You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > We need a new GK this week
November 16 2026 7.52am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

We need a new GK this week


Page 2 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
MikeCrete Flag Crete 08 Jan 18 10.42pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

I had to google him for info. His name is Kevin Trapp and is 27 yrs old. He played 24 games last season but lost his place to a young Spanish keeper and only has two appearances this season. Think I saw it on the BBC football site that he is looking for first team football but we are not the only club looking at him

He is a. Good keeper, but £10m, not sure we have the funds if we get a CB/DM in & a quality CF

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 08 Jan 18 10.46pm

Originally posted by MikeCrete

He is a. Good keeper, but £10m, not sure we have the funds if we get a CB/DM in & a quality CF

A German Int'l from Paris SG, if he is a class above either of our two then surely our survival in the PL would be worth £10 mil.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Durban Road Eagle Flag 08 Jan 18 10.48pm

[Link] Crystal Palace challenging Watford to sign Getafe goalkeeper Vicente Guaita

[Link] Crystal Palace are in negotiations with Getafe over goalkeeper Vicente Guaita, Sky Sports News understands.

[Link] Reports in Spain suggest that goalkeeper is close to making the move to England

Edited by Durban Road Eagle (08 Jan 2018 10.50pm)

 


Kentish Maid, born Beckenham, Kent; lifelong Palace supporter.

Palace 1979 Flag Surrey 08 Jan 18 10.51pm

A good keeper gives the whole team confidence and you could see the nerves tonight. Good centre halves and decent defensive midfielders are why Hennessey keeps cleans sheets.

When they hit the post tonight he had started his dive after the ball had rebounded out, his reactions are too slow and he just isn't good enough for this level.

I know he does his best, and you can see he is trying every match, but sadly neither him or Speroni are good enough, and until we get this sorted we will never show our full potential as a team.

I know we kept a clean sheet against Citeh, but imagine how many more we would keep with a quality keeper. We need to find another Nigel Martyn. There must be one out there!

 


Some people are like Slinkies … not really good for anything, but you can’t help smiling when you see one tumble down the stairs.

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 08 Jan 18 10.53pm

Originally posted by Palace 1979

A good keeper gives the whole team confidence and you could see the nerves tonight. Good centre halves and decent defensive midfielders are why Hennessey keeps cleans sheets.

When they hit the post tonight he had started his dive after the ball had rebounded out, his reactions are too slow and he just isn't good enough for this level.

I know he does his best, and you can see he is trying every match, but sadly neither him or Speroni are good enough, and until we get this sorted we will never show our full potential as a team.

I know we kept a clean sheet against Citeh, but imagine how many more we would keep with a quality keeper. We need to find another Nigel Martyn. There must be one out there!

Oh to have another Nige!

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

Mwncisee Flag Middlesbrough 08 Jan 18 10.55pm

If people check the Transfer Talk part of the forum you will see we have been linked with a few keepers.

Vicente Guaita looks the most likely at 3.6 mill

Also been linked with the Ipswich keeper, which Mick MCarthy has confirmed

And we have Origi, Kenyan/Norweigen keeper from Lillistrom on trial at the moment.

 

chateauferret Flag 08 Jan 18 11.03pm

Originally posted by merganser

Hennessy commanded his area and was alert throughout, making some decent saves.

Every time he concedes a goal, he is made a scapegoat for the whole defence.

I wouldn’t say there are more than half-a-dozen better keepers in the premier League than him and Speroni.

Can any of their critics identify affordable replacements?

There must be upgrades available but a lot of them would be short-term solutions due to age. We'd be back here again in short order.

The problem isn't that Hennessey is "s***"; the problem is that Speroni is 38.

Guaita looks like a decent option, conceding less than a goal a game behind a s*** defence. Don't know what his kicking and distribution is like though.

Edited by chateauferret (08 Jan 2018 11.04pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

chateauferret Flag 08 Jan 18 11.14pm

Originally posted by Palace 1979

A good keeper gives the whole team confidence and you could see the nerves tonight. Good centre halves and decent defensive midfielders are why Hennessey keeps cleans sheets.

When they hit the post tonight he had started his dive after the ball had rebounded out, his reactions are too slow and he just isn't good enough for this level.

I know he does his best, and you can see he is trying every match, but sadly neither him or Speroni are good enough, and until we get this sorted we will never show our full potential as a team.

I know we kept a clean sheet against Citeh, but imagine how many more we would keep with a quality keeper. We need to find another Nigel Martyn. There must be one out there!

