This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
It was not My information came from farmers, given that my daughter is one. A beet farmer?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
Was it not driven by the NFU
Edited by Spiderman (11 Jan 2021 10.22am) I believe it probably was As you probably know Tom himself was a spokesman for the NFU Sugar Board and grows a lot of sugar beet. He is also interested in bees so I am sure he personally is trying to get the balance right. I just struggle to agree with him on this point and feel there are other ways to skin the cat. I also note the haste with which this was brought in as soon as the controls of the EU were no longer in place. To quote from the University of Sussex when the ban came in: If these neonicotinoids are simply replaced by other similar compounds such as sulfoxaflor, cyantraniliprole and flupyradifurone (all new systemic insecticides), then we will simply be going round in circles. What is needed is a move towards truly sustainable farming methods that minimise pesticide use, encourage natural enemies of crop pests, and support biodiversity and healthy soils.
|
|
|
Originally posted by chris123
A beet farmer? She is in her third year of a farming Degree. She studies everything. I walked a beet field with her last winter to review the pests and she explained how each was managed. Were she a beet farmer then I am not sure how objective she would be on the topic. But neonicatinoids are used for a variety of crops, there is nothing special about beet other than currently it is being hit quite hard by Yellow Virus. This is what happens with monocropping.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
She is in her third year of a farming Degree. She studies everything. I walked a beet field with her last winter to review the pests and she explained how each was managed. Were she a beet farmer then I am not sure how objective she would be on the topic. But neonicatinoids are used for a variety of crops, there is nothing special about beet other than currently it is being hit quite hard by Yellow Virus. This is what happens with monocropping. Thanks for clarifying she is a student (and the very best of luck to her), not a farmer. Have you read what Tom has to say here? Is he a farmer? [Tweet Link]
|
|
|
Originally posted by davenotamonkey
Thanks for clarifying she is a student (and the very best of luck to her), not a farmer. Have you read what Tom has to say here? Is he a farmer? [Tweet Link]
I did not raise this question as a result of a comment from my daughter by the way. I keep an eye on farming social media and this came up this morning. Quite divisive it appears.
|
|
|
Here is the link to the petition if anyone interested.
|
|
|
is your daughter part of the Beet generation ?
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford |
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
I will read Tom's points when I have a moment to go onto Twitter Did you read the comments from Sussex University or the French Agency for Food, Environmental and Occupational Health and Safety? Now, maybe Tom knows things that they do not. I shall look into it. I have no idea what scientific studies he has done. My point remains the remarkable haste for us to break ranks with the EU, apparently against earlier detailed scientific analysis. And of course that some people in the UK stand to gain considerably by that quick change. Reading briefly through that article from the Guardian about it being driven by the NFU, it does state that the relaxation of the ban is only for emergency use to treat a current outbreak of yellow virus, so seemingly not a total overturn on the usage of this stuff.
A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers |
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
Of course. If you know anything about me you could have assumed I had looked at the science. This is about yield. Yields are down due to virus yellows. It is also about relative harm. I have yet to be persuaded that the use of neonicatinoids is essential and is appropriate given the damage to the bee population - amongst others. To me profit is being put before sustainability. Either: 1. The UK is ahead of the game as it can move quickly and be flexible based on the science, or 2. The UK is breaking ranks with the EU for profit, including making sure there isn't a level playing field, regardless of the long-term harm. Let's be absolutely crystal clear here. This is not the UK going it alone as some rogue state. The following EU countries have requested emergency use: Austria [Tweet Link]
France, in an act of typical EU solidarity has (much like the Germans proclaiming EU unity in joint vaccine procurement whilst ordering a stash just for themselves) decided to approve use anyway: ...and when even Jolyon-Moron tells us that it is incorrect to link neonicotinoid to Brexit, you might want to re-adjust your anti-Brexit blinkers. [Tweet Link]
|
|
|
Originally posted by davenotamonkey
Let's be absolutely crystal clear here. This is not the UK going it alone as some rogue state. The following EU countries have requested emergency use: Austria [Tweet Link]
France, in an act of typical EU solidarity has (much like the Germans proclaiming EU unity in joint vaccine procurement whilst ordering a stash just for themselves) decided to approve use anyway: ...and when even Jolyon-Moron tells us that it is incorrect to link neonicotinoid to Brexit, you might want to re-adjust your anti-Brexit blinkers. [Tweet Link]
That is interesting In that case maybe my original premise is incorrect, I am obliged for the correction. It was the coincidence of timing apparently. I still maintain that we now have the chance to look at other ways to manage agriculture. This seems a retrograde step to me.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
In that case maybe my original premise is incorrect, I am obliged for the correction. It was the coincidence of timing apparently. Credit for the handling of that.
