You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Massive Squad overhaul needed
November 16 2026 9.36am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Massive Squad overhaul needed


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
EverOptimisticEagle Flag 07 May 17 12.59pm

I can see as many as 13 players leave with Sahko and Remy's loans ending as well. So 15 in total.

An addition of 6 quality players coming in. GK, RB, LCB, DM, ACM, RW/ATT

That would leave the squad in a good place with a one out, one in policy moving forward.

 

cpj Flag Kent 07 May 17 12.59pm

Originally posted by Dan89


James mcarthur been terrible now for at least a month. Name one good game his played under Sam. I mentioned that Tomkins had done well earlier on the thread. Luka without Sakho you may aswell have jedinak. I've been impressed with schlupp but PVA is average at best. Dann is not prem standard anymore. I also stated that it's unlikely that many would leave but I wouldn't be disappointed if they did.

Edited by Dan89 (07 May 2017 12.57pm)

Since he got injured - may not be fully fit. Was excellent earlier in the season.

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 07 May 17 1.01pm

Originally posted by cpj

Since he got injured - may not be fully fit. Was excellent earlier in the season.

That maybe true but he's been back for at least a month. He form has diminished

He's been back since January 31st. He should be fully fit by now.

Edited by Dan89 (07 May 2017 1.08pm)

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 07 May 17 1.06pm

Originally posted by EverOptimisticEagle

I can see as many as 13 players leave with Sahko and Remy's loans ending as well. So 15 in total.

An addition of 6 quality players coming in. GK, RB, LCB, DM, ACM, RW/ATT

That would leave the squad in a good place with a one out, one in policy moving forward.

If 13 players plus loanees left and we signed 6, that would leave the squad pretty threadbare. It's bad enough covering injuries now without a net reduction of 9 in overall squad size.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 07 May 17 1.13pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

I just hope that finally the chairman will realise tht you can't do things on the cheap.

I'd say we need two center halfs, two strikers, another right back,goalkeeper and a midfielder. That's 7.

Outs,

Campbell,Chung,Fryers,Delaney,Kelly,Mandander.

Pretty much spot on. Kelly I might consider as a back up player (as he can play full back and centre back) but we need two central defenders, a right back, a goal keeper (Pickford from Sunderland maybe) and a defensive minded midfielder.

See, we do sometimes agree - All of those players, except maybe Kelly, I'd say are surplus to requirements over several seasons.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 07 May 17 1.27pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Pretty much spot on. Kelly I might consider as a back up player (as he can play full back and centre back) but we need two central defenders, a right back, a goal keeper (Pickford from Sunderland maybe) and a defensive minded midfielder.

See, we do sometimes agree - All of those players, except maybe Kelly, I'd say are surplus to requirements over several seasons.

We agree on quite a lot of things.

There is an argument for 2 centre halfs in and 1 out. Perhaps 3 in and 2 out would be better.

 

EverOptimisticEagle Flag 07 May 17 1.48pm

Originally posted by Cucking Funt

If 13 players plus loanees left and we signed 6, that would leave the squad pretty threadbare. It's bad enough covering injuries now without a net reduction of 9 in overall squad size.

With who I would keep/sell/release It would leave us with 19 players if you included speroni, boateng and Kai Kai. They would need to be included in the 25 due to age next year.

 

EverOptimisticEagle Flag 07 May 17 1.54pm

Originally posted by EverOptimisticEagle

With who I would keep/sell/release It would leave us with 19 players if you included speroni, boateng and Kai Kai. They would need to be included in the 25 due to age next year.

It would look something like this....if I was in charge (thank goodness I am not)

IMG_0270.PNG Attachment: IMG_0270.PNG (1,544.84Kb)

 

tonymikejoe Flag UK 07 May 17 1.55pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

I just hope that finally the chairman will realise tht you can't do things on the cheap.

I'd say we need two center halfs, two strikers, another right back,goalkeeper and a midfielder. That's 7.

Outs,

Campbell,Chung,Fryers,Delaney,Kelly,Mandander.


Parish will be choking on his champagne if he reads this.

This season we splashed a staggering £30m on Benteke, whose 14 goals give us a chance of staying up.

We also did £13m on an England international (Andros) and during the January window Parish spent another £30m-odd.

As a club we have thrown absolutely mental money at it.

 

OhthisbloodyPC Flag 07 May 17 2.00pm

I never realised the squad was so vast. Somewhere in those ranks there's a hiding Japanese soldier who doesn't know that World Wa II has ended.

Originally posted by Stuart Shave

Full Squad as it currently stands :

Goalkeepers - Wayne Hennessey, Steve Mandanda, Kleton Perntreou, Julian Speroni

Defenders – Luke Croll, Scott Dann, Damien Delaney, Zeki Fryers, Ryan Inniss, Martin Kelly, (Mamadou Sakho), Jeffrey Schlupp, Pape Souare, James Tomkins, Patrick van Aanholt, Joel Ward, Ben Wynter

Midfielders - Hiram Boateng, Yohan Cabaye, Luke Dreher, Mathieu Flamini, Noor Husin, Sullay KaiKai, Joe Ledley, Chung-Yong Lee, James McArthur, Luka Milivojevic, Jordon Mutch, Michael Phillips, Jason Puncheon, Bakary Sako, Andros Townsend, Aaron Wan-Bissaka, Jonathan Williams, Wilfried Zaha

Forwards - Keshi Anderson, Kwesi Appiah, Christian Benteke, Jonathan Benteke, Fraizer Campbell, Freddie Ladapo, (Loic Remy), Connor Wickham

Edited by Stuart Shave (07 May 2017 11.47am)

 

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 07 May 17 2.07pm

Originally posted by EverOptimisticEagle

With who I would keep/sell/release It would leave us with 19 players if you included speroni, boateng and Kai Kai. They would need to be included in the 25 due to age next year.