We won't show our "full potential as a team" this season because we don#t have the money required, if we did we'd breach FFP, and we had to extirpate de Boer before we could start to play by which time we were half a dozen games behind everyone else. De Boer spent the summer pardewing our existing players instead of participating in the transfer window so we're now having to catch up.

As I said a keeper upgrade would be most welcome but I don't think we'll go down with these two provided we do the other work required on the squad. (it's also a bit iffy having only two keepers anyway, of course).


Edited by chateauferret (08 Jan 2018 11.15pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

Palace 1979 Flag Surrey 08 Jan 18 11.31pm

I also believe we wont go down with the 2 keepers we have, but the additional points we will pick up compared to what they have both cost us this year will be massive for the 2nd half of the season and will put us in a much better position to start next season.

Don't get me wrong, Julian is a legend for this club and Wayne does the best he can, but neither has taken the shirt and made it their own this season and I think both have been given enough chances.

We need a keeper who will be vocal and command the whole of his area. It is what our back 4 have been crying out for and will breed even greater confidence. I truly believe a better keeper will change the whole team ethos and will mean we can open up a little more and not have to play a back 6 for most of the match to protect our clear weakness.

 


Some people are like Slinkies … not really good for anything, but you can’t help smiling when you see one tumble down the stairs.

palace chick Flag South Croydon 08 Jan 18 11.33pm

Easy to blame the keeper, but both goals against us tonight was firstly down to Cabaye not being close enough to block the attack just outside the area and the other was a mistake by Reidlewald giving away the free kick after losing control of the ball he had just won? We probably do need a new keeper but tonight wasn’t down to Hennessey

 

EagleEssex Flag Essex 08 Jan 18 11.34pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

Here we go again.

We gave them masses of pressure and put Delaney in front of him. Can't anyone see that if you give the other lot that much pressure you're asking for trouble no matter who is in goal? If we concede 10 shots on target and he misses 1 in 12, you might be OK. If we concede 20, well, do the math.

The problem was the central defenders and the lesson is that if we do anything in this window we need to provide cover for Tomkins. As the moment if anything happens to Kelly or Tomkins with Sakho and Dann out of it then we're relying on Delaney and he can't do it any more at this level. You'll have seen also that Riedewald was less effective when he was dropped deeper so he isn't going to be a centre-back. Same goes if you move Fosu-Mensah or van Aanholt into the middle.

The other problem is that they kept us deep in our own half for much of the game. We didn't get our last two league results by doing that, did we?

Tomkins and Kelly in central defence, and a decent attack of our own, and we stop City scoring for the first time in God knows how long. With Hennessey in goal. Tonight, same keeper, no Wilf and no Tomkins, lose to the weed.

Sorry to be the bearer of bad news but whilst a keeper upgrade would be most welcome (and seems to be in the offing), Hennessey is *not* the root cause of all our problems and neither is Speroni.

Solid post

 

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 09 Jan 18 12.14am

Originally posted by chateauferret

Here we go again.

We gave them masses of pressure and put Delaney in front of him. Can't anyone see that if you give the other lot that much pressure you're asking for trouble no matter who is in goal? If we concede 10 shots on target and he misses 1 in 12, you might be OK. If we concede 20, well, do the math.

The problem was the central defenders and the lesson is that if we do anything in this window we need to provide cover for Tomkins. As the moment if anything happens to Kelly or Tomkins with Sakho and Dann out of it then we're relying on Delaney and he can't do it any more at this level. You'll have seen also that Riedewald was less effective when he was dropped deeper so he isn't going to be a centre-back. Same goes if you move Fosu-Mensah or van Aanholt into the middle.

The other problem is that they kept us deep in our own half for much of the game. We didn't get our last two league results by doing that, did we?

Tomkins and Kelly in central defence, and a decent attack of our own, and we stop City scoring for the first time in God knows how long. With Hennessey in goal. Tonight, same keeper, no Wilf and no Tomkins, lose to the weed.

Sorry to be the bearer of bad news but whilst a keeper upgrade would be most welcome (and seems to be in the offing), Hennessey is *not* the root cause of all our problems and neither is Speroni.

Agreed

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 09 Jan 18 6.28am

Originally posted by palace chick

Easy to blame the keeper, but both goals against us tonight was firstly down to Cabaye not being close enough to block the attack just outside the area and the other was a mistake by Reidlewald giving away the free kick after losing control of the ball he had just won? We probably do need a new keeper but tonight wasn’t down to Hennessey

How many times do we hear this though? We need a strong match winning keeper that instilles confidence and belief and a fighting ethos into our team right from the back. Then we won’t have to keep debating the same point of whether the game was lost because of the goalkeeper or not, over and over again.

