This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
All you’re really concerned about is population (genetic) replacement, not population growth per se. Just say it - don’t mask it behind a debunked 50 year old theory. Anyway. The population could reach 100 billion. Any old unqualified figures can be banded about on a forum but I’d rather understandably go with current general consensus and probability - a scenario of around 12 billion before decline. There are far better ways to manage and distribute essential resources - if we don’t move towards a model that does, and fast, the population could level off now at 8bn and we’d still have serious issues because of our gluttonous, unthinking approach to resources. And on your constant topic of migration and immigration ‘Only 29% of people in the UK in 2022 said priority over jobs should go to local people, compared with 65% when the same question was asked in 2009.’ ‘The findings come as employers call for more migration to help fill more than 1m vacancies.’ The combination of a declining and aging population, in a mature economy, means unless you can somehow reduce the cost of having children and existing to a reasonable level or magically bring forward mass automation by 50 years you’re going to need significant immigration to keep the economy afloat. If you don’t do that everything declines anyway - so I’m afraid you’re either going to have to move to a small, self sustainable island community or deal with reality Edited by SW19 CPFC (23 Feb 2023 8.24am) I'm concerned by all aspects of population since they will affect my grandchildren. Nothing has been debunked. What you have is yet another highly politicised topic where the noisy Left claim that anything related to immigration is a far right wing conspiracy. My primary concern is obviously for England, and it won't take a population of 15 or 20 billion world wide to spell disaster for us. It amuses me when employers talk of needing immigrants for vacancies. The population is vastly bigger than it was 20 years ago and yet still not enough people? It's nonsense. We might have more non working old people but those coming here now will also get old. It is a cycle of population increase and need to service it. It is a self defeating principle. A growing population will alway need more and more commerse and servcies to support it and therefore it makes no sense to keep increasing population size. There are finite resources and infastructure which is much closer to collapse than most people want to think. A different model must be sought. You can spin it however you like but the evidence is everywhere. Our culture is being wrecked and our country is sinking under the demands of ever increasing numbers. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (23 Feb 2023 1.46pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
I'm concerned by all aspects of population since they will affect my grandchildren. Nothing has been debunked. What you have is yet another highly politicised topic where the noisy Left claim that anything related to immigration is a far right wing conspiracy. My primary concern is obviously for England, and it won't take a population of 15 or 20 billion world wide to spell disaster for us. It amuses me when employers talk of needing immigrants for vacancies. The population is vastly bigger than it was 20 years ago and yet still not enough people? It's nonsense. We might have more non working old people but those coming here now will also get old. It is a cycle of population increase and need to service it. It is a self defeating principle. A growing population will alway need more and more commerse and servcies to support it and therefore it makes no sense to keep increasing population size. There are finite resources and infastructure which is much closer to collapse than most people want to think. A different model must be sought. You can spin it however you like but the evidence is everywhere. Our culture is being wrecked and our country is sinking under the demands of ever increasing numbers. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (23 Feb 2023 1.46pm) You're demonstrably more concerned about the immigration lens on all issues, including this one. Pretty much every issue you contribute on is framed by immigration, or teed up to crowbar it in. Anyway The population bomb theory has recently been reappraised by... Paul Ehrlich. Who co-wrote it. It's almost as though things have changed since 1968... some great quotes actually 'We were worried then about the problems of feeding human society when there was three and a half billion people on the planet. Now we've got way over seven billion people.' 'The problem isn’t that there’s not enough to go around, says Ehrlich – the problem is that it’s not going around to everyone.' 'But it certainly is the case that there are a bunch of mistakes in The Population Bomb. Any scientist who is asked about his work 50 years before who still and particularly one it’s a broad thing, who still thinks exactly the same thing he thought 50 years before is a pretty weak scientist.' 'What was underestimated was the brilliance of many subsistence farmers who knew a lot more about what they could do on their land than a lot of the people at industrial agriculture.' Are we headed toward what nine or 10 billion people? More likely 11. Tell me anything social that you try and get done in a country like just the United States that will not be taken over by racists and used or by crazy economically give me more money people for their own purposes. On the other hand, what we did say and I've always said is that the last thing you want to try is coercion and I’ve never supported coercive policies. Now we haven't gotten where we need to be in terms of gender equity, but we’ve surely moved or maybe the most surprising thing is the speed with which people understood that it’s nobody else’s damn business how you enjoy sex as long as you're not hurting somebody. And that took place with us at almost blinding speed and of course some of the real dopes don't get it yet but they will. Needless to say