You are here: Home > Message Board > Gold Talk > Creation vs. Evolution Debate
November 19 2026 5.42pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Creation vs. Evolution Debate


Page 17 of 18 < 13 14 15 16 17 18 >
eryr Flag Caerphillydelphia 10 Jan 05 4.01pm

Matt, though completely differing from you views on the topic, I respect your right to air them and recognise you have true conviction in your beliefs. I find however your dismissive attitudes to other religions, particularly Islam, as breathtaking. It's little wonder that the Islamic world views the Christian West with such disdain and suspicion if your vision of Christianity is the norm. With western leaders like Bush and Blair, both arguably Christian fundamentalists , espousing secularism in the Islamic world whilst pursuing Christian agendas at home, is it any wonder?

 


Dulce et decorum est pro Palace mori

"Gee, you and I oughtta get on swell Mister Burton, as we're both Selts".
"No, I am a Selt. You are a Sunt."

"24 hours in a day, 24 beers in a case. Coincidence? I think not." ~ Stephen Wright

[Link]

mattwebb Flag Sutton 10 Jan 05 4.17pm

I don't understand, what views am I supposed to have?

Must I ignore the evil verses in the Koran, just to be politically correct?

How can I say I respect what Muslims believe, when I know the evil in their book?

I could be all fake for you if you like, but what does that achieve, yeah maybe more people would like me, but having read the Koran I couldn't do that in good conscience.

 

rach_cpfc Flag South Croydon 10 Jan 05 4.35pm

Personally, I realise I have more in common spiritually with those of other religions than with those of none.
That doesn't mean I think they're right, it does mean I've had very peaceful yet thought-provoking discussions.
Re. religious diffences causing conflict, I think I've said something similar before, but I'll say it again:
To my knowledge, all religions carry a message of peace, not violence. It is not the religions being evil that cause war, but people being evil and using a religion as a banner to fight their war under.
People support all manor of different football teams, yet very few of those choose to display those differences with acts of violence, and those that do tend to be dispaired of by the peaceful majority. It's the same for those of different religions (only, a little more serious in their differences, I grant you!!)

 


"....They will soar on wings like EAGLES; they will run and not grow
weary, they will walk and not be faint."

kav Flag The Helicopter View 10 Jan 05 4.39pm

At this point can I just say that there is cake and a nice pot ot tea in the living room for everyone.

 


Everytime I get high I lay my head on my baby's breasts

mattwebb Flag Sutton 10 Jan 05 4.45pm

eh?

 

eryr Flag Caerphillydelphia 10 Jan 05 4.49pm

Quote kav at 10 Jan 2005 4:39pm

At this point can I just say that there is cake and a nice pot ot tea in the living room for everyone.


Is that Christian tea from Sri Lanka, Hindi/Islamic tea from India or Buddhist tea from China?

 


Dulce et decorum est pro Palace mori

"Gee, you and I oughtta get on swell Mister Burton, as we're both Selts".
"No, I am a Selt. You are a Sunt."

"24 hours in a day, 24 beers in a case. Coincidence? I think not." ~ Stephen Wright

[Link]

Moose Flag In the sewer pipe... 10 Jan 05 5.13pm

Quote mattwebb at 10 Jan 2005 2:13pm
The dinosaurs died out in a world wide flood, (other species were on the ark so survived) and other animals have died out because of natural selection, as we discussed earlier, and the majority because of human interference.

I'm no expert in archaeology or paelentology, but are you suggesting here that dinosaurs and humans co-existed on the earth, and dinosurs were wiped out in Noah's flood?

(BTW, Matt, despite our obvious differences in opinion I think you're doing bloody well trying to keep your end up here!)

 


Goodness is what you do. Not who you pray to.

mattwebb Flag Sutton 10 Jan 05 5.20pm

The only reason scientists dont think that humans co-existed with dinosaurs is because they haven't found any fossils, which in their massively flawed dating process are aged the same time as dinosaurs.

Yes I totally believe we co-existed with dinosaurs, cave paitings and drawings from this time suggest that humans shared with dinosaurs.

There is NO PROOF, that we didn't.

 

IMpalace Flag London 10 Jan 05 7.36pm

Mattwebb, may i ask two things.

Firstly, what 'evil' did you read in the Koran?

Secondly did you read it in Arabic (im guessing not) or the translation, which similar to the bible, struggles to actually translate it all correctly?

 

mattwebb Flag Sutton 11 Jan 05 9.17am

I have explained this before in another thread, and I don't really want to be drawn into this again.

I have read the Koran and I admit it was in an English translation, but do you suppose Osama Bin Laden uses the English translation?

 

peter_todd_ Flag Oxted 11 Jan 05 11.09am

apparently there is a new theory about this whole "how the world started" etc. They are saying that God made the Big Bang, thoughts anyone.

