This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
She was entitled to be in a street. Just not in that street. When I was a kid we were able to walk in Downing Street. Not now, as access is restricted. For different reasons, but the effect is no different. The case, as prosecuted, eventually turned on a whether a point of law applied in a particular jurisdiction, or not. Both the lower court and the appeal court decided one way. The SC the other. What the EU court would have concluded is unknown because they didn't hear it. Under the application of the law that decided the case there was justice. That is very different from the concept that the outcome was just. Have you ever heard the expression that "the law is an ass?" I would love to hear what Lady Hale would say on that! No-one suggests that what "The Christian Institute" did was unlawful, even if sometimes they tread close to the line. Whether some of the things they do ought to be unlawful is another question entirely. Are they a force for good? Or are they an organisation trying to resist progress and turn the clock back? Opinions vary. "Unlimited immigration"? See my post at 5.25 pm in the BBC thread! It is your usual squid-ink on all of these issues. She was not prohibited from being in that particular street. She was prohibited from demonstrating. The police interpreted standing silently in the street as being a demonstration. All dictatorship would applaud such an interpretation. Here you go again on some so called point of law. I spelt out the actual wording of the charge and any reasonable person would quickly see that the Ashers were not guilty of that charge. I think the association of Lady Hale with an ass is very appropriate. Which things that the Christian Institute do would you outlaw in your quest for your so called ‘progress’. Are the likes of Stonewall a force for good? "Unlimited immigration"? See my reply at 8.09pm in the BBC thread. It reads “What are the issues with unlimited immigration?” Your list is eagerly awaited.
|
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
It is your usual squid-ink on all of these issues. She was not prohibited from being in that particular street. She was prohibited from demonstrating. The police interpreted standing silently in the street as being a demonstration. All dictatorship would applaud such an interpretation. Here you go again on some so called point of law. I spelt out the actual wording of the charge and any reasonable person would quickly see that the Ashers were not guilty of that charge. I think the association of Lady Hale with an ass is very appropriate. Which things that the Christian Institute do would you outlaw in your quest for your so called ‘progress’. Are the likes of Stonewall a force for good? "Unlimited immigration"? See my reply at 8.09pm in the BBC thread. It reads “What are the issues with unlimited immigration?” Your list is eagerly awaited. You are going round in circles. If that was the first time she had stood there then I doubt anything would have happened, other than being observed and a quiet word being offered in advice. It was a deliberate, provocative act disguised as a modest one. The Police's patience ran out. They had shown a great deal. As I have explained they were found not guilty by the SC after they examined conflicts in the way the law is applied in two jurisdictions. Which is a point of law. It's still the law, but that doesn't mean it ought to be. Lady Hale is a wise woman who's put down of Johnson in 2019 will live long in my memory. The Christian Institute are fundamentalists who oppose homosexuality and gay rights. I do not approve of religious fundamentalism, of any kind. I wouldn't "outlaw" them, but I would vigorously argue against them. I want our law to be based on reason, and not anything else. Stonewall aren't religious. I noticed you asked the same question, when the answer had already been given. Read it again. There's nothing to add.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
You are going round in circles. If that was the first time she had stood there then I doubt anything would have happened, other than being observed and a quiet word being offered in advice. It was a deliberate, provocative act disguised as a modest one. The Police's patience ran out. They had shown a great deal. As I have explained they were found not guilty by the SC after they examined conflicts in the way the law is applied in two jurisdictions. Which is a point of law. It's still the law, but that doesn't mean it ought to be. Lady Hale is a wise woman who's put down of Johnson in 2019 will live long in my memory. The Christian Institute are fundamentalists who oppose homosexuality and gay rights. I do not approve of religious fundamentalism, of any kind. I wouldn't "outlaw" them, but I would vigorously argue against them. I want our law to be based on reason, and not anything else. Stonewall aren't religious. I noticed you asked the same question, when the answer had already been given. Read it again. There's nothing to add. People are free to stand in public streets, that they are not banned from, as many times as they like. Only authoritarians would regard standing silently in a street as provocative. (It's like Germany in the 1930s!) They were found not guilty because they clearly were. All your so called points of law are just your usual squid-ink waffle trying to obscure what is in front of our noses. Lady Hale was a disgrace as a judge making politically motivated judgements. Stonewall are as dogmatic and intolerant as many religions are. The immigration question arose because you said that nobody supports unlimited immigration. I am merely enquiring as to the reasons why you don’t support unlimited immigration. I wonder why you will not give your reasons for not supporting unlimited immigration. Edited by georgenorman (13 Mar 2023 12.14pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
