You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > I Love Croydon-Roy
November 16 2026 2.28am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

I Love Croydon-Roy


Page 2 of 12 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
joe_cpfc Flag Basingstoke 15 Jan 21 1.23pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

You're right, he was amazing at England and Liverpool!
Just check Roberto Carlos' opinion on him from his time at Inter.

Are you comparing our current ability to attract managers to the position we were in as a club 10 years ago, at the bottom of the Championship, with 6 senior players?

and Glen Johnson at Liverpool. This summed him up for me [Link]
He's half decent at keeping smaller clubs up by making them hard to beat sometimes, nothing more than that. His teams play the most appalling football.

Edited by joe_cpfc (15 Jan 2021 1.28pm)

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 15 Jan 21 1.25pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

[Link]

With Guiata, Cahill, Clyne, Meyer picked up on a free, and Zaha for next to nothing. We've done remarkably well in the transfer market.

Arsenal have done terribly. Lots of flops and an imbalanced squad. Heads should roll in that organisation.

Full cost of each 25-man squad in the Premier League
Manchester City - £810,870,000

Manchester United - £628,130,000
Chelsea - £577,100,000
Arsenal - £454,800,000
Liverpool - £454,250,000
Everton - £388,050,000
Tottenham Hotspur - £385,300,000
Leicester City - £317,450,000
Wolverhamton Wanderers - £241,980,000
Aston Villa - £229,350,000
West Ham United - £218,500,000
Newcastle United - £198,100,000
Southampton - £170,550,000
Brighton & Hove Albion - £159,100,000
Crystal Palace - £149,860,000
Sheffield United - £120,700,000
Leeds United - £120,300,000
West Bromwich Albion - £97,700,000
Fulham - £94,350,000
Burnley - £82,600,000


When you can guide a squad costing under £150 million to beating teams costing over £600 million sharing the points with teams costing as Arsenal did £454million, or Spurs, £385million. Leicester a weakened side on the day but still an expensive squad. You must be doing something right.
That list in general shows you get what you pay for , that’s if you are not Arsenal. Or even Wolves and Newcastle..

 

joe_cpfc Flag Basingstoke 15 Jan 21 1.30pm

Originally posted by Putitout


When you can guide a squad costing under £150 million to beating teams costing over £600 million sharing the points with teams costing as Arsenal did £454million, or Spurs, £385million. Leicester a weakened side on the day but still an expensive squad. You must be doing something right.
That list in general shows you get what you pay for , that’s if you are not Arsenal. Or even Wolves and Newcastle..

If we had paid for the likes of Wan Bissaka and Zaha (what he's been worth after his first prem season) then we'd be just above Wolves in that list.

 

AuntyAnne70 Flag Tunbridge WElls 15 Jan 21 1.31pm

This so exciting football that some want would come at a price.

Who do you want in charge?

Think many would soon change their tune after our new expansive football led to a few defeats.

Without major investment, hardly likely to change in the short term.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 15 Jan 21 1.38pm

Originally posted by joe_cpfc

If we had paid for the likes of Wan Bissaka and Zaha (what he's been worth after his first prem season) then we'd be just above Wolves in that list.


If you added the value of home grown talent , most teams would have more value. Arsenal most certainly would . What value would Harry Cain, add to Spurs group. And of course Bissaka, is not in our squad.

 

jeeagles Flag 15 Jan 21 1.55pm

Originally posted by Putitout
When you can guide a squad costing under £150 million to beating teams costing over £600 million sharing the points with teams costing as Arsenal did £454million, or Spurs, £385million. Leicester a weakened side on the day but still an expensive squad. You must be doing something right.
That list in general shows you get what you pay for , that’s if you are not Arsenal. Or even Wolves and Newcastle..

We've had a pretty targeted approach to improving our weakest position since CPFC2010 took over.

Arsenal have a huge imbalance. Other teams, Newcastle, West Ham, Brighton, have spent money badly.

The call from many to just give Roy more money isn't a sensible course of action. We've just given him £20m to spend on a fantastic player who's yet to play in his preferred position.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 15 Jan 21 2.15pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

We've had a pretty targeted approach to improving our weakest position since CPFC2010 took over.

