sprites Auckland 15 Mar 21 4.08am |
|
|
99% of palace fans are in agreement that the idea scenario is Roy staying on until the end of season...giving us a finish of somewhere between 10 - 15th. Then calling it quits at the end of the season. Don't know why we need some many threads about it lol.
|
dreamwaverider London 15 Mar 21 4.16am |
|
Originally posted by Chaos
No, the untenable thinking of us being 03-04 Arsenal is the problem. We need to think within our resources. Yes, all of us want to be in Europe, but that road is looooooooong.
We cannot be That until we build up to it. And Roy is doing exactly what we need him to do. Namely, not be close to relegation.
This lays the foundation to build up, and Jordan's new stadium plan is the next step.
Jordan?
|
dreamwaverider London 15 Mar 21 4.26am |
|
|
All we need is Roy to retire a top manager come and a top marquee signing.
Say £50m to secure. Josh Harris could deliver that with his eyes wide shut.
Apploolo ar worth billions he's worth $5Biilion.
Stroll in the park
|
cryrst The garden of England 15 Mar 21 6.14am |
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
So presumably you never use any products containing cobalt, as to do so would be hypocritical which I am sure you are not.
Is cobalt used to make batteries for our new green cars?
|
HKOwen Hong Kong 16 Mar 21 12.40am |
|
|
Every lithium ion battery has cobalt as do almost all airplanes.
Presumably Midlands Eagle has no phone, laptop, and never flies.
Edited by HKOwen (16 Mar 2021 12.41am)
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.
|
PalazioVecchio south pole 16 Mar 21 8.32am |
|
|
we will all appreciate just how fantastic Roy has been after he has gone.
Keeping our best players and supplementing them with some upgrades to the weaker players, we will be all surprised at our sudden 'run of bad luck'
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford
|
TheBigToePunt 16 Mar 21 9.14am |
|
|
I've said it before and I'll say it again, happy for Roy to leave if, and very much only if, we get a better manager in his place.
Better in this case meaning more watchable football with results that aren't significantly worse.
And for the love of God please don't tell me that 'anything/anyone is better than Roy'. That's just childish nonsense. Is supporting Sheffield United better? Or West Brom? Or Newcastle, Brighton, Burnley? Of course not. The football we've played this year and part of last has been dire, but the results have been good. There isn't much joy in watching us play, but there is even less in seeing your team play poor football and lose every week too. We only have one of those to worry about.
|
Putitout Oxford 16 Mar 21 10.27am |
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
I've said it before and I'll say it again, happy for Roy to leave if, and very much only if, we get a better manager in his place.
Better in this case meaning more watchable football with results that aren't significantly worse.
And for the love of God please don't tell me that 'anything/anyone is better than Roy'. That's just childish nonsense. Is supporting Sheffield United better? Or West Brom? Or Newcastle, Brighton, Burnley? Of course not. The football we've played this year and part of last has been dire, but the results have been good. There isn't much joy in watching us play, but there is even less in seeing your team play poor football and lose every week too. We only have one of those to worry about.
This whole ,”Roy Out ,” thing has fallen foul of the failure of some to recognise , the constraints , that only the club are responsible for, and will be whoever manages CP. Hodgson, has done his job and kept us in the Premier league, that’s. a fact. It’s also a fact that Palace are a difficult watch. Everything else is a mixture of guessing ,wishful thinking, and failure to give any attention to facts of life for a club of Palaces stature. And the facts of life for every club of similar stature, now occupying a position lower in the Premier, or for many in the Championship, struggling with the question of what is the best way to play this game If it’s a regular place in the big league you want. Having said this, a change has to come. Hodgson can not go on much further . But change for change sake is probably not our best move right now, unless the club it’s self is the subject of substantial change in its financial status.
Edited by Putitout (16 Mar 2021 10.29am)
|
palace99 New Mills 16 Mar 21 12.23pm |
|
|
Roy inherited a unbalanced squad with no clear playing style/identity.
Benteke soon got injured so we had no striker. SP also bought Sakho on transfer deadline, days before Roy's appointment, so whilst Roy would no doubt have verbally approved it, he was probably unaware how hamstrung that would make future transfer windows. Perhaps his best early decision was to replace Puncheon with Luka. At the time Puncheon's performances had declined alarmingly over the last 12 to 18 months yet Pardew, Sam and FDB all made him captain. Roy immediately saw that he was slowing play and he lacked creativity (clearly Punch wasn't happy, as per the current interviews, but definitely the right decision).
He has never complained and has never criticised either the players or the board. A perfect gentleman.
However, 4 years on the ageing playing squad has caught up with us and it is clear that Roy doesn't have a plan B.
Just as Coppell didn't adjust after Wright's departure and relegation was a when not an if question after that, i think Palace and Roy are at the same crossroads.
Roy may be offered another year, but i don't think he will accept it. I think he can see where this is going
|
Uphill Bedford 16 Mar 21 5.27pm |
|
|
He's done his bit for the club.
Now is the time to retire before his 'magic' wears off and he gets the push in the middle of next season.
'Quit while you are ahead' is a sound maxim.
Man and boy Palace since my first game in 1948 sitting on my dad's shoulders
|
The Heath Eagle Thornton Heath 18 Mar 21 10.28am |
|
Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews
I think he should retire, he has done a great job with little support from Steve Parrish and the board. I still can’t believe we have spent hardly anything on players over the last 3 years and sold one of the best emerging right backs the Premiership has ever seen.
