You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > We can't progress because we won't let it happen
November 16 2026 9.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

We can't progress because we won't let it happen


Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
Mstrobez Flag 12 Aug 17 6.10pm

Originally posted by MKCPFC

What about them ?
They played a system that they had been playing all last season and were used to in the championship. They bought in some better players than they had last season and so were even better at it.
Probably played those players and system in the pre-season too.
They came up against us trying to play a similar system to them with a bunch of players that really were not comfortable with it . It was a gift of three points for them and most could see it coming a mile away.
Had we played the system we played once we had hit out stride under BS we would have had a much better chance of winning and I think we would have.

Now unless we think we can afford to keep on playing this system so we can get relegated and practice in the championship I would like us to play to our strengths and make progress slowly. That is , stay up attract and afford better players that we enable us to change our style gradually.


I don't necessarily disagree with this but the negative effect groaning every time a player tries to pass the ball out rather than hitting and hoping shouldn't be under estimated. It's like we refuse to even try.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 12 Aug 17 6.15pm

Originally posted by Mstrobez

I don't necessarily disagree with this but the negative effect groaning every time a player tries to pass the ball out rather than hitting and hoping shouldn't be under estimated. It's like we refuse to even try.

Trying is the operative word, if they could pass it out no one would moan , unfortunately we pass it three times for no reason then have to hoof it.

 

Mstrobez Flag 12 Aug 17 6.22pm

Originally posted by MKCPFC

Trying is the operative word, if they could pass it out no one would moan , unfortunately we pass it three times for no reason then have to hoof it.

I'm sorry but that's bulls***. We groaned *because* the ball was passed back to Hennessey and eventually it led to Riedewald hoofing it instead. I guess if that's the style you prefer to see then so be it

Edited by Mstrobez (12 Aug 2017 6.22pm)

Edited by Mstrobez (12 Aug 2017 6.22pm)

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

Sansbup Flag Norfolk 12 Aug 17 6.26pm

3:4:3 = relegation
4:3:3 = survival

Your choice.

Edited by Sansbup (12 Aug 2017 6.45pm)

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 12 Aug 17 6.51pm

Originally posted by MKCPFC

It's very simple . You play the system that suites your players until you are established enough to attract and afford players that can play a different system, and then maybe become Barca or suchlike.

Unfortunately the managers that understood this only stayed with us for half a season.

You cannot just announce a new system and expect the players to be able to play it.

And expect the keeper to suddenly change from being useless with the ball stuck between his feet to talented with the ball. And expect the players to keep giving it to him. Maybe a new keeper will solve this but I'd rather see all this after the players are in rather than before.

 


COYP

regal_eagle Flag somewhere 12 Aug 17 7.43pm

Originally posted by Mstrobez

I'm sorry but that's bulls***. We groaned *because* the ball was passed back to Hennessey and eventually it led to Riedewald hoofing it instead. I guess if that's the style you prefer to see then so be it

Edited by Mstrobez (12 Aug 2017 6.22pm)

Edited by Mstrobez (12 Aug 2017 6.22pm)

We were passing back to the Goalkeeper when under very little or no pressure, yet decided top hoof it up field when the defender was under pressure.

 

geoff Flag Midhurst 12 Aug 17 9.43pm

As a lifelong fan I want to see us progress in our 5th year in the premier league. I think the OP made some good points and think that people misunderstand richest league for best league.
I want to see us make progress in playing, ground, academy, coaches, training ground. But this has to be done over time. The team and squad have been built now for years around counter attacking aggressive speedy wingers type of football.we simply don't have the players who are comfortable with the ball at their feet to play 343. We have a different more traditional breed. It can work and we can change but we really need to spend to do it. Am really surprised in Parish going for this after the disaster Pardew made out of it with pretty much the same players. I want to see us dominate possession and pass the ball around and be more entertained but I want us to be in the premier league more and with gentle slow progression. We may have gone to quick to change too much too soon.

 

Dan1994 Flag Wallington 12 Aug 17 10.07pm

To be honest, I agree with pretty much everything Mstrobez said, bar the Huddersfield system, because their system is parking the bus and hassling, and always has been.

However, for me, it was very basic things we got very wrong... the passing, the crossing, the work ethic was all lacking today, and that is what worries me the most. You can tell when players are adapting, but for me it was the fundamentals which seemed to be very off today. Whether that's due to Huddersfield's game plan, I don't know.

At the end of the day, it's very difficult to say after just 1 game. I am in favour of trying the formation again, and if that means we gotta come back come November, that's fine, because we're Palace. I will always be there and cheer them on. Up the Palace.

