You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Plan of succession after Roy?
November 16 2026 7.52am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Plan of succession after Roy?


Page 2 of 9 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 17 Dec 17 3.17pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

No it is quite a valid thread.

Roy may simply decide to retire like BS did, rushing about the country at 70+ will take its toll, not to mention his nervous system !!!!

If there was someone in place to take over, after being his assistant perhaps for a while, that would make sense.

Jedi would be a good choice IMO if interested.

As far as I am aware he has no coaching experience at all.
Be interested to know on what you base your assertion.

 

Foxy0208 Flag Blackpool 17 Dec 17 3.18pm

Originally posted by AERO

Think a certain mr Freedman could be involved if that’s the road we take .

I suspect the same but not sure he would be the popular choice. Having said that neither were Sam or Roy.

 


Some people think football is a matter of life and death. I don't like that attitude. I can assure them it is much more serious than that.

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 17 Dec 17 3.20pm

Think Roy himself will have a say on this matter - when he consider retiring!

 

Foxy0208 Flag Blackpool 17 Dec 17 3.21pm

Originally posted by Willo

As far as I am aware he has no coaching experience at all.
Be interested to know on what you base your assertion.

Thats the point Willo - maybe bring in someone to learn their craft under Roy. I think Jedi is a leader and good managers need to lead. He isn't the only candidate - its more about planning ahead this time.

 


Some people think football is a matter of life and death. I don't like that attitude. I can assure them it is much more serious than that.

Foxy0208 Flag Blackpool 17 Dec 17 3.21pm

Originally posted by thai-eagle

Think Roy himself will have a say on this matter - when he consider retiring!

I hope he does have a say - we would be stupid to ignore his opinion

 


Some people think football is a matter of life and death. I don't like that attitude. I can assure them it is much more serious than that.

Reknaw Flag 17 Dec 17 3.44pm

Originally posted by Foxy0208

Why is it stupid to start a conversation? Shame you had to take time from your valuable day to respond.

No need to be rude - just ignore it

It’s a ridiculous thread. Any excuse to start a topic. It’s pointless, it’s null. We should be thinking about plans WITH Roy, not planning for his retirement already. The bloke comes in changes things and people are talking about what to do when he’s gone. Could be 3 years yet, how are we supposed to predict what happens between now and then.

 

inflikted Flag 17 Dec 17 3.46pm

I personally would love to see Graham Potter as Hodgson's successor.

 


Milkshakes Against Fascism

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 17 Dec 17 3.49pm

Tricky one got me.hopefully toy will take us to z mid table team, so we should really be looking for a top manager to take over from him when he decides to leave. But your not going to get a top manager to be Roy's 'apprentice' and it would be a huge gamble to get an inexperienced younger person to work alongside him and then take over.

 

joe_cpfc Flag Basingstoke 17 Dec 17 3.49pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

No it is quite a valid thread.

Roy may simply decide to retire like BS did, rushing about the country at 70+ will take its toll, not to mention his nervous system !!!!

If there was someone in place to take over, after being his assistant perhaps for a while, that would make sense.

Jedi would be a good choice IMO if interested.

Why? He might be a clueless coach/manager.I'd rather Lewington take over than any former Palace player with no managerial experience.I really don't get this obsession with ex Palace becoming managers and coaches purely for the fact they played for us.Yeah in a perfect world we would have a club run, managed and coached all by Palace people but whats the chances of that many people being excellent at their jobs?
We've had more people who aren't ex palace being better as manager as we have ex Palace being good managers.
I think we should grab Hodgson and throw him into the fountain of youth and become the best club of all time.

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 17 Dec 17 3.51pm

Originally posted by Reknaw

It’s a ridiculous thread. Any excuse to start a topic. It’s pointless, it’s null. We should be thinking about plans WITH Roy, not planning for his retirement already. The bloke comes in changes things and people are talking about what to do when he’s gone. Could be 3 years yet, how are we supposed to predict what happens between now and then.

With respect you are wrong.

We had no warning when BS suddenly retired and that left a vacuum leading to FDB's appointment seemingly in desperation.

Far better to have a plan and Parish will no doubt be working with Roy this time after what happened with BS.

Although BS lied it wasn't retirement he just wanted out.

 

Foxy0208 Flag Blackpool 17 Dec 17 4.00pm

Originally posted by Reknaw

It’s a ridiculous thread. Any excuse to start a topic. It’s pointless, it’s null. We should be thinking about plans WITH Roy, not planning for his retirement already. The bloke comes in changes things and people are talking about what to do when he’s gone. Could be 3 years yet, how are we supposed to predict what happens between now and then.

