You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Charlie Gard
November 21 2026 11.33pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Charlie Gard


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
Mr Palaceman Flag 11 Jul 17 12.52pm

Originally posted by Michaelawt85

Ashya king wasn't being kept alive by a ventilator with severe irreversible brain damage that for me is the key difference.

That's a very good point and I understand that.

My point is more that they don't always get it right. Most of the time I'm sure they do but they didn't give Ashya a chance. To the point that they actually tried to stop his treatment. It's like we're right and you can't even try, because we're right.

They may be right in this case, we can't know. The problem I have is that there is a slim option for another way at another hospital but the parents are being denied the right to try.

 


"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead"

Stan Laurel

Mr Palaceman Flag 11 Jul 17 12.59pm

Originally posted by Lyons550


I work in Social Services and i see all manner of services being provide for young and old; the cost of which is horrifying...but...it's not about the cost for a child that can be taken to rehabilition units...or sensory centers is it..it's about the practicalities and cost of keeping a child alive solely through machines...for what purpose? What quality of life is that for the child?

As I say...in my eyes its selfish to have the poor child suffer.

I appreciate it's certainly one of those morale scenarios that see's those commenting on it in one of two camps....which is why I guess it's best for the Courts to decide based on the evidence and come to a pragmatic decision.

I can understand that it's not always for the best and that may be so in this case.

I just think while there is a chance of some extra treatment, then they should not be denied the chance.

There are many cases where the doctors have been wrong.

 


"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead"

Stan Laurel

CambridgeEagle Flag Sydenham 11 Jul 17 1.10pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Surely that depends on why the parents are so insistent on keeping the child alive. Is it for their benefit or his?

The lad is severely brain damaged, cannot move arms or legs, is deaf and blind and cannot exist without a ventilator.

Even the Americans who are offering him this experimental drug treatment agree that it can't reverse his brain damage.

His quality of life is absolutely zero and unlikely to improve so surely it's in the child's best interests to let him die with dignity, especially as the doctors don't even know if he can feel pain

I agree.

My wife is a Doctor at GOSH and she tells me that she and the rest of the staff are finding this very upsetting. They are getting death threats on social media. GOSH is limited in what it can do in terms of making public statements as it has a legal responsibility to act in a certain way (purely in the interests of the child). They also care for hundreds of sick children every day and hundreds die every year in the hospital as it's a national centre for rare and complex conditions for children. They can only give Charlie Gard the same level of care and treatment they give all their children.

I think the media reaction to this has been over the top and has lead to undue pressure on the hospital and its staff who do an excellent job.

The experimental treatment has a very small chance of even limited success and would do very little to provide any really quality adjusted life years for this child. The Americans are using it as a political tool to demonstrate why state provision of health care is a bad thing.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 11 Jul 17 1.14pm

Charlie cannot communicate in any way and the doctors think that there is a good chance that his illness and treatments are causing him pain but he can't express it.

Even the US doctor who is happy to try out his experimental drug on him thinks that there isn't much chance as Charlie is far worse than he originally thought

 

Mr_Gristle Flag In the land of Whelk Eaters 11 Jul 17 1.21pm

I can't help feeling that this whole saga has crossed the line from being about the welfare of an infant who is unable to exist (I don't use the term "live" deliberately) without permanent life support to being about the wants and needs of his parents.

I'm glad that in my parenting career to date, I've never had to face what the Gards are having to deal with. Still, I'm convinced that they are no longer acting solely in the child's interests. I also think they're being swept along in the media bubble that now surrounds them and this too is not something that's being done with the child's interests at heart.

The massed ranks of expert medical and legal opinion is once again being portrayed by some media elements as being a malign force.

It's all starting to look a bit shabby, to be honest.


Edited by Mr_Gristle (11 Jul 2017 1.22pm)

 


Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune)

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 11 Jul 17 1.37pm

If there is treatment in the US, even if it fails which is highly likely, then let him go if that is what the parents want.

Because the poor lad will die anyway but at least if used as some kind of guinea pig then the results may mean better help for the kids in the future with the same condition and at least then his mum and dad will know they have exhausted all routes and something positive could still come out of it.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 11 Jul 17 1.49pm

I think that the parents are being incredibly selfish.

I can't condemn them for it though

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

wordup Flag 11 Jul 17 1.51pm

Originally posted by Michaelawt85

What are people's opinions on this case?

Didn't follow it from the very start but having picked the story up I am starting to have very strong thoughts on this.

1. The parents and their supporters are starting to turn this into a circus and about themselves rather than what is best for this child

2. Trump , the pope et al should keep their opinions to themselves

3. Why is it being dragged out all over the media. Should be kept private between the hospital, family and courts.

4. The very good name of GOSH is being dragged through the mud and trampled on. I had a child of mine treated there as a day old baby . The work they do is fantastic. It's a hospital like no other when you walk through the door and see some of the sites in there you cannot help but feel utterly humbled by what they are dealing with on an hourly basis there.