You are going round in circles. If that was the first time she had stood there then I doubt anything would have happened, other than being observed and a quiet word being offered in advice. It was a deliberate, provocative act disguised as a modest one. The Police's patience ran out. They had shown a great deal. As I have explained they were found not guilty by the SC after they examined conflicts in the way the law is applied in two jurisdictions. Which is a point of law. It's still the law, but that doesn't mean it ought to be. Lady Hale is a wise woman who's put down of Johnson in 2019 will live long in my memory. The Christian Institute are fundamentalists who oppose homosexuality and gay rights. I do not approve of religious fundamentalism, of any kind. I wouldn't "outlaw" them, but I would vigorously argue against them. I want our law to be based on reason, and not anything else. Stonewall aren't religious. I noticed you asked the same question, when the answer had already been given. Read it again. There's nothing to add. I have to say I have never thought that a person, all alone, standing silently, would be a provocative act. Do you consider 100s of doctors and nurses on picket lines to be provocative or is that the acceptable face of objection. After all the Police will have seen the same people on the same picket lines more than once and I didn’t see people being moved on or arrested? It would appear that the right to protest is now solely down to the discretion of the authorities regardless of democratic principles and what the law says. Interpretation has been bent past it’s point of elasticity and that single decision was a particularly poor example of it.
|
|
|
The gift that keeps on giving: [Tweet Link]
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
I have to say I have never thought that a person, all alone, standing silently, would be a provocative act. Do you consider 100s of doctors and nurses on picket lines to be provocative or is that the acceptable face of objection. After all the Police will have seen the same people on the same picket lines more than once and I didn’t see people being moved on or arrested? It would appear that the right to protest is now solely down to the discretion of the authorities regardless of democratic principles and what the law says. Interpretation has been bent past it’s point of elasticity and that single decision was a particularly poor example of it. You need to take that up with the authorities who declared an exclusion zone. Something they did because of the threat of intimidation from organisations who are rooted in the ant-abortion religious right from the USA. Gather enough support and you can vote in people who agree it ought not be done. The Police only do the minimum they have to do to keep the situation under control.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
People are free to stand in public streets, that they are not banned from, as many times as they like. Only authoritarians would regard standing silently in a street as provocative. (It's like Germany in the 1930s!) They were found not guilty because they clearly were. All your so called points of law are just your usual squid-ink waffle trying to obscure what is in front of our noses. Lady Hale was a disgrace as a judge making politically motivated judgements. Stonewall are as dogmatic and intolerant as many religions are. The immigration question arose because you said that nobody supports unlimited immigration. I am merely enquiring as to the reasons why you don’t support unlimited immigration. I wonder why you will not give your reasons for not supporting unlimited immigration. Edited by georgenorman (13 Mar 2023 12.14pm) You can stand everywhere you like, praying, juggling or bemoaning Palace's lack of points. What you cannot do is act in any way which is perceived as potentially intimidating in streets covered by a restriction. She was. End of. The Ashers were eventually found not guilty by the SC, on a single point of law. That's all it needed. Lawful, yes. Just, not in my book. Lady Hale has 10 times the integrity of Mr Johnson. That judgement was unanimous and also wise. It showed what a tosspot Johnson is for assuming he was above the law. Nobody in their right mind supports unlimited immigration. It must be managed, even when relaxed and liberal in approach. You don't just dismantle the barriers and admit everyone without verification.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
You can stand everywhere you like, praying, juggling or bemoaning Palace's lack of points. What you cannot do is act in any way which is perceived as potentially intimidating in streets covered by a restriction. She was. End of. The Ashers were eventually found not guilty by the SC, on a Ysingle point of law. That's all it needed. Lawful, yes. Just, not in my book. Lady Hale has 10 times the integrity of Mr Johnson. That judgement was unanimous and also wise. It showed what a tosspot Johnson is for assuming he was above the law. Nobody in their right mind supports unlimited immigration. It must be managed, even when relaxed and liberal in approach. You don't just dismantle the barriers and admit everyone without verification. So you are guilty of something if someone merely perceives that you are, what a dystopian society you wish us to live in. The Ashers were found not guilty as they clearly did not do what they were charged with, ie: discriminate against Garath Lee because he is a homosexual. There were a number of incidents in the odious Hales's career that were clearly driven by her political bias. I agree that nobody in their right mind should support unlimited immigration. You still shy away from listing the many problems that arise from immigration, as it would of course compromise your general support of immigration, particularly your devotion to the EU – where our membership led to massive immigration from EU countries. Edited by georgenorman (13 Mar 2023 5.14pm)
|
|
|
Ground breaking stuff I thought Spike Milligan had expired years go. So that is what GB News is like? 'I laughed until I stopped' - Daily Mail.
