

Its a marginal thing that has been given a crazy level of prominence. If you found out that the group of people most likely to rape are South Africans, would you feel as passionately about South Africans not being allowed in this country? You could certainly make a lot of arguements about the structure of the country just like people do with muslim countries.
If we deported every muslim rapist, would you be happy with the remaining muslims to stay?

I would argue that even if all muslims were model citizens, it wouldn't change most peoples mind on them either way, the rape gang thing is mostly convenient decoration to most people. I wouldn't mind but it has really infected actual political debate on day to day things that matter to peoples lives

 

Beanyboysmd Flag 17 Dec 19 3.39pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Racist?

There is no evidence that Robinson is 'racist' as you put it.

Islam is not a race and Robinson has non whites who support him. You are just repeating leftist propaganda.

The fact remains, the majority of Robinson's views aren't 'hard right'......and the reality of the 'hard right' is that they have more in common with the statist 'hard left' than people realise.

Edited by Stirlingsays (17 Dec 2019 3.10pm)

Gunning for muslims is racist bud, thats not propaganda. My point still stands (And actually yours too) that gunning for muslims is not a left or right point of view, its just gunning for muslims. I have no idea whether he is left or right because he has never given a speech talking tax rates or pensions. Far-right is generally linked to getting rid of foreigners in general, not muslims specificly. So i don't really consider him to have far-right or far-left views, doesn't mean he doesn't but his general views on immigration are not really discussed. Maybe he has some brilliant views on unemployment benifit that could revolutionise this country but until he stops this "Muslims bad..." message,we will never know where he stands politically.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 17 Dec 19 3.40pm

Originally posted by Beanyboysmd

I would argue that even if all muslims were model citizens, it wouldn't change most peoples mind on them either way
, the rape gang thing is mostly convenient decoration to most people. I wouldn't mind but it has really infected actual political debate on day to day things that matter to peoples lives


Sorry, I don't think that follows....

If this were true then people would also be saying the same things about Hindus and Sikhs.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 17 Dec 19 3.48pm

Originally posted by Beanyboysmd

Gunning for muslims is racist bud, thats not propaganda. My point still stands (And actually yours too) that gunning for muslims is not a left or right point of view, its just gunning for muslims. I have no idea whether he is left or right because he has never given a speech talking tax rates or pensions. Far-right is generally linked to getting rid of foreigners in general, not muslims specificly. So i don't really consider him to have far-right or far-left views, doesn't mean he doesn't but his general views on immigration are not really discussed. Maybe he has some brilliant views on unemployment benifit that could revolutionise this country but until he stops this "Muslims bad..." message,we will never know where he stands politically.

'Gunning for muslims is racist bud, thats not propaganda'.

Errrr...it kind of is.

A religion is not a race and it's a conflation.

Robinson may be lots of things but he's actual positions are heavily smeared and are kept out of public knowledge.

Because...the truth eh....far too inconvenient.....and there are plenty of Robinson's views I don't agree with.


Edited by Stirlingsays (17 Dec 2019 3.49pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Beanyboysmd Flag 17 Dec 19 4.06pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

'Gunning for muslims is racist bud, thats not propaganda'.

Errrr...it kind of is.

A religion is not a race and it's a conflation.

Robinson may be lots of things but he's actual positions are heavily smeared and are kept out of public knowledge.

Because...the truth eh....far too inconvenient.....and there are plenty of Robinson's views I don't agree with.


Edited by Stirlingsays (17 Dec 2019 3.49pm)

Sorry you are right, the term nowadays is interchangeable. I know its not technically correct but its really arguing in the margins.

So I would argue that Robinsons actual political views arn't kept out of public knowledge, they are just irrelevant as they are not really what he wants to be known for. He has plenty of platforms to choose from to discuss his politics, i'm not 100% against his views on the BBC (im an SNP supporter so feeling misrepresented by the BBC is something I can see his view on) but even he rarely discusses his political views (Unless you see his views on Muslims as a polital view which, as I mentioned earlier, I don't). Like I said, he might well have very reasonable views on a lot of stuff but its not like he livestreams to promote his "Hot-take" on whether you should pay VAT on Jaffa-cakes or not...

But yes, I used "racist" and should have been "prejudiced" so I will concede on that. Still stand by it not being a political view though

 

Stirlingsays Flag 17 Dec 19 4.18pm

Originally posted by Beanyboysmd

Sorry you are right, the term nowadays is interchangeable. I know its not technically correct but its really arguing in the margins.