Neither Boateng or Kaikai are good enough

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 07 May 17 2.21pm

Originally posted by Dan89


James mcarthur been terrible now for at least a month. Name one good game his played under Sam. I mentioned that Tomkins had done well earlier on the thread. Luka without Sakho you may aswell have jedinak. I've been impressed with schlupp but PVA is average at best. Dann is not prem standard anymore. I also stated that it's unlikely that many would leave but I wouldn't be disappointed if they did.

Edited by Dan89 (07 May 2017 12.57pm)

1 whole month? Yeah you're right I hadn't realised it had been such a run of poor form.

Luca has just arrived in the PL, if anything he has done well to adapt as quickly as he has. A lot of top European players tak a full season to adapt. We should see the best of him next season.

Interesting take on PVA v Schlupp, personally I think PVA is the better of the two but that's opinions I guess.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

ger20 Flag London 07 May 17 2.22pm

Think we can clear out Kelly, and Delaney. Possible sign Sahko or another equally competent CB. new RB with Ward becoming a squad player, Keep Cabaye, Townsend, Benteke if possible and buy a new striker

 

MrCParrot Flag Taunton 07 May 17 2.29pm

Originally posted by Cucking Funt
Neither Boateng or Kaikai are good enough

To be fairer I would say unproven at this level. I want to see them get a chance next season. Both have talent its a case of them proving it when they get a chance. Same with Lapado. If we don't give them a chance then why bother at all with young players.

Parrot

 


Mr Cadbury's Parrot says "Hello"

tonymikejoe Flag UK 07 May 17 2.36pm

Don't really see a massive overhaul occurring considering how much money has been invested into the current squad.

If we kept everybody currently with us the only area I see considerable improvement possible would be:

Goalkeeper; Left-footed centre-half and a Number 10 to support the centre-forward.

That's it, but would cost around £40m to be potentially really effective and not come with any guarantees.

 

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 07 May 17 2.37pm

Originally posted by MrCParrot

To be fairer I would say unproven at this level. I want to see them get a chance next season. Both have talent its a case of them proving it when they get a chance. Same with Lapado. If we don't give them a chance then why bother at all with young players.

Parrot

KaiKai is 44.

 


Pro USA & Israel

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 07 May 17 2.39pm

Originally posted by MrCParrot

To be fairer I would say unproven at this level. I want to see them get a chance next season. Both have talent its a case of them proving it when they get a chance. Same with Lapado. If we don't give them a chance then why bother at all with young players.

Parrot

They've already had chances whilst on loan and neither have been remarkable. They just haven't shown the spark of a Zaha, Clyne or even a Williams. If they were still below the age limit, then perhaps they could occasionally feature but they're both way below the standard required in a Premiership squad. Next season, quality in depth is going to be essential and, IMO, it's far too risky to include them. At this level, we need Premiership quality players across the whole squad.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

whitehorselane Flag 07 May 17 2.43pm

Originally posted by MrCParrot

To be fairer I would say unproven at this level. I want to see them get a chance next season. Both have talent its a case of them proving it when they get a chance. Same with Lapado. If we don't give them a chance then why bother at all with young players.

Parrot

Agree with Parrot. They have got to a better option than Remy. Got to develope our youngsters.

Cannot judge players until they've been given the opportunity

 

Pierre Flag Purley 07 May 17 2.50pm

Originally posted by Dan89

We had a lot of injuries this season, but it's clearly shown the lack of quality in the squad. A lot of fans thought this is the best squad we assembled. We can all blame pardew, he is part of the problem but the likes of puncheon, Delaney and many others are not up to prem anymore. If I was big Sam I would only keep Zaha,Benteke, Townsend and cabaye. The rest have massively let us down this season. Where's the James mcarthur of 2016. Even luka not as good as we first thought. It a big summer ahead to rectify a very poor squad. It proves that Sam doesn't trust the subs on the bench.

Your thoughts on our squad

How do propose to get around EUFA's FFP rules by executing this plan of action?

 

Painter Flag Croydon 07 May 17 2.58pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

I just hope that finally the chairman will realise tht you can't do things on the cheap.

quote]

You are talking a load of crap. A good scouting network to find new players is what's needed, not just splashing out cash on overpriced players with greedy agents.
It is impossible to clear out a squad of players, they are on contracts, if nobody is going to offer to buy them, your stuck with them. This is the problem every new manager has, they inherit players they don't want. As a club we cant afford to just ignore them, we have to try and get the best out of them and get them playing.
I think far to many posters on here think the Football Manager game is reality.

 

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Massive Squad overhaul needed