 


[Link]

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 12 Aug 17 11.55pm

Originally posted by Mstrobez

I'm sorry but that's bulls***. We groaned *because* the ball was passed back to Hennessey and eventually it led to Riedewald hoofing it instead. I guess if that's the style you prefer to see then so be it

Edited by Mstrobez (12 Aug 2017 6.22pm)

Edited by Mstrobez (12 Aug 2017 6.22pm)

TBH I don't know what you are talking about now , I said if it was working we would not be groaning , I said we passed it three times before hoofing it (doesn't matter who) and know you confess to being the joining in with the groaning you were moaning about .

 

Mstrobez Flag 13 Aug 17 12.57am

I meant we as in Palace fans. I didn't groan, I wanna at least give it a chance and I found the atmosphere around Selhurst today just ridiculous, prior to going 3 down.

It's almost as if the writing is on the wall already for Frank and perhaps Steve should've factored in the style of play palace fans actually want to see. As for many it's quite clear it's not this.

Frank was actually my third choice, Silva and Pellegrino were above him in my list but I just cannot for the life of me work out what outcome will come from this negativity other than tears.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

RH8Eagle Flag Oxted 13 Aug 17 11.44am

We all went into this game with a lot of trepidation as we knew the system was going to be completely different. The groans from our fans so early on is a real wind up for me also and it was music to the oppositions ears. I am surprised us as fans don't realise the tension we bring to our home games in general. I think SP has gambled a bit hoping we can be better over the season than 3 other teams and progress with this system. I have concerns as we saw a simple press on us early on and we looked ragged, what will Liverpool do to us. We say we have the best league in the world and I agree with that but only for exciting attaching football where anyone can beat anyone no one or two horse races here.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 13 Aug 17 11.49am

A lot of the groans were happening not just because it was something new but because we were 2-0 down at home after 26 mins. And it was to the team favourites to finish bottom.

It was not just because of a bad pass or whatever. A lot of us knew we weren't ready for this 3-4-3 without the players and that is what transpired.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 13 Aug 17 11.50am

As soon as the team's were announced the palace win drifted 10% or 15% and the draw shortened. I said that would happen.

 


COYP

A89M Flag Streatham 13 Aug 17 12.07pm

I agree with everything the OP has said. I don't agree with another poster who said that no effort was shown, I put what looked like lack of effort down to players who aren't comfortable in a possession based system not showing for the ball and instead shying away from it i.e Ward, Puncheon. Watch Punch for Danns mistake, he should be asking for the ball, instead he's hiding behind an opposition player and telling Dann to play backwards, this sort of mentality needs to be changed. We need CMs and Wing Backs who want the ball in tight areas. RLC showed how the system can work if confident enough in your own ability.

Next game needs, RLC in the centre alongside Mili with a RWB as a priority in the transfer window.

Edited by A89M (13 Aug 2017 12.08pm)

 

FinchleyEagle Flag 13 Aug 17 1.09pm

For me, De Boer does not yet understand Crystal Palace and is trying to change too much too quickly, without having the players to do it, or possibly the coaching acumen.

The same thing happened to Pardew.

Pulis is a massively underrated manager and certainly here because of the acrimonious nature of his departure. That aside, at every club he's been at, he's looked at the players he has and plays to the individual and collective strength, then gradually imposes where he wants to go with new signings. It's not rocket science but is surprisingly rare.

Allardyce had a simple approach that can be implemented at pretty much any prem club. That's why he's never been relegated.

De Boer needs to learn in double-quick time what he's got (a very good squad) and how to get the best out of them and get results. Over time he can refine while hopefully still getting enough results, but not straight away.

I can only presume he hasn't done his homework on Palace, either last season or since we've been in the prem, which is such a shocking thought I hope I'm wrong. He doesn't seem to know that Townsend is one of our best players, Ward is a good player but never a wing back and we are not comfortable in possession in front of our own box - although few are in this time of chasing players down.

I hope he rectifies quickly, it's ok to make mistakes, especially at the beginning, but to not adapt would be unforgiveable.

 


You'll be forever in my family's memories and it was an honor and privilege to play and lead in the red and blue
Yours sincerely
Mile Jedinak

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 13 Aug 17 1.16pm

Originally posted by black eagle.

Bloody hell relax people it's only one game.

My thoughts exactly. Some of the over reacting on here has been comical. Yes it was embarrassing and not nice to watch at all but it was the first game!!

We are playing a new system. It will take time... In Frank we trust.

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

FairweatherEagle Flag London 13 Aug 17 1.19pm

Originally posted by FinchleyEagle

For me, De Boer does not yet understand Crystal Palace and is trying to change too much too quickly, without having the players to do it, or possibly the coaching acumen.

The same thing happened to Pardew.

Pulis is a massively underrated manager and certainly here because of the acrimonious nature of his departure. That aside, at every club he's been at, he's looked at the players he has and plays to the individual and collective strength, then gradually imposes where he wants to go with new signings. It's not rocket science but is surprisingly rare.

Allardyce had a simple approach that can be implemented at pretty much any prem club. That's why he's never been relegated.

