This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
on balance it's good for football.
If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities. |
|
|
Originally posted by stuckinbristol
What happens if the said player allows his contract to expire, making him a free agent? Does the buy back expire with the contract, or is he forever held to ransom by the original club? In the circumstances that you describe the buy back would expire as the contract is between selling and buying club. However, I wouldn't put it past the selling club to sign a separate contract with the player to re-acquire him in those circumstances but I'm guessing that the Unfair Contracts laws could come into effect
|
|
|
Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig
on balance it's good for football. Really? If you support a big club you mean. The whole thing is being manipulated by big clubs and their greed.
COYP |
|
|
Pogba I believe went on a free Originally posted by Dan89
This now becoming more common, sides are prepared to sell their younger player but this gives them some protection, in case the player becomes excellent. Imagine Man Utd put a buy back clause in pogba deal, it would of saved them a lot of money.
|
|
|
Fully agree. City and Chelsea are prime examples of disgusting behavior in that respect. Any season there are about a dozen players here in the Dutch league on loan and the aim of that is not at all to prepare them for first team football at the parent club but to make financial profit. Van Ginkel even publicly stated Chelsea forced him to extend his contract before agreeing to another loan at PSV and he fully realizes he will never ever play for them again. Originally posted by EagleinSF
This is a growing (and worrying) trend. TBH I don't think it will stop (or decline) until there are limits put on the amount of players in the professional leagues that you can have out on loan. This would curb some of the hoovering up of young talent.
|
|
|
Originally posted by DutchEagleJohan
Fully agree. City and Chelsea are prime examples of disgusting behavior in that respect. Any season there are about a dozen players here in the Dutch league on loan and the aim of that is not at all to prepare them for first team football at the parent club but to make financial profit. Van Ginkel even publicly stated Chelsea forced him to extend his contract before agreeing to another loan at PSV and he fully realizes he will never ever play for them again. What is wrong with a football club making a "Financial profit" ? In the situation described, the parent club makes a profit, the player benefits from first team football and the club he plays for gets the use of a good player.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo What is wrong with a football club making a "Financial profit" ? In the situation described, the parent club makes a profit, the player benefits from first team football and the club he plays for gets the use of a good player.
For instance if we decided that one of our young players needed first team football to progress and we couldn't do that. We have 2 options either to loan out or sell with a sell on clause. We did later with a couple of youngsters last year effectively free but if sold on we get a hefty percentage. Problem then is if they get released the clause goes with them. This has advantage for all both clubs and player. A young player who may not be good enough for EPL football gets at worst a career at a lower level, lower league club gets a "prospect" with ability to sell on and selling club gets a possibility of return on academy costs. The difference with a buy back clause is that selling club gets a good price to start with and a guarantee that they can get the player back if sucessful for below market value. Thus the big club gets all the benefits and none of the risks. If it is correct that Arsenal want a buy back clause for Chambers. They want a figure in excess of £20 million, this is not peanuts so to want a buy back clause at slightly above this,is wrong in my view. I think the FA should look at this as it the big clubs using there economic muscle against the slightly smaller. I have nothing against a player being sold with first refusal on any future sale being given to selling club however this should be at market value. The Loan system is also being manipulated by the big clubs eg Van Ginkel and Chelsea insisting he signs a new contract before yet another loan. If a player is loaned out during contract, the club gets a loan fee and receiving club pay his salary so what is risk for loaning club? He gets injured and they make a loss on any initial transfer fee? Insurance cover this.I think that FA should look at introducing rules that players who have been loaned out for more than 50% of contract or have not played more than 25 first team games can not be forced to sign a new contract. They should be allowed to find a new club if they want with fee being decided by tribunal if not agreed by clubs
|
|
|
/quote] Originally posted by Palace in the Blood
For instance if we decided that one of our young players needed first team football to potentially progress and we couldn't do that. We have 2 options either to loan out or sell with a sell on clause. We did this with a couple of youngsters last year effectively free but if sold on we get a hefty percentage. Problem then is if they get released the clause goes with them. This has advantage for all both clubs and player. A young player who may not be good enough for EPL football gets at worst a career at a lower level, lower league club gets a "prospect" with ability to sell on and selling club gets a possibility of return on academy costs. The difference with a buy back clause is that selling club gets a good price to start with and a guarantee that they can get the player back if sucesful for below market value. Thus the big club gets all the benefits and none of the risks. If it is correct that Arsenal want a buy back clause for Chambers. They want a figure in excess of £20 million, this is not peanuts so to want a buy back clause at slightly above this,is wrong in my view. I think the FA should look at this as it the big clubs using there economic muscle against the slightly smaller. I have nothing against a player being sold with first refusal on any future sale being given to selling club however this should be at market value. The Loan system is also being manipulated by the big clubs eg Van Ginkel and Chelsea insisting he signs a new contract before yet another loan. If a player is loaned out during contract, the club gets a loan fee and receiving club pay his salary so what is risk for loaning club? He gets injured and they make a loss on any initial transfer fee? Insurance cover this.I think that FA should look at introducing rules that players who have been loaned out for more than 50% of contract or have not played more than 25 first team games can not be forced to sign a new contract. They should be allowed to find a new club if they want with fee being decided by tribunal if not agreed by clubs[
