You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Centre Forwards
November 16 2026 3.42am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Centre Forwards


Page 2 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 10 Feb 22 6.15pm

IMO, it is still too early to assess both Edouard and Mateta.Their PL experience amounts to:
Edouard = just 14 starts and 6 sub appearances.
Mateta = just 5 starts this season and 4 sub appearances and is enjoying his first run of games in the squad (I'd write off last year - apart from that Brighton goal - as he didn't get a look in because he wasn't yet up to scratch).

I want to see how the two of them do over the rest of the season as they become more and mor4e attuned to this toughest of football leagues (especially for strikers).

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 10 Feb 22 6.22pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

If Nketiah joins on a free and Plange already signed, and Mateta seemingly PVs first choice, Maybe Edouard maybe moved on, i expect Ayew to extend his contract. Olise and Rak-Sakyi on the right and Wilf on the left it dosent leave many games for Edouard.

Edouard has surely made more league appearances this season than all the players you’ve mentioned there - why on earth would he be the one moved on?
He’s also scored and created more than nearly all of them.

He’s averaging a goal every 200 mins in a brand new league, with a lot of minutes off the wing, and has just turned 24.. I think he’s one of the best prospects at the club, and whilst I agree he hasn’t quite cracked leading the line yet, his talent is there to see.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 10 Feb 22 6.51pm

Of the attacking midfielders and outright attackers, Mateta, Edouard, Olise, Eze, Plange, Rak-Sakyi, are all young.

Benteke 31, Ayew 30, Zaha 29, Schlupp 29

Given the direction we are heading and a move towards a more youthful squad, why would we look to move any of the young ones on. We should sell Benteke, Schlupp and Ayew along with Milivojevic, Kelly, Clyne, this summer and free up salaries to bring in 2 midfielders, a centre half and right back.

If Zaha finally goes then a top replacement winger would also be a priority.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 10 Feb 22 7.13pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Of the attacking midfielders and outright attackers, Mateta, Edouard, Olise, Eze, Plange, Rak-Sakyi, are all young.

Benteke 31, Ayew 30, Zaha 29, Schlupp 29

Given the direction we are heading and a move towards a more youthful squad, why would we look to move any of the young ones on. We should sell Benteke, Schlupp and Ayew along with Milivojevic, Kelly, Clyne, this summer and free up salaries to bring in 2 midfielders, a centre half and right back.

If Zaha finally goes then a top replacement winger would also be a priority.

Disagree - you can't field a team of youngsters. It's about finding the balance. Experience counts for an awful lot. Plus the players you've listed still have something to offer. There's a big difference between 29-31 and 36+. It's not like we're talking about Dann or Cahill last season. Potentially agree about Clyne if we're not going to use him, which it doesn't seem like we are.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 10 Feb 22 7.54pm

Originally posted by sprites

Disagree - you can't field a team of youngsters. It's about finding the balance. Experience counts for an awful lot. Plus the players you've listed still have something to offer. There's a big difference between 29-31 and 36+. It's not like we're talking about Dann or Cahill last season. Potentially agree about Clyne if we're not going to use him, which it doesn't seem like we are.

Not sure why you don’t agree perhaps you could elaborate. Rak-Sakyi or Olise for Ayew, Edouard, Mateta or Plange for Benteke, Eze or Edouard for Schlupp. Not sure where the loss of balance or experience is here and these players are all good enough (Rak-Sakyi, Plange of course still unproven at this level). The other players are young but they are not without PL experience. As others have mentioned elsewhere if you get a decent full back on the right you do not need Ayew to help out as much as he currently has to and Olise offers so much more going forwards and can score goals which is what forwards are primarily there for.

We know we need new midfielders and Kelly/Clyne are superfluous other than as emergency cover. Milivojevic is past it and Ward should ultimately be held onto only as cover for a new right back. I agree you need experience but I also think you should move players on whilst they still have some value. I would maybe keep Ayew but the rest can go in my opinion and be improved upon by new signings. There is adequate experience in the rest of the team.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 10 Feb 22 8.42pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Not sure why you don’t agree perhaps you could elaborate. Rak-Sakyi or Olise for Ayew, Edouard, Mateta or Plange for Benteke, Eze or Edouard for Schlupp. Not sure where the loss of balance or experience is here and these players are all good enough (Rak-Sakyi, Plange of course still unproven at this level). The other players are young but they are not without PL experience. As others have mentioned elsewhere if you get a decent full back on the right you do not need Ayew to help out as much as he currently has to and Olise offers so much more going forwards and can score goals which is what forwards are primarily there for.

We know we need new midfielders and Kelly/Clyne are superfluous other than as emergency cover. Milivojevic is past it and Ward should ultimately be held onto only as cover for a new right back. I agree you need experience but I also think you should move players on whilst they still have some value. I would maybe keep Ayew but the rest can go in my opinion and be improved upon by new signings. There is adequate experience in the rest of the team.

Yeah, that's a fair comment. Sorry wasn't disagreeing with everything...I had interpreted your previous post as wanting to fill the team with youngsters. Therefore was merely stating the importance of experience and older figures in the dressing room etc. But I think we sort of agree, so all good.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 10 Feb 22 10.08pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Of the attacking midfielders and outright attackers, Mateta, Edouard, Olise, Eze, Plange, Rak-Sakyi, are all young.

Benteke 31, Ayew 30, Zaha 29, Schlupp 29

Given the direction we are heading and a move towards a more youthful squad, why would we look to move any of the young ones on. We should sell Benteke, Schlupp and Ayew along with Milivojevic, Kelly, Clyne, this summer and free up salaries to bring in 2 midfielders, a centre half and right back.

