This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| croydon proud |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
Get JRM on there too and tell him to commute to Kigali for work every day. What about nanny?
|
|
| croydon proud |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
Rwanda are enjoying themselves anyway. Their government seems quite proactive. The estate agents and car dealerships are doing a thriving business with government officials alone, as one said, its win win!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Behind Enemy Lines
Also interesting that an EU country is controlling it's own immigration policy...
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Also interesting that an EU country is controlling it's own immigration policy... Maybe they don’t have so many do-Gooders
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
On this I agree Climate change will drive mass migration, no doubt. And it will almost certainly get nasty But this is simply fiddling whilst Rome burns. The approach has to be long term strategic, not short term tactical. And part of that has to be make life more attractive in countries that will export large numbers. I am sure you agree that the huge reduction in UK aid last year is deeply regrettable. And that action on climate is of the highest priority I agree. As I previously said, the Rwandan issue, which I don’t think will happen, is being introduced as a long term deterrent against illegal immigration and people smuggling.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
On this I agree Climate change will drive mass migration, no doubt. And it will almost certainly get nasty But this is simply fiddling whilst Rome burns. The approach has to be long term strategic, not short term tactical. And part of that has to be make life more attractive in countries that will export large numbers. I am sure you agree that the huge reduction in UK aid last year is deeply regrettable. And that action on climate is of the highest priority Making countries more attractive to stay in as in what exactly? I doubt anything we do will halt the inevitable natural climate change, regardless of any human effect. On top of that, we will add to the problem and exhaust the world's resources quicker if we make poorer countries more developed. The answer is for all First World countries to rewrite the book on migration so that international law protects its own citizens above migrants. The problem is that policy is being driven by the elites who could not care a hoot for the future of us plebeians. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (13 Jun 2022 6.04pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
They get heavily criticised at home but the news does not seem to make it abroad. They have basically stated they don't want asylum seekers at all, due to the abuse of the system. They have also had the usual problem of Islamification - where they are taking a tough approach too. It's an interesting example. Kind of closing the door after the horse has bolted by about twenty to thirty years.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
The argument that says that part of a solution is to, ' And part of that has to be make life more attractive in countries that will export large numbers' isn't common sense. The more you increase the standard of living in third world countries all you do in increase the numbers who can afford to emigrate....which will mainly be that country's middle class and is just a further brain drain....which again, works against improving that country. Most logical people, who aren't basically pro immigration, who think through that line of logic would reach that conclusion. I certainly agree that the west should help the third world and that actually has been happening over decades. Even though most of those countries have more than enough resources and human capital to be fully functioning without outside help. However, it is not the responsibility of countries to do that, it is purely a humanitarian humanistic response. I support that humanistic help, but not at the cost of giving away historical birth rights.....which this country has treated like confetti for decades....using the pyramid scheme of population increase The answer to the immigration problem has always been the same. Robustly defended borders that deport people who shouldn't be here and so defeat the enemies that believe in the global village. The conservatives have been in power for most of post war Britain and any Tory supporter who actually thinks that they want anything other than the global village just hasn't been really been taking note. Edited by Stirlingsays (13 Jun 2022 6.23pm) I have become used to you claiming things are self evident without any research I am not like that so here’s some.
1. The international community needs to acknowledge formally the predicament of forced climate migrants. While it is not clear that an expanded definition of a refugee under international law that included environmental degradation as a “valid” driver of displacement would lead to net benefits for all (traditional and environmental) refugees, some kind of international recognition is required to cement the issue on the international agenda. 2. Development and adaptation policies in potential source countries of forced climate migrants need to focus on reducing people’s vulnerability to climate change, moving people away from marginal areas and supporting livelihoods that are more resilient. In particular more efficient use of existing resources would offset some of the predicted impacts of climate change. In pakistan, for example, irrigated agriculture uses 85 per cent of the country’s fresh water supply but leakage and evaporation means that it is only 50 to 65 per cent efficient. . A great deal more research is needed to understand the causes and consequen- ces of climate migration and to monitor numbers. Practitioners, meanwhile, should develop better communication and working relationships between the different human rights, population, environmental and migration organizations that share a mandate to respond to population displacement. 4. Finally, the international community needs to help generate incentives to keep skilled labour in developing countries but also to allow developing countries to capitalize on the benefits that fluid labour markets can bring. The international regulation of labour migration, adaptation to climate change and capacity building in vulnerable countries are inherently intertwined. Migration will be used by some households in vulnerable countries as a means of adapting to climate change. Clearly there has to be a balance of policies that promotes the incentives for workers to stay in their home countries whilst not closing the door of international labour mobility.
