This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Mathers
Absolutely is true! Luka’s passing this season has been diabolical. Along with his lack of pace, poor set pieces, discipline, leadership and general attitude. 1 goal and 1 assist for a central midfielder is piss poor by any standard. If he has personal issues that have affected his game then he shouldn’t have been playing and certainly shouldn’t have been captain. I don’t recall another player who’s form has fallen so far, so quickly. From being one of our best players in 2018-19 season he is now easily our biggest liability.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Uphill
Personally I wish he was one of the many whose contract expires next month. His main value was as a penalty taker but he lost that crown against Southampton. I hope the new manager sees his limitations and if the player has any value get rid. Can you seriously see Zaha, who is 28 himself and frustrated at still being with his boyhood club, being taken under anyone’s wing ? That said the best protection I’ve seen him given recently was the treatment Ward-Prowse got from McCarthy in the opening game. I think Luka has been decent and bargain for us at £10mil but his legs have gone.
|
|
|
1 assist, 1 goal & 19 shots in 38 games nothing to write home about.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
What’s the point here???? Gary Cahill also has 83% passing accuracy, 1 goal and 1assist. Passing accuracy is a pointless f***ing stat if the passes are going sideways and backwards. Why don’t you take a look at JWP on your new favourite website? Similar teams, both are primary set piece takers and captains so will likely play most games. 87% passing accuracy, 7 assists and 8 goals. Can not stand him as a player but he is miles ahead of Luka is every facet of the game.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mathers
What’s the point here???? Gary Cahill also has 83% passing accuracy, 1 goal and 1assist. Passing accuracy is a pointless f***ing stat if the passes are going sideways and backwards. Why don’t you take a look at JWP on your new favourite website? Similar teams, both are primary set piece takers and captains so will likely play most games. 87% passing accuracy, 7 assists and 8 goals. Can not stand him as a player but he is miles ahead of Luka is every facet of the game. For avoidance of doubt, I peruse a plethora of websites and don't have a "New favourite website". My 'Link' was in response to comments apropos Milivojevic's passing prowess. I am not of the opinion that an 83% pass success rate over 27 games and over 1300 passes indicates that he has a severe lack of passing ability. I accept he is not a Glenn Hoddle but the ability to regularly pass to a team-mate, even though the passes might not be too adventurous at times is a good quality to possess. My opinion is that overall, Milivojevic has been more influential in previous seasons. Edited by Willo (30 May 2021 11.50pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
For avoidance of doubt, I peruse a plethora of websites and don't have a "New favourite website". My 'Link' was in response to comments apropos Milivojevic's passing prowess. I am not of the opinion that an 83% pass success rate over 27 games and over 1300 passes indicates that he has a severe lack of passing ability. I accept he is not a Glenn Hoddle but the ability to regularly pass to a team-mate, even though the passes might not be too adventurous at times is a good quality to possess. My opinion is that overall, Milivojevic has been more influential in previous seasons. Edited by Willo (30 May 2021 11.50pm) He certainly has. No one is denying that. But to write him off is premature. He's shown time and time again the ability to split defences with great passes or hit great diagonals to the wings. He hasn't suddenly lost that ability...he's just lost a bit of form. (Also hard to demonstrate your ability on the ball with an overall team possession rate of 20 - 30 every game. Bottom line for me: Luka Milivojevic is a decent player.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cROYdonrogers
There appears to be some level of boredom, so I’ll throw this one out. Clearly not the player he was, but why? Jairo Riedewald happened to Luka. It must be like carrying a bag of sand on his shoulder.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EddieMac
Jairo Riedewald happened to Luka. It must be like carrying a bag of sand on his shoulder. And when Jairo wasn’t in the team? I believe Jairo has started 19 games to Luka’s 31. So not necessarily Jairo’s fault but as you have made it quite clear you don’t think Jairo should be anywhere near the squad, I suppose it is as good an excuse as any Edited by Spiderman (31 May 2021 7.28am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
And when Jairo wasn’t in the team? I believe Jairo has started 19 games to Luka’s 31. So not necessarily Jairo’s fault but as you have made it quite clear you don’t think Jairo should be anywhere near the squad, I suppose it is as good an excuse as any Edited by Spiderman (31 May 2021 7.28am) I don’t believe Luka has played 31 bad games this season. There is a massive drop in his quality when Jairo plays beside him.
|
|
|
Could the ex managers rigid positional tactics not be a reason for lukas dip in form?
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Could the ex managers rigid positional tactics not be a reason for lukas dip in form? Possibly yes
|
|
|
Originally posted by EddieMac
Jairo Riedewald happened to Luka. It must be like carrying a bag of sand on his shoulder. Maybe not a bag of sand but yes he has had to look after his less experienced team mate in the heat of battle . Roys two in the middle ,often up against 3 hasnt helped either nor I would suggest has the effects of the covid . All things put together (along with the stress of family issues ,whatever they are ) and its no wonder we have not seen the best Luka on show .
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Could the ex managers rigid positional tactics not be a reason for lukas dip in form? Add to that the vitriol he has been given by a large number of Palace fans...Luca’s got a captain’s ego and would thrive better on encouragement rather than a slagging off IMO
|
|
|
He appeared so BORED with tactics expected to play under Roy and it put too much pressure on the defensive midfielders, with no creative midfielder as an outlet.. Originally posted by crvenaeagle
Very likely it could be management, not that I wish to point the finger. Was excellent under Sam but then slowly dwindled over time.
|
|
|
Originally posted by A1969Eagle
He appeared so BORED with tactics expected to play under Roy and it put too much pressure on the defensive midfielders, with no creative midfielder as an outlet.. Agree. The defensive mids under a Roy regime are on a hiding to nothing.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
For avoidance of doubt, I peruse a plethora of websites
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) |
|
|
According to The Athletic, Luka's is away on compassionate grounds. Does anyone know whether this is indeed the case and what the issue is?
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.