You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Confederate Statues
November 22 2026 12.23am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Confederate Statues


Page 15 of 30 < 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 >
Mapletree Flag Croydon 21 Aug 17 2.08pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

You struggle answering questions. Probably a reflection of your painfully obvious self absorption.

Haven't my comments laid it out as overtly as possible? If the local democracy around vote for something that's within the law then I have no issues with it. So if they want a statue there or not a statue there that's for them.

I don't agree with mobs tearing down statues no....This happens in times of war and conflict but I've never agreed that this is how you deal with stuff.


Edited by Stirlingsays (21 Aug 2017 1.18pm)

Why the ad hominem attack Stirling? And by the way I look forward to your examples.

Coming back to the point, no you have not answered the question. If the question is 'should people rally against extremists or simply allow the law to handle the issue' then the law is not designed for that. It is designed for when people overstep the mark in a specific case but not for when people continually sail close to the wind to build an impression over time that what they say has validity. That is when you need opposing viewpoints.

Considering all that you have said on this site about allowing freedom of speach and encouraging a variety of view I am actually shocked that you appear to disapprove of direct action. I don't approve of breaking the law but I heartily approve of groups of people banding together to protest.

It's also rather good fun.

Edited by Mapletree (21 Aug 2017 2.34pm)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 21 Aug 17 3.39pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

Why the ad hominem attack Stirling? And by the way I look forward to your examples.

Coming back to the point, no you have not answered the question. If the question is 'should people rally against extremists or simply allow the law to handle the issue' then the law is not designed for that. It is designed for when people overstep the mark in a specific case but not for when people continually sail close to the wind to build an impression over time that what they say has validity. That is when you need opposing viewpoints.

Considering all that you have said on this site about allowing freedom of speach and encouraging a variety of view I am actually shocked that you appear to disapprove of direct action. I don't approve of breaking the law but I heartily approve of groups of people banding together to protest.

It's also rather good fun.

Edited by Mapletree (21 Aug 2017 2.34pm)

I wouldn't take my 'ad hominem' attacks too seriously....let's say I'm a critical person...too critical sometimes...it's a character flaw...I can't help it...see I'm even criticising myself.....Being a teacher doesn't help....being an arsehole is almost a part requirement (though there are lovely teachers as well).

For me, I take the position that opinions are opinions and actions are actions....don't get me wrong, we know where are overlaps and that cause and affect are realities but I step very carefully on that minefield.

Sometimes people say 'sh1t' and it isn't nice but doing stuff about it ends up causing more harm than good long term.....I think we are on that path at the moment and I'm most definitely 'tutting' about it.

Recent movements towards 'hate speech' ....which I initially had a little sympathy for but have since become a critic of.....Well, those movements are worrying to me. I'm a believer in the restrictions on libel, violence and obscenity....but setting these restrictions lower rather than higher....because society contains very different groups and I'm more socially liberal than not.

If people are banding together to cause violence I most definitely want the Police to intervene in that....that's what taxes are for.

If people are banding together to protest something then I have zero problem with that.....as long as they aren't smashing windows or physically involving themselves it's a healthy display of democracy.

Of course if one group of morons rush you then self defence is valid. However, placing yourself in their path is deliberately setting up a fight.

I'm aware that my stance kind of inhibits revolution....it's essentially protecting the establishment when sometimes the establishment is far from ideal.

However I watched a clip on TV a while back where they were in Russia interviewing some guy on the street about revolution and he said, 'good rarely comes from revolutions'......he's right...normally you are replacing one set of arseholes with another set of arseholes with different priorities....It's just a different set of people lined up against the wall.

Better to reform the arseholes you have.....though I recognise that this isn't always possible....so context for every situation is relevant.

Edited by Stirlingsays (21 Aug 2017 3.43pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 21 Aug 17 3.51pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Really?

There are plenty of people on here who present very reasonable arguments from all sides of politics and can write very impressively on a number of subjects.
Nick and a few others I could mention are not among that number.

The Nick of old use to be less conflict and more interested in discussion .....ok not as much as some but it was there.

He's more Wolfe Smith now but it's all part of the Hol diaspora. There are plenty of cerebral left of centre commentators for discussion and trading of ideas... though we don't have many centralists....and you get your Kermits and Nicks for your rows and rants.

We all know we get worse.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Mapletree Flag Croydon 21 Aug 17 4.01pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

I wouldn't take my 'ad hominem' attacks too seriously....let's say I'm a critical person...too critical sometimes...it's a character flaw...I can't help it...see I'm even criticising myself.....Being a teacher doesn't help....being an arsehole is almost a part requirement (though there are lovely teachers as well).

