This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Willo
It is a fact that Boris Johnson was the choice of the members in 2019 and he has been removed by the Parliamentary Party without referral to the membership. Edited by Willo (20 Jul 2022 6.39pm) I am back from a largely politics, and a completely Hol, free week, so have only just read the above. The idea that Johnson's removal ought to have been referred to the Tory Party membership staggers me in its arrogance. Who do these people think they are? That nobody else reacted to it, I also find concerning, as though this attitude is acceptable. The task of any political party's membership must surely be limited to the selection of the candidate who will represent them in each constituency. The electorate then decide who represents them in Parliament. The candidate at that point becomes an MP, and the representative of all the people in the constituency. They are not sent to Parliament as delegates of the Tory, Labour or any other Party. Together they constitute our Parliament, with a Government formed by a group able to command the confidence of the House, whether from one party, or a coalition. The PM leads that Government. The decision of who will be the PM is therefore solely the task of Parliament. Lose the confidence, and someone must be found who has it. This is why I find it totally offensive that the Tory Party membership will determine who becomes the PM, and not the MPs. No group of activists, outside our sovereign Parliament, should possess such power. It now seems probable that the Tory MPs, who know the issues and the candidates much better than anyone else, prefer Sunak, but the Tory membership will go for Truss. It's nonsensical and highly offensive to every voter, outside the tiny core of activists. Whilst neither candidate fills me with any great optimism, the idea of Liz Truss as PM appals me. She is really dim and is trotting out populist sugar when hard realities need to be faced and the people told the truth. We need leadership, not another PM desperate to become leader for their own vanity. Leaving it to the MPs makes it much more likely that we would get what we need, and not just what a tiny bunch of activists want.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
British politics has gone from world renowned to world ridiculed. Well done MPs of all the so called parties. Truly bottom dwellers and eaters of poo. Pretty much. Meritocracy, as delivered, isn't working properly. Edited by Stirlingsays (27 Jul 2022 2.01pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| W12 27 Jul 22 2.33pm | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I am back from a largely politics, and a completely Hol, free week, so have only just read the above. The idea that Johnson's removal ought to have been referred to the Tory Party membership staggers me in its arrogance. Who do these people think they are? That nobody else reacted to it, I also find concerning, as though this attitude is acceptable. The task of any political party's membership must surely be limited to the selection of the candidate who will represent them in each constituency. The electorate then decide who represents them in Parliament. The candidate at that point becomes an MP, and the representative of all the people in the constituency. They are not sent to Parliament as delegates of the Tory, Labour or any other Party. Together they constitute our Parliament, with a Government formed by a group able to command the confidence of the House, whether from one party, or a coalition. The PM leads that Government. The decision of who will be the PM is therefore solely the task of Parliament. Lose the confidence, and someone must be found who has it. This is why I find it totally offensive that the Tory Party membership will determine who becomes the PM, and not the MPs. No group of activists, outside our sovereign Parliament, should possess such power. It now seems probable that the Tory MPs, who know the issues and the candidates much better than anyone else, prefer Sunak, but the Tory membership will go for Truss. It's nonsensical and highly offensive to every voter, outside the tiny core of activists. Whilst neither candidate fills me with any great optimism, the idea of Liz Truss as PM appals me. She is really dim and is trotting out populist sugar when hard realities need to be faced and the people told the truth. We need leadership, not another PM desperate to become leader for their own vanity. Leaving it to the MPs makes it much more likely that we would get what we need, and not just what a tiny bunch of activists want. That's simply not true because most Tory members would have voted for Kemi Badenoch as she was the only candidate remotely conservative. Now they have a choice between (1) a member of the World Economic Forum and (2) .....a member of the World Economic Forum. At least in the next election the public will get the choice to vote for someone who is a member of the Trilateral Commission.
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
Why, oh why, could people possibly want Johnson back with his deplorable record? 'Every day for Johnson is a different performance - William Haigh.' The public are no longer being entertained - they miss the Archie Rice of politics bringing blustering chaos it's endearing for some reason. As for Starmer, well he is not making ridiculous promises that he cannot keep. He is probably quite able, but it is a bore, isn't it, the public need incompetence on a grand scale. Well they got it and it serves them right.