This is a forum - i am entitled to start a thread - you are entitled to skip by it to the next one. I am concerned that Roy may only want to deal with the stress of PL management for another season after this one. I doubt I am the only one who thinks about the future of the club.

Its certainly not ridiculous - I do not start threads on a regular basis but as a supporter for nearly 50 years I am allowed an opinion which you can disagree with but please don't say its stupid and ridiculous.

 


Some people think football is a matter of life and death. I don't like that attitude. I can assure them it is much more serious than that.

Reknaw Flag 17 Dec 17 4.05pm

Originally posted by Foxy0208

This is a forum - i am entitled to start a thread - you are entitled to skip by it to the next one. I am concerned that Roy may only want to deal with the stress of PL management for another season after this one. I doubt I am the only one who thinks about the future of the club.

Its certainly not ridiculous - I do not start threads on a regular basis but as a supporter for nearly 50 years I am allowed an opinion which you can disagree with but please don't say its stupid and ridiculous.

It’s ridiculous.

 

BillyH Flag 17 Dec 17 4.31pm

Originally posted by Reknaw

It’s ridiculous.

This is funny.

 

Foxy0208 Flag Blackpool 17 Dec 17 4.35pm

Originally posted by Reknaw

It’s ridiculous.

In the spirit of pantomime - oh no it isn't - its an opinion - just like all the speculation about who might be bought and sold in the transfer window - all peoples opinions which they are entitled to.

 


Some people think football is a matter of life and death. I don't like that attitude. I can assure them it is much more serious than that.

Foxy0208 Flag Blackpool 17 Dec 17 4.37pm

Originally posted by BillyH

This is funny.

I will allow funny - its ridiculous I object to!

 


Some people think football is a matter of life and death. I don't like that attitude. I can assure them it is much more serious than that.

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 17 Dec 17 4.39pm

Originally posted by Reknaw

It’s ridiculous.

Oh no its not &#128516;

 

doublesuited77 Flag London (Camden) 17 Dec 17 4.54pm

i'd prefer chris wilder. (who incidentally was Sam's recommendation as well.)

Plays attacking football with good defense base and focus on speed on the wings. Mature manager who wont be intimidated by PL.

 


Be Loud, Be Proud, Be Palace

Reknaw Flag 17 Dec 17 5.11pm

Originally posted by Foxy0208

In the spirit of pantomime - oh no it isn't - its an opinion - just like all the speculation about who might be bought and sold in the transfer window - all peoples opinions which they are entitled to.

It’s a topic that shouldn’t even be crossing your mind at this stage. Talk about how well Roy is doing. Why speculate about him going, and planning for his departure. It’s quite simply ridiculous and stupid.

Edited by Reknaw (17 Dec 2017 5.12pm)

 

andyg Flag york 17 Dec 17 5.25pm

Originally posted by Reknaw

It’s a topic that shouldn’t even be crossing your mind at this stage. Talk about how well Roy is doing. Why speculate about him going, and planning for his departure. It’s quite simply ridiculous and stupid.

Edited by Reknaw (17 Dec 2017 5.12pm)

Why? Any reasonable business would be planning to replace a senior manager if they were in their 70s when they want to go. It’s nothing against Roy - he’s doing an amazing job.

Equally I would expect palace to have a list of players who might potentially be able to replace zaha, benteke etc if a crazy offer comes in or they get injured etc. It’s just sensible planning. In the past few years we’ve had 2 managers leave us in the lurch, if we had someone who could potentially take over ready it would make a transition so much easier.

Isn’t it what Barcelona and Real Madrid do (Zidane and Guardiola for example)

It’s a thing that’s just not done in football, but in our situation it does make sense

 

Dan1994 Flag Wallington 17 Dec 17 5.32pm

Originally posted by Reknaw

It’s a topic that shouldn’t even be crossing your mind at this stage. Talk about how well Roy is doing. Why speculate about him going, and planning for his departure. It’s quite simply ridiculous and stupid.

Edited by Reknaw (17 Dec 2017 5.12pm)

To be fair, you're the only one who thinks it is a ridiculous thread. I think it's a good thread, because we need to prepare our options for when Roy inevitably retires; we don't know how long he'll be around - he could technically pack it all in at the end of the season, and then we'd be up s*** creek again. When do we talk about it then? After January? End of the season? Just as Roy announces his retirement?

Conversely, look at a team like Southampton, where they have HUGE dossiers on lots of different options and outcomes. They are a stable Premierleague team now despite being in League One about 10 years ago, and that is in part due to their preparedness. Piss poor preparation leads to piss poor performance.

 


[Link]

Page 2 of 9 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Plan of succession after Roy?