You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > NUT strike.
November 22 2026 1.00am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

NUT strike.


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 05 Jul 16 10.45am

One of my team has twins, 12 people in the year, 55 in the school. Bloody overcrowding

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

JohnyBoy Flag 05 Jul 16 10.58am

Originally posted by nickgusset

Teachers all over the country will be wiothdrawing their labour on 5th July.

March tomorrow at 11am from Portland Place.
I will be there defending the UK education system.

Here's some reasons why:

1. It's not really about pay.
As a profession I think we are well paid. That is why we have good quality professionals working hard to teach children, inspire them and look after them. But this is about to change.

2. The white paper
The governments latest white paper proposes DEREGULATION of teachers pay and conditions. Currently all local authority employed teachers in England are paid according to the same contract. Like nurses and doctors, teachers have automatic pay progression (so the longer you serve the more you get - an incentive to stay in the profession), pay portability (if we move schools we get the same basic pay - they can't pay us less - this stops a competition between schools for teachers based on money - without it richer schools will always poach good staff from poorer schools) .

3. What is performance-related pay?
The introduction of performance related pay will mean that teachers get paid according to exam results. As a parent I would never want a teacher to look at my child and think 'is he going to wreck my data and stop my pay rise?' We are not working in sales - it is hugely problematic to pay us based on exam results.

4. Why should non-teachers care about teachers pay and conditions?
Deregulation also means that our working hours, holidays, pay, sick pay and maternity pay will be individually decided by the employer - the academy that is. An Academy in Manchester has in its contract that maternity pay will be 'subject to affordability'. Who will become a teacher if the terms and conditions are unattractive? A mum said to me yesterday 'but in my job I don't get good maternity pay - why should I care about teachers?'. My answer is this: public sector pay and conditions set the bar for private sector pay and conditions. If we get screwed you will get screwed too.

5. What's the problem with academies and free schools?
Academies and free schools are businesses. That means their primary concern is money. The government is paving the way for them to become profit-making businesses. Already many academies double up as wedding venues, conference facilities etc. No harm in generating revenue eh? Well only if it's being ploughed back into the school and The children. Let's remember schools are about children aren't they? It seems not. Many academies including Harris academies have recently got in trouble for deliberately excluding 'problem children' and paying local authority schools to take them off their hands - because they wreck the data. How can you publish your excellent GCSE results if some stubborn children just won't make progress! The answer in some academies is to get rid of them - then you don't have to report their results.
So if the money isn't spent on the kids where does it go?


Do a Google search on haberdashers free school account fraud. He ran off with £4million! How did he manage to do that? Answer - because he was only accountable to the board of governors and the head teacher. Local authority schools are overseen by a democratically elected local council. Academies don't have to bother with that level of accountability. And the government also wants to get rid of parent governors. This would mean that academies would only be accountable to themselves. We're talking about millions of pounds of public money. Already there have been many documented cases of fraud in academies and free schools.

6. Qualified teachers V unqualified teachers
Academies and free schools don't have to employ qualified teachers. Unqualified teachers are cheaper of course. But I know which one I want teaching my children.

Interesting insight Nick, and although i am one of the affected parents, am supportive of this strike. Its never going to be an easy decision because kids are affected but if you dont make a stand, it seems the quality of our schools & teaching will decline. Seeing as the tories have just decimated our economy, our constitution, our prosperity and our life chances please dont let them mess up the education system as well

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 05 Jul 16 11.00am

Originally posted by JohnyBoy

Interesting insight Nick, and although i am one of the affected parents, am supportive of this strike. Its never going to be an easy decision because kids are affected but if you dont make a stand, it seems the quality of our schools & teaching will decline. Seeing as the tories have just decimated our economy, our constitution, our prosperity and our life chances please dont let them mess up the education system as well

Total and utter hogwash.Typical Anti-Tory rhetoric.

Let's not get into the wider debate as I shall only get on my "Soapbox".

Regards education spending this year has been the highest at £40Bill, an increase of some £4Bill since 2012.

Strike called by NUT when only some 25% actually voted.

Anyhow I am off out now.Probably bump into a load of children affected by the strike.

Edited by Willo (05 Jul 2016 11.07am)

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 05 Jul 16 11.10am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

How many pupils in your class, Nick? 30 or 35?

