This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by cryrst
How many dead is a good number if we had not locked down. Protect the vulnerable and distancing being the methods.? How many would you think there would have been and would that number be acceptable to prevent the financial issues we may face. I think your personal situation is different just as the elderly should isolate as much as possible.....but outside of that it's not about acceptability it's about how we live. Why don't we have a speed limit of 25mph? We could reduce traffic deaths by huge amounts. Life is and has always been about risk and its management....but because we live in the 'Diana' age no one in power is willing to be the adult that spells that out. Instead of being politicians and taking decisions they will hide behind one set of 'expert advice'....craving certainty where none exists. Some might say....why not just get rid of the politicians then. The actions we have taken are definitely going to have a severe economic and life impact on the most vulnerable the longer we carry on. That's already going to be baked in now. Edited by Stirlingsays (19 Apr 2020 8.31pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
How many dead is a good number if we had not locked down. Protect the vulnerable and distancing being the methods.? How many would you think there would have been and would that number be acceptable to prevent the financial issues we may face. I do wonder how much we would have protected the elderly and vulnerable if everyone was at work and school as normal. I still wonder when everyone goes back, although there will be lots of regular local providers of groceries and prescriptions now that can continue. It’s just going to be much more difficult when lots of people go back to work. And don’t rely on supermarkets delivering to those who need a delivery. That didn’t last longer than a week before they reverted back to delivery slots for anyone lucky enough to get one, and at that point they order 3-4 weeks of cupboard food and booze, compared to the more likely small shop by many of the elderly and vulnerable, apart from of course the big wine drinking baby boomers and big families with a child during treatment or a low immune system. Twitter is full of people bragging or envious of people booking a delivery slot after all the supermarkets have done is politely ask customers to go to the shop and leave the delivery slots for those who need them. No, I do not believe the elderly and vulnerable would have been protected without a lockdown and many people have needed the lockdown to get some grasp of social distancing. Some still don’t get it or are bored of it. That’s mainly teenagers but they aren’t alone on this.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
I do wonder how much we would have protected the elderly and vulnerable if everyone was at work and school as normal. I still wonder when everyone goes back, although there will be lots of regular local providers of groceries and prescriptions now that can continue. It’s just going to be much more difficult when lots of people go back to work. And don’t rely on supermarkets delivering to those who need a delivery. That didn’t last longer than a week before they reverted back to delivery slots for anyone lucky enough to get one, and at that point they order 3-4 weeks of cupboard food and booze, compared to the more likely small shop by many of the elderly and vulnerable, apart from of course the big wine drinking baby boomers and big families with a child during treatment or a low immune system. Twitter is full of people bragging or envious of people booking a delivery slot after all the supermarkets have done is politely ask customers to go to the shop and leave the delivery slots for those who need them. No, I do not believe the elderly and vulnerable would have been protected without a lockdown and many people have needed the lockdown to get some grasp of social distancing. Some still don’t get it or are bored of it. That’s mainly teenagers but they aren’t alone on this. Psychology will play a part short to mid term. Awareness is going to stick for most with distancing etc.
|
|
| Tom-the-eagle |
|
|---|---|
|
"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
Looks like we are sleepwalking into another great depression. But this time we had a choice. I hope I'm entirely wrong. I remember well how poor we were at times in the past. Thought my kids would never have to live the way I had to but they could even face worse now. So exactly what were those choices? Do what was done and allow the NHS to seemingly just about cope, albeit under huge strain, a lack of resources and the losses of their staff? Or not do it. Maybe just isolate the very vulnerable, allow the children to go to school and most working age people to continue to work and hope they observed social distancing, or worked from home? Not close the shops, pubs or restaurants? Allow people to travel freely? Attend football matches wearing masks? The consequences of that would surely have seen the NHS overwhelmed, with even fewer staff than they have now, and the very real possibility that the whole system could have collapsed. The social unrest and fear that would follow such a scenario cannot be imagined. Nor could the economic impact, which is what those who advocate a different approach seem most concerned about. The actual scale of the economic impact can now only be guessed at. It may be a depression but not necessarily. It is not anyway in our hands alone. If our markets decline then so do we. If we conquer this as quickly as possible and then take the same kind of decisive action we did once we decided on the "lockdown" then we can recover. Not to where we were, because somethings are going to change for ever, but we can recover. It could even be better. Those of working age may have to work harder and longer than before and either be paid less or taxed more. Probably both. Those retired will see their pensions frozen or even cut. We will all have to adjust our life styles as a consequence. But we will still have life styles to enjoy. And that's the point. Some things are much more important than money and the most important of all is life and the love of your family and friends.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