He's managed the astounding feat of being an even more boring figure than Gordon Brown....but without Brown's skepticism over the EU. He was literally a large part of giving the Tories an 80 seat majority due to his unrelenting zeal for overturning Brexit I can't personally see any evidence for competence at all. He couldn't see what was right in front of him....such poor instincts aren't a good portent. He only stands out amongst Labour because their standards are so poor. Even on the grooming gangs alone I just fail to see how anyone can really support Labour today. It really says something that Labour fans will deride Johnson's behaviour yet have some sort of blindness for the behaviour of their own administrations up and down the country. The seriousness of which isn't even close....their collective incompetency and negligence enabled the rape of tens of thousands of girls. Johnson has double standards but it's not in the same ballpark. Edited by Stirlingsays (27 Jul 2022 3.06pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by W12
That's simply not true because most Tory members would have voted for Kemi Badenoch as she was the only candidate remotely conservative. Now they have a choice between (1) a member of the World Economic Forum and (2) .....a member of the World Economic Forum. At least in the next election the public will get the choice to vote for someone who is a member of the Trilateral Commission. The Tory members are making the final decision. The current system is ridiculous and makes the MPs have to play games to try to make sure the membership aren't able to vote in someone they could not accept at all. It is as bad as the Labour Party being dominated by the Unions and Momentum. As soon as activists are allowed to dominate political parties, they swing to the extremes, which is not where most voters want them to be. The Party that is able to restrain this, and stay in touch with the moderate voter, will win elections. Being at the WEF is a wholly positive and sensible thing for every politician. Hearing first hand what others in positions of responsibility around the world are thinking about the many problems we face is essential. Edited by Wisbech Eagle (27 Jul 2022 3.10pm)
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
| W12 27 Jul 22 4.34pm | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
The Tory members are making the final decision. The current system is ridiculous and makes the MPs have to play games to try to make sure the membership aren't able to vote in someone they could not accept at all. It is as bad as the Labour Party being dominated by the Unions and Momentum. As soon as activists are allowed to dominate political parties, they swing to the extremes, which is not where most voters want them to be. The Party that is able to restrain this, and stay in touch with the moderate voter, will win elections. Being at the WEF is a wholly positive and sensible thing for every politician. Hearing first hand what others in positions of responsibility around the world are thinking about the many problems we face is essential. Edited by Wisbech Eagle (27 Jul 2022 3.10pm) What you class as "moderate" is basically the status quo. Most people are unhappy with that because the current system does not work for them hence the rise of populism (which is just "what most people want" ). The wealth gap gets ever wider at an ever increasing rate, the middle class is being destroyed along with small businesses, many people are sick/overweight through bad food and pharmaceuticals and/or unhappy because they have no sense of meaning or connection and live their life for the next purchase. All this is happening at the hands of governments, central banks, media and corporations (energy /food production/pharmaceutical/military industrial etc) and our choices not to participate is this system are being systematically removed by ever increasing draconian legislation enforced by surveillance and control. The fact you simply can't see it is really your problem. Edited by W12 (27 Jul 2022 5.31pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
All too bright for me mate. You do yourself a disservice, sir.
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) |
|
|
Originally posted by YT
You do yourself a disservice, sir. I tip my hat YT.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by W12
What you class as "moderate" is basically the status quo. Most people are unhappy with that because the current system does not work for them hence the rise of populism (which is just "what most people want" ). The wealth gap gets ever wider at an ever increasing rate, the middle class is being destroyed along with small businesses, many people are sick/overweight through bad food and pharmaceuticals and/or unhappy because they have no sense of meaning or connection and live their life for the next purchase. All this is happening at the hands of governments, central banks, media and corporations (energy /food production/pharmaceutical/military industrial etc) and our choices not to participate is this system are being systematically removed by ever increasing draconian legislation enforced by surveillance and control. The fact you simply can't see it is really your problem. Edited by W12 (27 Jul 2022 5.31pm) This is nonsense, which I suppose is only to be expected given its source. Moderate politics has nothing to do with the status quo! You can see the need for change from a "moderate" perspective, at least as well as from any other, probably better. Seeing the need for tolerance, compromise and respect and to do things with careful thought, good management and trying to bring everyone along with persuasive argument doesn't mean no change. Or, indeed, for decisive and urgent change. Taking a consistent middle road, with no wild swings from left to right, consuming time and energy when making corrections by one side or the other, is much more efficient and ultimately delivers a better result. You can see the benefits all over Europe. Populism is not just "what most people want". People want good government. They