Do people not remember a time when this debate didn’t happen all the time? Because I do. And it’s so frustrating!

Edited by Brentmiester_General (09 Jan 2018 7.01am)

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

orpingtoneagle Flag Orpington 09 Jan 18 8.13am

Problem last night was not big Wayne it was if any one person Delaney. The guy is a warrior but now so past his best.

Also our squad. It's thin and old. Neither team played their first team but sad to say they played a team of younger players who were hungry and out to impress we played a team of over paid journeymen more keen on keeping warm, especially in the first half.

Whole team simply not good enough.

Bristol City all over

 

The Dolphin Flag 09 Jan 18 8.33am

We do need a better keeper but given our injury woes I think we need another centre half before a goalkeeper as well as the obvious centre forward.
WH was not great last night to be honest regerdless of the fact that the defense in front of him was shocking.
Hie no mans land positioning for their second goal was rank bad in my opinion.

 

cpj Flag Kent 09 Jan 18 9.06am

An upgrade to a keeper who makes match-winning saves on a regular basis would be great. Both WH and JS do it occasionally - Speroni against Leicester with that low save that WH wouldn't have got to, Hennessey with that tip-over at Southampton that JS would not have reached. Both let in goals they should perhaps stop - WH last night, JS at Newcastle and a couple of the Arsenal goals for instance. What is not fair from BG and others is to blame WH for every goal he concedes whilst claiming that all those JS let in were unstoppable. If money allows, we need a better keeper - end of.

 

cpj Flag Kent 09 Jan 18 9.08am

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

How many times do we hear this though? We need a strong match winning keeper that instilles confidence and belief and a fighting ethos into our team right from the back. Then we won’t have to keep debating the same point of whether the game was lost because of the goalkeeper or not, over and over again.

Do people not remember a time when this debate didn’t happen all the time? Because I do. And it’s so frustrating!

Edited by Brentmiester_General (09 Jan 2018 7.01am)

Because you bring it up every game that WH plays yet ignore any goals that JS lets in!

 

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 09 Jan 18 9.28am

Originally posted by cpj

Because you bring it up every game that WH plays yet ignore any goals that JS lets in!

This isn’t about last night. I’ve nit once mentioned Wayne’s performance in my previous post. I haven’t even mentioned Wayne’s name in my previous post for god sake man. Me agreeing that we need a new goalkeeper that can save us matches and be strong at the back is not a slant on Henessey. It’s agreeing with this subject and putting my point across as to why I agree. Stop being so hyper sensitive.

Edited by Brentmiester_General (09 Jan 2018 9.30am)

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

cpj Flag Kent 09 Jan 18 10.21am

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

This isn’t about last night. I’ve nit once mentioned Wayne’s performance in my previous post. I haven’t even mentioned Wayne’s name in my previous post for god sake man. Me agreeing that we need a new goalkeeper that can save us matches and be strong at the back is not a slant on Henessey. It’s agreeing with this subject and putting my point across as to why I agree. Stop being so hyper sensitive.

Edited by Brentmiester_General (09 Jan 2018 9.30am)

The thread was started last night by someone moaning about Hennessey's performance yesterday and you have already made SEVEN contributions to the thread. OK, so you haven't mentioned Hennessey by name but we all know what you are talking about in your posts so don't pretend otherwise.

 

swisseagle93 Flag 09 Jan 18 10.34am

Originally posted by cpj

The thread was started last night by someone moaning about Hennessey's performance yesterday and you have already made SEVEN contributions to the thread. OK, so you haven't mentioned Hennessey by name but we all know what you are talking about in your posts so don't pretend otherwise.

Sorry mate but Speroni is clearly past his prime and is a good back up solution but not a viable n°1 and concerning Hennessey he is able of the best and the worst and more often the worst than the best his game against City was incredible but his performance yesterday was very very poor and it's been the case for far too long we can't say Hennessey hasn't had the chances he has been our n°1 for 3 years now and it has gone from bad to worse... He only cost us 1.6M at the time so definetly a good signing but we need to move on and get a new keeper ! Guaita wouldn't be my first choice because I would like someone younger to fix this long going issue for the nex 5 years... But signing someone is now an OBLIGATION !

 

Page 2 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > We need a new GK this week