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
Credit for the handling of that. Seconded.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
That is interesting In that case maybe my original premise is incorrect, I am obliged for the correction. It was the coincidence of timing apparently. I still maintain that we now have the chance to look at other ways to manage agriculture. This seems a retrograde step to me.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I’ll answer for him, he may be embarrassed
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
That is interesting In that case maybe my original premise is incorrect, I am obliged for the correction. It was the coincidence of timing apparently. I still maintain that we now have the chance to look at other ways to manage agriculture. This seems a retrograde step to me. Yes, indeed we do, specifically ways that suit the biodiversity of our Isles, rather than a one-size-fits-all centralised body spanning their entire empire. Shall we move on to Xylella fastidiosa and Ceratocystis platani? Xylella fastidiosa: a bacterial disease with many sub species and strains not known to occur in the UK. It is considered to be one of the most dangerous pathogens for plants anywhere in the world. It affects cherry, almond and plum trees as well as olives. Ceratocystis platani: is a fungus not yet present in UK that attacks and kills plane trees. This pathogen poses a significant risk to plane trees in the UK because plane is widely used as an urban amenity species in parks and public gardens, and alongside streets and roads. We were found in breach of EU rules for placing stricter controls on imports for plants carrying these pests (neither of which are endemic to the UK). Should we lower our standards to those of the EU, or is it better that we took unilateral action (despite being in breach of the wonderful lower EU standards)? Should we now lower our standards to ensure a "level playing field" with the EU? Do you think they were complaining mainly because it meant continental exports to the UK would be subject to higher standards, and that would disadvantage them? Or do they genuinely think that lower standards are better, as long as they are EU standards?
|
|
|
Originally posted by davenotamonkey
Yes, indeed we do, specifically ways that suit the biodiversity of our Isles, rather than a one-size-fits-all centralised body spanning their entire empire. Shall we move on to Xylella fastidiosa and Ceratocystis platani? Xylella fastidiosa: a bacterial disease with many sub species and strains not known to occur in the UK. It is considered to be one of the most dangerous pathogens for plants anywhere in the world. It affects cherry, almond and plum trees as well as olives. Ceratocystis platani: is a fungus not yet present in UK that attacks and kills plane trees. This pathogen poses a significant risk to plane trees in the UK because plane is widely used as an urban amenity species in parks and public gardens, and alongside streets and roads. We were found in breach of EU rules for placing stricter controls on imports for plants carrying these pests (neither of which are endemic to the UK). Should we lower our standards to those of the EU, or is it better that we took unilateral action (despite being in breach of the wonderful lower EU standards)? Should we now lower our standards to ensure a "level playing field" with the EU? Do you think they were complaining mainly because it meant continental exports to the UK would be subject to higher standards, and that would disadvantage them? Or do they genuinely think that lower standards are better, as long as they are EU standards? Informative post, thank you.
|
|
|
Originally posted by davenotamonkey
Let's be absolutely crystal clear here. This is not the UK going it alone as some rogue state. The following EU countries have requested emergency use: Austria [Tweet Link]
France, in an act of typical EU solidarity has (much like the Germans proclaiming EU unity in joint vaccine procurement whilst ordering a stash just for themselves) decided to approve use anyway: ...and when even Jolyon-Moron tells us that it is incorrect to link neonicotinoid to Brexit, you might want to re-adjust your anti-Brexit blinkers. [Tweet Link]
Thank you for this link Dave. It provided very interesting reading. It’s a bit of a microcosm of many bigger debates raging along the lines of we don’t have to be great, just better than the others. Tom Clarke is asking for time to find non-chemical solutions. What frustrates is that we could have done that long ago but it would need political will as there is no money in it for the pharma companies. The world is so behind in addressing such a crucial problem of the gradual destruction of our food sources. Beet isn’t great for soil degradation by the way.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.