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
Much in life relates to accident of birth and the particular resources that are under your feet (Prisoners of Geography is a good read). And of course getting a fair rate for those resources rather than middle men or other nations or interests worming their way in. Just an interesting tangent to ponder. I'd never blame anyone for trying to make a better life for themselves, but agree that countries should form their own strategies and consensus for how best to deal with that. Ultimately the government view should largely reflect that of the people. That's clearly not happening, but really when you look at most areas of life the government policy rarely reflects anything that's people focused. Unfortunately they're there to control us, and throw us the odd bone as part of the illusion of having a choice, rather than to actually give us a leg up in life. When you realise that get on with making your own luck, as they say. Whilst I agree with your first paragraph, I am surprised at the second. To my mind, the government view should be what they believe is in the best interests of the people, and never to simply reflect the people's view. If the people don't like the result, then they have complete control over who they elect to be in the next government. They just need to exercise that control. We don't send delegates to Parliament, we send representatives to do the consultations, research and hold debates that we neither have the time nor opportunity to do ourselves. The people are far too heavily influenced by groups with vested interests, like the Mail, Sun, FB groups etc, for that to be a sensible way to set policy. The government don't exist to control us. Their survival depends on us, so they need to show they are capable of serving our needs.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Whilst I agree with your first paragraph, I am surprised at the second. To my mind, the government view should be what they believe is in the best interests of the people, and never to simply reflect the people's view. If the people don't like the result, then they have complete control over who they elect to be in the next government. They just need to exercise that control. We don't send delegates to Parliament, we send representatives to do the consultations, research and hold debates that we neither have the time nor opportunity to do ourselves. The people are far too heavily influenced by groups with vested interests, like the Mail, Sun, FB groups etc, for that to be a sensible way to set policy. The government don't exist to control us. Their survival depends on us, so they need to show they are capable of serving our needs. Different opinions are available.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Whilst I agree with your first paragraph, I am surprised at the second. To my mind, the government view should be what they believe is in the best interests of the people, and never to simply reflect the people's view. If the people don't like the result, then they have complete control over who they elect to be in the next government. They just need to exercise that control. We don't send delegates to Parliament, we send representatives to do the consultations, research and hold debates that we neither have the time nor opportunity to do ourselves. The people are far too heavily influenced by groups with vested interests, like the Mail, Sun, FB groups etc, for that to be a sensible way to set policy. The government don't exist to control us. Their survival depends on us, so they need to show they are capable of serving our needs. In an ideal world where they had no other motive but to genuinely represent the will of their people, 'and' the process of doing so resulted in those who are at least a fairly good fit for that role doing so, I would completely agree with you. However, we see the various influences in and swirling around politics that have nothing to do our own (corporate etc), and those who often rise through the ranks are the Eton crowd and the likes, thoroughly detached from normal life and people. I'm not saying that direct democracy is a great idea either as people flip this way and that so that would come with its own problems. However, due to self interest ,political circles end up being more about looking after their own interests and propping up a system that works for them, than they do about the people. So I don't expect them to be lockstep with the voter at all times, but enough that so very many dont come to see it as a rigged game. Maybe PR or a different voting sytem would shake things up a bit, because right now it's a two horse race and so people often vote accordingly. Edited by BlueJay (14 Jun 2022 12.16am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
I have become used to you claiming things are self evident without any research I am not like that so here’s some.
