You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > 5 most overrated british bands.
November 22 2026 1.00am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

5 most overrated british bands.


Page 2 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
legaleagle Flag 25 Apr 15 8.07pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 25 Apr 2015 6.11pm

Quote legaleagle at 25 Apr 2015 5.40pm

The Clash
Oasis
Led Zeppelin
The Police
ELP
Genesis


When I include Led Zeppelin,I don't mean to suggest they were not a decent band who made some decent albums.But,"one of the all time greats"? Nah. Peter Grant was a very good manager and they had a lot of hype IMO.

Edited by legaleagle (25 Apr 2015 5.42pm)


Have to disagree... in all depts. they were masters of their craft.

Nearly all decent drummers took their hats off to Bonzo even Keef Moon.

John Paul Jones driving bass riffs were legendary.

Jimmy Page was as good as Hendrix/Clapton/Young/Knopfler.

Very few vocalists had Robert Plant's range.

Their albums were always critically acclaimed and bought in there millions.

In comparison to let's say The Rolling Stones... they p1ssed all over them.

They might not be everyone's cup of tea genrewise but you cannot deny their talent and appeal over a long period of time.

Whoever suggested U2 as overrated was spot on though.... and their egos.


Led Zep pissed all over the Rolling Stones? Had to check the calendar to make sure it wasn't 1 April!

Mind you,agree with you 110% about U2.

 

Apollofuzz Flag On the edge of reason 25 Apr 15 9.49pm

The Smiths
Elbow
The Smiths
Radiohead
The Smiths

 


I ride a GS scooter with my hair cut neat
I wear my war time coat in the wind and sleet.

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 25 Apr 15 10.00pm

Quote punksnotdead at 25 Apr 2015 1.02pm

the Beatles
Oasis
Radiohead
Pink Floyd
Spandau Ballet

Just a quickie U2 aren't British , they're Irish

..........and still overated!!

 


Pro USA & Israel

Pikester Flag Worthing 25 Apr 15 10.41pm

Quote Jamesrichards8 at 25 Apr 2015 4.03pm

Quote Kermit8 at 25 Apr 2015 3.58pm

Quote Pikester at 25 Apr 2015 2.45pm

The Clash - I know this will anger many on here but I just never 'got' them.

Should I stay or should I go is ok - but Rock The Casbah is bloody awful.


*applauds* - with you all the way on that one Pikes. Listened to their album 'Give 'em enough rope' - It's ok and so are they but well overrated.


That's funny I just purchased give em enough rope on vinyl and I think it's f***ing amazing. How can you tell me you don't think it's very good? Gotta be one of the most energetic and rebellious albums ever.
The clash are overrated? How many hit singles did they have? Honestly this is one instance where I don't care about respecting opinions. You two are f***ing crazy


I did say it might anger some on here..

It's not necessarily hit singles - it's you lot on here for starters and then all the NME etc. top 100 albums and bands and they are very very rated by a lot of people - and IMHO - OVERrated.

 


You fed me, you bred me, I'll remember your name.

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 25 Apr 15 11.52pm

Quote Kermit8 at 25 Apr 2015 4.12pm

Quote Jamesrichards8 at 25 Apr 2015 4.03pm

Quote Kermit8 at 25 Apr 2015 3.58pm

Quote Pikester at 25 Apr 2015 2.45pm

The Clash - I know this will anger many on here but I just never 'got' them.

Should I stay or should I go is ok - but Rock The Casbah is bloody awful.


*applauds* - with you all the way on that one Pikes. Listened to their album 'Give 'em enough rope' - It's ok and so are they but well overrated.


That's funny I just purchased give em enough rope on vinyl and I think it's f***ing amazing. How can you tell me you don't think it's very good? Gotta be one of the most energetic and rebellious albums ever.
The clash are overrated? How many hit singles did they have? Honestly this is one instance where I don't care about respecting opinions. You two are f***ing crazy


There were just so many outstanding bands around roughly the same time when they first got noticed - The Stranglers, Joy Division, early Simple Minds, The Jam and afew others, that they always seemed Championship rather than Prem to me. Their stuff just doesn't stand up in comparison though appreciate they have a massive following still - and I've only heard probably a fifth of their stuff - so must have something about them. Not for me though. Average.

Have to agree with you on this one Kermit. Have for many years thought the Clash were vastly over rated. Do believe that if people talk things up enough, other people will start to believe that it must be brilliant, when really, its just OK.
Now the other bands you mention, The Jam, Joy Division etc, now they really are premiership level.