 

mattwebb Flag Sutton 11 Jan 05 11.11am

Type Theistic Evolution into Google and see what you come up with, there is also a thing called The Gap Theory, which may be of interest to some of you.

 

Bean Flag Ipswich 11 Jan 05 1.01pm

As i am an athiest, it is not up to me to prove the non-existence of God by for believers to prove his existence, which Matt is trying to do, and fair play to him.

Please remember that this is just my point of view, and no offence is meant.

However, if the Matt is unable to make a persuasive argument as to the existence of God (which i believe he cannot) then my beliefs in athiesm are justified.

I believe that i am a strong athiest, and therefore i have certain issues with the existence of God.

I cannot believe that an omniscient, onmipotent, and benevolent God can be in existence as our world is so full of evil and suffering.

If he is omniscient, then he KNOWS how to stop it, if he omnipotent then he is ABLE to stop it,
and if he is benevolent then he WANTS to stop it. So then, why does he do none of these things? Because he does not exist....

2. I have a problem with the doctrine of divine omnipotence, that God is all powerful, mainly because it is absurd, illogical, and impossible that any being can be Omnipotent. Therefore, God does not exist.

3. I also have a problem with omniscience, (God is all knowing), because God cannot possibly know everything, as this is illogical, and also inconsistent with Divine Impeccability the theory that God cannot sin), and is proved false by the existence of human freedom. Therefore, no God!

4. Divine justice is another area to look at. This conflicts with the idea that God is forgiveing. A just got sees that each person gets their just desserts, when a forgiving God sees that some peoples sins go unpunished.

Heaven and hell are unjust, if your sent to hell for one sin, how can it be justified that you stay there infinitly?

Surely punishment and reward should be proportionate to the goods and bads done by people, but the concept of heaven and hell means that its all or nothing.

5. The argument from autonomy is the argument that the existence of morally autonomous agents is inconsistent with the existence of God, and so that the fact that morally autonomous agents do exist disproves the existence of God. God, if he exists, is worthy of worship. If a being is truly worthy of worship, though, then he is entitled to our unconditional obedience. Moral agents, however, cannot be required to give unconditional obedience to any agent. Moral agency requires autonomy, and so the idea of a moral duty to give up one's autonomy is incoherent; in giving up one's autonomy one would cease to be a moral agent so would cease to have moral duties at all. We cannot, therefore, have a duty of unconditional obedience to any agent, and there therefore cannot be any agent that worthy of worship. There can therefore be no God.

Therefore, I can never agree with Matt, but well done for putting your opinions across.

 


Boys are Studpid, Throw Rocks at Them........

IMpalace Flag London 11 Jan 05 1.41pm

Quote mattwebb at 11 Jan 2005 9:17am

I have explained this before in another thread, and I don't really want to be drawn into this again.

I have read the Koran and I admit it was in an English translation, but do you suppose Osama Bin Laden uses the English translation?

That has to be one of the most blinded comments i have ever seen. Osama bin Laden has got f-all to do with the Koran mate. Just because some nutty terrorist tries to use Islam to his advantage, as a way of winning over many Muslims, doesn't mean the Koran contains evil in it. What do you think the Koran is TELLING Osama bin Laden to be a terrorist? Bit of a dosey comment if you ask me. Anyway im not really interested in getting in a long winded argument. Full marks to you for holding up your side of the argument for 20 or so pages mate.


 

Bean Flag Ipswich 11 Jan 05 3.17pm

i think interpretation is everything in these situations. every little tiny sentance can be twisted and interpreted to mean anything that the reader wants it to

 


Boys are Studpid, Throw Rocks at Them........

Petealiator Flag 1066 Country! 11 Jan 05 7.44pm

What's all this then? Is there some kind of debate going on?

 


My Rocksteady band...
[Link]
[Link]
IT'S NOT SKA, IT'S ROCKSTEADY!

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 11 Jan 05 7.59pm

Quote Petealiator at 11 Jan 2005 7:44pm

What's all this then? Is there some kind of debate going on?


Nah mate, it's nothing really. They must've all missed the real debate on the Mohammed thread I reckon!

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

mattwebb Flag Sutton 31 Jan 05 3.21pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Who created God?' by jcreedy

[Link]

this came up in the creation/evolution debate so I found somewhere that explains it quite well.

 

jcreedy Flag 31 Jan 05 3.23pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Who created God?' by jcreedy

God doesn't exist

 


It was my dream to play for Palace and to make my debut. I've always played for the club so if I'm playing here, I wouldn't want to be anywhere else.

- John Bostock (Nov 2007)

mattwebb Flag Sutton 31 Jan 05 3.26pm

I take it you read the link jcreedy?

 

Page 17 of 18 < 13 14 15 16 17 18 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Gold Talk > Creation vs. Evolution Debate