|
|
|
Originally posted by Palace in the Blood
For instance if we decided that one of our young players needed first team football to progress and we couldn't do that. We have 2 options either to loan out or sell with a sell on clause. We did later with a couple of youngsters last year effectively free but if sold on we get a hefty percentage. Problem then is if they get released the clause goes with them. This has advantage for all both clubs and player. A young player who may not be good enough for EPL football gets at worst a career at a lower level, lower league club gets a "prospect" with ability to sell on and selling club gets a possibility of return on academy costs. The difference with a buy back clause is that selling club gets a good price to start with and a guarantee that they can get the player back if sucessful for below market value. Thus the big club gets all the benefits and none of the risks. If it is correct that Arsenal want a buy back clause for Chambers. They want a figure in excess of £20 million, this is not peanuts so to want a buy back clause at slightly above this,is wrong in my view. I think the FA should look at this as it the big clubs using there economic muscle against the slightly smaller. I have nothing against a player being sold with first refusal on any future sale being given to selling club however this should be at market value. The Loan system is also being manipulated by the big clubs eg Van Ginkel and Chelsea insisting he signs a new contract before yet another loan. If a player is loaned out during contract, the club gets a loan fee and receiving club pay his salary so what is risk for loaning club? He gets injured and they make a loss on any initial transfer fee? Insurance cover this.I think that FA should look at introducing rules that players who have been loaned out for more than 50% of contract or have not played more than 25 first team games can not be forced to sign a new contract. They should be allowed to find a new club if they want with fee being decided by tribunal if not agreed by clubs Without getting into protracted and fiesty debate let's just say we are on "Opposite sides of the house" on this matter. Gout in hand precludes me from lengthy keying ! Edited by Willo (26 Jul 2017 11.33am)
|
|
|
I could write a book about everything that's wrong with it. Players as young as 12 being poached away with their parents offered a job, may promising youth players never ever making it out of their trusted environment, financially powerful clubs having over 50 players out on loan, lesser league's like the Dutch one having even their mediocre plus players taken away by foreign clubs with buying power and not because they want the player for the first team but to make business. In my eyes it is a s wrong as it gets. Originally posted by Willo
What is wrong with a football club making a "Financial profit" ? In the situation described, the parent club makes a profit, the player benefits from first team football and the club he plays for gets the use of a good player.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
Really? If you support a big club you mean. The whole thing is being manipulated by big clubs and their greed. yeah really. good for the game because the current loan system is a catastrophe for talent development. every club buying a Chelsea youth player simply needs to evaluate the buyback when bidding. not that hard.
If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities. |
|
|
Well said by Palace in the blood.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
What is wrong with a football club making a "Financial profit" ? In the situation described, the parent club makes a profit, the player benefits from first team football and the club he plays for gets the use of a good player. Becuase it means all a super club has to do is buy all the young talent and watch while the other clubs pay to make them superstars before they leave... Let's pay £18m for Chambers and then once he's better Arsenal can have him back for £28m. Transfer inflation would likely mean he's worth more than that anyway.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig
yeah really. good for the game because the current loan system is a catastrophe for talent development. every club buying a Chelsea youth player simply needs to evaluate the buyback when bidding. not that hard. Yes but if, united, city, Arsenal and the other top clubs keep first loaning players to other Prem teams then it's not long before the market is saturated with there academy players. Those players then have Prem experience and are the ones you want to sign. Then said super clubs say you can only sign these players with buy back clauses... It's a complete monopoly... rigged for them.. everyone else become finishing schools with virtually no chance of uncovering the best talent...
|
|
|
Originally posted by Goldfiinger
Yes but if, united, city, Arsenal and the other top clubs keep first loaning players to other Prem teams then it's not long before the market is saturated with there academy players. It wouldn't be so bad if the players were brought up through their academies but they aren't as they just buy up talent and loan them out for others to develop. Whatever happened to Michael Hector who we were after a couple of years ago but who signed for Chelsea instead and disappeared into obscurity?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Goldfiinger
Becuase it means all a super club has to do is buy all the young talent and watch while the other clubs pay to make them superstars before they leave... Let's pay £18m for Chambers and then once he's better Arsenal can have him back for £28m. Transfer inflation would likely mean he's worth more than that anyway. A contractual negotiation and agreement between the buying club and selling club.If the buying club is content with the transfer agreement then fine - they have got the player they want. Perhaps our club would enter into a similar deal with a club wishing to purchase one of our assets in similar circumstances.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
Whatever happened to Michael Hector who we were after a couple of years ago but who signed for Chelsea instead and disappeared into obscurity? Should have Googled it before I posted as he's just joining Forest on loan.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.