For me, I take the position that opinions are opinions and actions are actions....don't get me wrong, we know where are overlaps and that cause and affect are realities but I step very carefully on that minefield.

Sometimes people say 'sh1t' and it isn't nice but doing stuff about it ends up causing more harm than good long term.....I think we are on that path at the moment and I'm most definitely 'tutting' about it.

Recent movements towards 'hate speech' ....which I initially had a little sympathy for but have since become a critic of.....Well, those movements are worrying to me. I'm a believer in the restrictions on libel, violence and obscenity....but setting these restrictions lower rather than higher....because society contains very different groups and I'm more socially liberal than not.

If people are banding together to cause violence I most definitely want the Police to intervene in that....that's what taxes are for.

If people are banding together to protest something then I have zero problem with that.....as long as they aren't smashing windows or physically involving themselves it's a healthy display of democracy.

Of course if one group of morons rush you then self defence is valid. However, placing yourself in their path is deliberately setting up a fight.

I'm aware that my stance kind of inhibits revolution....it's essentially protecting the establishment when sometimes the establishment is far from ideal.

However I watched a clip on TV a while back where they were in Russia interviewing some guy on the street about revolution and he said, 'good rarely comes from revolutions'......he's right...normally you are replacing one set of arseholes with another set of arseholes with different priorities....It's just a different set of people lined up against the wall.

Better to reform the arseholes you have.....though I recognise that this isn't always possible....so context for every situation is relevant.

Edited by Stirlingsays (21 Aug 2017 3.43pm)

I agree with you Stirling. Revolutions almost inevitably set back populations and destroy value. But it isn't revolution I was talking about, it was controlled pressure brought to bear to prevent an opposing viewpoint from rolling out unassailed. Goodness knows this has currency right now. You have to avoid unaligned people from tacitly supporting extremists and making them ever bolder. I watched Harry Potter last night, I know what I am talking about.

I worked in Romania just after Ceausescu was shot. It was weird how, having 'terminated' his family the population voted in his old cronies. When I asked why I was told because they were the only people who had a clue how things worked. They were tolerated for a while in the name of reconstruction.


Edited by Mapletree (21 Aug 2017 4.02pm)

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 21 Aug 17 4.04pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

The Nick of old use to be less conflict and more interested in discussion .....ok not as much as some but it was there.

He's more Wolfe Smith now but it's all part of the Hol diaspora. There are plenty of cerebral left of centre commentators for discussion and trading of ideas... though we don't have many centralists....and you get your Kermits and Nicks for your rows and rants.

We all know we get worse.

Gotta agree with you again.

But I do think Nick getting more hardline coincided with one or two people becoming more hard line vocal on the other wing and - indeed - taking themselves more seriously.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 21 Aug 17 4.29pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

Gotta agree with you again.

But I do think Nick getting more hardline coincided with one or two people becoming more hard line vocal on the other wing and - indeed - taking themselves more seriously.

Indeed.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 21 Aug 17 4.39pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

I agree with you Stirling. Revolutions almost inevitably set back populations and destroy value. But it isn't revolution I was talking about, it was controlled pressure brought to bear to prevent an opposing viewpoint from rolling out unassailed. Goodness knows this has currency right now. You have to avoid unaligned people from tacitly supporting extremists and making them ever bolder. I watched Harry Potter last night, I know what I am talking about.

I worked in Romania just after Ceausescu was shot. It was weird how, having 'terminated' his family the population voted in his old cronies. When I asked why I was told because they were the only people who had a clue how things worked. They were tolerated for a while in the name of reconstruction.


Edited by Mapletree (21 Aug 2017 4.02pm)

Working in Romania round about then must have been interesting.

I've seen orgies on snooker tables and tragically planes fly into buildings....but I know bugger all about Romania....is it true that the women are hairier over there?....mustaches and all that?

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Mapletree Flag Croydon 21 Aug 17 4.47pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Working in Romania round about then must have been interesting.

I've seen orgies on snooker tables and tragically planes fly into buildings....but I know bugger all about Romania....is it true that the women are hairier over there?....mustaches and all that?

Therein lies many a tale.

Due to fog, the one and only modern Tarom plane got stuck in Romania so they flew in an old Ilyushin from another airfield. It seems they also flew in the normal air stewardesses. Far more impressive moustaches than I could muster and meat with the texture and taste of Doc Martin's boot tongues after a four day festival.