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Pussay Patrol Flag 26 Apr 15 12.07am

Blur
Primal Scream
Kasabian
Mumford and sons
Queen

 


Paua oouaarancì Irà chiyeah Ishé galé ma ba oo ah

Hoof Hearted 26 Apr 15 9.56am

Quote Apollofuzz at 25 Apr 2015 9.49pm

The Smiths
Elbow
The Smiths
Radiohead
The Smiths


Oh yes...... Bands do not get much drearier than Elbow....... build a rocket boys and shove it up your arse!

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 26 Apr 15 10.59am

1 - Oasis
2 - Blur
3 - Pink Floyd
4 - Led Zep (they're good but not that good)
5 - The Beatles (see 4).

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 26 Apr 15 11.02am

Quote Jamesrichards8 at 25 Apr 2015 3.59pm

So far all of the replies are f***ing nonsense. The beatles? The who? Overrated my f***ing arse. I'm not a led zeppelin fan, but overrated they are not. It's actually making me laugh. I think you may be confusing 'overrated' with 'I've never listened to any of their material outside of what's on the radio'. That can be the only explanation.

Edited by Jamesrichards8 (25 Apr 2015 4.04pm)

Edited by Jamesrichards8 (25 Apr 2015 4.05pm)

Edited by Jamesrichards8 (25 Apr 2015 4.06pm)

They're overated, doesn't mean they're not good or even great bands, just that they're no where near as relevant or good as they're portrayed. Beatles released maybe two really good albums (Revolver and the White Album).

Good, but definitely overrated, probably because of their popularity.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 26 Apr 15 11.15am

Quote punksnotdead at 25 Apr 2015 1.02pm



Just a quickie U2 aren't British , they're Irish


sorry, the irish had a vote. We disowned U2 ages ago. They are mongolian for tax purposes and their musical homeland is disneyland.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

martinb75 Flag Tampere 26 Apr 15 11.18am

Coldplay
Radiohead

 

OllieMaidstoneEagle Flag Maidstone, Kent 26 Apr 15 2.04pm

Quote Tom-the-eagle at 25 Apr 2015 11.52pm

Quote Kermit8 at 25 Apr 2015 4.12pm

Quote Jamesrichards8 at 25 Apr 2015 4.03pm

Quote Kermit8 at 25 Apr 2015 3.58pm

Quote Pikester at 25 Apr 2015 2.45pm

The Clash - I know this will anger many on here but I just never 'got' them.

Should I stay or should I go is ok - but Rock The Casbah is bloody awful.


*applauds* - with you all the way on that one Pikes. Listened to their album 'Give 'em enough rope' - It's ok and so are they but well overrated.


That's funny I just purchased give em enough rope on vinyl and I think it's f***ing amazing. How can you tell me you don't think it's very good? Gotta be one of the most energetic and rebellious albums ever.
The clash are overrated? How many hit singles did they have? Honestly this is one instance where I don't care about respecting opinions. You two are f***ing crazy


There were just so many outstanding bands around roughly the same time when they first got noticed - The Stranglers, Joy Division, early Simple Minds, The Jam and afew others, that they always seemed Championship rather than Prem to me. Their stuff just doesn't stand up in comparison though appreciate they have a massive following still - and I've only heard probably a fifth of their stuff - so must have something about them. Not for me though. Average.

Have to agree with you on this one Kermit. Have for many years thought the Clash were vastly over rated. Do believe that if people talk things up enough, other people will start to believe that it must be brilliant, when really, its just OK.
Now the other bands you mention, The Jam, Joy Division etc, now they really are premiership level.

The Clash are most definitely Champions League,semi-final losing on penalties! Possibly more of an influence than all the above and probably left more of a legacy! My 5 bands are;The Police(nice to see lots in agreement);Coldplay(why?);Hard-Fi(wanna-be-Clash);Duran Duran(too poncey);UB40(ja-fake-can reggae at it's worst)https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wjmh52fkQJA Ollie's Dad,Ash.

 


Red and Blue Army!
LONDON BORN PALACE BRED LIVE AND DIE FOR BLUE AND RED
Football is not just a game, its a religion

Eagle_SA Flag Just outside Cape Town 26 Apr 15 3.20pm

Spice Girls
Take That
Bros
Westlife
One Direction


Is there a theme here.....

 


And I see signs of half remembered days, I hear bells that chime in strange familiar ways

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 26 Apr 15 11.24pm

Quote punksnotdead at 25 Apr 2015 1.02pm

the Beatles
Oasis
Radiohead
Pink Floyd
Spandau Ballet

Just a quickie U2 aren't British , they're Irish

I can accept it if someone doesn't like the Beatle's music - each to our own and all , but to say they are overrated is nonsense.

They single handedly changed the face and sound of popular music. I don't know how old you are but if you were around and listening to music in the early 60s you would know just how seismic their arrival on the scene was.

