You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Steve Mandanda
November 16 2026 7.06am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Steve Mandanda


Page 2 of 19 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 02 Nov 16 5.19pm

Originally posted by cpj

Shhh, don't let BrentmeisterGeneral know of your dark thoughts! You are not allowed to criticise Mandanda because we bought him for a French club so he must be good.

How people can say he's made a load of great saves is beyond me - yes, one excellent one on Saturday, but other than that he's been beaten by some pretty ordinary efforts (Bournemouth, Sunderland, Boro come to mind) and has a worrying tendency not to even try saving some shots (W Ham and Everton, although apparently the latter was all the fault of the wall unlike when WH was being beaten by free kicks last season).

Re the corners on Saturday, for the second one he started out about 4 yards from goal, but moved back to his line once he saw the trajectory of the ball. Unlike our corners, which are floated in and give the keeper an age to follow the ball and grab it, the Liverpool corners were whipped in with pace and swing, so I'm not blaming Mandanda as much now for those.

Still not impressed with him though. As was said above, very much in the Speroni mode of making a few flash saves. And don't get me started on his dodgy distribution.

Someone has mentioned Barthez and said he was not too impressive when he started at Man Utd.Barthez was actually a player who had excellent distribution with hands and feet and liked to get rid of the ball quickly to build an attack.

Some saw him as a clown or eccentric figure but Houllier did say that he made the saves that matter.

 

Pierre Flag Purley 02 Nov 16 5.21pm

So for all of his appearances for us Mandanda watches Dann, Delaney or Tomkins clear crosses, free kicks and corners at will away from anywhere in the area but on Saturday suddenly he is faced with 2 virtually unstoppable headers one after half a challenge from Dann the other totally unchallenged.

But some on here want him suddenly to dash of his line and pluck the ball out of the air in his hands as if he knew it was going to happen!

We usually are much better at defending set pieces than that and I'm sure it has hurt the offending culprits this week and they will want to make up for it on Saturday (I bet Dann scores at Burnley).

However Mandanda is not to blame, is quality keeper and has already made some very fine saves.

Sort the back 4 out in front of him, that's what is going to make the difference this season so Palace are not always conceding first and having to try and win matches from behind all the bloody time!!!

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 02 Nov 16 5.24pm

Originally posted by Painter

Your opinion is misguided, his inability to come for crosses is unsettling the defence, it's pretty obvious.

A keeper that cannot catch a ball is the same player that cannot trap a ball.

People are blinded by the fact he is the French reserve keeper, let's face it, he doesn't compare to Lloris.

He has only made 11 appearances for France in the last 5 years.

But he was 'Ligue 1' goalkeeper of the year in 2014/15 and 2015/16.


Edited by Willo (02 Nov 2016 5.28pm)

 

paperhat Flag croydon 02 Nov 16 5.26pm

Originally posted by cpj

Shhh, don't let BrentmeisterGeneral know of your dark thoughts! You are not allowed to criticise Mandanda because we bought him for a French club so he must be good.

How people can say he's made a load of great saves is beyond me - yes, one excellent one on Saturday, but other than that he's been beaten by some pretty ordinary efforts (Bournemouth, Sunderland, Boro come to mind) and has a worrying tendency not to even try saving some shots (W Ham and Everton, although apparently the latter was all the fault of the wall unlike when WH was being beaten by free kicks last season).

Re the corners on Saturday, for the second one he started out about 4 yards from goal, but moved back to his line once he saw the trajectory of the ball. Unlike our corners, which are floated in and give the keeper an age to follow the ball and grab it, the Liverpool corners were whipped in with pace and swing, so I'm not blaming Mandanda as much now for those.

Still not impressed with him though. As was said above, very much in the Speroni mode of making a few flash saves. And don't get me started on his dodgy distribution.

This post coming from the WH fan club who self -admittedly hasn't seen much of Mandanda this season!!

The highlighted part of your post, the main difference - SM would naturally have expected the wall to do what walls do, block and jump. they did neither, hence A) his annoyance and B) his lack of movement.

WH set his wall up, let it block the half of the goal it was meant to, moved into 'his part' of the goal mouth, then inexplicably, moved back behind the wall as the ball was struck. Not once, but at least twice in the space of as many matches if I recall.

Your fixation with WH is almost as un-nerving as Willos love of Mark Clattenburg.

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 02 Nov 16 5.29pm

Originally posted by Willo

He has only made 11 appearances for France in the last 5 years.

So not as experienced internationally as WH then?

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 02 Nov 16 5.33pm

Originally posted by sickboy

So not as experienced internationally as WH then?

Hennessey is far more experienced internationally.

 

Satan_Claus Flag Aalborg 02 Nov 16 6.13pm

C'mon...this thread was obviously meant as trolling...
Unfortunately MARKY must be having a good laugh now...

 

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 02 Nov 16 6.33pm

Originally posted by Willo

Hennessey is far more experienced internationally.