So I would argue that Robinsons actual political views arn't kept out of public knowledge, they are just irrelevant as they are not really what he wants to be known for. He has plenty of platforms to choose from to discuss his politics, i'm not 100% against his views on the BBC (im an SNP supporter so feeling misrepresented by the BBC is something I can see his view on) but even he rarely discusses his political views (Unless you see his views on Muslims as a polital view which, as I mentioned earlier, I don't). Like I said, he might well have very reasonable views on a lot of stuff but its not like he livestreams to promote his "Hot-take" on whether you should pay VAT on Jaffa-cakes or not...

But yes, I used "racist" and should have been "prejudiced" so I will concede on that. Still stand by it not being a political view though

Nowadays the term is interchangeable?

Who are the people responsible for that Beanyboysmd?

So if you're against a religion you're a racist?....Blimey.

Should we not be resisting the abuse of words for political propaganda? This is much like the abuse of the word 'Nazi'.

If Scotland voted for independence I'd support that endeavour, as an expression of justified self determination.....but I wouldn't if say, London wished for it.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Midlands Eagle Flag 17 Dec 19 4.23pm

If I could move posts off threads I would but the software isn't that sophisticated so could you please keep this thread to (roughly) Who Is To Blame and post Tommy Robinson stuff to his own existing thread

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 17 Dec 19 4.32pm

Originally posted by Beanyboysmd

Its a marginal thing that has been given a crazy level of prominence. If you found out that the group of people most likely to rape are South Africans, would you feel as passionately about South Africans not being allowed in this country? You could certainly make a lot of arguements about the structure of the country just like people do with muslim countries.
If we deported every muslim rapist, would you be happy with the remaining muslims to stay?

I would argue that even if all muslims were model citizens, it wouldn't change most peoples mind on them either way, the rape gang thing is mostly convenient decoration to most people. I wouldn't mind but it has really infected actual political debate on day to day things that matter to peoples lives

I would happily deport all the rapists whether they are 'British' or not.
I certainly do not approve of the oppression of individuals based on religion or the actions of other individuals.
Does that mean that I approve of Islamic teaching or that I'm happy with its spread into Britain? Does it mean I don't think it poses a threat to our culture or our citizens?

Certainly not.

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 17 Dec 19 5.58pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

Actually I think it was only about 3 who were critical of him. So who is exaggerating?

Everyone else defended his actions and claimed outrage when he was charged, found guilty and jailed.

Which is only to be expected here. Anything else would be totally out of character.

If you despise this place and the people on it, why do you spend so much time on here?

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 17 Dec 19 6.11pm

Originally posted by Willo

The point I was making is the fact that someone has a thread dedicated to them does not necessarily mean there is a groundswell of lauding in their direction.

Read the thread and then let a few others, with a variety of political viewpoints also read it before you make a judgement on that.

I certainly don't detect a hard-right cabal on HOL and if you assert that there is, I will vehemiently disagree with you no matter what arguments you put forward.

Whether you perceive opinions as centre right or hard right nearly always depends on your own point of view. Many here believe the BBC to be far to the left politically whilst many left leaning forums think they are a hard right outfit. However I don't think it is really possible to argue that this place is anything other than dominated by hard right sentiment. I think most of them would accept that is the case with some pride.

I do get the impression that you prefer opposition to your views as it provides you with the impetus to continue spoon-feed us what the great and good on HOL might view as warm diarrhoea.

Forums which do nothing than confirm your bias also teach you nothing. That others might react to my posts as you suggest is entirely to be expected. I would be in the wrong place if that didn't happen. There are very, very few on here who could claim to be among the "great and the good". I have been aware of these types of attitudes for 60 years or more. I grew up in a tough neighbourhood where there was a very simplistic approach to politics. Fortunately I was lucky enough to have benefited from some exposure to more sophisticated political thinking later on.

I have no intention whatsoever of casting personal slurs in your direction as this poisons the well of debate but the tone of vaunting superiority coupled with what many consider 'Bilgewater' has not really added value to this cherished site.You are in good company as 'Yours Truly' has been accused of similar sentiments in the distant past!

What others think of me and my posting style is irrelevant. I don't post here to massage my ego. If I occasionally get someone to rethink their attitude then that's reward enough.

Finally, far from besmirching you as a person I will give you some credit.To my miniscule mind (As opposed to yours) not too many persons aged 75, would have the energy nor inclination to debate on a plethora of sites, nor perhaps travel the world and arise at 3AM to view streams of our games.A few people that I have met of your era are technical deserts but clearly you are totally 'Au Fait' with present day technology - clearly more than me!

