You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The James McCarthy thread
November 16 2026 5.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The James McCarthy thread


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
taylors lovechild Flag 18 Jan 20 5.17pm

I thought he was great today with him and McArthur hunting as a pack to shut down City's midfield. Keep playing like that and Luka might have a fight to get back in.

 

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 18 Jan 20 5.44pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

I thought he was great today with him and McArthur hunting as a pack to shut down City's midfield. Keep playing like that and Luka might have a fight to get back in.

Agreed... Thought that was the best he’s played so far. He just seems to pop up all over the place... I hope he can stay fit and carry on like that.

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 18 Jan 20 5.54pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

I thought he was great today with him and McArthur hunting as a pack to shut down City's midfield. Keep playing like that and Luka might have a fight to get back in.

Didn't they have a successful stint together at Bolton?

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 18 Jan 20 6.00pm

this humble pie is delicious

 

Brinscall Eagle Flag Brinscall Lancashire/ Villamartin ... 18 Jan 20 6.07pm

McCarthy was brilliant today he did a great job on DeBruyne. He is so much more mobile than a Luka and just as tenacious in the tackle. Great asset to our squad.

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 18 Jan 20 6.19pm

Originally posted by premier fan

He's been poor - get our money back if poss.

Is this a wind up?

Find us another player who can go to Man City, play like that and cost us 3 million.

Terrific deal.

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

The Dolphin Flag 18 Jan 20 6.21pm

Originally posted by Brinscall Eagle

McCarthy was brilliant today he did a great job on DeBruyne. He is so much more mobile than a Luka and just as tenacious in the tackle. Great asset to our squad.

100% agree!!

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 18 Jan 20 6.34pm

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

this humble pie is delicious

Credit to you but only on this thread

 

davehuggins Flag 18 Jan 20 6.40pm

Brilliant signing for 3m in IMO

 

mattteo Flag 18 Jan 20 6.46pm

He may be good, but the point is there are too many purely defensive midfielders.

1 starter is enough. With 1 backup. And the other one should be someone like Jimmy Macca or Cabaye, more attack minded.

So, if we like McCarthy so much after the City game, let him or Kouyate start and sell Luka.

2 of them starting at the same time will still mean we're one of the poorest teams in terms of scoring, if not THE poorest.

 

EddieMac Flag 18 Jan 20 8.02pm

Originally posted by mattteo

He may be good, but the point is there are too many purely defensive midfielders.

1 starter is enough. With 1 backup. And the other one should be someone like Jimmy Macca or Cabaye, more attack minded.

So, if we like McCarthy so much after the City game, let him or Kouyate start and sell Luka.

2 of them starting at the same time will still mean we're one of the poorest teams in terms of scoring, if not THE poorest.

I wouldn’t class McCarthy as a defensive midfielder, he is different type of player than all of our midfielders but he is very comfortable on the ball and loves a tackle. We have 4 centre midfield players and none of them would be classed as an out and out attacking midfielder/midfielder but why do we need one when that is not the way Roy plays. Roy has a system and that’s just the way it is. Like it or lump it.

 

EaglesEaglesEagles Flag 18 Jan 20 8.13pm

McArthur, Cabaye, Tomkins, Van Aanholt, Townsend, Schlupp, Kouyate, Ayew, Cahill and now McCarthy.

Granted we don't often look to bring in untried Championship talent, but if you look at the club's record at bringing in players with plenty of Premier League experience (who aren't past it), then you have to give credit to Parish.
It's proved a pretty solid strategy and the outlay hasn't been too great. The exception has been Sakho because he can't keep fit and cost far too much, but still a player.

 


I ain't got nuthin' funny to say. Sorry.

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 18 Jan 20 8.16pm

Originally posted by mattteo

He may be good, but the point is there are too many purely defensive midfielders.

1 starter is enough. With 1 backup. And the other one should be someone like Jimmy Macca or Cabaye, more attack minded.

So, if we like McCarthy so much after the City game, let him or Kouyate start and sell Luka.