De Boer needs to learn in double-quick time what he's got (a very good squad) and how to get the best out of them and get results. Over time he can refine while hopefully still getting enough results, but not straight away.

I can only presume he hasn't done his homework on Palace, either last season or since we've been in the prem, which is such a shocking thought I hope I'm wrong. He doesn't seem to know that Townsend is one of our best players, Ward is a good player but never a wing back and we are not comfortable in possession in front of our own box - although few are in this time of chasing players down.

I hope he rectifies quickly, it's ok to make mistakes, especially at the beginning, but to not adapt would be unforgiveable.

Great post, nicely balanced.

 

Mstrobez Flag 13 Aug 17 1.25pm

Originally posted by kennybrowns leftfoot

My thoughts exactly. Some of the over reacting on here has been comical. Yes it was embarrassing and not nice to watch at all but it was the first game!!

We are playing a new system. It will take time... In Frank we trust.

You wanna see some of the reactions on twitter. People hurling abuse at Frank on Instagram etc. "Best fans in England" my backside, we are an as fickle group as they come.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 13 Aug 17 2.22pm

Not the best league, but definitely the most competitive and physical. Football is not outlawed though as Arsenal have proved over the years. Difference is in England we don't stand off and watch teams play like they do in Europe. Pep found out last season and FdB has to learn from his misfortunes at City and his own yesterday.
Years and years of watching football especially on the box I noticed something last season I'd never seen before. Normally on a Goalkick the camera pans back and the only person in the half is the keeper, yet because of the way Pep wanted to play on Goalkicks there were now three defenders and three forwards in the picture applying pressure. In Spain Bravo had a 95% pass completion rate, but he was under no pressure, suddenly that completion rate declined. Huddersfield did that to us, so we should of changed to combat it, mix it up a bit. Also why didn't we do that to them?

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 13 Aug 17 2.25pm

Originally posted by Mstrobez

After an extremely poor result and performance I'm gonna put an opinion out that I know will prove unpopular but here goes.

In England, we delude ourselves senseless that we have the best league in the world. We go on about how much harder it is in england in comparison to Spain and Germany but our top teams never compete in Europe. We constantly talk down a possession based style of play, despite the fact that the best teams in the world play with this style and produce some of the most entertaining and successful teams and players in the world.

A new manager comes to the premier league, say a Pep or Van Gaal and instantly everyone calls them out to fail because "it doesn't work in the premier league". And the minute there is a bad result, the media and the fans are on progressive type managers like a pack of wolves with the "I told you so's" "you ain't in Spain/Holland/Germany/Italy anymore pal" etc etc.

No one ever stops to see the bigger picture, everyone wants instant results and success, regardless of longevity. Regardless of building anything in the long term. Regardless of whether or not overall they could build a more successful team that actually wins consistently or continentally. It's all now now now. The consequence of this is teams like Chelsea, playing a s***ty brand of football, winning the league and then the next season not even coming close to doing anything, getting knocked out by a European giant in the champions league and sacking Conte.

This is the epitome of what I saw at Selhurst today. There has been negativity around trying a new approach from the minute it was brought up. Every time we tried to play out from the back, the crowd groaned. Every time Hennessey or Dann or Riedewald didn't hoof the ball out, the crowd groaned. Ironically, when they did then hoof it out, the crowd also groaned. I think as fans we massively underestimate the amount it undermines the team and quite frankly one game in to the season, I think it was utterly pathetic.

The reason we won't progress is because of this attitude, we cannot improve without giving it a chance. Its funny how we bang on about "OH NOT A FAN OF THIS TIPPY TAPPY NONSENSE" yet completely ignore the fact that the newly promoted side who tanked us today are a team who've worked on a progressive type system for the past year. They're no hoof ball merchants, they're patient in possession, tactically sound and they play as a team.

There were many negatives in today's performance, that goes without saying. I have my own reservations about De Boer. We looked defensively all over the place and god forbid we sustain any injuries because barring Cabaye that would've been pretty much a fully fit team we put out today. But unless we try and get better, unless we adapt to the modern game, we will stagnate and it will inevitably lead to relegation because there are only so many Big Sams and Pulises knocking about and we've used up those 2 life lines already.

I predict the media will inevitably already have De Boer as a target and it would seem the fans have already passed judgement and deemed this a failed experiment. This will probably lead to a half hearted approach to our new style at the fear of being ruined by the press and booed every time we evade Hennessey hitting and hoping for the best. I've got my tin hat firmly on for this one and I will make a speedy exit before I undoubtedly get destroyed by many on here but this is my opinion about the Premier league in general. And it's one I've had for years, I don't buy the media nonsense pushed down our throat in this country about how amazingly excellent our league is.
Watch how one of the European giants play on a big champions league night, that's the best football in the world in my opinion, not this counter attacking "let's be avin ya" 80s type s*** that is common in the premier league.

Excellent post.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > We can't progress because we won't let it happen