might think they want something else, but when you scratch below the surface, most people aren't stupid. They know 2 +2 = 4, and money doesn't grow on trees. Populism is pandering to instant gratification and the desire to win and hold onto office. It serves only the politicians who use it. That the wealth gap is continuing to widen is undoubtably true, but not because of some conspiracy involving governments, business, the media, food suppliers, pharma and central bankers. Having just returned from a week's holiday, my first abroad since Brexit, and visiting Spain, France and Italy during my trip, the contrast between the average citizen in those countries and ourselves is stark. They might be living with "ever increasing draconian legislation enforced by surveillance and control" but they look fitter, appear better educated, are more polite and respectful, have better behaved children, eat more sensibly and seem generally happier. They are doing something right, which we aren't. You want to blame some illogical groups who are only trying to operate within the boundaries we set for them. I blame Brexit and the Eurosceptics among us. The fact you simply can't see it is really your problem.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
British politics has gone from world renowned to world ridiculed. Well done MPs of all the so called parties. Truly bottom dwellers and eaters of poo. It has, but don't blame the MPs, nor the electorate, who can only vote for who is put in front of them. Blame the system by which the candidates are selected, and then the first past the post system. We need a root and branch overhaul, and the introduction of PR to set ourselves on a path of recovery. One which I am too old to see any benefit from, but my grandchildren might.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Along with many many changes to how society functions if I had the the fantasy option of deciding how party leadership selections worked I'd have a universal system independent of what mainstream party it was. I would pretty much invert how the selection works. I would have the membership deciding the last two and the MPs selecting from them....as it is the elites essentially decide the limited choices. I would also give the wider country a say.....On the day of the membership choice I'd allow an online vote, where the country's vote on the candidates had a....say 30 percent affect on the candidates. Though the voting rules would obviously have to be water tight. I think that would be far more democratic and balanced than present systems.
Establishing a Commission to look at this and then enact changes makes perfect sense to me. What we have now simply doesn't work and is producing a disaster for us all. I don't agree with your system, which I don't think has really been thought through. MPs aren't "elites". We choose them, so we can also reject them. They act for us, and not for themselves. Should they forget that, then they risk their own future.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Establishing a Commission to look at this and then enact changes makes perfect sense to me. What we have now simply doesn't work and is producing a disaster for us all. I don't agree with your system, which I don't think has really been thought through. MPs aren't "elites". We choose them, so we can also reject them. They act for us, and not for themselves. Should they forget that, then they risk their own future. Well I'm not exactly writing a white paper on it but it's my 'shooting the breeze' take on it. MPs are certainly a tier of elites, not at the top but a sub tier form of elites. This idea that people get a choice of MP is nonsense. They get a choice of candidates pre-selected as acceptable by that party's system, which is no different to the Chinese system. Edited by Stirlingsays (27 Jul 2022 7.33pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Well I'm not exactly writing a white paper on it but it's my 'shooting the breeze' take on it. MPs are certainly a tier of elites, not at the top but a sub tier form of elites. This idea that people get a choice of MP is nonsense. They get a choice of candidates pre-selected as acceptable by that party's system, which is no different to the Chinese system. Edited by Stirlingsays (27 Jul 2022 7.33pm) Neither of us are writing a white paper. This needs some careful study and to then convince some Turkeys to vote for Christmas. I realise that central offices try to parachute their preferred voting sheep into seats, but it is still the local parties that make the choice. My own MP, who is a Tory, is very local, has strong connections with the area, and works hard. She has helped me a lot, writing to Ministers on my behalf. I have a meeting with her in a few weeks time. This local connection I want to see as the normal. I want to see the Party an MP belongs to become less relevant than their character. David Penhaligon was the local MP for 12 years, local and hugely popular amongst voters of every party. He happened to be a Liberal and could easily have led them had he not died in a car accident. We cannot avoid the party system completely, but I want to see Parliament asserting its authority when it chooses to do so, and not allowing itself to be whipped quite so readily by the party machines. I favour PR, with smaller parties gaining representation through a single transferrable vote. Doubtless coalitions would result, but these would have the benefit of stopping large variations in approach happening.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
It has, but don't blame the MPs, nor the electorate, who can only vote for who is put in front of them. Blame the system by which the candidates are selected, and then the first past the post system. We need a root and branch overhaul, and the introduction of PR to set ourselves on a path of recovery. One which I am too old to see any benefit from, but my grandchildren might. But the system in place is that preferred by those we supposedly elect to make decisions for us.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.