You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Vicente Guaita thread
November 16 2026 5.54am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Vicente Guaita thread


Page 18 of 22 < 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 >
Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 09 Oct 19 2.37pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'The Vicente Guaita thread' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

My beef was with quite a number of posters who did say WH was a rubbish keeper. I have insisted he wasn't and suffered some pretty vile personal insults on here for saying so. I have noted that a lot of posts on this thread are now acknowledging the fact that he isn't a bad keeper after all even if they think VG is the better keeper.

I do understand that the man currently in command stays there unless he suffers a dramatic loss of form or suffers an injury. It's good to know we have a capable back up keeper as some of those saves shown were top class and should show that. Only those with closed minds won't acknowledge that fact.

One fact you mentioned is that Guiata is currently operating behind the 3rd best defence in the league. A luxury that WH has never experienced.

There is the argument of course that could be advanced propounding the opinion that it is the 3rd best defence because of a part played by Guaita in thwarting opposition attacks.

In my humble opinion, Guaita is deserving of wearing the gloves at the present time and that Hennessey is not as dire and abject as many had suggested on HOL.Perhaps on occasions knee-jerk reactions and emotions came into play after a defeat when Hennessey was not at his best.

Edited by Willo (09 Oct 2019 2.40pm)

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 09 Oct 19 2.55pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'The Vicente Guaita thread' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow


No, Guita is currently part of the 3rd best defence in the league, something which WH never achieved.

You’re not suggesting a back four of Ward, Kelly, Cahill and PVA is the best we’ve had in the past 5 years, I’m sure.

I'm sure you have noted that I was quoting the previous poster. Are you trying to suggest we are only where we are due to one man. Seems so as you seem to dismiss the fact that Ward, Kelly, Cahill and PVA have anything to do with it.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 09 Oct 19 2.57pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'The Vicente Guaita thread' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by Willo

There is the argument of course that could be advanced propounding the opinion that it is the 3rd best defence because of a part played by Guaita in thwarting opposition attacks.

In my humble opinion, Guaita is deserving of wearing the gloves at the present time and that Hennessey is not as dire and abject as many had suggested on HOL.Perhaps on occasions knee-jerk reactions and emotions came into play after a defeat when Hennessey was not at his best.

Exactly Willo just like this forum did when we lost tp Spurs. There was a post (NOT by me) that said the defending was bad and even VG was rubbish.
Edited by Willo (09 Oct 2019 2.40pm)

Edited by PZ Eagle (09 Oct 2019 3.00pm)

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 09 Oct 19 3.07pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'The Vicente Guaita thread' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

I'm sure you have noted that I was quoting the previous poster. Are you trying to suggest we are only where we are due to one man. Seems so as you seem to dismiss the fact that Ward, Kelly, Cahill and PVA have anything to do with it.

It doesn’t matter who you were quoting; the point doesn’t make sense.

I’m not trying to suggest that at all - that would be as nonsensical as your original point.

Do you think Ward, Kelly, Cahill and PVA is the best back four in the last 5 years? If the answer is no, the notion that Guita benefits from something Hennessey never did doesn’t hold up.

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 09 Oct 19 3.17pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'The Vicente Guaita thread' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

It doesn’t matter who you were quoting; the point doesn’t make sense.

I’m not trying to suggest that at all - that would be as nonsensical as your original point.

Do you think Ward, Kelly, Cahill and PVA is the best back four in the last 5 years? If the answer is no, the notion that Guita benefits from something Hennessey never did doesn’t hold up.

They have not been our back four all season long, and besides it's not always only down to the back four.The midfielders are also part of the defence.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 09 Oct 19 3.30pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'The Vicente Guaita thread' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

They have not been our back four all season long, and besides it's not always only down to the back four.[The midfielders are also part of the defence.

Very true, it’s not always only down to the back four... do you know who else is also part of the defence... the bloody goalkeeper!

