You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Referee for Watford
November 16 2026 6.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Referee for Watford


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
Spiderman Flag Horsham 24 Aug 18 12.37pm

Originally posted by TomThePalaceFanatic

Personally I think Oliver got both big decisions right on Monday.

Some people don't.

We're still divided after seeing all the replays in the world, and he has a split second to make a decision.

Him and Atkinson best refs we've got. Someone like Jon Moss isn't up to standard but digging Oliver out for somebody sort of mystery bias is just silly

I am one but hey ho we must move on. However one other decision that really riled me was the PVA tackle in the first half on Milner, resulting in Wilf being free. Ref did not give it, despite looking in that direction, it was given by Linesman, then Oliver booked PVA. From where Linesman was he could not possibly have seen whether it was dangerous play, obviously swayed by Milner clutching his leg as if it was broken.

 

Lakeview Flag Lincoln 24 Aug 18 12.41pm

You should try the refs in League Two-they regularly turn to their assistant refs in the manner of a blind man to their guide dog,often because they seem to have lost concentration. Tuesday at Lincoln City saw 2 players with similar ethnicity & haircuts confused with each other by both ref & assistant. I agree though, that the big club bias still seems to be present at times; I believe VAR would help that issue.

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 24 Aug 18 12.44pm

Originally posted by Superhorns3

And then are surprised when the ref makes a mistake with one quick look at an incident in real time..

I thought VAR might help but clearly the Premier league didn't want it to come in.

Persoally don't believe VAR is Ready yet. It needs to be much quicker, and More transparent to the fans,

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 24 Aug 18 1.03pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

I am one but hey ho we must move on. However one other decision that really riled me was the PVA tackle in the first half on Milner, resulting in Wilf being free. Ref did not give it, despite looking in that direction, it was given by Linesman, then Oliver booked PVA. From where Linesman was he could not possibly have seen whether it was dangerous play, obviously swayed by Milner clutching his leg as if it was broken.

Obviously I don't know for a fact, but it is possible that when the players came together, Oliver was focussed on the ball, which was won cleanly by PVA hence play was allowed to continue but it was the Assistant who wasn't that far from the incident who saw the follow through, informed Oliver and advised him it was dangerous.Just a possibility.

Edited by Willo (24 Aug 2018 1.10pm)

 

Superhorns3 Flag Harpdenden 24 Aug 18 3.13pm

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

Persoally don't believe VAR is Ready yet. It needs to be much quicker, and More transparent to the fans,

True - seemed to be better used in the World Cup but still there were issues of course including the final with the France penalty for handball.

On a week to week basis you might not get consistent usage or mangers complaining why wasn't it used for one incident and not another.

And yes rugby style comminication could be useful but the folks in charge seem seem to think we're all going to kick off big style when a replay is shown..

We aren't all Millwall/West Ham!


Edited by Superhorns3 (24 Aug 2018 3.14pm)[/sm

Edited by Superhorns3 (24 Aug 2018 3.14pm)

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 24 Aug 18 3.33pm

Originally posted by Willo

Obviously I don't know for a fact, but it is possible that when the players came together, Oliver was focussed on the ball, which was won cleanly by PVA hence play was allowed to continue but it was the Assistant who wasn't that far from the incident who saw the follow through, informed Oliver and advised him it was dangerous.Just a possibility.

Edited by Willo (24 Aug 2018 1.10pm)

It was impossible for the Assistant to have seen any follow through as PVA was blocking his view and I believe Oliver may have even been closer to the incident.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 24 Aug 18 3.36pm

Originally posted by Superhorns3

True - seemed to be better used in the World Cup but still there were issues of course including the final with the France penalty for handball.

On a week to week basis you might not get consistent usage or mangers complaining why wasn't it used for one incident and not another.

And yes rugby style comminication could be useful but the folks in charge seem seem to think we're all going to kick off big style when a replay is shown..

We aren't all Millwall/West Ham!


Totally agree, think the rugby model is really well used. I do not think there is any more chance of fans kicking off watching a replay, than there is having to accept the refs word for it. Thought VAR in the World Cup turned out better than I anticipated. Of course, may not help the "Big Clubs" in the Premier League.

Edited by Superhorns3 (24 Aug 2018 3.14pm)[/sm

Edited by Superhorns3 (24 Aug 2018 3.14pm)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 24 Aug 18 3.42pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

It was impossible for the Assistant to have seen any follow through as PVA was blocking his view and I believe Oliver may have even been closer to the incident.

With the greatest of respect it appeared as though the Assistant alerted Oliver to the follow-through so he must have had a good view of the incident.

We have our respective opinions on this and perhaps it is best that we don't engage in any protracted debate about the incident, else in the past such debates only disintegerate into acrimony.

Edited by Willo (24 Aug 2018 3.43pm)

 

jeeagles Flag 24 Aug 18 3.46pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

And yes rugby style comminication could be useful but the folks in charge seem seem to think we're all going to kick off big style when a replay is shown..

I couldn't agree more with this. The reason football gave against doing this years ago was that they were concerned about players swearing at the ref. Not a good enough reason in my view and it's just pandering to unacceptable behavior. If they swear at the ref they should be booked.

In a similar way we have allowed the same to happen with diving. It's obvious when a player is trying to con a referee even if there is contact. Some degree of contact has to be allowed as it's turning the game into a farce. I'd like to see players with a bit of pride play the game with honesty and integrity. Not throw them self about on the floor like toddlers having a fit.

