You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Let's criticise our managers.eh?
November 16 2026 6.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Let's criticise our managers.eh?


Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 14 Apr 19 9.31pm

Originally posted by westnorwoodeagle

It’s so frustrating watching Palace with such an incredibly gifted individual such as Wilf and us playing such mediocre football. We are failing Wilf and Hodgson is the culprit. Not only Wilf though we have a French international Cb in Mamadou we have a rising german star in Meyer who Hodgball refuses to start, but why?! He’s clearly a positive influence on the game he moves the ball quickly and links up with Wilf brilliantly. Don’t get me started about Roy and substitutions we are massively under achieving and wasting the talent of Zaha in his prime. Move on Roy please!

I see, so it had nothing to do with the fact that not one of our players would get into their team and all of theirs would instantly be in ours ..of course it had nothing to do with that, how silly am I.

 

Invalid user 2019 Flag 14 Apr 19 9.35pm

It's easy to be a nay sayer and hyper critical, but surely credit where credit's due. At this level even staying up is an achievement of sorts. Roy's kept us up and he's a grafter rather than particularly flash or inventive. He just gets on with it and has kept us in a position where we have something to build on.

We don't have money to spunk up the wall and no new manager is going to swoop in and transform us into a top 5 team overnight anyway. It's a matter of degrees at this level and there's positives to be taken from the season.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 14 Apr 19 9.37pm

Originally posted by Willo

With respect, in the PL Charlton were not a consistent top ten team.They only finished twice in the top ten in 8 PL seasons.

Stoke in their 10 seasons in the PL prior to being relegated they only finished in the top ten 3 times.

Edited by Willo (14 Apr 2019 9.05pm)

Proves the point that any team outside the top six are capable of being relegated and being a top half club is cuckoo poo.

 

rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 14 Apr 19 9.42pm

The arguments about Hodgson are getting tedious and are ruining decent conversations about the qualities and performances of the team.
The argument which goes on and on is really about how good our team really is. Yes it is better than most Palace teams of the past but so is the standard of the rest of the premier league. The only real way to discuss the merits or otherwise of the team is to compare the squad player for player with the other 19 teams and see where we are. If you do that then you can see why we are about a 11-14 place team which is where we find ourselves.
Today every player in the opposition team including every single player on the bench would walk into our team and we did all right. Not great, I agree, but all right.
I really do not agree with the criticism of Hodgson as our manager, who is doing ok with the resources he has. I do think our recruitment policy is short-sighted and that is why we have the team we have. However I understand that in our current circumstances it is hard to find resources to invest in the future whilst fire-fighting our annual battle.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 14 Apr 19 9.48pm

Originally posted by dollardays

It's easy to be a nay sayer and hyper critical, but surely credit where credit's due. At this level even staying up is an achievement of sorts. Roy's kept us up and he's a grafter rather than particularly flash or inventive. He just gets on with it and has kept us in a position where we have something to build on.

We don't have money to spunk up the wall and no new manager is going to swoop in and transform us into a top 5 team overnight anyway. It's a matter of degrees at this level and there's positives to be taken from the season.

Definitely, especially when considering the players he has had to work with this season ..some of whom would struggle within Ipswich's squad.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 14 Apr 19 9.54pm

Originally posted by Painter

I think the point you are missing is, Hodgson is being compared to previous Palace managers by a lot of the longstanding fans. He actually stacks up very well against all of them except Coppell, the rest by and large have had serious flaws, Bruce, Dowie and Pulis were good, but sh_t people, the rest weren't very good.

The new fans expect us to be pushing for Europe, beating all the top teams etc, the reality is it isn't going to happen as we haven't the financial resources of the top teams. The older fans still cant quite believe we are still in the Premier after years of being a yoyo club and see staying here as progression and are happy with Hodgson as he can keep us in there.

I wonder how well his record would have been if he hadn't encouraged ball booting

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 14 Apr 19 10.07pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Yep all good comments I feel.

