You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Shock! A Corbyn policy worth supporting.
November 21 2026 11.59pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Shock! A Corbyn policy worth supporting.


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
Nest Flag 06 Apr 17 2.20pm

Originally posted by Only 10 a year!!

How does offering free school meals for all benefit?

healthier children, better academic performance and an end to the stigma around free school meals

 

Only 10 a year!! Flag 06 Apr 17 2.22pm

Originally posted by Nest

healthier children, better academic performance and an end to the stigma around free school meals

But the majority do not need the help, so why focus £2b of income where it is not needed?

There is not that great a stigma to FSM.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 06 Apr 17 2.23pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

You can't stop teachers wanting the best paid and appealing jobs. You could ban private education but I doubt that would work out too well. The system reflects Darwinian principles. Those that succeed have the advantages and make the rules. Appealing as it is to equalise things through policy, I believe it is doomed to failure. VAT on school fees is really just a stealth tax on the rich. I'm not convinced it is going to work for the purposes of social engineering.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (06 Apr 2017 2.13pm)

Personally I would ban the private education system.

In the same way we ban private armies or private fire services.

Private systems are divisive and produce and encourage elites....who then suck up the best within society just for themselves and their kids.

Government should be run for the many not the few.

We should encourage meritocracy not elitism.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 06 Apr 17 2.25pm

Maggie wouldn't even let kids have free milk.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 06 Apr 17 2.25pm

Originally posted by Only 10 a year!!

But the majority do not need the help, so why focus £2b of income where it is not needed?

There is not that great a stigma to FSM.

I think you have a point about where the funding is being directed here.

I'm more just against the concepts behind the private system in the first place.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 06 Apr 17 2.27pm

Originally posted by We are goin up!

It's related yes, but not really relevant. You can be for the abolition of private schools and still think this policy is pure garbage. It doesn't actually improve the education of one single child, does it? It's gesturing, plain and simple.

Edited by We are goin up! (06 Apr 2017 2.11pm)

Maybe you have a point there.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

We are goin up! Flag Coulsdon 06 Apr 17 2.30pm

Privatise the education system with government funded vouchers given to families based on their household income. Competition for standards and everyone has equal access to the system. Would be worth it for the NUT's reaction alone.

 


The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money.

Only 10 a year!! Flag 06 Apr 17 2.31pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

I think you have a point about where the funding is being directed here.

I'm more just against the concepts behind the private system in the first place.

Yes. I have nothing against taxing Private Schools as they could probably afford it although a few would probably close but I would rather see any money spent on other things such as literacy/numeracy programs or holiday or after school provision.

FSM for all is such a cheap shallow people pleaser.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 06 Apr 17 2.31pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Personally I would ban the private education system.

In the same way we ban private armies or private fire services.

Private systems are divisive and produce and encourage elites....who then suck up the best within society just for themselves and their kids.

Government should be run for the many not the few.

We should encourage meritocracy not elitism.

I agree, but meritocracy leads to what we have now. That is the bind. Those that succeed make the rules. What is the point of doing well in education if it has no meaning full advantage? Those that have money want their kids to well and so it goes.
In practice, would banning private education really improve all other education?

 

Nest Flag 06 Apr 17 2.32pm

Originally posted by We are goin up!

It's related yes, but not really relevant. You can be for the abolition of private schools and still think this policy is pure garbage. It doesn't actually improve the education of one single child, does it? It's gesturing, plain and simple.

Edited by We are goin up! (06 Apr 2017 2.11pm)

There is plenty of research and analysis to prove it is very worthwhile
healthier children, better academic performance and end the stigma around free school meals

'Shock'

 

We are goin up! Flag Coulsdon 06 Apr 17 2.34pm

Originally posted by Nest

There is plenty of research and analysis to prove it is very worthwhile
healthier children, better academic performance and end the stigma around free school meals

'Shock'


Yeah because fried food every weekday lunchtime really promotes good health.

 


The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money.

Stirlingsays Flag 06 Apr 17 2.36pm

Originally posted by We are goin up!

Privatise the education system with government funded vouchers given to families based on their household income. Competition for standards and everyone has equal access to the system. Would be worth it for the NUT's reaction alone.

The teacher unions are full of lefty idealogs who I rarely agree with.

