You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Free Speech
November 21 2026 9.15pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Free Speech


Page 2 of 9 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 28 Nov 21 8.26am

wrote ?

Damn,....missed the Edit

Edited by Forest Hillbilly (28 Nov 2021 8.27am)

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Stirlingsays Flag 28 Nov 21 8.31am

Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly

Yep Stirling, there are many threads entwined within 1984. A broken love story, disillusionment, re-writing of history, etc.

My own feelings on the book was that Big Brother didn't exist, but was a figurehead of an entirely human construct. something the elite controlled (wealth, power, goods), but the masses below had the power to change things. The masses were given 'just enough' to get by and to keep their basic need sated.
Assisting the system, obviously gave a better lifestyle.

I ended up feeling angry, that although things could have been better, human nature to improve/rebel, was supressed by lies and other factors.

Orwell was prophetic, even though he was commenting on regimes in his present. As human nature doesn't really change there is much commentary on it from the past that still applies today......I imagine Orwell would regard today much in the way you describe.

It's weird that he's mostly held up today by the right considering he was a socialist...albeit an honest one. Then again he lived in far more socially conservative times so being on the left back then isn't today....he certainly had fierce criticisms for authoritarianism and its lies, left or right and was pretty solid on it throughout his life.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 28 Nov 21 8.34am

And protests have taken a turn for the worse.

Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Bill 2021: protest powers
(source gov.uk)
"Protests are an important part of our vibrant and tolerant democracy. Under human rights law, we all have the right to gather and express our views. But these rights are not absolute rights. That fact raises important questions for the police and wider society to consider about how much disruption is tolerable, and how to deal with protesters who break the law. A fair balance should be struck between individual rights and the general interests of the community.

Having reviewed the evidence, our conclusion is that the police do not strike the right balance on every occasion. The balance may tip too readily in favour of protesters when – as is often the case – the police do not accurately assess the level of disruption caused, or likely to be caused, by a protest."

More suppression of free speech, aided by Covid Restrictions.

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 28 Nov 21 8.34am

Originally posted by Badger11

Orwell wrote a biography of his time during the Spanish Civil war when he fought with the communists and how he became disillusioned with the lies they told. If you have read 1984 the genesis of that book is all there in Homage to Catalonia, well worth a read.

Edited by Badger11 (28 Nov 2021 8.26am)

Orwell fought in the P.O.U.M brigades, Trotskyist communists who were against Stalin (Trotsky disavowed them!)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 28 Nov 21 8.57am

Originally posted by georgenorman

Orwell fought in the P.O.U.M brigades, Trotskyist communists who were against Stalin (Trotsky disavowed them!)

I think if he'd survived the pick he might have reconsidered the disavowal.

Not that Trotsky was much better than Stalin....he was the military instrument used in Lenin's betrayal of the many useful idiots who believed the red's lies and helped them to power.....god knows who many were on those death lists, friend and foe alike.

Edited by Stirlingsays (28 Nov 2021 8.57am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 28 Nov 21 9.14am

Today Orwell like Attlee would no doubt be considered traitors to the socialist cause by a large part of the Labour Party.

By the way fun fact he called the book 1984 because it was published in 1948 geddit!

 


One more point

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 28 Nov 21 9.57am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

I think if he'd survived the pick he might have reconsidered the disavowal.

Not that Trotsky was much better than Stalin....he was the military instrument used in Lenin's betrayal of the many useful idiots who believed the red's lies and helped them to power.....god knows who many were on those death lists, friend and foe alike.

Edited by Stirlingsays (28 Nov 2021 8.57am)

I agree that Trotsky was not much better than Stalin. Orwell attached himself to the POUM organisation largely because it had affiliations to the Independent Labour Party (ILP) in Britain to which Orwell later became a member, and he had a letter of introduction to John McNair an ILP/POUM organiser in Spain. POUM (Partido Obrero de Unification Marxist – the United Marxist Workers’ Party) was a hotchpotch of anti-Stalin communists, anarchists, socialists and miscellaneous anti-fascists. The Stalinist communists just branded the entire organisation as Trotskyites. You have to read Orwell’s ‘Homage to Catalonia’ to get some idea of the complexity and motives of the various factions involved in the Spanish civil war.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 28 Nov 21 10.18am