On the other hand Romanian girls had a habit of wearing incredibly short skirts and many were really attractive. None as attractive as Slovakians though, they are truly the chosen race.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 21 Aug 17 4.48pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Working in Romania round about then must have been interesting.

I've seen orgies on snooker tables and tragically planes fly into buildings....but I know bugger all about Romania....is it true that the women are hairier over there?....mustaches and all that?

By the way, all public buildings had 20 Watt lights and many of the buildings were riddled with bullet holes.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 21 Aug 17 5.29pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

I agree with you Stirling. Revolutions almost inevitably set back populations and destroy value. But it isn't revolution I was talking about, it was controlled pressure brought to bear to prevent an opposing viewpoint from rolling out unassailed. Goodness knows this has currency right now. You have to avoid unaligned people from tacitly supporting extremists and making them ever bolder. I watched Harry Potter last night, I know what I am talking about.

I worked in Romania just after Ceausescu was shot. It was weird how, having 'terminated' his family the population voted in his old cronies. When I asked why I was told because they were the only people who had a clue how things worked. They were tolerated for a while in the name of reconstruction.


Edited by Mapletree (21 Aug 2017 4.02pm)

Very true, and a mistake many make in considering (including the US and UK in Iraq). One of the classic problems of any tyranny, is that its not just power that's in the hands of the privillaged - its knowledge.

Take South Africa and Zimbabwe - Its not the political change per se that's f**ked these countries, its the pander to their supporters (like the murder of farmers to give the farms to people who had no idea how to run a farm). In situations like this, its more important to keep things running, than to be popular.

You can't just hand over the management of a power station to a crony, and expect it to work - You have to have the knowledge that makes it work - and in South Africa especially, the failure of the ANC to realise that they would have to work with White South Africans to achieve a functioning country, meant a brain drain, as those white South Africans left, because a) they were endangered b) they could see the writing on the wall c) they had the kind of skills that appeal on immigration forms.

The problem of revolutionaries is that they don't really have a plan for what comes next (usually because they're to focused on staying alive long enough to have a punt at running things).

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 21 Aug 17 5.30pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

By the way, all public buildings had 20 Watt lights and many of the buildings were riddled with bullet holes.

Could be parts of Baltimore, except in some areas a 20 watt light might be considered a luxury.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 21 Aug 17 5.30pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

So what are you suggesting here? That people should be drowned out? That people shouldn't be allowed to speak? This is free speech.....if you allow groups to shut down legal speech then they are going to come to your rally and do the same to you....escalation and then violence.

These are people talking. I've seen this 'shutting down of speech' by crowds at Berkeley and other campuses in America.


Just to clarify a few things on "free speech" protections:

- You have them in the U.S. but not in, say, the U.K or Germany where racist and/or pro-Nazi speech is banned.

- In the U.S. you have constitutional protections from censorship by the government only. If you came into my home chanting "Blood and Soil" then I am well within my rights to kick you out. Also, the silencing of deliberately inflammatory speech has been upheld by the Supreme Court - so not all speech is protected (although I doubt Nazi chants would rise to the level of censorable speech).

- In the U.S. you have a constitutional right to free assembly. Again, this is only protection from the government, so you can't freely assemble in my living room. And, of course, because anyone can freely assemble in public spaces, that means that everyone can freely assemble in public spaces. So, if you want to hold your Nazi rally without interference from counter-protesters, find a private venue that will let you in (Mar-a-Lago has some openings in its calendar that came available very recently). Otherwise, in a public space like Emancipation Park, Charlottesville or the Boston Common (it's in the effing name) everyone is allowed to show up and speak their minds.

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

hedgehog50 Flag Croydon 21 Aug 17 7.02pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

Gotta agree with you again.

But I do think Nick getting more hardline coincided with one or two people becoming more hard line vocal on the other wing and - indeed - taking themselves more seriously.

The left get more hardline when they see their ideas and policies failing, they start calling for more of the measures that are causing the failures. If Corbyn ever came to power you would see him getting more and more authoritarian as his polices become more and more unworkable.

 


We have now sunk to a depth at which the restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men. [Orwell]

Mapletree Flag Croydon 21 Aug 17 8.26pm

Originally posted by hedgehog50

The left get more hardline when they see their ideas and policies failing, they start calling for more of the measures that are causing the failures. If Corbyn ever came to power you would see him getting more and more authoritarian as his polices become more and more unworkable.