If Zaha finally goes then a top replacement winger would also be a priority.


Of the 6 you are proposing to sell, I believe 4 (Ayew, Kelly, Clyne and Schlupp) are out of contract this summer so can simply be allowed to leave, although I can see the club keeping both Schlupp and Ayew. As to the other 2 you mentioned, we need to find someone who wants them and are prepared to pay the kind of wages we are paying. Quite frankly, I would be surprised if there'll be any takers for either Benteke or Milivojevic and so we will probably have them until their contracts expire next summer (2023).

 

sprites Flag Auckland 10 Feb 22 10.17pm

Originally posted by doombear


Of the 6 you are proposing to sell, I believe 4 (Ayew, Kelly, Clyne and Schlupp) are out of contract this summer so can simply be allowed to leave, although I can see the club keeping both Schlupp and Ayew. As to the other 2 you mentioned, we need to find someone who wants them and are prepared to pay the kind of wages we are paying. Quite frankly, I would be surprised if there'll be any takers for either Benteke or Milivojevic and so we will probably have them until their contracts expire next summer (2023).

There should definitely be takers. Playing in the right system, they've both still got a lot to offer. A newly promoted for example would benefit from Luka...and a team that puts lots of crosses in would see a lot of goals out of Benteke.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 10 Feb 22 10.21pm

Originally posted by sprites

There should definitely be takers. Playing in the right system, they've both still got a lot to offer. A newly promoted for example would benefit from Luka...and a team that puts lots of crosses in would see a lot of goals out of Benteke.


But can such clubs afford the wages?

 

sprites Flag Auckland 10 Feb 22 10.25pm

Originally posted by doombear


But can such clubs afford the wages?

That is the 90,000 question I suppose!

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 10 Feb 22 11.03pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Edouard has surely made more league appearances this season than all the players you’ve mentioned there - why on earth would he be the one moved on?
He’s also scored and created more than nearly all of them.

He’s averaging a goal every 200 mins in a brand new league, with a lot of minutes off the wing, and has just turned 24.. I think he’s one of the best prospects at the club, and whilst I agree he hasn’t quite cracked leading the line yet, his talent is there to see.

But he isn't in the first team

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

sprites Flag Auckland 10 Feb 22 11.49pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

But he isn't in the first team

He's very much part of the first team. Just because someone doesn't get picked to start one week, doesn't suddenly make them not part the team. In fact there's no such thing as a 'first team' in premier league football anymore. It's about the squad. Horses for courses etc.

 

aashman12 Flag 11 Feb 22 6.10pm

We're a graveyard for strikers, we should revert to Roy's 4222 and have wilf plus 1 up top,

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 12 Feb 22 6.11pm

Must be so frustrating for the lot of them knowing there's a position there for the taking, it is now becoming as much a problem as Ferguson.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 12 Feb 22 6.49pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

Must be so frustrating for the lot of them knowing there's a position there for the taking, it is now becoming as much a problem as Ferguson.

Mateta is by far the best CF, and he is only average, Edouard doesn't have a clue how to play CF, he may have been alright against the crap up in Scotland but he looks clueless now

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

aashman12 Flag 12 Feb 22 7.05pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Mateta is by far the best CF, and he is only average, Edouard doesn't have a clue how to play CF, he may have been alright against the crap up in Scotland but he looks clueless now

He's been much better playing off the left with mateta or big Ben in the middle, he's never a prem cf

 

PatrickA Flag London 12 Feb 22 7.35pm

Edouard did not play well today but even Messi would struggle playing against three centre backs with no support or teammates getting close to support him.
Vieira identified a major problem in the post match interview that Edouard had been left too isolated.
Edouard thrives on short passes into the penalty area so he can use his clever footwork to get a shot away or set up an opening.
I can’t recall more than a couple of these instances today and it’s valid to question whether the current system will enable him to flourish in the central role.
Vieira seems to have concluded that Benteke is not the answer as he has not recently even been used as an option when we’re struggling to threaten.
That leaves Mateta who is more mobile, runs in behind and seems to suit the current system at least in the lone central role currently employed.
However, the jury is out as to whether he has enough quality to be the solution.
On the limited occasions that Mateta and Edouard have featured as a pairing the team has looked more threatening.
This does not appear to fit in with the preferred 433 system.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 12 Feb 22 8.16pm

i think PVs lack of managerial experience is showing, he needs to learn fast

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 12 Feb 22 8.52pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

Edouard did not play well today but even Messi would struggle playing against three centre backs with no support or teammates getting close to support him.
Vieira identified a major problem in the post match interview that Edouard had been left too isolated.
Edouard thrives on short passes into the penalty area so he can use his clever footwork to get a shot away or set up an opening.
I can’t recall more than a couple of these instances today and it’s valid to question whether the current system will enable him to flourish in the central role.
Vieira seems to have concluded that Benteke is not the answer as he has not recently even been used as an option when we’re struggling to threaten.
That leaves Mateta who is more mobile, runs in behind and seems to suit the current system at least in the lone central role currently employed.
However, the jury is out as to whether he has enough quality to be the solution.
On the limited occasions that Mateta and Edouard have featured as a pairing the team has looked more threatening.
This does not appear to fit in with the preferred 433 system.

On the money mate, can’t disagree.

 

radicalsteve Flag ottawa 12 Feb 22 11.40pm

same here - we are not setting up to maximise our players strengths, particularly Edouard. I think Viera has to set up a consistent team for the current squad strengths, during this whole transition, as he evolves the squad to fit his required style and system. We still have a lot of "leftovers" that admittedly have to play for now, until we get the right blend in place. Many of them will not be here next season.

 

Page 2 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Centre Forwards