This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by rawpalace05
I'm always up for being open minded and sticking up for those who seem to take the brunt of criticism, however this post has sent me over the edge. Why do you bother? Nothing better to do. Quite sad. I almost feel sorry for him.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by ParchmoreEagle
This is my belief too. Look how ridiculous Hodgson was with England. Honestly, some institutions are so well run that the man at the top is just a figurehead. I'm not saying Mourinho and such can't do a job, but unless they transform crap teams into gold ones like Sam and his like does then I'm not going to be convinced. I'm more and more convinced that Silva may be the man, but his zonal marking and Hull's woeful goals conceded need to be addressed with him. Basically, if he is no good on keeping clean sheets then I'd rather Dyche or someone else. BTW, someone needs to explain to me about zonal marking, because I've heard somewhere that Silva had a good defensive record. Was this him employing zonal marking? Is there a zonal marking strategy that, when done well, is better than man-2-man? I'm going to google it now. A good question and I'd like to know the answer. Personally I see no pros to zonal marking but maybe that's just me be uneducated on it
|
|
|
Originally posted by ParchmoreEagle
This is my belief too. Look how ridiculous Hodgson was with England. Honestly, some institutions are so well run that the man at the top is just a figurehead. I'm not saying Mourinho and such can't do a job, but unless they transform crap teams into gold ones like Sam and his like does then I'm not going to be convinced. I'm more and more convinced that Silva may be the man, but his zonal marking and Hull's woeful goals conceded need to be addressed with him. Basically, if he is no good on keeping clean sheets then I'd rather Dyche or someone else. BTW, someone needs to explain to me about zonal marking, because I've heard somewhere that Silva had a good defensive record. Was this him employing zonal marking? Is there a zonal marking strategy that, when done well, is better than man-2-man? I'm going to google it now. I could go on and on about 'Zonal marking' but it would de-rail this thread. Yesterday the name of 'Garry Monk' was brought up in speculation about our vacancy.At Leeds when they were defending corners he had his best headers not marking man-to-man but free as they could get blocked off when trying to attack the ball.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I could go on and on about 'Zonal marking' but it would de-rail this thread. Yesterday the name of 'Garry Monk' was brought up in speculation about our vacancy.At Leeds when they were defending corners he had his best headers not marking man-to-man but free as they could get blocked off when trying to attack the ball. But then surely this puts the attacking player at an advantage because they're either a) open or b) being marked by a weaker header of the ball which would mean more chance of winning a second ball
|
|
|
Originally posted by AshfordEagle94
But then surely this puts the attacking player at an advantage because they're either a) open or b) being marked by a weaker header of the ball which would mean more chance of winning a second ball 'Zonal marking' is based on the principle that when free-kicks are taken in the attacking third in wide positions or from corners, there is a dangerous space where goals are scored fom the first touch. Team who employ 'Zonal marking' deploy the best headers of the ball in that space with other players in positions to defend the second ball. 'Zonal marking' is a collective responsibility as opposed to man-to-man marking which is down to individuals picking up players they are designated to mark. And as I mentioned in another post, some Teams deploy a combination of both zonal and man-to-man marking. Anyway this is getting away from the subject matter of this thread.
|
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Willo
'Zonal marking' is based on the principle that when free-kicks are taken in the attacking third in wide positions or from corners, there is a dangerous space where goals are scored fom the first touch. Team who employ 'Zonal marking' deploy the best headers of the ball in that space with other players in positions to defend the second ball. 'Zonal marking' is a collective responsibility as opposed to man-to-man marking which is down to individuals picking up players they are designated to mark. And as I mentioned in another post, some Teams deploy a combination of both zonal and man-to-man marking. Anyway this is getting away from the subject matter of this thread. Not really, because it's one of the issues with Silva. I think managers and teams that resort to zonal marking without due aforethought are being lazy and are taking a risk, as one player thinks an opponent leaving his "zone" is being handed over to another but these handoffs are not managed. All a player like Benteke has to do is move about enough and he can find himself in acres of space. If Silva thinks he can improve our defence by making it use zonal marking all the time he is IMHO wrong and could be a disaster. Whether he is of that mind I don't know.
============ |
|
|
FYP have tweeted Marco Silva is to be our next manager on a two year contract, anyone else seeing this?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Dan89
They don't but it's about ambition. Do you really think Zaha will sign a new deal with silva in charge because I highly doubt it. Bet you wish you had a bit of hindsight? Don't need a manager in place, just dangle a financial carrot.
|
|
|
Originally posted by rollercoaster
I guess the crux of what Willo is saying (but not put very well in my opinion) is, is it better to recruit a tired failed premier league manager or do we go for a fresh successful manager from the lower divisions or from Europe? The Silva discussion comes down to: do we think Silva is a failed prem manager for relegating Hull or a successful one for getting them close. I suppose also is a few months in the Prem adequate experience to judge? Given my argument I draw the conclusion that the Fulham manager would be a better choice because he is a success now and he managed Watford successfully. Edited by rollercoaster (26 May 2017 11.49am) He actually got Watford promoted into the PL - Qualities which we might need if (God forbid) we are relegated !
|
|
|
Originally posted by lefty27
FYP have tweeted Marco Silva is to be our next manager on a two year contract, anyone else seeing this? Wouldn't be surprised at all.
|
|
| palace99 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I see all the speculation about certian managers going here and there and they are all 'Name' managers. I look at someone who hasn't had a mention on here - step forward Derek Adams of Plymouth.He did a terrific job at Ross Co on a 'Shoestring' getting them promotion to the Scottish league and just missing out on Europe by a point. In his first season at Plymouth, having signed 'Loanees' and 'Frees' he led them to the play-off final where they lost to AFC Wimbledon.Last pre-season they lost a lot of players yet Adams signed a load of 'Frees' and they got promotion to Division One. This is what I call real achievement, NOT winning the league at Olympiakos and the cup at Sporting.I accept winning league/Cup is commendable but I look at the 'Bigger picture'.Rest assured I'm not being critical of Silva, just saying that his achievements have been 'Over-stated' by many on here.This is my main point, not a strident criticism of Silva. Edited by Willo (26 May 2017 8.38am) you are forgetting Silva's achievement of getting a small 2nd div club promoted to the top flight in Portugal earning him the Sporting job. Surely that should be mentioned when you look at the bigger picture too
|
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by lefty27
FYP have tweeted Marco Silva is to be our next manager on a two year contract, anyone else seeing this? Nope.
============ |
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
He actually got Watford promoted into the PL - Qualities which we might need if (God forbid) we are relegated ! Worry about that if and when it happens then
Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan |
|
|
Originally posted by lefty27
FYP have tweeted Marco Silva is to be our next manager on a two year contract, anyone else seeing this? Odds still 6/4 so go and make some money if you believe it.
|
|
|
Originally posted by palace99
you are forgetting Silva's achievement of getting a small 2nd div club promoted to the top flight in Portugal earning him the Sporting job. Surely that should be mentioned when you look at the bigger picture too No I didn't forget about Estoril. Was focussing on his league and cup honours. Please accept that I am NOT "Dissing" his achievements, justing putting them into perspective in relation to the "Real deal" adulation he is receiving. IF he is appointed I will of course wish him all the very best and hope that he wins honours with us.I just happen to think that any honours he wins with us will surpass what he has achieved to-date in Portugal and Greece.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Dancer Cat
I'm not getting excited until it's announced officially. Palace have a "rap sheet" for "being linked" with promising managers, They spend far too much time gauging opinion on HOL, BBS and TWITTER !!!!
Edited by Willo (26 May 2017 12.02pm)
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.