Originally posted by georgenorman

I agree that Trotsky was not much better than Stalin. Orwell attached himself to the POUM organisation largely because it had affiliations to the Independent Labour Party (ILP) in Britain to which Orwell later became a member, and he had a letter of introduction to John McNair an ILP/POUM organiser in Spain. POUM (Partido Obrero de Unification Marxist – the United Marxist Workers’ Party) was a hotchpotch of anti-Stalin communists, anarchists, socialists and miscellaneous anti-fascists. The Stalinist communists just branded the entire organisation as Trotskyites. You have to read Orwell’s ‘Homage to Catalonia’ to get some idea of the complexity and motives of the various factions involved in the Spanish civil war.


This is where Orwell got the idea of the of the shifting allegiances between the 3 superpowers who rule the world and the various people attached to them. One moment they are the hated enemy next they are an ally.

In Spain the commies were more interested in factional fighting than in fighting the Franco forces.

 


One more point

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 28 Nov 21 10.24am

Originally posted by Badger11

This is where Orwell got the idea of the of the shifting allegiances between the 3 superpowers who rule the world and the various people attached to them. One moment they are the hated enemy next they are an ally.

In Spain the commies were more interested in factional fighting than in fighting the Franco forces.

Yes, along with the obvious parallels of the Nazi-Soviet pact and then America and Britian becomming allies with Stalin.

 

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 28 Nov 21 10.35am

Populace control was the ultimate aspiration. When person conspired against person perpetuated by fear or compliance with the governing system.
That's what is disappoints me with the current political scene. There is no viable alternative to Government at the moment, and we are seeing all sorts of restrictions put in place,...because they can.

Ignorance is strength
Freedom is slavery
War is Peace

War is Peace was the mind-opener for me on a perspective of society. Today the UK is at war with the EU over trade, France over immigration, the perpetual terror threats.

And the pointless discussions of the electorate won't change the System. And neither will an election.

When I see Socialist neighbours speaking with pride about how their children/grand children are within the Private Education system, and earning £££, then you wonder what politics is for.

Socialism is seemingly gone, for all its potential/theoretical virtues.
The Proles are left to argue over political parties, none of which has the electorate as their key concern, except keeping them in power.

Yes, we are free to speak. But in many cases the audience is dead. Just turn on your telescreen.

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Stirlingsays Flag 28 Nov 21 12.13pm

Originally posted by georgenorman

I agree that Trotsky was not much better than Stalin. Orwell attached himself to the POUM organisation largely because it had affiliations to the Independent Labour Party (ILP) in Britain to which Orwell later became a member, and he had a letter of introduction to John McNair an ILP/POUM organiser in Spain. POUM (Partido Obrero de Unification Marxist – the United Marxist Workers’ Party) was a hotchpotch of anti-Stalin communists, anarchists, socialists and miscellaneous anti-fascists. The Stalinist communists just branded the entire organisation as Trotskyites. You have to read Orwell’s ‘Homage to Catalonia’ to get some idea of the complexity and motives of the various factions involved in the Spanish civil war.

Educational, I tip my hat George.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 28 Nov 21 12.49pm

Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly

Populace control was the ultimate aspiration. When person conspired against person perpetuated by fear or compliance with the governing system.
That's what is disappoints me with the current political scene. There is no viable alternative to Government at the moment, and we are seeing all sorts of restrictions put in place,...because they can.

Ignorance is strength
Freedom is slavery
War is Peace

War is Peace was the mind-opener for me on a perspective of society. Today the UK is at war with the EU over trade, France over immigration, the perpetual terror threats.

And the pointless discussions of the electorate won't change the System. And neither will an election.

When I see Socialist neighbours speaking with pride about how their children/grand children are within the Private Education system, and earning £££, then you wonder what politics is for.

Socialism is seemingly gone, for all its potential/theoretical virtues.
The Proles are left to argue over political parties, none of which has the electorate as their key concern, except keeping them in power.

Yes, we are free to speak. But in many cases the audience is dead. Just turn on your telescreen.

Excellent post.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 28 Nov 21 1.22pm

And a few similarities on HOL, especially with the 'new' Politics forum.
Reminds me of The Hate Hour in 1984. Where people are so entrenched in their (political) positions, just the mention of the enemy name is enough to turn some people to hysteria, shouting at their telescreens and pledging allegiance to The Party.