They clearly love their son but I feel they are being selfish and have a mentality that he's theirs, they own him and can do what they like with him. It leaves a bad taste in the mouth.

Thoughts?

1 and 3 - It's their child and they clearly care deeply about him and want to give him a decent shot. It may be that in doing so the attention paid to this and the coverage can get a bit unwieldy. I on't agree that they've intentionally turned it into a media circus and all about them them.

4- Your experience of GOSH may not mirror theirs. At the end of the day hospitals have budgets and sadly they're not solely about 'what's the best for the child'. If this family can get access to treatment that may improve the life of their child then I don't blame them for fighting for it. You could argue that it would be a dereliction of duty if they didn't.


They're in such a terrible spot and I think people should pause before throwing around some of the terms they've used to described this family in suffering. Then again with the focus on the nation on them I can see why there are strong emotions on all sides.

 

Michaelawt85 Flag Bexley 11 Jul 17 1.59pm

Originally posted by Kermit8

If there is treatment in the US, even if it fails which is highly likely, then let him go if that is what the parents want.

Because the poor lad will die anyway but at least if used as some kind of guinea pig then the results may mean better help for the kids in the future with the same condition and at least then his mum and dad will know they have exhausted all routes and something positive could still come out of it.

From reading more about the case today the treatment hadn't even been tested on mice.
I totally 'get' what you are saying. Treatment and research has to start somewhere and over the generations there have been plenty of treatments which people have initially dismissed which later prove to be beneficial.

But.. there is something deeply uncomfortable about the parents having the 'right' to do this. From what I understand the child is unable to cry or express in any way whether he's in any form of pain. Hence doctors saying in their initial judgement they don't know whether he's in any pain or not. His breathing activity which could be an indicator can't be looked at to help as it's a machine performing that act for him. The treatment could help future cases but it could leave him to die an absolutely hideous death. All this is ifs, buts and maybes but I personally don't feel it's right to do that to any child and for what ends. Essentially turn them into a lab rat.

 


When I was a young girl my Mother said to me.. You listen here kid you're CPFC

chris123 Flag hove actually 11 Jul 17 2.07pm

Originally posted by Michaelawt85

From reading more about the case today the treatment hadn't even been tested on mice.
I totally 'get' what you are saying. Treatment and research has to start somewhere and over the generations there have been plenty of treatments which people have initially dismissed which later prove to be beneficial.

But.. there is something deeply uncomfortable about the parents having the 'right' to do this. From what I understand the child is unable to cry or express in any way whether he's in any form of pain. Hence doctors saying in their initial judgement they don't know whether he's in any pain or not. His breathing activity which could be an indicator can't be looked at to help as it's a machine performing that act for him. The treatment could help future cases but it could leave him to die an absolutely hideous death. All this is ifs, buts and maybes but I personally don't feel it's right to do that to any child and for what ends. Essentially turn them into a lab rat.

Better parents than the state surely?

 

bubble wrap Flag Carparks in South East London 11 Jul 17 3.21pm

Originally posted by Kermit8

If there is treatment in the US, even if it fails which is highly likely, then let him go if that is what the parents want.

Because the poor lad will die anyway but at least if used as some kind of guinea pig then the results may mean better help for the kids in the future with the same condition and at least then his mum and dad will know they have exhausted all routes and something positive could still come out of it.

Would be the easiest thing to do. But if it is going to cause Charlie further suffering its not the right thing to do.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 11 Jul 17 3.36pm

Originally posted by Michaelawt85

This is the thing and it's a very difficult area to discuss. But it's so they don't live with the what if. What about the child. He is being kept alive by a machine and has absolutely no quality of life and never will have. The treatment may help some of the symptoms but it will not cure him or make him get better in that sense. His mother keeps talking about him being able to ride a bike. I can understand she had that dream for her child when she gave birth but eventually reality and rational thinking needs to be paramount over your emotions. Anyone can be kept going by a machine doesn't mean it's the right thing to do.

I can't be alone in thinking the time they have left with him could be spent actually being at his side instead of doing the rounds of t.v. shows and shouting out in court rooms.

I make you right on all counts in each of your posts.

We lost two and later had one 13 weeks prem.

This family has another child. In the end they will have to move on as they appear to be causing suffering to Charlie and must be neglecting all other areas of their family life. Charlie too must be allowed to move on. And their other child should not have to live indefinitely in the shadow of what is evidently a hopeless case.

Doctors don't give up easily and GOSH is a fine institution. The parents are ruining the lives of everyone involved and nosey ill-informed outsiders voicing opinions and encouraging them is more than selfish.

