This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Willo
Like an interrogation in the 'Ipcress Files'. I have always maintained that officials do err from time to time but fallibility on occasions does not make them incompetent. Everyone knows that referees have a very tough job, made tougher by players' constant attempts to con them, but, as Spiderman said VAR has the advantage of repeats, different angles, slow motion, etc and yet still get it wrong.
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
If the laws were simplified, not constantly made more complicated and open to interpretation, VAR would not be necessary. Of course refs make mistakes but in the competitions free of VAR like the championship and our own U21 and 18s, it is a much better experience for everybody. Enjoyable the PL ain't, neither is it just. I'd rather have a bounty....
Also doesn't help that players like Grealish are praised for being clever after "winning" a penalty like he did today.
|
|
|
Originally posted by m/k mick
For my penny’s worth, for one weekend I absolutely love VAR, kept a smile on my face, masked a poor performance for us, they were good, but the sound of “who are ya “ being returned with interest, loved it It went our way this week for sure and yes the 'who are ya' was the highlight of the 'banter'
|
|
|
VAR will produce a level playing field, BUT it's run by idiots with no computer training
|
|
|
The interfering with play thing has always been something that irks me - clearly if an attacking player is on the field of play in the opponent's half then he is interfering with play, either directly to receive the ball or indirectly by running interference, giving the player with the ball an option or hoping for a rebound - in any event the defending team has to make efforts to nullify this attacking threat or option - To me there is some allowance that could be made where an attacker is laying on the floor with injury sustained from a previous attack, provided that player isn't laying in such a position to influence the attack, i.e inside the 6 yard box. Clarify the rules & get rid of the subjectivity of is he interfering with play or not - Originally posted by Willo
Even then there is the issue of Interfering or not interfering etc etc.
|
|
|
Originally posted by OneWayTicketToMars
I like the idea that VAR evens itself out for all the clubs. In essence, it has just alleviated the 'on the day' vitriol referees would be individually subject to. We now just have criticism and ire aimed at a collective of them safely tucked away somewhere for failing to do their job properly. The point of VAR was to remove subjectivity and make clearly evidenced, objective decisions. Them not even being able to do that with the technology has only reinforced general opinions of them and perhaps justified for many, their hate over the years. This weekend saw an inability to call offsides, understand what constitutes a red card and confusion as to whether an outfield player can use their arm to stop a shot destined for goal. Personally, I think we should have some type of 'Wheel of Fortune' spinning device to determine decisions. There'd probably be a greater percentage of correct calls plus far more entertainment.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
In essence, it has just alleviated the 'on the day' vitriol referees would be individually subject to. We now just have criticism and ire aimed at a collective of them safely tucked away somewhere for failing to do their job properly. The point of VAR was to remove subjectivity and make clearly evidenced, objective decisions. Them not even being able to do that with the technology has only reinforced general opinions of them and perhaps justified for many, their hate over the years. This weekend saw an inability to call offsides, understand what constitutes a red card and confusion as to whether an outfield player can use their arm to stop a shot destined for goal. Personally, I think we should have some type of 'Wheel of Fortune' spinning device to determine decisions. There'd probably be a greater percentage of correct calls plus far more entertainment. There has always been the "Clear and obvious error" factor, accordingly it has always been known that subjectivity would enter the equation.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
There has always been the "Clear and obvious error" factor, accordingly it has always been known that subjectivity would enter the equation. So offsides and handballs are subjective opinions now?
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
In essence, it has just alleviated the 'on the day' vitriol referees would be individually subject to. We now just have criticism and ire aimed at a collective of them safely tucked away somewhere for failing to do their job properly. The point of VAR was to remove subjectivity and make clearly evidenced, objective decisions. Them not even being able to do that with the technology has only reinforced general opinions of them and perhaps justified for many, their hate over the years. This weekend saw an inability to call offsides, understand what constitutes a red card and confusion as to whether an outfield player can use their arm to stop a shot destined for goal. Personally, I think we should have some type of 'Wheel of Fortune' spinning device to determine decisions. There'd probably be a greater percentage of correct calls plus far more entertainment. After every round of games, referees errors / judgement calls would be discussed. Now we have supplemented that with erroneous VAR calls. In a couple of the cases at the weekend, including the one in our game, citing '' human error '' is not enough. It was negligence.
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
So offsides and handballs are subjective opinions now? Subjectivity does not generally enter the equation in terms of offside decisions. Some handballs are clear-cut decisions but there can be some which are not and of course "Clear and obvious error" enters the equation.
|
|
|
I assume that's you casting your vote or 'thumb' on BBC Willo in response to whoever sent in this?
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
I assume that's you casting your vote or 'thumb' on BBC Willo in response to whoever sent in this? Heavens above! I don't wish to be associated with the Woke/PC BBC, I cannot abide that organisation. Have to pay a licence fee for that hogwash.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
There has always been the "Clear and obvious error" factor, accordingly it has always been known that subjectivity would enter the equation. But VAR has disallowed goals for offside on the basis of a shoulder or toe which were neither clear or obvious.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
But VAR has disallowed goals for offside on the basis of a shoulder or toe which were neither clear or obvious. Some calls are very marginal but trust is placed on the lines that are drawn from different angles. "Clear and obvious error" enters the equation in respect of a referee's decision with regards to a red card,penalty and mistaken identity. Edited by Willo (13 Feb 2023 1.03pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Some calls are very marginal but trust is placed on the lines that are drawn from different angles. "Clear and obvious error" enters the equation in respect of a referee's decision with regards to a red card,penalty and mistaken identity.
More than marginal. Particularly when the VAR official forgets to draw the lines. Can you imagine that happening in any other sport?
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.