For a far inferior international nation with no one out there to challenge his place. It is an invalid argument the whole "he
Plays for wales" thing. If there was another half decent welsh goalie out there then he wouldn't be playing.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 02 Nov 16 6.35pm

Anyway, this thread isn't about Wayne f***ing Hennessey. Let's not make it about him eh.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

cpj Flag Kent 02 Nov 16 6.38pm

Originally posted by paperhat

This post coming from the WH fan club who self -admittedly hasn't seen much of Mandanda this season!!

The highlighted part of your post, the main difference - SM would naturally have expected the wall to do what walls do, block and jump. they did neither, hence A) his annoyance and B) his lack of movement.

WH set his wall up, let it block the half of the goal it was meant to, moved into 'his part' of the goal mouth, then inexplicably, moved back behind the wall as the ball was struck. Not once, but at least twice in the space of as many matches if I recall.

Your fixation with WH is almost as un-nerving as Willos love of Mark Clattenburg.

I've now seen him 3 times and have been underwhelmed on each occasion.

 

cpj Flag Kent 02 Nov 16 6.39pm

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

Anyway, this thread isn't about Wayne f***ing Hennessey. Let's not make it about him eh.

As with Clattenburg, 'it's all about you' and your hatred for one of our players!

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 02 Nov 16 6.56pm

I have to say I'm not over impressed with Mandada and I don't think he's that much better than WH. Liverpool's fourth goal, albeit, not entirely his fault I admit, but he went down far too early which gave Firmini an easy task to dink it over his prone body. If he had stood tall just maybe he would have had a chance to stop the goal.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 02 Nov 16 6.57pm

Originally posted by Pierre

So for all of his appearances for us Mandanda watches Dann, Delaney or Tomkins clear crosses, free kicks and corners at will away from anywhere in the area but on Saturday suddenly he is faced with 2 virtually unstoppable headers one after half a challenge from Dann the other totally unchallenged.

But some on here want him suddenly to dash of his line and pluck the ball out of the air in his hands as if he knew it was going to happen!

We usually are much better at defending set pieces than that and I'm sure it has hurt the offending culprits this week and they will want to make up for it on Saturday (I bet Dann scores at Burnley).

However Mandanda is not to blame, is quality keeper and has already made some very fine saves.

Sort the back 4 out in front of him, that's what is going to make the difference this season so Palace are not always conceding first and having to try and win matches from behind all the bloody time!!!


This...as fans we were all suprised at letting in 2 goals from set pieces. Mandanda would have been expecting dann to clear the first, and at least someone to challenge for the second. Can't believe people are blaming him for these goals, and not praising him for what was one unbelievable save and an excellent save when mane was clean through.


 

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 02 Nov 16 7.50pm

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

For a far inferior international nation with no one out there to challenge his place. It is an invalid argument the whole "he
Plays for wales" thing. If there was another half decent welsh goalie out there then he wouldn't be playing.

How far did they get at the euros with him in goal?

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 02 Nov 16 10.38pm

This is nonsense.

First of hall Hennessey's command of the area was very poor despite his height.

He was also, on a number of occasions, slow to go for the ball or completely flat footed.

While we're being picky it was also a poor kick from him that indirectly led to United's winner the cup final.

Some serious amnesia in this thread

 

coulsdoneagle Flag London 02 Nov 16 10.47pm

11th out of 24 keepers across the league for saves made this season.

 

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 02 Nov 16 11.12pm

Originally posted by sickboy

How far did they get at the euros with him in goal?

They did fantastically well and surprised everyone. Not going to deny that at all. In general though, France are a far superior outfit. With a lot more competition in every position than Wales and most other footballing nations.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

Alexi_the_Eagle Flag Newton-le-Willows 02 Nov 16 11.13pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

This is nonsense.

First of hall Hennessey's command of the area was very poor despite his height.

He was also, on a number of occasions, slow to go for the ball or completely flat footed.

While we're being picky it was also a poor kick from him that indirectly led to United's winner the cup final.

Some serious amnesia in this thread

^This. Had Hennessey been in goal for the Liverpool game, we would of all been baying for his blood on here. As for Mandanda, he's a solid keeper. Just needs the defence to sort themselves out around him.

 


"Look at that. Accident blackspot? These aren't accidents! They're throwing themselves into the road gladly! Throwing themselves into the road to escape all this hideousness!"

batcountry Flag Melbourne 03 Nov 16 2.43am

SM has been a sitting duck lately. We could have Neuer, Courtois and Mandanda playing simultaneously and our defence would still find a way to give them no chance.

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 03 Nov 16 6.36am

Does he speak English well, do we know? With Hennessy, I felt the defence seemed to give away fewer chances than it did with Speroni and now Mandanda. I don't know if that's really the case or just my impression. But I do wonder if Mandanda speaks fluent English and, if not, how the defence communicates in some of the more nuanced parts of a match. The Steeeeeeve chant probably helps Mandanda's popularity. For the record, I like him but then I also thought Hennessey was under rated.

I don't see them miles apart.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Page 2 of 19 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Steve Mandanda