Right, I am now going to say this bluntly.

It is you and one other person that has ruined Nick's posts for the rest of us. By constantly blindly attacking 'the left', whatever that means, you have become a damned nuisance. Get a life, think independently and lay off with all this party political nonsense. Stop forcing others into defending their positions ad nauseum.

This is not a political forum, it is a site to debate all sorts of things.

You are sufficiently boring to have really started irritating me. You hijack almost every post and are totally one-dimensional. Perhaps I am on my own in this case.

Edited by Mapletree (21 Aug 2017 8.27pm)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 21 Aug 17 8.37pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

Right, I am now going to say this bluntly.

It is you and one other person that has ruined Nick's posts for the rest of us. By constantly blindly attacking 'the left', whatever that means, you have become a damned nuisance. Get a life, think independently and lay off with all this party political nonsense. Stop forcing others into defending their positions ad nauseum.

This is not a political forum, it is a site to debate all sorts of things.

You are sufficiently boring to have really started irritating me. You hijack almost every post and are totally one-dimensional. Perhaps I am on my own in this case.

Edited by Mapletree (21 Aug 2017 8.27pm)

Oh come on Nick loves it.

He starts threads deliberately to provoke sometimes and personally I've no problem with that......I think the row and knockabout element to Hol has its place.

Sure it can go a little too far sometimes but for the most part...you know...blah blah blah and all that stuff.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 21 Aug 17 8.45pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

Therein lies many a tale.

Due to fog, the one and only modern Tarom plane got stuck in Romania so they flew in an old Ilyushin from another airfield. It seems they also flew in the normal air stewardesses. Far more impressive moustaches than I could muster and meat with the texture and taste of Doc Martin's boot tongues after a four day festival.

On the other hand Romanian girls had a habit of wearing incredibly short skirts and many were really attractive. None as attractive as Slovakians though, they are truly the chosen race.

I don't know much about Romania but I did notice from a lot of teaching of eastern Europeans that the dynamic between male and female was more traditional than the UKs. Kind of like being in the eighties again....I prefer it to the dour asexual PC parade of currently approved British culture.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Mapletree Flag Croydon 21 Aug 17 8.47pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

I don't know much about Romania but I did notice from a lot of teaching of eastern Europeans that the dynamic between male and female was more traditional than the UKs. Kind of like being in the eighties again....I prefer it to the dour asexual PC parade of currently approved British culture.

I can recommend a couple of Cheeky Romanian girls.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 21 Aug 17 8.57pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

Right, I am now going to say this bluntly.

It is you and one other person that has ruined Nick's posts for the rest of us. By constantly blindly attacking 'the left', whatever that means, you have become a damned nuisance. Get a life, think independently and lay off with all this party political nonsense. Stop forcing others into defending their positions ad nauseum.

This is not a political forum, it is a site to debate all sorts of things.

You are sufficiently boring to have really started irritating me. You hijack almost every post and are totally one-dimensional. Perhaps I am on my own in this case.

Edited by Mapletree (21 Aug 2017 8.27pm)

And you don't think that the reverse is equally true.

Constant insinuations of racism. Blinkered ideological nonsense justifying every position.
Constantly claiming the moral and intellectual high ground.

You get what you give.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 21 Aug 17 9.07pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

I can recommend a couple of Cheeky Romanian girls.

Yep, they went far....shows you where good genes can get you....I wonder what they are doing now.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 21 Aug 17 9.16pm

Originally posted by Ray in Houston

Just to clarify a few things on "free speech" protections:

- You have them in the U.S. but not in, say, the U.K or Germany where racist and/or pro-Nazi speech is banned.

- In the U.S. you have constitutional protections from censorship by the government only.

So what you are saying is that the government can't shut you up, but that private citizens can?

Are you sure that's how it works in practice?

As for the 'banning' of 'racist and/or pro-Nazi speech'....on the surface in the UK and elsewhere I see grounds where some speech touches on race within an 'incitement to violence' context and I agree with action being taken on those grounds.

However, the problem is that once you have these realities on the books it's open to massive abuse....political agendas work to identify all speech they can crowbar in as 'racist' or 'Nazi' speech as a method of intimating people and closing down opposite opinions.

You have people in the US doing this now....that guy standing up and saying that 29 percent of America are Nazis and that it means that we can fight them and win.

It's loony tunes central in parts of America.

Edited by Stirlingsays (21 Aug 2017 9.17pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Page 15 of 30 < 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Confederate Statues