But when it comes to equality of opportunity for children....I tend to agree with them.

In terms of the state, all children should start off with a clean slate and be treated equality.


 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Nest Flag 06 Apr 17 2.36pm

Originally posted by We are goin up!

Yeah because fried food every weekday lunchtime really promotes good health.

“This is a welcome move which we have long campaigned for. The evidence on the benefits for children of extending school meals is very strong. It shows children’s school results are boosted, their diet improves and parents in food poverty have more to spend on nutritious breakfast and dinners for their kids. What’s more, free school meals save families much-needed money and strengthen work incentives, helping parents get better off through work.

“The minority of children currently on free school meals tell us they feel stigmatised; extending entitlement should reduce, if not eliminate, that problem. If the concern is the well-being of children in just-managing families, the case for extending entitlement is a compelling one.”

Child Poverty Action Group Chief Executive Alison Garnham

 

Stirlingsays Flag 06 Apr 17 2.39pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

I agree, but meritocracy leads to what we have now. That is the bind. Those that succeed make the rules. What is the point of doing well in education if it has no meaning full advantage? Those that have money want their kids to well and so it goes.
In practice, would banning private education really improve all other education?

So are you saying that if you are working class and you do well in education that you have access to the same opportunities that rich kids in private schools have?

I don't believe that is the case at all. None of the statistics back that up for example.

People talk about meritocracy but within society the reality is very different.

I don't think you could entirely ban private education but you could certainly make it more difficult and not state supported.

Edited by Stirlingsays (06 Apr 2017 2.42pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

regal_eagle Flag somewhere 06 Apr 17 2.40pm

Labour in promise to spend more of your money shocker!

 

Stirlingsays Flag 06 Apr 17 2.45pm

Originally posted by regal_eagle

Labour in promise to spend more of your money shocker!

Well those sending their children to private schools have less to pay because the tax payer gives their institution hand outs in the form of tax breaks.

So who is making money out of whom?

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

OknotOK Flag Cockfosters, London 06 Apr 17 2.48pm

Originally posted by regal_eagle

Labour in promise to spend more of your money shocker!

Depends on who you are? If you're not one of the small % with children attending private school then all you'll get is money back (assuming that the pledge is funded as intended).

It is utterly bizarre that private schools are exempt from VAT. It cannot be justified ideologically.*

And there is *some* evidence that universal provision of free school meals can lead to an overall improvement in standards. There appears to be some debate at the moment about the exact magnitude of that improvement and whether the studies were reasonable for extrapolation. I guess more research is needed.

But the worst that would happen would be a tax break largely for the very rich would be taken away (VAT exemption leading to a reduction in fees) and replaced with a benefit mostly given to the middle class (FSM). So that doesn't seem a particularly bad thing.

*Having said that it would be interesting to see the projections for the number who are likely to leave the private school system and the costs associated with that for the state. I've not seen the numbers touted by the Head of the Private School Association this morning about 20% being from families with less than £50k but I would think it is very unlikely. Even if the average fees are £10k (which is the lower end of the scale) then the vast majority of those on under £50k a year would find that completely unaffordable. So it suggests that actually they are on bursaries/scholarships - which would mean they wouldn't be affected by increases in fees to the same extent?

Edited by OknotOK (06 Apr 2017 2.51pm)

 


"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 06 Apr 17 2.58pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

So are you saying that if you are working class and you do well in education that you have access to the same opportunities that rich kids in private schools have?

I don't believe that is the case at all. None of the statistics back that up for example.

People talk about meritocracy but within society the reality is very different.

I don't think you could entirely ban private education but you could certainly make it more difficult and not state supported.

Edited by Stirlingsays (06 Apr 2017 2.42pm)

No.
I'm saying that you will have winners and losers in any system you employ and that those who lose will always want to change the system and those that win will always want to fix the system to benefit their offspring.

 

hedgehog50 Flag Croydon 06 Apr 17 3.01pm

I don't think private schools should get tax breaks. I don't think charities should get tax breaks. I don't think all primary school children should get free dinners.

 


We have now sunk to a depth at which the restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men. [Orwell]

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 06 Apr 17 3.14pm

Will the fat kids get free meals as well?

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Shock! A Corbyn policy worth supporting.