You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Workers to pay for social care
November 21 2026 9.56pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Workers to pay for social care


Page 2 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 07 Sep 21 7.55pm

Originally posted by punksnotdead

I think it's great that people who've worked hard all their lives now won't lose everything if they end up in care, shouldn't have put it on N.I but maybe guarantee a part of V.A.T for it so that everyone contributed.
Or maybe the £350,000,000 a week we were saving for the N.H.S due to brexit.

I hadn’t even read the details. I assumed all the talk was about care in the community. Turns out it’s nobody pays more than £86,000 for their care from October 2023.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (07 Sep 2021 11.48pm)

 


COYP

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 07 Sep 21 8.07pm

Originally posted by Orange1290

Covid is being used as a very convenient excuse to cover up the shambles of brexit and the very poor deal Johnson agreed to sign with the EU.

Ah. Of course. You think that furlough and the shutdown of society cost nothing. Whereas in the real world, it cost plenty. And that money may be what is missing from the "fix social care" pledge. So a pledge must be broken. Which should it be, in your opinion?

Not that it matters anything to you, being an Anglophobe, and living in another country.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 07 Sep 21 8.34pm

Originally posted by DanH

A manifesto pledge broken by Johnson but does anyone give a sh*t what he does or doesn’t do or say?

Edited by DanH (07 Sep 2021 5.37pm)

do you think that fella can give the rest of us a morality lesson ?

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Orange1290 Flag 07 Sep 21 8.36pm

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3660709]

Ah. Of course. You think that furlough and the shutdown of society cost nothing. Whereas in the real world, it cost plenty. And that money may be what is missing from the "fix social care" pledge. So a pledge must be broken. Which should it be, in your opinion?

Not that it matters anything to you, being an Anglophobe, and living in another country.


Yep, the usual denial from the blinkered. Often looking in from the outside the real situation can be seen, it's called perspective of which you seem to have very little.

 


Pro China, EU & Palestine

Spiderman Flag Horsham 07 Sep 21 8.49pm

Originally posted by DanH

1.25% point increase on employees’ and employers’ National Insurance Contributions, a 10% increase on current rates, to pay for state subsidised social care. Given that it’s only those employed and their employers that pay this tax and no one over 65, whether employed or not, pays it or not, is this fair? Unearned income such as rental profits, dividends, interest etc. not subject to NIC. A tax that only hits the younger, working, less wealthy population.

Given the demographic on here I’m sure you’re all delighted my generation will be working the next 30 years to pay for someone to wipe your arse in a couple of year’s time but thoughts on here? A manifesto pledge broken by Johnson but does anyone give a sh*t what he does or doesn’t do or say?

Edited by DanH (07 Sep 2021 5.37pm)

I worked and paid NI for 44 years, I’m sure I have paid for plenty of arses to be wiped over that time.

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 07 Sep 21 8.58pm

Originally posted by Orange1290


Yep, the usual denial from the blinkered. Often looking in from the outside the real situation can be seen, it's called perspective of which you seem to have very little.

Address what I wrote, or carry on trolling. Your choice.

If you think that you know better than me, show me an alternative for this particular situation. How would the situation be better if we were still a member of the union of Europe? You think they would pay "to fix social care" for us? Or would it be more likely that UK would be helping to bail out failing economies in southern Europe? Making the matter worse for our own social care? You idealists just never think it through.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

becky Flag over the moon 07 Sep 21 9.49pm

Of course, they could always cancel HS2, make people spend 20 minutes longer on their journeys, and solve the cost of social care and a few other things all in one fell swoop.......... or is that too easy?

No doubt DanH would still complain about oldies wasting his important time......

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 07 Sep 21 10.30pm

As a retired man whose income is partially dependent on rent generating property purchased with his pension fund, I can see why some consider this to be an unfair way of funding the very real changes that are needed.

My income is, of course, still fully taxed, and I paid both personal NI whilst employed, and Class 4 NI when running my businesses, alongside employer's NI for my staff.

So over the 52 years I was paying NI, I have contributed a lot. Which I did willingly, as I understand how this works.

Apart from my state pension (which is also subject to tax), I have never drawn a benefit, not even sick pay. I do, of course, benefit from the NHS.

So is this fair? The answer for me is both yes, and no. It's fair for the low to average income pensioner and no for the higher income pensioner.

But not just higher income pensioners ought to pay more. All higher earners, from whatever source and at whatever age, ought to pay a little more via income tax.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Teddy Eagle Flag 07 Sep 21 11.12pm

Originally posted by DanH

1.25% point increase on employees’ and employers’ National Insurance Contributions, a 10% increase on current rates, to pay for state subsidised social care. Given that it’s only those employed and their employers that pay this tax and no one over 65, whether employed or not, pays it or not, is this fair? Unearned income such as rental profits, dividends, interest etc. not subject to NIC. A tax that only hits the younger, working, less wealthy population.

Given the demographic on here I’m sure you’re all delighted my generation will be working the next 30 years to pay for someone to wipe your arse in a couple of year’s time but thoughts on here? A manifesto pledge broken by Johnson but does anyone give a sh*t what he does or doesn’t do or say?

Edited by DanH (07 Sep 2021 5.37pm)

From each according to his ability, to each according to his needs. Unless you think Groucho more worth listening to than Karl. You’ve got it. Others haven’t. Hand it over.

 

DanH Flag SW2 07 Sep 21 11.19pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

From each according to his ability, to each according to his needs. Unless you think Groucho more worth listening to than Karl. You’ve got it. Others haven’t. Hand it over.