As has been said, this is what forums are for and so that's fine but I appreciate the fact that many recognise the reality that teams like Palace live with in this division.

We are lucky to have a manager like Hodgeson and just because he isn't a miracle worker or very imaginative doesn't mean that he doesn't deserve accolades for the sterling job he has done.

We are a couple of signings and retentions away from moving away from lower mid table to top ten.

Edited by Stirlingsays (14 Apr 2019 5.59pm)

This season should have been about improving our position of the last - 11th. We have under achieved and as has been said previously by many on here it’s not the loss so much to City today that’s the issue but losing at HOME to the Southampton, Watford, Brighton etc. Watching us against the weed was akin to witnessing England in the dying throes of Hodgson’s reign.

I am fed up with reading about this being the most successful period of Palace’s history but simply ensuring that we avoid relegation is not ambition and we constantly look down rather than up. Unless we change our outlook we will not attract the calibre of player we need to get we should be.... secondly, retain the key players that are again needed and thirdly see a decline in home support to the totally negative and tepid football served up.

I think back to us playing City about 3 (maybe more) years ago when we put in incredible effort and came out winning with that superb free kick by Puncheon. Then the 3-3 with Liverpool, coming back from the dead. This inspired fans and proved that irrespective of what money had been spent by the opposition you can get near to a level playing field by a positive game plan and a collective belief in a will to win not just keep the score down.

 


Bring back Brolin

PatrickA Flag London 14 Apr 19 10.40pm

Watch the interview with Hodgson on Palace Player.
He says he can’t keeping ‘raising the bar for the players’ as he has done for 2 years or ‘life will get very uncomfortable for everyone.’
This smacks to me that he doesn’t feel he’s had enough support on resources and he can’t get any more out of the players available.
Personally I think the squad is strong and think he could be getting more out of them.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 14 Apr 19 10.48pm

It’s interesting how much blame or credit the manager gets for success or failure - how much responsibility should the coaching staff bear?

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 14 Apr 19 11.01pm

Originally posted by dynamicdick

This season should have been about improving our position of the last - 11th. We have under achieved and as has been said previously by many on here it’s not the loss so much to City today that’s the issue but losing at HOME to the Southampton, Watford, Brighton etc. Watching us against the weed was akin to witnessing England in the dying throes of Hodgson’s reign.

I am fed up with reading about this being the most successful period of Palace’s history but simply ensuring that we avoid relegation is not ambition and we constantly look down rather than up. Unless we change our outlook we will not attract the calibre of player we need to get we should be.... secondly, retain the key players that are again needed and thirdly see a decline in home support to the totally negative and tepid football served up.

I think back to us playing City about 3 (maybe more) years ago when we put in incredible effort and came out winning with that superb free kick by Puncheon. Then the 3-3 with Liverpool, coming back from the dead. This inspired fans and proved that irrespective of what money had been spent by the opposition you can get near to a level playing field by a positive game plan and a collective belief in a will to win not just keep the score down.

We had Murray though didn't we
The stats against City were about the same as today's ..26% with five shots ..three on target and everyone loved Pardew didn't they??

[Link]

[Link]

The City team today is much stronger.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 14 Apr 19 11.09pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

It’s interesting how much blame or credit the manager gets for success or failure - how much responsibility should the coaching staff bear?

Responsibility comes down to individual players not doing the things the manager and coach wants them to do mainly because the individual players are not as competent on and with the ball as the players they are facing, which usually happens when one team has better resources.

Edited by Tickled pink (14 Apr 2019 11.09pm)

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 14 Apr 19 11.14pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

Watch the interview with Hodgson on Palace Player.
He says he can’t keeping ‘raising the bar for the players’ as he has done for 2 years or ‘life will get very uncomfortable for everyone.’
This smacks to me that he doesn’t feel he’s had enough support on resources and he can’t get any more out of the players available.
Personally I think the squad is strong and think he could be getting more out of them.

Your username is a very good example. The squad is not good enough to be where you personally think it should be, shame that it be.

