This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Wilesy01
I'm glad a jury found these protestors not guilty. I can't imagine anyone who would tolerate a statue of a slave owning murderer being acceptable iconography in a civil society, apart from those who support such practices. Haha. You think that people that who hold these views might just be tabloid employees until you read the likes of Wilesy. The lunatic fringe has always been with us. Some grow older and wiser, and the remaining few just grow old.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
There are lots of things that people find offensive there are also plenty of ways to seek redress without resorting to violence. Bristol Council held a referendum on the statue and the people did not vote to remove it but then I guess democracy is only acceptable when it comes up with the right answer. This is not about whether Colston was a good or bad person but about criminal damage.
I wholeheartedly agree with your comments.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
There are lots of things that people find offensive there are also plenty of ways to seek redress without resorting to violence. Bristol Council held a referendum on the statue and the people did not vote to remove it but then I guess democracy is only acceptable when it comes up with the right answer. This is not about whether Colston was a good or bad person but about criminal damage.
There was never an official referendum on the status of the statue. There were polls in the local newspaper but nothing like an actual referendum. As opposed to your last point the defendants never stated they didn't damage the statue, but maintained the point I made about the historical context of the statue and the inaction of the council to remove it as to why they acted.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
Did he not invest heavily in local community? Presumably anything he paid towards is being taken down Yes towards schools, the University, hospitals, churches and almshouses. What he paid for will not be taken down. Much of it cannot be due to its listed status. There are still charities bearing Colstons name like the Colston society, which instead of changing its name intends to cease benefitting the poor of Redcliffe area (near the docks) of the City it was set up to help. Colston philanthropy was the reason the statue in the centre existed.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wilesy01
There was never an official referendum on the status of the statue. There were polls in the local newspaper but nothing like an actual referendum. As opposed to your last point the defendants never stated they didn't damage the statue, but maintained the point I made about the historical context of the statue and the inaction of the council to remove it as to why they acted. So they were guilty of criminal damage then? Was that not what Jury should have been deciding on? Unbelievable
|
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
There are lots of things that people find offensive there are also plenty of ways to seek redress without resorting to violence. Bristol Council held a referendum on the statue and the people did not vote to remove it but then I guess democracy is only acceptable when it comes up with the right answer. This is not about whether Colston was a good or bad person but about criminal damage.
There were polls and petitions. That less than .. Well it might not have been even 1% of the population ever took part ... It was a non issue.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Pembroke
Yes towards schools, the University, hospitals, churches and almshouses. What he paid for will not be taken down. Much of it cannot be due to its listed status. There are still charities bearing Colstons name like the Colston society, which instead of changing its name intends to cease benefitting the poor of Redcliffe area (near the docks) of the City it was set up to help. Colston philanthropy was the reason the statue in the centre existed. I am sure a listed status would not stop these thugs, unless of course they have benefited from any of these establishments
|
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
Following a mob pulling down the statue of Colston in Bristol, London Mayor, Sadiq Khan, set up a committee to look at which statues in London should be taken down. Chilembwe sounds awful, you should appeal against it being put up. I think.most of us would support you.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Haha. You think that people that who hold these views might just be tabloid employees until you read the likes of Wilesy. The lunatic fringe has always been with us. Some grow older and wiser, and the remaining few just grow old. A majority of a jury seemingly agrees with me, Hrolf. Seems you're on the lunatic fringe now!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wilesy01
A majority of a jury seemingly agrees with me, Hrolf. Seems you're on the lunatic fringe now! All is not always as it seems Wilesy. I think the vast majority have just about had enough of 'woke'.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
I am sure a listed status would not stop these thugs, unless of course they have benefited from any of these establishments Many people benefit in Bristol, particularly the wealthy and middle class students. These four benefitted from their status. If they were from working class areas like Hartcliffe and Knowle West they would have been convicted and be receiving prison sentences.
|
|
|
Should the judge not have directed the Jury to decide on offences rather than their ownpolitical views?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Beanyboysmd
Chilembwe sounds awful, you should appeal against it being put up. I think.most of us would support you. Colston was born into money. His money came from a wide variety of businesses. He was also an MP in Bristol.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Pembroke
Colston was born into money. His money came from a wide variety of businesses. He was also an MP in Bristol.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wilesy01
There was never an official referendum on the status of the statue. There were polls in the local newspaper but nothing like an actual referendum. As opposed to your last point the defendants never stated they didn't damage the statue, but maintained the point I made about the historical context of the statue and the inaction of the council to remove it as to why they acted. Yup back to that pesky democracy, direct action is the answer. Don't like Tony Blair getting a knighthood go smash up his house. If the jury had any sense they would have found them guilty the judge would then have taken any mitigation into account, but they didn't so it is a moot point.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Yup back to that pesky democracy, direct action is the answer. Don't like Tony Blair getting a knighthood go smash up his house. If the jury had any sense they would have found them guilty the judge would then have taken any mitigation into account, but they didn't so it is a moot point. What mitigation? A man makes money, the same as thousands of others, using legal slave labour and because a few Black people and White guilt morons can't understand that people of the past cannot have their historical morality and laws judged by today's, we should forgive them their irrationality, thuggery and vandalism? Statues are a side issue. This is about who holds the power in this country. Do we uphold our institutions and democratic process, or allow a load of mentally immature fruitcakes to erase and rewrite our history so they feel better about themselves?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
What mitigation? A man makes money, the same as thousands of others, using legal slave labour and because a few Black people and White guilt morons can't understand that people of the past cannot have their historical morality and laws judged by today's, we should forgive them their irrationality, thuggery and vandalism? Statues are a side issue. This is about who holds the power in this country. Do we uphold our institutions and democratic process, or allow a load of mentally immature fruitcakes to erase and rewrite our history so they feel better about themselves? I really enjoy how you're trying to justify slavery in a historical context. I look forward to your sympathetic take on the Nazis and the Holocaust as your next hot take.
|
|
|
I'm off to pull down Nelson Mandela's statue he's a terrorist and a wife beater and an adulterer I am offended. So that's okay then.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Wilesy01
I really enjoy how you're trying to justify slavery in a historical context. I look forward to your sympathetic take on the Nazis and the Holocaust as your next hot take. -.-' Typical far left tactic, off to Godwin's law we go. As African chiefs were selling the slaves to the British and everyone else and had been using slavery since their history was recorded, perhaps you should start over there.....they did genocide as well seeing as you want to bring up the Holocaust from the earlier part of last century...which had nothing to do with the British anyway. Hey, slavery is actually still going on over there in parts of Africa....but where do we find the oh so brave people who pretend to care about slavery? Yeah, in Bristol and waffling away mostly in middle class enclaves....clap clap, really making a difference comrades. Far left attacks on history are frequently anti white disfigured one eyed takes.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Wilesy01
I really enjoy how you're trying to justify slavery in a historical context. I look forward to your sympathetic take on the Nazis and the Holocaust as your next hot take. Wow. Getting Hitler in early. Nice. It is a ridiculous position to suggest that acknowledging the reality of slavery is to justify it. It is that kind of illogic that makes people like you lack credibility.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.