Stand aside Roy your job is done you have nothing more to prove.
You think he should retire for his sake or for Palace?
If for Roy's sake then fair enough, but that should be his decision if he is up for another season or not!!
For Palace's sake, again who do you have in mind who can do a better job?
I am Roy IN for another season to rebuild the team in a solid way. Not someone inexperienced or a chancer who will send us straight down.
Edited by The Heath Eagle (18 Mar 2021 10.29am)
|
ASCPFC Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 18 Mar 21 10.52am |
|
Originally posted by The Heath Eagle
You think he should retire for his sake or for Palace?
If for Roy's sake then fair enough, but that should be his decision if he is up for another season or not!!
For Palace's sake, again who do you have in mind who can do a better job?
I am Roy IN for another season to rebuild the team in a solid way. Not someone inexperienced or a chancer who will send us straight down.
Edited by The Heath Eagle (18 Mar 2021 10.29am)
How about his sake and ours? He's not exactly a spring chicken and we have gone stale. The run in will put paid to the sudden Roy love in. Lucky results are papering over cracks the size of Vesuvius. I haven't forgotten last season personally. But, I do accept Roy has done his job as needed. And good luck to him when he does leave.
Red and Blue Army!
|
m/k mick milton keynes 18 Mar 21 11.38am |
|
|
I have said before, if Roy is going to stay, i am personally fine with that, but it must be sorted out very soon, if he is going, then we must appoint a new manager now, or by the end of the month, if we wait till the end of the season, 23rd May, the players will be off for a rest, back about the 1st July, which will give a new manager no time to assess what he has, who to keep who to buy, nightmare scenario, we must give a new guy time to look at his players inc academy Roy must sign now, or appoint a new guy now, we cannot be sentimental
|
The Heath Eagle Thornton Heath 18 Mar 21 12.38pm |
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
How about his sake and ours? He's not exactly a spring chicken and we have gone stale. The run in will put paid to the sudden Roy love in. Lucky results are papering over cracks the size of Vesuvius. I haven't forgotten last season personally. But, I do accept Roy has done his job as needed. And good luck to him when he does leave.
People have such short memories just how much of a yoyo club we used to be. Things were going fantastically before Roy came in with Warnock, Pardew, FDB et al.
Let's just get rid because he is getting on and give Cabaye the job just because he is young and a former player. Bound to work.
|
cantrbury eagle Canterbury 18 Mar 21 12.54pm |
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
I've said it before and I'll say it again, happy for Roy to leave if, and very much only if, we get a better manager in his place.
Better in this case meaning more watchable football with results that aren't significantly worse.
And for the love of God please don't tell me that 'anything/anyone is better than Roy'. That's just childish nonsense. Is supporting Sheffield United better? Or West Brom? Or Newcastle, Brighton, Burnley? Of course not. The football we've played this year and part of last has been dire, but the results have been good. There isn't much joy in watching us play, but there is even less in seeing your team play poor football and lose every week too. We only have one of those to worry about.
|
cantrbury eagle Canterbury 18 Mar 21 12.57pm |
|
|
Good point made Potterball is very good till they get in the penalty area then the forwards panic with the amount of chances made even Benteke would get 10 a season.
|
Palace Old Geezer Midhurst 18 Mar 21 1.06pm |
|
|
Right now there's a 'Keep Roy' thread on the Home page at the same time as a 'Roy Out' one.
What a fickle lot we are. Or are we? It didn't take long for the Keep thread to say the opposite, and for quite a few pages a lot of support was garnered on the Out case and it's moved that way again thanks to sensible input from BTP.
I'm sticking to my view that Roy has done what he was required to do and kept us in the Premiership so has done his job well. His contract comes to an end in the summer so the odds are that he'll retire gracefully like the gentleman he is. Talk of 'getting rid' is so disrespectful to the man.
I reckon a straw poll would find most of us wishing him well whilst hoping for a creative and exciting man to replace him next season. None of us like to watch defensive and negative football, that's a given.
However, I do get the jitters when I consider who Roy's replacement might be. Especially when I see some of the names lobbed about on here.
Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.
|
The Heath Eagle Thornton Heath 18 Mar 21 3.58pm |
|
Originally posted by Palace Old Geezer
However, I do get the jitters when I consider who Roy's replacement might be. Especially when I see some of the names lobbed about on here.
This.
Pardew has been mentioned more than once. Steve Coppell too.
Might as well go and see if Arthur Rowe can be persuaded out retirement, once we find what plot he was buried in.
|
ASCPFC Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 18 Mar 21 4.04pm |
|
Originally posted by The Heath Eagle
This.
Pardew has been mentioned more than once. Steve Coppell too.
Might as well go and see if Arthur Rowe can be persuaded out retirement, once we find what plot he was buried in.
Might as well, probably have similar ideas to what we do now. Fear of change is hurting us.
Red and Blue Army!
|
The Heath Eagle Thornton Heath 18 Mar 21 5.28pm |
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
Might as well, probably have similar ideas to what we do now. Fear of change is hurting us.
I am not afraid to change the manager but fans such as yourself lack perspective. You want to see a change no matter what, when Roy is keeping us safely in the league while the board are selling players for £50m and not reinvesting the money in the squad. How is Roy responsible for such lack of ambition at board level?
I want there to be a clear idea and philosophy from board level downwards. Some punt on an ex player or some foreign coach while the fundamentals at board level are missing is a recipe for relegation.
I do hope you will be there back in the champo if you get your way. Somehow I doubt it.
|