Arsenal have a huge imbalance. Other teams, Newcastle, West Ham, Brighton, have spent money badly.

The call from many to just give Roy more money isn't a sensible course of action. We've just given him £20m to spend on a fantastic player who's yet to play in his preferred position.


Is this your idea of his preferred position? His own? Or his actual best position.? As I see it Eze, has shown what he brings to the team, and it’s great to see, his ability on the ball , and most of his linking play is top rate. He is not a finished article , his work in defensive situations is still needing work. But considering he has freedom of movement in the left side of the pitch. It would seem he is playing to his strengths already.

 

joe_cpfc Flag Basingstoke 15 Jan 21 2.43pm

Originally posted by Putitout


If you added the value of home grown talent , most teams would have more value. Arsenal most certainly would . What value would Harry Cain, add to Spurs group. And of course Bissaka, is not in our squad.

Thats true

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 15 Jan 21 2.45pm

Originally posted by AuntyAnne70

This so exciting football that some want would come at a price.

Who do you want in charge?

Think many would soon change their tune after our new expansive football led to a few defeats.

Without major investment, hardly likely to change in the short term.

I’m not even sure I want to change the way we play, I just want to find some players who can pass the ball to players with the same shirt on. It can’t be too much to ask at this level surely? If you have to fork out £25m in each position to be able to do this then football truly has gone mad. I’m not sure about major investment, I reckon a prudent manager could find 4 or 5 decent players at the right price that could transform this team.

 

joe_cpfc Flag Basingstoke 15 Jan 21 2.48pm

Originally posted by AuntyAnne70

This so exciting football that some want would come at a price.

Who do you want in charge?

Think many would soon change their tune after our new expansive football led to a few defeats.

Without major investment, hardly likely to change in the short term.

I don't think any Roy hater is thinking we should be playing like Barcelona. I just think they don't want to sit through 90 minutes every single week of 11 men behind the ball at all times.

 

jeeagles Flag 15 Jan 21 3.14pm

Originally posted by Putitout


Is this your idea of his preferred position? His own? Or his actual best position.? As I see it Eze, has shown what he brings to the team, and it’s great to see, his ability on the ball , and most of his linking play is top rate. He is not a finished article , his work in defensive situations is still needing work. But considering he has freedom of movement in the left side of the pitch. It would seem he is playing to his strengths already.

His best position is behind the striker in a Puncheon role. It's widely documented, and would mean he'd not have to do as many defensive duties.

That would allow Wilf and Townsend on the wings, delivering for CB. The 3 players behind the striker would be interchangeable which would be a nightmare for defenders. With Eze and Zaha latching on to lay-offs from Benteke but also able to drop back when required. Eze isn't really a winger. Zaha isn't really a striker.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 15 Jan 21 3.53pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

His best position is behind the striker in a Puncheon role. It's widely documented, and would mean he'd not have to do as many defensive duties.

That would allow Wilf and Townsend on the wings, delivering for CB. The 3 players behind the striker would be interchangeable which would be a nightmare for defenders. With Eze and Zaha latching on to lay-offs from Benteke but also able to drop back when required. Eze isn't really a winger. Zaha isn't really a striker.


With respect he is doing just that. . He is not playing the wing .unless it’s his option. He is allowed to go anywhere on the left side. He is already the feed for Zaha, and Benteke, . But he doesn’t stray to the right because the hole he sits in would be left to exposed.if he was to do as you seem to think he should .
Our midfield and defence already gets exposed at times by losing possession to easily at the front of the team.
If he was allowed to not have to protect that left side we would get done week in week out.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 15 Jan 21 4.24pm

Originally posted by Putitout


With respect he is doing just that. . He is not playing the wing .unless it’s his option. He is allowed to go anywhere on the left side. He is already the feed for Zaha, and Benteke, . But he doesn’t stray to the right because the hole he sits in would be left to exposed.if he was to do as you seem to think he should .
Our midfield and defence already gets exposed at times by losing possession to easily at the front of the team.
If he was allowed to not have to protect that left side we would get done week in week out.

