This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by EddieMac
I actually looked at the fixtures earlier and thought to myself that the next 4 games were a decent run for picking up points.
|
|
|
Interesting thoughts and questions. You could argue that the current academy could result in ‘the team of the late 2020s’ in the similar fashion to how ‘the team of the 80s’ came about, but this time built on the foundations of the style of play instigated by PV. As you say it could be suggested El Tel just reaped the benefits of the work done by Allison. However, it was a long painful process to get there and 6 years out of the top division to get there. Does anybody want to endure that again? And of course the dream team of the 80s fell apart within 2 years of gaining promotion to the top tier! Originally posted by sydtheeagle
What cannot be contested is that while Allison never reaped the fruit, he did plant the tree. He changed our style and led the transition to and initial success of what was then the best youth setup in the country. The reinvention of Palace occurred under his watch. Yes, he didn't get us over the hump; it was Terry Venables who did that (and reaped the dividends) but without Allison doing the legwork and rebuilding our entire philosophy, there's a strong argument that the Team of the Eighties would never have happened. All this leads to a valid question. If Vieira is, as you suggest, possibly a latterday Malcolm Allison and we moved on from him at the end of this season but, in two years' time we found ourselves in Europe, how much more fondly would PV's critics today look back on his time as our manager? And equally, if we had stuck with Big Mal for another twelve months, would we have won the promotion that Venables led us to anyway? Just food for thought.
|
|
|
I think a lot of people would stop going if it happened again and before you know it you are looking at how Charlton and Portsmouth have ended up. Some may argue not being in the Premier doesn’t really matter, but not sure enough do these days when the financial rewards are so massively different between the divisions, far more than was the case years ago Originally posted by cryrst
The big question though is would you still go to Selhurst ?
|
|
|
It appears fans are bored of being mid table and are desperate for a relegation battle for a bit of excitement. We havent been anywhere near relegation since 2016.
|
|
|
Option 5 - there are always 3 worse teams than us* *proven thus far
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
My assessment of Havertz is that he is not quite a No 10 or a No 9 but is a hybrid. A few years ago he said he has played as a No 6, a No 8, a No 10, out wide and as a striker but he prefers to play as a No 10. Are you aware that this is "Palace" Talk?
|
|
|
Originally posted by viveasheagle
I think we are right in the mix for a relegation spot. My main reasons are our inability to create chances coupled with the other team's now all starting to look better than us. Bournemouth are creating chances as are Southampton (thankfully Che Adams keeps missing them) The two new lads should help with moving the ball forward and, hopefully, creating better quality chances.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
Are you aware that this is "Palace" Talk? I am fully cognisant of this fact.
|
|
|
Originally posted by doombear
Hmmmm, hope you are right, i think a couple of goals from open play might be a start.
“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn |
|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
It’s hugely disappointing that we are having to debate this issue at all, given where we were 12 months ago. My perception now is that the club just want to hold onto PL status as cheaply as possible, survive this season and then have a financial reset in the summer when we have a number of players coming to the end of their contracts. If that’s the case then it’s frustrating not only for us fans, but the manager as well. It becomes a test of nerve, and some people are all doom and gloom already. And that’s after a really tough run of fixtures. Performances have shown some improvement of late but our lack of composure in front of goal is hurting us. I think we will be ok, but it feels like a Roy type slog to 40 points albeit with a radically different playing style I think this is spot on. I just hope we can hold on, and that any financial reset involves huge investment. Unfortunately I am not tgat confident on either issue
|
|
|
Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad
Hmmmm, hope you are right, i think a couple of goals from open play might be a start. Goals can come from anywhere and all count. A particular favourite of mine was route one against Manchester United whereby Guaita punted a long ball for Schlupp to head on into the path of Ayew who calmly side footed past a hapless De Gea, marvellous.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
I think this is spot on. I just hope we can hold on, and that any financial reset involves huge investment. Unfortunately I am not tgat confident on either issue Here we go again "investment". What you mean is that you want a wealthy person or persons to splurge their money on big transfer fees and excessive player wages to give us a team that we can enjoy watching - a few of us even buying a ticket for the privilege of doing so. Where do you hope this money will come from?
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) |
|
|
Originally posted by Vectis
As I wrote on the Man Utd match thread, trying to play stylish possession based football is all very commendable, but you need the right players to do it. This team has not got enough of them to do it successfully. PV may have taken the job on the basis that he change the style of football, but this disregards the lack of adequate recruitment of such players needed. A good manager works with what he is given. Roy did so for 4 years with almost no backing in the transfer market. After only a week, Dyche has turned a disorganised collection of players at Everton into a team that beat the previously almost unstoppable league leaders. He previously took Burnley into Europe. Many sneer at the style these type of managers employ, but it’s pragmatic and gets results even if not pretty. I think PV is too influenced by his time at Man City, where they do have the quality of players to play the expansive passing style of football. Trying to impose that on the squad at Palace is just not working often enough. Sure, there is the odd game when it comes together, but overall results show it’s not sufficient. Swansea tried and ultimately failed to use this approach to stay in the Premier. FDB had similar ideas and look how that turned out. Turning the clock way back, Malcolm Allison had grand ideas of expansive football being played by Palace. I remember he even wanted to widen the pitch at Selhurst to give more room for passing down the wings. He was a highly regarded coach that also coincidentally had spent a successful spell at Man City. It was all a fine and commendable ambition, but again didn’t match the capabilities of the players at his disposal. Sure there were exciting times when it occasionally all came together, such as the FA Cup run in 1976, but ultimately what Allison achieved were successive relegations from the First Division/Premier to the Third Division/League One. He then failed two years in a row to get promoted back out of the third tier. Now I know this was back in the 1970s and many will say it’s ancient history. But as the saying goes ‘those who fail to study history are doomed to repeat it’ and if the current board and management continue the way they are it could all happen over again. Apologies, but late to this party. I cant argue with any point, save that we are in a completely different world to the 70s. The Premiership is very, very big business. And to sell to the world, you have to play entertaining football. Our style is not good enough for the top half but good enough to beat most teams below us. The results are proving that. Mid table, entertaining fare, that will draw viewers and money. Very risky, of course, but what isn't? Everton have chucked vast sums at the task and have been compelled to revert to dull pragmatism just to survive. I prefer our model.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
I think this is spot on. I just hope we can hold on, and that any financial reset involves huge investment. Unfortunately I am not tgat confident on either issue I also like his post save I don't agree the fault has been a lack of composure in front of goal. Man City attack wave after wave with the best strikers in the game, yet may only score 2 goals in 90 + mins. Not all attacks end in goals. Our strikers get a hard time on here but watch the bloody games. They have to feed on scraps or, sometimes, nothing at all. We are simply not passing enough/any decent balls to them to exercise their composure. There is almost no point in playing strikers unless you have a midfield competent to supply through some of the world's best defences. We have brilliant, exciting forward midfielders; but none able to produce that killer pass with any consistency. I hope the new boys can improve that. Otherwise, my priority for the summer alongside RB.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid
It looks between Leeds and us for the third relegation . Not according to the Bookies, who don’t usually get it wrong.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.