|
|
|
Originally posted by PalazioVecchio
Norway, Switzerland, Iceland........all doing fine outside the EU. And all still not had a tsunami of refugee men of military age.
You ever tried taking a rubber dinghy from Calais to Iceland ? Muppet.
|
|
|
Originally posted by PalazioVecchio
Norway, Switzerland, Iceland........all doing fine outside the EU. And all still not had a tsunami of refugee men of military age.
One of our biggest attractions is our language. Most people can speak a little, enough to ask the basics. They get it from watching TV. Iceland must be difficult to reach, Norway not easy either, and neither speak English. Switzerland has always received refugees. Switzerland is in 3rd place in the OECD in terms of the share of immigrants in its population, with the foreign-born accounting for 26% of the total population. 24% of them arrived in the last 5 years compared with 22% on average across OECD countries. I recognise that is not the whole story, but neither is yours!
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by glazedallover
You ever tried taking a rubber dinghy from Calais to Iceland ? Muppet. A legal barrier is a much more effective barrier than any sea. why use a dinghy when an airplane will do ? Muppet yourself.
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Iceland must be difficult to reach, Norway not easy either, and neither speak English. Switzerland has always received refugees. the contrast between Norway, with its ok border controls....and open-door Lefty Sweden ? is a total stark contrast.
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford |
|
|
Originally posted by PalazioVecchio
A legal barrier is a much more effective barrier than any sea. why use a dinghy when an airplane will do ? Muppet yourself. Ireland ? So not Iceland. Muppet.
|
|
|
Or maybe they fly to Ireland and then rent a coracle at Dingle bay , hoping to be nudged by Fungie the dolphin towards their desired destination Iceland ?
|
|
|
Originally posted by glazedallover
Or maybe they fly to Ireland and then rent a coracle at Dingle bay , hoping to be nudged by Fungie the dolphin towards their desired destination Iceland ? Coracles are Welsh and typical for inland waterways...Tá Fungie Marbh since October 2020......Muppet toi meme. Edited by PalazioVecchio (14 Mar 2023 12.40am)
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
One of our biggest attractions is our language. Most people can speak a little, enough to ask the basics. They get it from watching TV. Iceland must be difficult to reach, Norway not easy either, and neither speak English. Switzerland has always received refugees. Switzerland is in 3rd place in the OECD in terms of the share of immigrants in its population, with the foreign-born accounting for 26% of the total population. 24% of them arrived in the last 5 years compared with 22% on average across OECD countries. I recognise that is not the whole story, but neither is yours! I would say a close second to that is the willingness of the public to accept immigrants especially in jobs (and the generous benefits system of course). Many of our European neighbours talk the talk but little else. Next time you go to the Mediterranean see how many migrants are working in bars and restaurants, they're not. These countries pass all the equality laws and then ignore them local jobs for local people. As for claiming asylum it appears to be a lot easier in the UK than others which is why they choose to come here.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
One of our biggest attractions is our language. so why did Sweden get colonized by military-aged men ? the elephant in the room is a overly generous benefits regime. Which is something GB news are happy to discuss....and Omerta with BBC and Sky.
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.