In both cases on Monday Salah went down like he had been shot, even though it took countless replays to establish where contact had been made and people still aren't certain. Some people accept the narrative that if a player gets touched they have a right to go down. As far as I'm concerned, that's just giving in to the cheats.

Going back to rugby, its very difficult for the players to get away with anything anymore, unless your New Zealand. It took a few years to sort this out, but VAR has to be brought in at some stage and we'll have to go through these teething issues.

 

Aray Flag South London 24 Aug 18 3.48pm

I read an article a couple of weeks back that suggested that last season with regard to refereeing decisions/mistakes - we didn't do too badly on a points basis. In fact we came out roughly flat.

Shame I cant remember where I read it.

 

michaelpearce Flag grays 24 Aug 18 3.52pm

sorry but was the post about good old tony taylor who has given us 6 pens one against watford gasp shook horror, and 4 against so dont make silly statements unless you think taylor is such a bad ref he got our pens wrong,think about it.

and dont forget tony taylor played for us could be his dad maybe

Edited by michaelpearce (24 Aug 2018 4.02pm)

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 25 Aug 18 8.22am

Originally posted by Willo

With the greatest of respect it appeared as though the Assistant alerted Oliver to the follow-through so he must have had a good view of the incident.

We have our respective opinions on this and perhaps it is best that we don't engage in any protracted debate about the incident, else in the past such debates only disintegerate into acrimony.

Edited by Willo (24 Aug 2018 3.43pm)

My final word on this, I did say that the Assistant alerted Oliver to the incident but from where he was he could not possibly have seen anything as PVA was blocking his view, he was persuaded by Milner staying down, I sit very close to this incident and am fully aware of the position of the Assistant.

 

jabber Flag pease pottage 25 Aug 18 9.30am

Originally posted by chateauferret


Martin Atkinson: OK
Mike Dean: OK
Kevin Friend: S***
Andre Marriner: Not too bad
Michael Oliver: S***
Craig Pawson: S***
Anthony Taylor: Bit pants
Stuart Attwell: Don't know
Chris Kavanagh: S***
Lee Mason: S***
Jonathan Moss: S***
Graham Scott: Don't know
Paul Tierney: S*** IIRC

mostly northerners

 

michaelpearce Flag grays 25 Aug 18 5.37pm

it really shows how people read things someone points out that we have had decisions our way and totally ignore it because they dont like people pointing out facts

 

chateauferret Flag 26 Aug 18 7.11pm

Originally posted by michaelpearce

it really shows how people read things someone points out that we have had decisions our way and totally ignore it because they dont like people pointing out facts

So I take it you were happy with Taylor's performance today then?

On Monday I said that was the worst ref performance I'd seen for a while and today Taylor goes and tops it within a few minutes. Blatant sending off offence against Wilf not given and then gives Wilf the most preposterous yellow card. Sent a clear message to Watford that thuggery was fine by him and it was unfair of us to field such a good player. He then looked stupider and stupider as he failed to make his subsequent decisions look consistent with those two.

Two total disgraces out of three so far. Good going.

It's absolutely f***ing pathetic, it really is.


Edited by chateauferret (26 Aug 2018 7.12pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

Spiderman Flag Horsham 26 Aug 18 8.07pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

So I take it you were happy with Taylor's performance today then?

On Monday I said that was the worst ref performance I'd seen for a while and today Taylor goes and tops it within a few minutes. Blatant sending off offence against Wilf not given and then gives Wilf the most preposterous yellow card. Sent a clear message to Watford that thuggery was fine by him and it was unfair of us to field such a good player. He then looked stupider and stupider as he failed to make his subsequent decisions look consistent with those two.

Two total disgraces out of three so far. Good going.

It's absolutely f***ing pathetic, it really is.


Edited by chateauferret (26 Aug 2018 7.12pm)

I do agree with you. The only thing I can think about Capoue's challenge is that from the ref's angle he may have not seen the raking of the calf, only a trip. Where is VAR when you need it, thought Graham Souness was brilliant, he looked visibly upset at the assault. Wilf's booking was caused by the reaction of the Watford players (why did Palace players not react in the same way). Jaanmats challenge on PVA warranted a booking and his attempt to get Wilf sent off was disgraceful (thought the ref handled that well). Watford really are a scummy club, read their forum about Capoues tackle on Wilf.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 26 Aug 18 8.25pm

The ref was very poor you could say Watford should of had another player sent off towards the end when Palace had a free kick one of their players who had been booked already refused to let palace take freekick I think he even kicked the ball away so it should of been another yellow.

if palace player had done this in the book straight away

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

kingdowieonthewall Flag Sussex, ex-Cronx. 26 Aug 18 9.05pm

ref was a major see you next tues.
mayor of c unt town.

 


Kids,tired of being bothered by your pesky parents?
Then leave home, get a job & pay your own bills, while you still know everything.

Jamesrichards8 Flag 26 Aug 18 9.25pm

That zaha booking was shocking. If that’s how soft the premier league has become im done with it. Too much money in the game and the refs are far too worried about protecting ‘assets’. And yet capoue gets away with murder. The decisions of referees are inconsistent but the standard of refereeing is consistently crap. No wonder we had no refs in the World Cup.

 


When you’re knocked on your back and your life’s a flop...

Superhorns3 Flag Harpdenden 26 Aug 18 9.28pm

Zaha with his skill and ability must be more of an "asset" than any of our players ?

 

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Referee for Watford