I do one to one tutoring with kids not in mainstream now. Lot of travelling between houses but rewarding.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 05 Jul 16 11.13am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I've heard about how Harris Academies have improved the performance and behaviour of pupils. The former Haling Manor on Pampisford Road a good example. A problem school. Now we know why, well partly why.

How many warning do Harris give? How and why are all the pupils still there still behaving? Is it because they know they have to go to Lanfranc and possibly chuck the opportunity away that pupils who go to Lanfranc or the old Haling Manor didn't have?

Is it because the teachers actually have measures in discipline they can practice whereas before they tried to and the child just walked out of the office claiming their independence and to repeat the next day or day after.

Just putting it out there. Teachers had little discipline. Sounds like these academy teachers have a bit to protect the children there to cooperate. Nice flash school. Decent grades, decent future. Stop f***ing about or go to the school built on an old refuse site with class disruptions every 5 minutes if you're lucky.


Harris get rid of 'failing' kids a lot of whom are on the autistic spectrum.

Staff turnover at Harris is a lot higher than average.

 

gbox82 Flag Meols, Wirral 05 Jul 16 12.15pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

Teachers all over the country will be wiothdrawing their labour on 5th July.

March tomorrow at 11am from Portland Place.
I will be there defending the UK education system.

Here's some reasons why:

1. It's not really about pay.
As a profession I think we are well paid. That is why we have good quality professionals working hard to teach children, inspire them and look after them. But this is about to change.

2. The white paper
The governments latest white paper proposes DEREGULATION of teachers pay and conditions. Currently all local authority employed teachers in England are paid according to the same contract. Like nurses and doctors, teachers have automatic pay progression (so the longer you serve the more you get - an incentive to stay in the profession), pay portability (if we move schools we get the same basic pay - they can't pay us less - this stops a competition between schools for teachers based on money - without it richer schools will always poach good staff from poorer schools) .

3. What is performance-related pay?
The introduction of performance related pay will mean that teachers get paid according to exam results. As a parent I would never want a teacher to look at my child and think 'is he going to wreck my data and stop my pay rise?' We are not working in sales - it is hugely problematic to pay us based on exam results.

4. Why should non-teachers care about teachers pay and conditions?
Deregulation also means that our working hours, holidays, pay, sick pay and maternity pay will be individually decided by the employer - the academy that is. An Academy in Manchester has in its contract that maternity pay will be 'subject to affordability'. Who will become a teacher if the terms and conditions are unattractive? A mum said to me yesterday 'but in my job I don't get good maternity pay - why should I care about teachers?'. My answer is this: public sector pay and conditions set the bar for private sector pay and conditions. If we get screwed you will get screwed too.

5. What's the problem with academies and free schools?
Academies and free schools are businesses. That means their primary concern is money. The government is paving the way for them to become profit-making businesses. Already many academies double up as wedding venues, conference facilities etc. No harm in generating revenue eh? Well only if it's being ploughed back into the school and The children. Let's remember schools are about children aren't they? It seems not. Many academies including Harris academies have recently got in trouble for deliberately excluding 'problem children' and paying local authority schools to take them off their hands - because they wreck the data. How can you publish your excellent GCSE results if some stubborn children just won't make progress! The answer in some academies is to get rid of them - then you don't have to report their results.
So if the money isn't spent on the kids where does it go?


Do a Google search on haberdashers free school account fraud. He ran off with £4million! How did he manage to do that? Answer - because he was only accountable to the board of governors and the head teacher. Local authority schools are overseen by a democratically elected local council. Academies don't have to bother with that level of accountability. And the government also wants to get rid of parent governors. This would mean that academies would only be accountable to themselves. We're talking about millions of pounds of public money. Already there have been many documented cases of fraud in academies and free schools.

6. Qualified teachers V unqualified teachers
Academies and free schools don't have to employ qualified teachers. Unqualified teachers are cheaper of course. But I know which one I want teaching my children.

Is this post all your own work Nick? It's just that I've seen an incredibly similar post on Facebook...

Edited by gbox82 (05 Jul 2016 12.15pm)

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 05 Jul 16 2.01pm

Originally posted by gbox82

Is this post all your own work Nick? It's just that I've seen an incredibly similar post on Facebook...