2 of them starting at the same time will still mean we're one of the poorest teams in terms of scoring, if not THE poorest.

You clearly haven’t been paying attention to the way Roy sets the team up

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 18 Jan 20 8.26pm

Originally posted by mattteo

He may be good, but the point is there are too many purely defensive midfielders.

1 starter is enough. With 1 backup. And the other one should be someone like Jimmy Macca or Cabaye, more attack minded.

So, if we like McCarthy so much after the City game, let him or Kouyate start and sell Luka.

2 of them starting at the same time will still mean we're one of the poorest teams in terms of scoring, if not THE poorest.

Whilst there's not a lot of goals or flair in the midfield the idea that they're all defensive isn't true either. Kouyate and the two JMs are decent box to box players.

Would be nice to see a few more goals from midfield but Roy's just setting up to players' strengths.

 

pssguy Flag 18 Jan 20 8.30pm

Good to see his dead ball delivery. Hopefully he can keep that on full time. Finally we score from a corner

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 18 Jan 20 8.33pm

Originally posted by doombear

Didn't they have a successful stint together at Bolton?

wigan.

everton paid double what we did for jimmy mac

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


southnorwoodhill Flag 18 Jan 20 8.38pm

An astute signing. Gives Roy a selection problem, but one I suspect he's happy to have. Luka needs to up his game.

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 18 Jan 20 8.41pm

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

its all relative, innit.

we paid £3m for the guy, who had been injured for a few years and needed to get back to fitness, given evertons spending whilst he had been injured that seems a fair price.

i like him, he is a ball winning tenacious midfielder, who does have decent distribution and he works hard for the team.

he has fire in his belly and is up for the scrap, which lets make no bones about it, fits the club perfectly...which as a team mate you love to have that player lining up next to you.

we chastise watford for being a nasty team but you need that to survive in this league and he adds that.

would i start him above kouyate when everybody is fit? no, but im happy to have him & he cost is diddily squat.

to add to this, and this isnt based afted todays game...our midfield options sit at...

jimmy mac
jimmy mac
kouyate
luca
meyer
schlupp
jairo
banks

considering we now have 8 players for 3/4 slots, 3 of them are versatile, personally im very happy with our options.

if a reasonably priced attacking playmaker came up then thats a good idea but normally they cost fortunes, so we need to find our way to goal another way.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


mattteo Flag 18 Jan 20 9.21pm

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

You clearly haven’t been paying attention to the way Roy sets the team up

I know how Roy plays and that he uses 3 central midfielders. I just don't think it's a good way to play. I'm writing this as we drew 2-2 away at Man City, so I'm going into the lion's den, but in the long term, I think it's horrible to be the team with least goals scored in the Premier League. It may very well get us relegated in a relatively short period, just as WBA got relegated after they had finished 7th the previous year with the best defense. Stoke never recovered and started scoring after the Tony Pulis period either. Burnley had the best defense in the PL 1-2 years ago and now they're almost down.

Youngsters need to be taught that they have to score 3-4 times in a match. If they become accustomed to defending a lot and having just 2 chances per game....they will never recover scoring form. The more chances you make in a game, the better your players will become with time. The more goals the attacking players score, the higher their price goes. So, even in case of less points, you still get to be more financially stable, cause you sell at a higher price.

Edited by mattteo (18 Jan 2020 9.27pm)

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 18 Jan 20 9.58pm

Originally posted by mattteo

He may be good, but the point is there are too many purely defensive midfielders.

1 starter is enough. With 1 backup. And the other one should be someone like Jimmy Macca or Cabaye, more attack minded.

So, if we like McCarthy so much after the City game, let him or Kouyate start and sell Luka.

2 of them starting at the same time will still mean we're one of the poorest teams in terms of scoring, if not THE poorest.

But we just drew at Man City and are 9th, Brighton are playing a more expansive game, where are they?
I would like us to play a more attacking entertaining style but what we are doing is working at the moment

 

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The James McCarthy thread