I have just had a look at the pop chart for January 1962, a year before the Beatle's first big hit, Please Please Me. It is full of fairly dull anodyne stuff .. Cliff Richard, Russ Conway, Helen Shapiro, Petula Clark. Hearing the Beatles for the first time was like one great blast of fresh air. It was so different and exciting.

Overnight they rendered the vast majority of chart acts obsolete.That chart of 1962 didn't feature one single group i.e. guitarists, drums, vocals. By the end of 1963, thanks to the influence of The Beatles, it was full of groups.

Also, I doubt if one single song in that 1962 chart was written by the performer(s). Again, the Beatles changed all that making it acceptable for artists to write their own material.

It would have been quite understandable had the Beatles, after their phenomenal success, played it safe and carried on churning out more She Loves Yous and I Want To Hold Your Hands. But no, they innovated and experimented with sound, instruments, production and lyrics.

They were very good musicians,could sing and harmonise beautifully, and wrote a wonderful catalogue songs that are still enjoyed, if not by you, by millions today.

On that basis it is just meaningless to say they are overrated. And if that argument is not enough I give you a group who gave us Strawberry Field, Eleanor Rigby, Norwegian Wood, Penny Lane, Help, We Can Work it Out, Hey Jude, Revolution, Day in the Life, In My Life, Let it Be, I Am the Walrus, Long and Winding Road, Tomorrow Never Knows, Blackbird ..... all so different and never ever sounding the same.

I rest my case.


Edited by Pete53 (26 Apr 2015 11.25pm)

 

davenotamonkey Flag 26 Apr 15 11.51pm

Quote martinb75 at 26 Apr 2015 11.18am

Coldplay
Radiohead

Thank you!

Coldplay. Yes, Coldplay.

You hear that wailing catlike thing in the cafe when you're having a fry up?

Chris Fcuking Martin

Whale song? In Bluewater shopping centre? How?

Chris Fcuking Martin

Hey, haven't they been playing the same song for the past hour? Is it on repeat? ...An album? Oh... who is it?

Chris Fcuking Martin

T0sser.


 

Part Time James Flag 27 Apr 15 12.01am

Oasis
Coldplay
The Beatles (not because they're bad, just nowhere near as good as people rated them)
Arctic Monkeys
Kaiser Chiefs

 




silvertop Flag Portishead 27 Apr 15 11.42am

Quote Pikester at 25 Apr 2015 2.45pm

The Clash - I know this will anger many on here but I just never 'got' them.

Should I stay or should I go is ok - but Rock The Casbah is bloody awful.


Pikester I think I love you. Unfortunately, the last time I posted on here a few years ago to like effect, I was all but threatened with death.

It's a real shame. Mick Jones cannot sing or write a decent song. If he was excised from the band or just played his instrument and shut up, the Clash could have been one of the greats.

The others to the list:

Rolling Stones [after Brian Jones]
Who [save their early mod stuff]
Queen

On Queen, I have so much to say I could fill a thread such is my hatred of them and alarm at their ever-lasting popularity. Suffice to say they are 4 extremely talented individuals who produced ground breaking material and some really good songs but somehow collectively their "music" has an effect like a cheese grater to the cochlea. It is beyond awful.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 27 Apr 15 11.49am

Quote pefwin at 25 Apr 2015 7.48pm

1 Yes
2 Style Council
3 The Police
4 The Beatles
5 Status Quo

There are so many.

Edited by pefwin (25 Apr 2015 7.49pm)

Since when have they been rated? They started as the "poor mans Canned Heat" and progressed to stadium novelty act. We are talking bands who critics wet their knix over for no discernible reason... like the Clash

 

palace777 Flag belfast 27 Apr 15 11.52am

u2,u2,u2,u2 and u2

 

Hoof Hearted 27 Apr 15 11.56am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 26 Apr 2015 11.02am

Quote Jamesrichards8 at 25 Apr 2015 3.59pm

So far all of the replies are f***ing nonsense. The beatles? The who? Overrated my f***ing arse. I'm not a led zeppelin fan, but overrated they are not. It's actually making me laugh. I think you may be confusing 'overrated' with 'I've never listened to any of their material outside of what's on the radio'. That can be the only explanation.

Edited by Jamesrichards8 (25 Apr 2015 4.04pm)

Edited by Jamesrichards8 (25 Apr 2015 4.05pm)

Edited by Jamesrichards8 (25 Apr 2015 4.06pm)

They're overated, doesn't mean they're not good or even great bands, just that they're no where near as relevant or good as they're portrayed. Beatles released maybe two really good albums (Revolver and the White Album).

Good, but definitely overrated, probably because of my love of pretentious musical genres.


EFA

 

Page 2 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > 5 most overrated british bands.