There is a theoretical gene in the human gene, named The Selfish Gene. It theorises that the organism will do whatever it takes to ensure its survival, even if it means destroying its habitat and also destroying other organisms from the same species.

It's quite saddening when people put behaviour down to genes, or some other excuse. Humans are capable of far better. But most choose not to.

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Stirlingsays Flag 28 Nov 21 1.58pm

Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly

And a few similarities on HOL, especially with the 'new' Politics forum.
Reminds me of The Hate Hour in 1984. Where people are so entrenched in their (political) positions, just the mention of the enemy name is enough to turn some people to hysteria, shouting at their telescreens and pledging allegiance to The Party.

There is a theoretical gene in the human gene, named The Selfish Gene. It theorises that the organism will do whatever it takes to ensure its survival, even if it means destroying its habitat and also destroying other organisms from the same species.

It's quite saddening when people put behaviour down to genes, or some other excuse. Humans are capable of far better. But most choose not to.

I don't think they are.

And personally I put it down to genes because there is nothing else....Culture is environment and while it can affect genes (some more than others) the extent of its affect on genes will mostly be minor...when it comes to behaviour.

The bright child will be bright even given a dull environment...just not as bright as they could have been....and the dull child will never be bright even if Einstein had taught them exclusively.....though obviously it would benefit them.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 28 Nov 21 2.49pm

Originally posted by georgenorman

Yes, along with the obvious parallels of the Nazi-Soviet pact and then America and Britian becomming allies with Stalin.

Indeed excellent point.

 


One more point

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 28 Nov 21 3.04pm

The 'elective dictatorship' now upon us according to Kenneth Clarke, and first by Lord Hailsham in 1961, each occurring in the third term of a tory government.

In the present case with a very large majority.

So it may be said that the elective dictatorship was voted for.

Obviously our system is weak unrepresentative and supports the establishment, monarchy the very rich etc.

They are not going to give it up, only entrench their rule more.

.

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 28 Nov 21 4.20pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

The 'elective dictatorship' now upon us according to Kenneth Clarke, and first by Lord Hailsham in 1961, each occurring in the third term of a tory government.

In the present case with a very large majority.

So it may be said that the elective dictatorship was voted for.

Obviously our system is weak unrepresentative and supports the establishment, monarchy the very rich etc.

They are not going to give it up, only entrench their rule more.

.

Can we change it? Yes we can? Will we change it? No, we won't, unless and until enough of us see it as a priority.

It's impossible to see the current parties doing anything voluntarily. Turkeys & Christmas!

So we need a new party with constitutional change as a central plank of its manifesto. Any new party requires funding, and that is very unlikely to well up in sufficient volume from its roots.

So a super wealthy benefactor needs to emerge who loves his country more than his self-interest and seeks a place in history. We need a UK George Soros.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 28 Nov 21 4.26pm

This thread is developing into a very good one with some sensible comments and a welcome lack of acrimony. What is going on?!

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 28 Nov 21 4.35pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

The 'elective dictatorship' now upon us according to Kenneth Clarke, and first by Lord Hailsham in 1961, each occurring in the third term of a tory government.

In the present case with a very large majority.

So it may be said that the elective dictatorship was voted for.

Obviously our system is weak unrepresentative and supports the establishment, monarchy the very rich etc.

They are not going to give it up, only entrench their rule more.

.

As a Communist, I would have though that you would be all for dictatorships.
I guess it is more about the Tories being in charge for you.

I suspect a big majority brings good and bad. Things might get done without politically motivated interference from the opposition, but on the flip side, there is the potential for corruption.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 28 Nov 21 4.37pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

The 'elective dictatorship' now upon us according to Kenneth Clarke, and first by Lord Hailsham in 1961, each occurring in the third term of a tory government.

In the present case with a very large majority.

So it may be said that the elective dictatorship was voted for.

Obviously our system is weak unrepresentative and supports the establishment, monarchy the very rich etc.

They are not going to give it up, only entrench their rule more.

To be fair, it's not as though the choices are great....in most elections it comes down to the lesser evil.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Page 2 of 9 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Free Speech