Please don't belittle yourself. You are one of the more eloquent and reasonable opponents whose attacks are generally more sarcastic than vicious. I have long had an interest in computing and was writing programmes for an Amstrad at least 30 years ago. Gotta keep up! By the way I have recently been asked to become captain of my bowls club so not everyone thinks I am a complete numpty. Although some here no doubt think all bowlers are numpties.

Edited by Willo (17 Dec 2019 2.07pm)

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 17 Dec 19 6.31pm

From from being a chef d'oeuvre I have concluded that the latest thoughts of the erudite erstwhile computer programmer might be declamatory but alas is the propogation of palpable tosh and a rambling farago of hogwash delivered in a tone of vaunting superiority.The arguments creak like the hip-joint of an octogenarion harlot.Mere thermals, slinging more bull's excrement than a Pamplona street cleaner.

Whilst I dismiss his sentiments out of hand amidst barks of derision I am grateful for the compliments he paid to me in his final paragraph.Enjoy the bowls - probably a member of the 'Green Party' !

Edited by Willo (17 Dec 2019 6.35pm)

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 17 Dec 19 6.38pm

Originally posted by the silurian

If you despise this place and the people on it, why do you spend so much time on here?

I spend much less than you might imagine. Currently I spend much longer on several Labour supporting sites arguing about their need to move direction back to the centre.

I drift in and out according to the political landscape. These are both interesting and dangerous days and it's always useful to understand what people on the margins are thinking and for your own ideas to be torn to shreds.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 17 Dec 19 6.40pm

Originally posted by Willo

From from being a chef d'oeuvre I have concluded that the latest thoughts of the erudite erstwhile computer programmer might be declamatory but alas is the propogation of palpable tosh and a rambling farago of hogwash delivered in a tone of vaunting superiority.The arguments creak like the hip-joint of an octogenarion harlot.Mere thermals, slinging more bull's excrement than a Pamplona street cleaner.

Whilst I dismiss his sentiments out of hand amidst barks of derision I am grateful for the compliments he paid to me in his final paragraph.Enjoy the bowls - probably a member of the 'Green Party' !

Edited by Willo (17 Dec 2019 6.35pm)

Rarely agree with you willo (especially about referees) but this time I wholeheartedly concur!

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 17 Dec 19 6.43pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

I spend much less than you might imagine. Currently I spend much longer on several Labour supporting sites arguing about their need to move direction back to the centre.

I drift in and out according to the political landscape. These are both interesting and dangerous days and it's always useful to understand what people on the margins are thinking and for your own ideas to be torn to shreds.

I suspect that over the years your own ideas have suffered such a fate and continue to this day.

Edited by Willo (17 Dec 2019 6.44pm)

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 17 Dec 19 6.43pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

I spend much less than you might imagine. Currently I spend much longer on several Labour supporting sites arguing about their need to move direction back to the centre.

I drift in and out according to the political landscape. These are both interesting and dangerous days and it's always useful to understand what people on the margins are thinking and for your own ideas to be torn to shreds.

so you are here just to attempt brainwashing us over to your point of view? Is your real name Kim Jong Truro??..Little tip.....you will NEVER change me to your way of thinking! Im in Truro on Sunday, may bump into you?

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 17 Dec 19 6.53pm

Originally posted by Willo

From from being a chef d'oeuvre I have concluded that the latest thoughts of the erudite erstwhile computer programmer might be declamatory but alas is the propogation of palpable tosh and a rambling farago of hogwash delivered in a tone of vaunting superiority.The arguments creak like the hip-joint of an octogenarion harlot.Mere thermals, slinging more bull's excrement than a Pamplona street cleaner.

Whilst I dismiss his sentiments out of hand amidst barks of derision I am grateful for the compliments he paid to me in his final paragraph.Enjoy the bowls - probably a member of the 'Green Party' !

Edited by Willo (17 Dec 2019 6.35pm)

If I were you I would consign that mess of verbal diarrhea to the swill bin asap. It's not fit to be served up to any diner.

It makes me smile when I am accused of "vaunting superiority" or similar intended insults. It always suggests to me that those who write them actually lack confidence in their own opinions so need to resort to attacking the opposition as their defence. We see this a lot these days, not least from Mr Trump.

Most of my bowls club colleagues are staunch Tories and enthusiastic leavers. Take from that whatever you like!

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Page 14 of 22 < 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Who is to blame?