1. The international community needs to acknowledge formally the predicament of forced climate migrants. While it is not clear that an expanded definition of a refugee under international law that included environmental degradation as a “valid” driver of displacement would lead to net benefits for all (traditional and environmental) refugees, some kind of international recognition is required to cement the issue on the international agenda. 2. Development and adaptation policies in potential source countries of forced climate migrants need to focus on reducing people’s vulnerability to climate change, moving people away from marginal areas and supporting livelihoods that are more resilient. In particular more efficient use of existing resources would offset some of the predicted impacts of climate change. In pakistan, for example, irrigated agriculture uses 85 per cent of the country’s fresh water supply but leakage and evaporation means that it is only 50 to 65 per cent efficient. . A great deal more research is needed to understand the causes and consequen- ces of climate migration and to monitor numbers. Practitioners, meanwhile, should develop better communication and working relationships between the different human rights, population, environmental and migration organizations that share a mandate to respond to population displacement. 4. Finally, the international community needs to help generate incentives to keep skilled labour in developing countries but also to allow developing countries to capitalize on the benefits that fluid labour markets can bring. The international regulation of labour migration, adaptation to climate change and capacity building in vulnerable countries are inherently intertwined. Migration will be used by some households in vulnerable countries as a means of adapting to climate change. Clearly there has to be a balance of policies that promotes the incentives for workers to stay in their home countries whilst not closing the door of international labour mobility. Sorry comrade? I think you missed the door leading to global government a few turnings ago. Are you trolling me or something? It doesn't address the issues I raised anyway other than waffle away like a Instagram girl's wishlist. Sending me a lot of waffle about what the 'International community' (international elites) want....meaning that should dictate national policy. Have you heard of something called Brexit? Seems you still have some wax in your ears from 2016. Out of respect I won't say exactly what I think of that text, but let me assure you it wouldn't be out of charm school. Edited by Stirlingsays (14 Jun 2022 12.48am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
In an ideal world where they had no other motive but to genuinely represent the will of their people, 'and' the process of doing so resulted in those who are at least a fairly good fit for that role doing so, I would completely agree with you. However, we see the various influences in and swirling around politics that have nothing to do our own (corporate etc), and those who often rise through the ranks are the Eton crowd and the likes, thoroughly detached from normal life and people. I'm not saying that direct democracy is a great idea either as people flip this way and that so that would come with its own problems. However, due to self interest ,political circles end up being more about looking after their own interests and propping up a system that works for them, than they do about the people. So I don't expect them to be lockstep with the voter at all times, but enough that so very many dont come to see it as a rigged game. Maybe PR or a different voting sytem would shake things up a bit, because right now it's a two horse race and so people often vote accordingly. Edited by BlueJay (14 Jun 2022 12.16am) The problem with Burke's view is that it dates from 250 years ago. There was no need for MPs to reflect the opinion of the population when 97% of them didn't have the vote.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
The problem with Burke's view is that it dates from 250 years ago. There was no need for MPs to reflect the opinion of the population when 97% of them didn't have the vote. It was also one's man's opinion just because it is old doesn't mean it is right. He was also writing at a time when political parties were in their infancy. He did not believe in full democracy because he felt only certain people were capable of governing. In other words his ideal government was a small group of elites who made decisions on behalf of the rest of us and for our own good. Luckily that never happened
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
It was also one's man's opinion just because it is old doesn't mean it is right. He was also writing at a time when political parties were in their infancy. He did not believe in full democracy because he felt only certain people were capable of governing. In other words his ideal government was a small group of elites who made decisions on behalf of the rest of us and for our own good. Luckily that never happened Err...yes; that is lucky...
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
In an ideal world where they had no other motive but to genuinely represent the will of their people, 'and' the process of doing so resulted in those who are at least a fairly good fit for that role doing so, I would completely agree with you. However, we see the various influences in and swirling around politics that have nothing to do our own (corporate etc), and those who often rise through the ranks are the Eton crowd and the likes, thoroughly detached from normal life and people. I'm not saying that direct democracy is a great idea either as people flip this way and that so that would come with its own problems. However, due to self interest ,political circles end up being more about looking after their own interests and propping up a system that works for them, than they do about the people. So I don't expect them to be lockstep with the voter at all times, but enough that so very many dont come to see it as a rigged game. Maybe PR or a different voting sytem would shake things up a bit, because right now it's a two horse race and so people often vote accordingly. Edited by BlueJay (14 Jun 2022 12.16am) I am certainly in favour of PR and for more people to be engaged and believing that their vote counts. It may well arrive after the next GE.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I am certainly in favour of PR and for more people to be engaged and believing that their vote counts. It may well arrive after the next GE. It doesn't particularly work in Ireland. Endless bodge job coalitions. Our current one is the two main rival parties who were always in power, now together in power along with the greens. Somebody will probably go in with Sinn Fein next time.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.