You’re tying yourself in knots here mate.

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 09 Oct 19 3.59pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'The Vicente Guaita thread' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Very true, it’s not always only down to the back four... do you know who else is also part of the defence... the bloody goalkeeper!

You’re tying yourself in knots here mate.

No I'm not it's you being pedantic. I can distinctly remember on the long WH thread when I pointed out he'd had a good game people used to say "Nah it's down to the defence in front of him" which is exactly my point The inclusion of Cahill has made all the difference and the defence in front of VG is giving him an easier ride overall. If you are still insisting you are right
then the fact that we have avoided relegation for the last three seasons must have been down to Hennessy as much as anyone.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 09 Oct 19 4.09pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'The Vicente Guaita thread' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

No I'm not it's you being pedantic. I can distinctly remember on the long WH thread when I pointed out he'd had a good game people used to say "Nah it's down to the defence in front of him" which is exactly my point The inclusion of Cahill has made all the difference and the defence in front of VG is giving him an easier ride overall. If you are still insisting you are right
then the fact that we have avoided relegation for the last three seasons must have been down to Hennessy as much as anyone.

Your inability to process basic logic is quite something - what someone else said, on another thread, is of no concern to me; they could have been wrong, the same way you are here.

Anyway, you’re clearly willing to die on this particular hill, so I’ll leave you to it - it’s really not difficult to see that Guita is a considerably better keeper though.

 

Casual Flag Orpington 09 Oct 19 5.13pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'The Vicente Guaita thread' by Midlands Eagle

So there is no confusion. I still think that Hennessy is a sh*t keeper, who makes the odd good save. Like Akinbiyi was a sh*t forward who scored the odd goal.

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 09 Oct 19 5.59pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'The Vicente Guaita thread' by Midlands Eagle

Hennessey is okay as a squad keeper but was stretched as a 1st team, PL keeper.

Guaita has added some physicality to his game this season and now looks a very decent PL, first-team keeper. Even if he also can't kick to save his life with his wrong foot!

I don't know who our 3rd choice is, but Guaita and Hennessey are about right for our needs/financial status.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 09 Oct 19 7.35pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'The Vicente Guaita thread' by Midlands Eagle

Just to clarify.

VG = good
WH = sh@t

Close the thread

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 09 Oct 19 10.42pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'The Vicente Guaita thread' by Midlands Eagle

So it's turned into another Wayne Hennessey thread.

Guaita is a better athlete, positions himself better, is braver in his decision making, has better hands and better reflexes, quicker around the goal and our results improved as soon as he came into the side.

Wayne, at times, hasn't looked like he wants to be there. Even VG's body language is better.

Clearly an upgrade.

With regard to previous Martyn was a fantastic keeper back in the day but my recall was that his command of the box and dealing with crosses wasn't that great and why he never really displaced David Seaman despite being a better shot stopper and Seaman having a rick in him. This at a time when the ball was moved slower and the game not as fast generally.

 

MikeCrete Flag Crete 10 Oct 19 6.16pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'The Vicente Guaita thread' by Midlands Eagle

One fact you mentioned is that Guiata is currently operating behind the 3rd best defence in the league. A luxury that WH has never experienced.

That is because VG is so far superior to WH not because of who is in the defence. Have not read through the posts since yours but doubt if there are too many who disagree. Aston Villa away.. lost 1 nil solely down to WH, So many other examples of hos lack of commanding his 6 yard box, let alone area. VG will get us higher up the table by a few places & at £1.9M per place that's very useful at the moment.

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 10 Oct 19 7.42pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'The Vicente Guaita thread' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

Anybody that infers that I am another man's boyfriend is not on and same goes for you who said you were wondering the same thing. So no apology from me rather it should be the other way round.

Wales just about to kickoff against Slovakia.

You might want to get yourself in front of the telly with a big box of tissues mate.