I think what he is saying is that with Eze in the 10 role, Zaha would effectively revert to left midfield/wing rather than Eze. However, neither are defenders which then raises the question when fit of having Schlupp left midfield and Zaha/Eze in free roles up top and Benteke dropped. That would be interesting but we would not have a target man.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 15 Jan 21 5.45pm

Originally posted by joe_cpfc

and Glen Johnson at Liverpool. This summed him up for me [Link]
He's half decent at keeping smaller clubs up by making them hard to beat sometimes, nothing more than that. His teams play the most appalling football.

Edited by joe_cpfc (15 Jan 2021 1.28pm)

He was also the last Englishman to take an English club to a European final, not bad for a half decent manager.

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 15 Jan 21 6.11pm

I don't think Fulham played too bad under Roy, and West Brom played better under him then they did for Pulis. When we had Cabaye and an in-form Loftus Cheek we played good stuff, we bought in few half decent sticking plasters like Ayew and McCarthy but they are starting to peel off a bit. Maybe when he looks at the opposition his first thought is how to stop them, but the team does look vulnerable when there's too big a gap between defence and midfield, so we play deep and tightly packed and mainly on the counter, the personnel we have is what mainly dictates how we have to play to secure points. Even with a different manager it probably wouldn't be much prettier and we might have less points.

 

PatrickA Flag London 15 Jan 21 6.36pm

I don't think we have the players to counter attack with pace the way we used to.
We don't have Bolassie anymore, Zaha seems to have lost a yard and Townsend's pace has deserted him.
Can anyone imagine him now running the length of the field and scoring as he did a few years ago against WBA?
We also lack pace in midfield.
Encouragingly Eze gives us a difference during transition with his cleverness on the ball,but we really need an injection of pace up front and on the right.
Sarr would have been a good addition and Antonio would suit a counter attacking approach.
I hope we can address the lack of pace on the next couple of windows.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 15 Jan 21 10.50pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

I don't think we have the players to counter attack with pace the way we used to.
We don't have Bolassie anymore, Zaha seems to have lost a yard and Townsend's pace has deserted him.
Can anyone imagine him now running the length of the field and scoring as he did a few years ago against WBA?
We also lack pace in midfield.
Encouragingly Eze gives us a difference during transition with his cleverness on the ball,but we really need an injection of pace up front and on the right.
Sarr would have been a good addition and Antonio would suit a counter attacking approach.
I hope we can address the lack of pace on the next couple of windows.

I genuinely believe 3 or 4 correct signings (not necessarily mega expensive, but correct), could transform our team. Hopefully our manager and our owners can see that too.

 

jeeagles Flag 15 Jan 21 11.01pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

I genuinely believe 3 or 4 correct signings (not necessarily mega expensive, but correct), could transform our team. Hopefully our manager and our owners can see that too.

I think the fans of every team across the land would say the same thing.

Batshuayi, Eze, Ferguson, Butland and Clyne were particularly good business for £20m over the summer.

No need for 1 or 2 more players this window if that.

We've freed up one place.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 15 Jan 21 11.15pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

I genuinely believe 3 or 4 correct signings (not necessarily mega expensive, but correct), could transform our team. Hopefully our manager and our owners can see that too.

My view is that 3 or 4 players who would genuinely transform our team in the PL would cost a significant amount of money and there will be precious little added to our coffers from the players who depart.

We have 15 players who will be in their 30s at the end of this season (Some are already!)and whilst they have experience they are past their best.If many of them are still with us next season on the back of new contracts and there are precious few newcomers due to lack of funds, then God help us!

Edited by Willo (15 Jan 2021 11.17pm)

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 15 Jan 21 11.24pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

I think the fans of every team across the land would say the same thing.

Batshuayi, Eze, Ferguson, Butland and Clyne were particularly good business for £20m over the summer.

No need for 1 or 2 more players this window if that.

We've freed up one place.

So you think all or most of the contracts due for renewal should be renewed then? Batshuyai was terrible business, he doesn’t fit in our team and you can’t comment on Ferguson because he may never be fit. Clyne is average, no more than that. Eze and Butland both good signings in my opinion.

 

Page 2 of 12 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > I Love Croydon-Roy