This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote matt_himself at 04 Nov 2015 8.26am
Quote jamiemartin721 at 04 Nov 2015 8.14am
Quote matt_himself at 03 Nov 2015 10.31pm
Quote leifandersonshair at 03 Nov 2015 7.08pm
The politics and the system work- but, as Serial notes, state socialism is unsustainable in the current global climate of unfettered capitalism. Just as, in a world of successful socialist states, the single capitalist country would inevitably fail. Calling socialism 'mumbo jumbo' is lazy and no real argument. Capitalism is a bunch of old hogwash. See? I can do it too!
Venezuela would probably fit that bill.
Please provide evidence that Venezuela is democratic. From everything I have read, the government there is doing a lot of things to restrict freedom that if they happened elsewhere, you and your sort would be up in arms over. Sweden isn't socialist. You can delude yourself that the 'Nordic model' is socialism but it clearly isn't. It is a free market economy, highly taxed and with a social safety net. It is not socialist by definition. Indeed, but its still democratic. In the same way we're democratic, whilst fitting into a system that favours the dominant party. We have a system where 15% of the electorate (roughly) vote for the Greens and UKIP (they got a seat each) - Hardly a fair model when you consider the votes the Liberal Democrats received was at least half that, and they got 8 seats. Hardly a fair system either. Sweden
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote serial thriller at 04 Nov 2015 9.10am
Quote matt_himself at 04 Nov 2015 9.02am
Quote serial thriller at 04 Nov 2015 8.45am
Quote matt_himself at 03 Nov 2015 5.24pm
Quote serial thriller at 03 Nov 2015 5.04pm
My reading of the situation in Venezuela is this. Since the fall of the Berlin wall and the expansion of global capitalism in to virtually every corner of the globe, state Socialism has faced a two-fold problem in terms of maintaining itself. Either it attempts to fight against the tide, building nationalist movements like you saw in France in the 80s or Corbyn at the moment, which push for socialist policies within a framework of global capitalism. This almost inevitably leads to compromise and disappointment, especially if the grassroots movement that propel them fade away. The other option is the Venezuelan model of becoming a pretty insular society, relying on funding via a high level export. You see it in Scandanavia to an extent as well. Problem is, once that export evaporates or demand goes down, you're pretty f*cked. I actually think in the past few decades Venezuela has done some brilliant things for its people, and been relatively democratic and open in the process. But ultimately without a concerted global move away from capitalism, it is hard to see a way of making it stick. The problem is that the politics and the system doesn't work. Everyone knows that this 'mumbo jumbo' is simply an expensive social engineering project which is doomed to failure from the start. Also, I guess its which country you compare the country with when calling it 'relatively democratic'. Are you using the DPRK as the comparison model?
The link you posted, however, is fairly interesting. From what I've read, the political situation in Venezuela is certainly at breaking point, but what that article completely fails to identify is the other side of the story. The other side of the story is that democracy is incredibly difficult to maintain in Venezuela because the opposition seem to have such a total disregard for it. The 2014 US Federal reserve gave million to opposition groups in Venezuela, while coups are commonplace. Even after Maduro was narrowly elected in 2013, there was an attempted coup, despite independent bodies suggesting it was a fair and transparent election. This isn't to suggest that Venezuela is some model for democratic socialism, but the lack of balance in that piece is questionable. And when I talk about relatively, I'll give you a couple of examples. Look at the recent Turkish elections, in a country often cited as a beacon of thriving capitalism. The day before the election, the government closed down the major opposition news channel; added to that, Turkey has more journalists in jail than any other country in the world, and even an 11 year old child was threatened with legal action by the government after criticising Erdogan on facebook. Meanwhile, the June attacks on rival Kurdish party HQ have gone completely unpunished, the government reentered combat with the PKK days before the election, despite the latter stating their desire for peace until the elections were concluded. Police violence, particularly in Kurdish areas, on election day was rife, and Erdogan now hopes to push through a law to transfer power away from parliament and towards himself. Or perhaps a better parallel to Venezuela would be Congo, a resource rich nation that has embraced Capitalism, and is now one of the fastest growing economies on the planet...even while over half of its people don't have access to clean drinking water. Of course, it's the Venezuelan oppositions fault that democracy and independent public bodies are being suppressed. And I ask you this, if a coup was launched against a right wing government that was suppressing democracy, would you support it or bemoan the fact that the opposition 'were not taking democracy seriously'?
I'd never support a coup, it's a full proletarian revolution or nothing
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
If anyone goes there, you have to take dollars. You get a lot more Boli's for your money. Do not use the 'official' exchange!
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote stevegood at 04 Nov 2015 11.03am
Quote jamiemartin721 at 04 Nov 2015 10.54am
Quote matt_himself at 04 Nov 2015 8.26am
Quote jamiemartin721 at 04 Nov 2015 8.14am
Quote matt_himself at 03 Nov 2015 10.31pm
Quote leifandersonshair at 03 Nov 2015 7.08pm
The politics and the system work- but, as Serial notes, state socialism is unsustainable in the current global climate of unfettered capitalism. Just as, in a world of successful socialist states, the single capitalist country would inevitably fail. Calling socialism 'mumbo jumbo' is lazy and no real argument. Capitalism is a bunch of old hogwash. See? I can do it too!
Venezuela would probably fit that bill.
Please provide evidence that Venezuela is democratic. From everything I have read, the government there is doing a lot of things to restrict freedom that if they happened elsewhere, you and your sort would be up in arms over. Sweden isn't socialist. You can delude yourself that the 'Nordic model' is socialism but it clearly isn't. It is a free market economy, highly taxed and with a social safety net. It is not socialist by definition. Indeed, but its still democratic. In the same way we're democratic, whilst fitting into a system that favours the dominant party. We have a system where 15% of the electorate (roughly) vote for the Greens and UKIP (they got a seat each) - Hardly a fair model when you consider the votes the Liberal Democrats received was at least half that, and they got 8 seats. Hardly a fair system either. Sweden You talk about 'social restrictions', 'a critique of capitalism' and 'a socialist model'. In fact it is just a democratically elected government passing laws that they think benefit society - just as we have done in this country over the years. It is not socialism at all. Sweden would quickly go down the pan if all means of production, distribution and exchange were in the hands of the state. This is how I see socialism as a working model within a capitalist world, as a means of social provision. I don't really abide by the idea of communism at all, which promotes tyranny, but the idea of the will of the people and the state serving the best interest of society. In terms of socialism, I regard the vanguard approach of Marxist-Lenninism and Moaists as being a 'failed experiement' as it forces socialism by force of arms and tyranny, but proscribe to the approach of Marx where in Socialism must grow out of the failures of capitalism by the will of the people as a social change (similar to how capitalism grew out of the industrial revolution and the demise of agrarianism, which replaced feudalism). Sweden also requires very strict laws on the economic stability of companies, that would be considered Marxist by any other standards, that are specifically devised towards ensuring a company security for the benefit of employees and the state, rather than the directors. so for me, Sweden represents the way forwards, capitalism coupled to a social or socialist priority. I believe in the freedom of the individual (being more of an anarchist than a commie), and democracy that represents each and every single person. These I feel are vital to prevent tyranny of the majority (which communism, represents). As for the UK passing laws for the benefit of society, that I disagree with, for most of my life I would say we pass laws based on maintaining the support of the parties voters, and primiarly the interests of corporations.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.