 

Michaelawt85 Flag Bexley 11 Jul 17 4.22pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

I make you right on all counts in each of your posts.

We lost two and later had one 13 weeks prem.

This family has another child. In the end they will have to move on as they appear to be causing suffering to Charlie and must be neglecting all other areas of their family life. Charlie too must be allowed to move on. And their other child should not have to live indefinitely in the shadow of what is evidently a hopeless case.

Doctors don't give up easily and GOSH is a fine institution. The parents are ruining the lives of everyone involved and nosey ill-informed outsiders voicing opinions and encouraging them is more than selfish.

If I didn't know differently I would think they had the Mccanns pr team running this. Funds (in excess of £2million raised which they have access to) but have asked for more to cover legal fees and it was then revealed their legal representatives are working pro bono. More money requested to pay for the Pastor from the US to come over and pray at the child's bedside. GOSH said no to this and r He parents took to all types of social media to complain how unfair it was until the hospital eventually backed down. The father at court yesterday with the child's cuddly toy placed in his jacket pocket . That's what I mean by circus. It's a hospital. Goodness only knows what the parents and families visiting their own children on the same ward must be thinking of all this intrusion. The mum placing the child's passport in his hand saying he's ready and wanting to go to America and taking a photo for Twitter of the whole thing. People react differently to things and hopefully I will be lucky enough to never have to be in their shoes but I can't help but feel it's turned into a situation of us against the professionals / state. Alot of people hitching their wagon to this particular campaign are also very anti establishment anti state and quite simply they are against the state or legal body having any say over this poor child's treatment .

Edited by Michaelawt85 (11 Jul 2017 4.23pm)

 


When I was a young girl my Mother said to me.. You listen here kid you're CPFC

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 11 Jul 17 4.32pm

Originally posted by chris123

Better parents than the state surely?

Better the doctors than the parents?

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Mapletree Flag Croydon 11 Jul 17 4.50pm

Originally posted by chris123

Better parents than the state surely?

Because the parents are in a position to view this objectively. The comment from the very erudite mother on TV was 'a parent knows what their child wants'. Really? Sure there is a bond but there is also a great deal of wishful thinking (I like to pretend my kids have brains for example).

 

Michaelawt85 Flag Bexley 11 Jul 17 4.56pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

Because the parents are in a position to view this objectively. The comment from the very erudite mother on TV was 'a parent knows what their child wants'. Really? Sure there is a bond but there is also a great deal of wishful thinking (I like to pretend my kids have brains for example).

My children are older than charlie gard but if I asked them what they want replies would range from sweets to a certain toy to a trip out somewhere or maybe a friend round for a sleepover. This child cannot communicate in any way shape or form. Is only 10 months old so wouldn't form much of a rational response anyway and even if he was older no one would be having these types of conversations about life or death with a child. More crucially and very sadly he is completely unable now or in the future of doing any of the things a completely healthy or even another child with some disabilities can do. I am only starting to skirt round these kind of topics with my own mother and she's 66 and I am 32!! She has health problems and I am the next of kin and should the worst happen it will be on my shoulders to make the call. You have to think to yourself would the other person want to live like this. I am pretty sure no one would to be honest

Edited by Michaelawt85 (11 Jul 2017 4.58pm)

 


When I was a young girl my Mother said to me.. You listen here kid you're CPFC

the_mcanuff_stuff Flag Caterham 11 Jul 17 5.40pm

Even with this experimental treatment (and assuming it's a success), the poor boy will be left with irreversible brain damage and unable to live unassisted, without medical means. His quality of life will still be zero.

I'm a parent and also the uncle to a disabled boy, but I'm sorry to say, in this case they should let him die peacefully and with dignity.

And also, I can 100% understand the parent's stance and why they can't rationally distance themselves from the decision. Every parents views change when it's "your own". It's a perfectly natural bias. They are in denial about the severity of their son's condition, as is often the case with parents of disabled children, in my limited experience.

 

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 11 Jul 17 7.30pm

Originally posted by bubble wrap

Would be the easiest thing to do. But if it is going to cause Charlie further suffering its not the right thing to do.

Agreed. Was basing it on him not suffering anymore than he is already and if there is strong medical belief he would be even worse off then it's correct that the parents have the decisions made for them as tough as that is.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Lyons550 Flag Shirley 12 Jul 17 9.28am

Well done everyone for contributing in a rational and reasoned manner to a potentially incendiary subject...both sides of the debate having their say and getting their views across without the usual slanging matches erupting.

Some great and valid points from both sides

Just how HOL should be

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

HeathMan Flag Purley 12 Jul 17 9.54am

Have shared all your contributions with my wife. Please accept thanks from both of us.

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Charlie Gard