So exactly what were those choices? Do what was done and allow the NHS to seemingly just about cope, albeit under huge strain, a lack of resources and the losses of their staff? Or not do it. Maybe just isolate the very vulnerable, allow the children to go to school and most working age people to continue to work and hope they observed social distancing, or worked from home? Not close the shops, pubs or restaurants? Allow people to travel freely? Attend football matches wearing masks? The consequences of that would surely have seen the NHS overwhelmed, with even fewer staff than they have now, and the very real possibility that the whole system could have collapsed. The social unrest and fear that would follow such a scenario cannot be imagined. Nor could the economic impact, which is what those who advocate a different approach seem most concerned about. The actual scale of the economic impact can now only be guessed at. It may be a depression but not necessarily. It is not anyway in our hands alone. If our markets decline then so do we. If we conquer this as quickly as possible and then take the same kind of decisive action we did once we decided on the "lockdown" then we can recover. Not to where we were, because somethings are going to change for ever, but we can recover. It could even be better. Those of working age may have to work harder and longer than before and either be paid less or taxed more. Probably both. Those retired will see their pensions frozen or even cut. We will all have to adjust our life styles as a consequence. But we will still have life styles to enjoy. And that's the point. Some things are much more important than money and the most important of all is life and the love of your family and friends. Good post. Reckon those who advocate an alternative approach would soon change their tune if a parent or loved one died from it because they had needlessly caught it if we didn't take the measures we are now.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
I’ve just seen Andrew Marr on the Parliament channel. I didn’t get round to watching it on iplayer. [Link] Somehow I missed it this morning. There is just a glint of light at the end of the tunnel so I’d be crossing all fingers and toes on a vaccine. Plus this could go on for quite a long time. Interview transcript: The guy from the OECD played down a depression and believes it’ll be more like a usual recession that’ll last this year, come out of it next year but have some scars to heal in the 2 years after. Something like that. Another economic spokesperson stating governments first responsibility is the lives of its citizens. I thought all the speakers were impressive. Even Gove seemed less like a schoolboy than usual. Angel Gurria was especially sage and it was reassuring.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
The next time certain people drive at 70mph on the highway....just remember you are engaging in an activity that kills thousands every year. Just imagine that it was your child or a loved one. So I take it they won't drive at over 30 in future. Edited by Stirlingsays (19 Apr 2020 10.55pm) Yes because you can definitely compare a highly infectious virus which has caused a global pandemic with driving at the speed limit on a motorway.
|
|
|
Originally posted by DanH
Yes because you can definitely compare a highly infectious virus which has caused a global pandemic with driving at the speed limit on a motorway.
But you carry on, don't worry your little self about it....just tell yourself what you wish to.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
But you carry on, don't worry your little self about it....just tell yourself what you wish to. This isn't narrowing it down much.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
How many dead is a good number if we had not locked down. Protect the vulnerable and distancing being the methods.? How many would you think there would have been and would that number be acceptable to prevent the financial issues we may face. It's self serving guff from the I'm alright jack types. Nobody with immune issues, or elderly, or vulnerable or looking after anyone in those categories thinks the lockdown was a bad idea. It has allowed us to build capacity and bought valuable time. We'll no doubt start transitioning out of it mid to late next month and that's a good balance I'd say. The brushing under the carpet with what's going on in care homes is a travesty, no plan, no resources. There was effectively no lockdown period at alll for them and they paid a high price for it.
|
|
|
Originally posted by DanH
This isn't narrowing it down much. Sigh.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Pro USA & Israel |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
The next time certain people drive at 70mph on the highway....just remember you are engaging in an activity that kills thousands every year. Just imagine that it was your child or a loved one. So I take it they won't drive at over 30 in future. Edited by Stirlingsays (19 Apr 2020 10.55pm) Good thing road traffic accidents aren’t highly contagious then.
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
It's self serving guff from the I'm alright jack types. Nobody with immune issues, or elderly, or vulnerable or looking after anyone in those categories thinks the lockdown was a bad idea. It has allowed us to build capacity and bought valuable time. We'll no doubt start transitioning out of it mid to late next month and that's a good balance I'd say. The brushing under the carpet with what's going on in care homes is a travesty, no plan, no resources. There was effectively no lockdown period at alll for them and they paid a high price for it. My grandad was released from a hospital back to his care home the same day there have been the first covid-19 death in the same hospital. Thankfully he was fine and admittedly this was before lockdown, but understand there is still very little testing on elderly patients leaving hospital for unrelated issues corona treatment. Potentially putting someone infected back into a group of very vulnerable people.
|
|
|
Originally posted by SavoyTruffle
Good thing road traffic accidents aren’t highly contagious then. So all traffic accidents just involve the one person then. Besides the point is about risk management. Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Apr 2020 12.42am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.