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

cryrst Flag The garden of England 10 Oct 19 7.44pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'The Vicente Guaita thread' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle

Wales just about to kickoff against Slovakia.

You might want to get yourself in front of the telly with a big box of tissues mate.

Tom please.
Kleenex are the best.
So I've heard.

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 10 Oct 19 8.10pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'The Vicente Guaita thread' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by MikeCrete

One fact you mentioned is that Guiata is currently operating behind the 3rd best defence in the league. A luxury that WH has never experienced.

That is because VG is so far superior to WH not because of who is in the defence. Have not read through the posts since yours but doubt if there are too many who disagree. Aston Villa away.. lost 1 nil solely down to WH, So many other examples of hos lack of commanding his 6 yard box, let alone area. VG will get us higher up the table by a few places & at £1.9M per place that's very useful at the moment.

A goal keeper alone will not win you the league or get you relegated. Sunderland relegated with Jordon Pickford who sold for £30 mil now England's regular keeper. It was suggested once we should have gone for Ben Foster an ex England keeper and a bloody good one.
However one plays for Everton and the other Watford and look where they are in the table now. If the defence, or the team, is not good the best goalkeeper in the country will not save you. I think that is reasonable to conclude that however good you think VG is he is not doing it alone. VG is in situ at the moment but if he gets injured Hennessey will be in goal and do a good job.

If you want to quote a game three years ago to highlight an error by WH I suggest you remember under Sam A when were not safe and had Chelsea Arsenal and Liverpool where we won all three with Hennessey in goal. He was brilliant against Chelsea and probably winning that game maybe gave us the spur to go and beat Arsenal and Liverpool and was a major factor in avoiding relegation.

All I am really saying is WH is a competentt PL keeper and not "sh1t" as some infer.

Edited by PZ Eagle (10 Oct 2019 8.13pm)

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 10 Oct 19 8.17pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'The Vicente Guaita thread' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle

Wales just about to kickoff against Slovakia.

You might want to get yourself in front of the telly with a big box of tissues mate.

Think your'e funny do you? I am an England fan and couldn't give a monkeys about Wales.

Edited by PZ Eagle (10 Oct 2019 9.08pm)

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Casual Flag Orpington 10 Oct 19 9.00pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'The Vicente Guaita thread' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

Think your'e funny do you? I am an England fan and couldn't give a toss about Wales.

“Couldn’t give a toss”
Very good if you meant it.
Tragic if you never

 

Casual Flag Orpington 11 Oct 19 6.20am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'The Vicente Guaita thread' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

Think your'e funny do you? I am an England fan and couldn't give a monkeys about Wales.

Edited by PZ Eagle (10 Oct 2019 9.08pm)

You edited “ toss” to “monkeys.”
Ha ha

 

sprites Flag Auckland 11 Oct 19 7.27am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'The Vicente Guaita thread' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

A goal keeper alone will not win you the league or get you relegated. Sunderland relegated with Jordon Pickford who sold for £30 mil now England's regular keeper. It was suggested once we should have gone for Ben Foster an ex England keeper and a bloody good one.
However one plays for Everton and the other Watford and look where they are in the table now. If the defence, or the team, is not good the best goalkeeper in the country will not save you. I think that is reasonable to conclude that however good you think VG is he is not doing it alone. VG is in situ at the moment but if he gets injured Hennessey will be in goal and do a good job.

If you want to quote a game three years ago to highlight an error by WH I suggest you remember under Sam A when were not safe and had Chelsea Arsenal and Liverpool where we won all three with Hennessey in goal. He was brilliant against Chelsea and probably winning that game maybe gave us the spur to go and beat Arsenal and Liverpool and was a major factor in avoiding relegation.

All I am really saying is WH is a competentt PL keeper and not "sh1t" as some infer.

Edited by PZ Eagle (10 Oct 2019 8.13pm)

Word. Agree. Lucky to have a decent #2.

 

Page 18 of 22 < 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Vicente Guaita thread