You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Ledley & McArthur
November 16 2026 11.43am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Ledley & McArthur


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
We are goin up! Flag Coulsdon 19 Sep 16 10.07am

We shouldn't forget we played similarly brilliantly with Cabaye in the team at the start of last season. However, away from home especially the McArthur/Ledley combination seems to just work.

It's not always about playing the best players, it's the best combinations. Look at the Gerrard/Lampard conundrum England had for years, two unbelievable players but they didn't work together.

The balance of the team is more important. Cabaye has lost his place as far as I'm concerned and must earn it back as McPunchley (sorry) is working a treat at the moment.

 


The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 19 Sep 16 10.08am

Originally posted by Frickin Saweet

I thought our midfield was so fluid and the best I've seen it work for a long time. There seemed to be an understanding where each could push forward or drop back to cover which saw the extremes of Ledley being far forward whilst Punch dropped deep and both looked comfortable. Also Benteke dropping deep gave Stoke so much more movement to contend with and we pulled them quite out of shape at times.

I think that's going to be the upside of not having a real number 10 and playing 3 centre mids at the same time. It'll work quite a bit and then when it doesn't will frustrate quite a bit.

 


COYP

Loz83 Flag Crawley 19 Sep 16 10.41am

I think cabaye will be one of those players who looks class when the team is confident and on form, but when you need to grind out a result he goes missing. It's a long season and all the squad will be needed and I'm sure cabaye and Ledley will be key.

 

Hansy Flag 19 Sep 16 10.48am

I have never been a Ledley fan.Always thought he was a poor man's Jedinak. But the last two games he has won me over, with great performances.

He allows Punch and McArthur to start pushing more forward to help the wingers and Benteke. And covers the Defence really well. I am a huge Cabaye fan, but Yohan will need to prove his worth imo.

 

citizensmudge Flag midlands 19 Sep 16 10.55am

Regardless of who you think should start when everyones fit it just goes to show how strong we are in the engine room despite getting rid of Jedi.Its healthy competition and maybe the rotation may help with regard to the niggly injuries we seem to pick up.

 

Alex1991 Flag Ashford 19 Sep 16 12.24pm

Originally posted by Croydonlad

its McArthur thats the key here
Ledley is average
Flamini is better than both he and Cabaye

Edited by Croydonlad (19 Sep 2016 2.27am)

Not sure what you're basing this on so far

McArthur was so on point yesterday. When he plays like that we tick, and could be seen as the most important midfielder we have.

 


"Brighton are talking about how they're coming for us. And it's like, we've been waiting in the Premier League for you for ages." Wilfried Zaha, 2017.

Aray Flag South London 19 Sep 16 12.37pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

Well quite, he is Welsh after all.

I am not anti-Cabaye, I happen to think he has been underrated by many Palace fans, I just happen ti think that as a partnership Mcledley works better.

Interesting that you mentioned Cabaye running the French midfield, he played one full game and two minutes of another.

lol! Yes his nationality is Welsh!! But I think you know what I meant

And I can understand what you say there but the circumstances of a particular combination working or not are important factors to consider. He did play only one full game and played his socks off.

Unfortunately for him his competion is Pogba, Kante and others.

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 19 Sep 16 1.34pm

Originally posted by citizensmudge

Regardless of who you think should start when everyones fit it just goes to show how strong we are in the engine room despite getting rid of Jedi.Its healthy competition and maybe the rotation may help with regard to the niggly injuries we seem to pick up.


I would disagree, I think it shows how reliant we are on Jimmy Mc, all the talk is who to partner him not replace him.

If he gets injured we are potentially back to square one

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Aray Flag South London 19 Sep 16 1.41pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

I would disagree, I think it shows how reliant we are on Jimmy Mc, all the talk is who to partner him not replace him.

If he gets injured we are potentially back to square one

A good point - I reckon Cabaye would have to play the box-to-box role with either Ledley or Flamini holding. But let's pray for J Mac's food health!

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 19 Sep 16 1.44pm

Originally posted by Aray

A good point - I reckon Cabaye would have to play the box-to-box role with either Ledley or Flamini holding. But let's pray for J Mac's food health!

Food? We will have to call him Big Mac


he should be in cotton wool and one player we definitely don't play in the league cup (which kinda contradicts what I said on the cup thread)

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

georgey wood Flag South London and Proud 19 Sep 16 1.47pm

I think pardiola has stumbled on a good formation here. Ledley and jimmy mac have the extra legs and defensive nouse to allow the front 4 rotate and play freely. Although cabaye a class above technically he hasnt got the legs or natural defensive instincts of either. His passing range with benteke and townsend running in behind may be interesting to see when hes back. However in current system can only see him fitting in for jimmy mac whos best player at club for me. Dm flamini or ledders, centre jimmy mac or cabaye. With punch and lee fighting out 10 role.for me shape is so important as you have to expect punch and zaha to lose the ball at times its just the way they play. I think we have a nice blend in middle now but must play best mix not always best individuals, of which cabaye clearly is. Yohan over to you mate to get back in side...