 

RH8Eagle Flag Oxted 14 Apr 19 11.34pm

The internet is a fantastic invention but it’s obviously given rise to a great number of critical people who probably if they were actually to meet up with the person in the public eye, would I am guessing be rather more polite with their greeting. So it’s a phenomenon that is now very common and the more moderate amongst us have to live with, and I am fairly sure the likes of Roy and SP will know it comes with the territory and they can handle most of it all in a days work.
In my moderate view Roy has steadied a rocking ship and the premier is probably the toughest league in the world and a big leap higher than the championship. So where we have come from and what we have available to where we are today we don’t pull the plug as we don’t really know what might go down the hole.

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 14 Apr 19 11.36pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

Your username is a very good example. The squad is not good enough to be where you personally think it should be, shame that it be.[/

No, he is not getting the best out of the team at home through his negative game plan.

 


Bring back Brolin

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 14 Apr 19 11.47pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

Responsibility comes down to individual players not doing the things the manager and coach wants them to do mainly because the individual players are not as competent on and with the ball as the players they are facing, which usually happens when one team has better resources.

Edited by Tickled pink (14 Apr 2019 11.09pm)


You have real trouble levying any blame on the manager....... the problem is that the players ARE carrying out what the manager wants that is why we are being served up such negative rubbish at home. Do you really think they enjoy playing to this rigid system evvvvvvery home game? It’s England re-visited!

 


Bring back Brolin

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 14 Apr 19 11.51pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

We had Murray though didn't we
The stats against City were about the same as today's ..26% with five shots ..three on target and everyone loved Pardew didn't they??

[Link]

[Link]

The City team today is much stronger.[/quote

But now we have Benteke!

 


Bring back Brolin

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 15 Apr 19 8.40am

Mad, irrelevant, illogical or all of the above things people say to justify their own personal fear of failure:
1) Look at Charlton, be careful what you wish for.
2) We should never have got rid of Murray
3) Roy Hodgson is doing well compared to our other managers.
4) Clinging on to premier League survival is more important that trophies.
5) It's the players' fault for long term underperformance

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 15 Apr 19 8.48am

Originally posted by Painter

I think the point you are missing is, Hodgson is being compared to previous Palace managers by a lot of the longstanding fans. He actually stacks up very well against all of them except Coppell, the rest by and large have had serious flaws, Bruce, Dowie and Pulis were good, but sh_t people, the rest weren't very good.

The new fans expect us to be pushing for Europe, beating all the top teams etc, the reality is it isn't going to happen as we haven't the financial resources of the top teams. The older fans still cant quite believe we are still in the Premier after years of being a yoyo club and see staying here as progression and are happy with Hodgson as he can keep us in there.

I'm not a new fan and I think the ambition should be to push for top 8.

The past is completely irrelevant. What you describe is a fear of failure.

Just keep slogging out survival is not success and is completely unsustainable.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 15 Apr 19 9.37am

Originally posted by ChrisGC

I'm not a new fan and I think the ambition should be to push for top 8.

The past is completely irrelevant. What you describe is a fear of failure.

Just keep slogging out survival is not success and is completely unsustainable.

Ambition and expectation are not the same, All clubs have ambition, it’s how you achieve it not easy.

The past is very relevant, as all the top clubs have a history of success going back years, trying to break into that group is virtually impossible. They have a vested interested in keeping other clubs below them and use their financial muscle to do so, generally buying clubs best players.

All clubs outside the top 6 have a fear of failure, as relegation is just devastating to a club in financial terms. You want change and more success, so did many other clubs that are now desperately trying to get back into the Premier. In our current financial state, I just can’t see the benefit of getting rid of Roy.

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 15 Apr 19 10.10am

Originally posted by ChrisGC

I'm not a new fan and I think the ambition should be to push for top 8.

The past is completely irrelevant. What you describe is a fear of failure.

Just keep slogging out survival is not success and is completely unsustainable.

Me the same (3rd Division South 1st game) and 100% agree with your post.

 


Bring back Brolin

Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Let's criticise our managers.eh?