Newly qualified graduates with student debt who earn over the £28k threshold now have a marginal tax rate of 42.25% with repayments taken into account. How is that generation ever meant to save to get on the housing ladder?

 

DanH Flag SW2 07 Sep 21 11.22pm

Originally posted by becky

Of course, they could always cancel HS2, make people spend 20 minutes longer on their journeys, and solve the cost of social care and a few other things all in one fell swoop.......... or is that too easy?

No doubt DanH would still complain about oldies wasting his important time......

HS2 is a monstrous waste of public money.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 07 Sep 21 11.27pm

Originally posted by DanH

Newly qualified graduates with student debt who earn over the £28k threshold now have a marginal tax rate of 42.25% with repayments taken into account. How is that generation ever meant to save to get on the housing ladder?

This isn’t the first generation in history.; it’s always been the same. How was I supposed to get on the housing ladder when I started work in the 70s and earned £26.10 a week?

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 07 Sep 21 11.44pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

This isn’t the first generation in history.; it’s always been the same. How was I supposed to get on the housing ladder when I started work in the 70s and earned £26.10 a week?

It is much harder now. It’s been proven and confirmed by many different bodies. It isn’t even difficult to prove. How many times more than average wages the cost of the average property, or any property.

In the ‘70s you didn’t have 20 years of property speculation and the other reasons why supply compared to demand is low. You also had a lot of social housing.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (08 Sep 2021 1.00am)

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 08 Sep 21 12.04am

It’s going to take a long time for this to sit right with everyone, but it will eventually. Young people will know that they’re all covered for care when they get old, and those who’ve prospered or ‘done the right things’ as is often used, won’t get taxed heavily while others get it free - whether that’s because they just didn’t prosper or didn’t care about anything and always knew the state would support them.

But we’re at a time when young people are getting the rough end of a lot of sh1t while knowing that people will be keeping hundreds of thousands of pounds while they’ll be taxed more and maybe not get any inheritance themselves in the case of generations of families in social housing. Whether that’s through choice or bad choices or not falls into the why should they get free care question.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (08 Sep 2021 12.05am)

 


COYP

DanH Flag SW2 08 Sep 21 12.15am

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

This isn’t the first generation in history.; it’s always been the same. How was I supposed to get on the housing ladder when I started work in the 70s and earned £26.10 a week?

Have you seen the average wage to house price ratio over the last 50 years?

 

DanH Flag SW2 08 Sep 21 12.16am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

It’s going to take a long time for this to sit right with everyone, but it will eventually. Young people will know that they’re all covered for care when they get old, and those who’ve prospered or ‘done the right things’ as is often used, won’t get taxed heavily while others get it free - whether that’s because they just didn’t prosper or didn’t care about anything and always knew the state would support them.

But we’re at a time when young people are getting the rough end of a lot of sh1t while knowing that people will be keeping hundreds of thousands of pounds while they’ll be taxed more and maybe not get any inheritance themselves in the case of generations of families in social housing. Whether that’s through choice or bad choices or not falls into the why should they get free care question.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (08 Sep 2021 12.05am)

Agree with a lot of this. The idea and principle is sound. How it’s being funded in the short term really isn’t.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 08 Sep 21 12.38am

Originally posted by DanH

Agree with a lot of this. The idea and principle is sound. How it’s being funded in the short term really isn’t.

I think so too. And the people they should tax a bit more for this via non work incomes will benefit sooner from not having to pay over the same in real terms equal to £86,000 in October 2023 if they’re unable to look after themselves in old age. There’s effectively a chunk of people gaining this old age security for less of a tax burden, and after years of not paying this higher NI the younger generations will do from scratch.

 


COYP

Jacey Flag 08 Sep 21 8.12am

All employees choosing to work after the age of 66 will also be paying increased NI.
Government's having been struggling with this issue for well over twenty years and have all spectacularly failed to agree on the way forward.
At least a plan has been formulated,like it or not,and clearly,there are winners and losers.
Dividends now to be included,but not,for the time being,landlord rental income.Why ??

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 08 Sep 21 9.07am

In Germany pensioners pay, split 50:50 with their pension provider, up to a cap.

As a pensioner, you pay the same health insurance contribution rate of 15.9%, just like other insured parties. This contribution rate is a combination of the general contribution rate of 14.6% and the additional contribution of 1.3%. For nursing care insurance, as well, you pay the same contribution as any other insured party. In 2019, the contribution rate for nursing care is 3.05%.
The contributions for health and nursing care insurance are calculated on the basis of your individual income. The following sources of income are taken into account in this case:

Statutory pensions under the German pension insurance scheme and agricultural pensions
Foreign pensions
Benefit payments from your former employer
Earnings from lump-sum benefits and lump-sum settlements
Income from self-employed work (earned income)

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 08 Sep 21 9.21am

I tend to take a kind of relaxed view of this sort of thing - not because I don't care but because there is naff all I can do about it -

Tory breaks Manifesto promises - Nothing really new there & given that we went into Brexit without really knowing what it would actually mean / cost (it was a kind of suck it & see situation) & then Covid came along with all that it brought with it, something no one has known in living memory so all told I am not surprised that manifesto promises made in 2019 were broken.

Overall - the cost has to be carried somewhere, there will inevitably be winners & losers in this - all I ask is that we as a country come up with the fairest way possible to get maximum benefit for what we are trying to achieve, that we stop wasting money on ridiculous projects that non one wants / needs & when we send money overseas we carry out realistic sufficient due diligence to see that the overseas donations really do get utilised where they are needed

 

Page 2 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Workers to pay for social care