Edited by georgey wood (19 Sep 2016 1.49pm)

 

Hoof Hearted 19 Sep 16 1.49pm

When they're both on their A games Cabaye should shade it over Ledley.

However, Cabaye has been unfit/off form whereas Ledley had a good 2016 Euro performance with Wales and has come back strong.

Agree with most that McCarthur is the key.

We're in a lucky position to have all 3 players that can do a good job as defensive midfielder.

Right now Ledley and McCarthur hold sway and Cabaye will have to wait on the bench if he gets fit and if he does come on, Benteke is taking the penalties too.

 

sxp55 Flag South Norwood 19 Sep 16 1.53pm

If we're picking the best team not the best players then currently for me Cabaye doesn't start.

 


@sxp55555

Mr_Gristle Flag In the land of Whelk Eaters 19 Sep 16 1.55pm

Originally posted by Alex1991


McArthur was so on point yesterday. When he plays like that we tick, and could be seen as the most important midfielder we have.

Said it before and I'll say it again - Jimmy Mac is the heartbeat of the team.

It's only a good thing that Ledley is putting pressure on Cabaye for a place next to him in the midfield. Once Cabaye gets back into the side though, can we keep him away from set piece delivery?

 


Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune)

BarEagle Flag Monmouth 19 Sep 16 2.06pm

I just don't think Cabaye can or should walk straight back into the team.

He is class but his penalties have been woeful, as have his free kicks and corners.

 

Alex1991 Flag Ashford 19 Sep 16 2.06pm

Originally posted by Mr_Gristle

Said it before and I'll say it again - Jimmy Mac is the heartbeat of the team.

It's only a good thing that Ledley is putting pressure on Cabaye for a place next to him in the midfield. Once Cabaye gets back into the side though, can we keep him away from set piece delivery?

And I shall agree with you once again

For me McCabaye is the best midfield combo, although Ledley has been very good. Yohan would have had a field day yesterday I believe.

 


"Brighton are talking about how they're coming for us. And it's like, we've been waiting in the Premier League for you for ages." Wilfried Zaha, 2017.

wally2606 Flag Cheltenham 19 Sep 16 2.38pm

It's a great position of strength to have and a nice headache for Pardew to have, Cabaye hasn't looked himself, apart from 2nd half versus Spurs, he hasn't been 100% fit yet and this break to get his fitness will do him the world of good, I thought Ledley and Macarthur were outstanding yesterday, Jimmy Mac in particular he is possibly our most important player who links everything

 

Username Flag Horsham 19 Sep 16 3.53pm

Originally posted by georgey wood

I think pardiola has stumbled on a good formation here. Ledley and jimmy mac have the extra legs and defensive nouse to allow the front 4 rotate and play freely. Although cabaye a class above technically he hasnt got the legs or natural defensive instincts of either. His passing range with benteke and townsend running in behind may be interesting to see when hes back. However in current system can only see him fitting in for jimmy mac whos best player at club for me. Dm flamini or ledders, centre jimmy mac or cabaye. With punch and lee fighting out 10 role.for me shape is so important as you have to expect punch and zaha to lose the ball at times its just the way they play. I think we have a nice blend in middle now but must play best mix not always best individuals, of which cabaye clearly is. Yohan over to you mate to get back in side...

Edited by georgey wood (19 Sep 2016 1.49pm)

Completely disagree.

Cabaye showed last season that he has both.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

silvertop Flag Portishead 19 Sep 16 3.58pm

Yup. There were a number of reasons for our drop in form from xmas - almost all down to injuries with a consequent drop in confidence.

Lazy journalists pointed at the loss of Bolasie as he is a flash media-friendly player. For my part, the loss of Jimmy Mac was the more important. There was almost an exact correlation between his absence and the team's failings.

I would be a much happier man if Mac was like The Unbreakable Jedinak. Imagine him going season after season with barely an injury?

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 19 Sep 16 4.02pm

Originally posted by Username

Completely disagree.

Cabaye showed last season that he has both.

...In spades.

Which is more than I can say for Flamini. He got left for dead yesterday and could have cost us a goal [if it was anyone but Stoke]. I can't recall the last time I saw one of our players so well beaten for pace. Hopefully, this is something the coaches are working on to get him back to full match fitness.

 

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Ledley & McArthur