Edited by gbox82 (05 Jul 2016 12.15pm)

Got me. Said what I would've done.

 

gbox82 Flag Meols, Wirral 05 Jul 16 2.17pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

Got me. Said what I would've done.

D- Copying is unacceptable.

See me at lunchtime detention ;-)

 

Stuk Flag Top half 05 Jul 16 2.30pm

Points 2, 3 & 4 seem to thoroughly rubbish point 1.

You're just annoying parents and keeping kids out of school. Missing 1 day of is critical, or so we're told when it comes to the parents making that choice.

 


Optimistic as ever

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 05 Jul 16 2.37pm

Originally posted by Stuk

Points 2, 3 & 4 seem to thoroughly rubbish point 1.

You're just annoying parents and keeping kids out of school. Missing 1 day of is critical, or so we're told when it comes to the parents making that choice.

Yep. Teachers are on strike annoy parents and lose a days pay to do so.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 05 Jul 16 2.44pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

Yep. Teachers are on strike annoy parents and lose a days pay to do so.

You seem to have overlooked the contradiction I pointed out.

Unions can provide strike pay.

 


Optimistic as ever

Southampton_Eagle Flag At the after party 05 Jul 16 2.51pm

Teachers are like the French, any excuse to strike and cause inconvenience to the parents who's tax pays their wages.

 

twist Flag Miami, Florida 05 Jul 16 3.17pm

Teachers pay does need to be tied to performance in some way, but its not so cut and dry as to look at students exam results.
It does take a village to raise a child, so you can get one school where the parents are completely engaged and children are more likely to ace any test, whereas other schools the parents just are not involved and the teacher has a much harder job of it.

They tried to do this in Florida a couple years back, amazingly the rules for determining performance related pay were made up by a panel of 12 people, only one of which had teaching experience! It did not go down well, and when it was put to referendum it was shot down by the electorate.
But, its coming back in a revised fashion, as Florida learned their lesson and engaged a private company to come up with "fair" rules related to performance pay.

Many teachers are in it for the money and an easy ride, many more got into teaching for the love of it, but now dislike or even hate it.

My 2 boys are 14 and 16 now, had dozens of teachers over the years, 60% of them were excellent, 25% good, but i would say 15% of them just didnt care any more. Its those 15% we have to sort out, either turn them around with monetary incentives, or get them out of the profession.
My 16 year old would be failing school if not for his mother,he had several very disappointing teachers.

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 05 Jul 16 3.25pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

Yep. Teachers are on strike annoy parents and lose a days pay to do so.

Parents lose money too

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Stuk Flag Top half 05 Jul 16 3.29pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

Parents lose money too

And they can't get strike pay.

 


Optimistic as ever

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 05 Jul 16 3.33pm

Originally posted by Stuk

And they can't get strike pay.

......as Nick is teaching 'One on One' should you not class (pun)that as being a Sub contractor?

 


Pro USA & Israel

elgrande Flag bedford 05 Jul 16 3.47pm

Originally posted by Jimenez

......as Nick is teaching 'One on One' should you not class (pun)that as being a Sub contractor?

Amazing what these middle class parents will pay for finger painting now days....

 


always a Norwood boy, where ever I live.

Stuk Flag Top half 05 Jul 16 3.48pm

Originally posted by Jimenez

......as Nick is teaching 'One on One' should you not class (pun)that as being a Sub contractor?

No. A bona fide sub-contractor has to provide cover for absent labour, rather than telling it's clients tough titties.

 


Optimistic as ever

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 05 Jul 16 4.10pm

Originally posted by elgrande

Amazing what these middle class parents will pay for finger painting now days....

It's through Croydon council. They're still responsible for educating kids even if not in school. of the ones I'm teaching, 1 can't attend school as she has cancer. The others have been excluded. The tuition is part of gradual reintegration to the mainstream.

That said I am looking towards private tuition. Can get around 30 quid an hour.

As for the strike fund, you have to jump through a lot of hoops to qualify so really it's a total myth that all teachers get paid regardless.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 05 Jul 16 4.13pm

Originally posted by Stuk

You seem to have overlooked the contradiction I pointed out.

Unions can provide strike pay.

It's about national pay scales. Getting rid of these leads to sink schools that find it difficult to get staff.

That's why pay scales were introduced in the first place.

 

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > NUT strike.