a lot of that chimes with my previous post re. population, human ingenuity, there being more than enough to go around and greed and waste being more significant issues than overpopulation. On the worker shortage – well there are significant vacancies, so if it's nonsense, they'd be filled. People need to be qualified or skilled in the sectors that need workers. And they also need people willing to do so. Clearly we have a significant lack of both. Hence the fallback on migrant labour. Immigration does not result in a cycle of population increase if the birthrate is declining and you have an ageing population that is dying off. Which is where we are heading, and we're going to get there before automation fills the gap. When labour shortages start affecting quality of life in mature economies over the coming decades I'm pretty sure people will quite quickly become more pro-immigration. I'd agree that things are much closer to collapse than most realise, but there are many solutions to those problems, some that have not yet been thought of, and talk of 15-20 billion is, based on current consensus and observable fact is hyperbole. We can cope with a few more billion, but only if we manage things better. Population isn't the issue per se. It's how we manage and distribute our resources fairly and effectively. Our good friend Paul clearly agrees on that one.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
That poll does not ring true. I haven't bothered but there's a poll to counter or prove basically anything these days. Basically no one wants more immigration - it's around 9 out of 10. Immigrants don't want more immigration - it's not the race thing that it is made into. It's a quality of life decision. For some people it is perhaps race but you can always ask your black or asian friends if they want more immigration if you like. As for needing to bring people in to work: the unemployment figures for December were 1.27 million. You say there are over 1 million vacancies. I wonder what could possibly be done? That's a different poll though. This wasn't a poll specifically asking 'are you pro or against immigration', which is what you're arguing against. It was a poll asking would you prefer local jobs went to local people. Also worth noting local in this context could mean someone living in Kent and working in London, or someone living in France and migrating to work in Bolton. Also the quality of life issue will become very prescient in an economy declining because of an ageing population and growing workforce shortage. The only potential impact to quality of life when it comes to immigration is speed of change. It also very much depends where you live as to whether it is impacting you or not. It's not universally problematic. As you know. Manage it properly and you lessen that impact. But when it comes to the crunch, if it's the only thing that will save economies, the government will not hesitate to increase it.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
You're demonstrably more concerned about the immigration lens on all issues, including this one. Pretty much every issue you contribute on is framed by immigration, or teed up to crowbar it in. Anyway The population bomb theory has recently been reappraised by... Paul Ehrlich. Who co-wrote it. It's almost as though things have changed since 1968... some great quotes actually 'We were worried then about the problems of feeding human society when there was three and a half billion people on the planet. Now we've got way over seven billion people.' 'The problem isn’t that there’s not enough to go around, says Ehrlich – the problem is that it’s not going around to everyone.' 'But it certainly is the case that there are a bunch of mistakes in The Population Bomb. Any scientist who is asked about his work 50 years before who still and particularly one it’s a broad thing, who still thinks exactly the same thing he thought 50 years before is a pretty weak scientist.' 'What was underestimated was the brilliance of many subsistence farmers who knew a lot more about what they could do on their land than a lot of the people at industrial agriculture.' Are we headed toward what nine or 10 billion people? More likely 11. Tell me anything social that you try and get done in a country like just the United States that will not be taken over by racists and used or by crazy economically give me more money people for their own purposes. On the other hand, what we did say and I've always said is that the last thing you want to try is coercion and I’ve never supported coercive policies. Now we haven't gotten where we need to be in terms of gender equity, but we’ve surely moved or maybe the most surprising thing is the speed with which people understood that it’s nobody else’s damn business how you enjoy sex as long as you're not hurting somebody. And that took place with us at almost blinding speed and of course some of the real dopes don't get it yet but they will. Needless to say a lot of that chimes with my previous post re. population, human ingenuity, there being more than enough to go around and greed and waste being more significant issues than overpopulation. On the worker shortage – well there are significant vacancies, so if it's nonsense, they'd be filled. People need to be qualified or skilled in the sectors that need workers. And they also need people willing to do so. Clearly we have a significant lack of both. Hence the fallback on migrant labour. Immigration does not result in a cycle of population increase if the birthrate is declining and you have an ageing population that is dying off. Which is where we are heading, and we're going to get there before automation fills the gap. When labour shortages start affecting quality of life in mature economies over the coming decades I'm pretty sure people will quite quickly become more pro-immigration. I'd agree that things are much closer to collapse than most realise, but there are many solutions to those problems, some that have not yet been thought of, and talk of 15-20 billion is, based on current consensus and observable fact is hyperbole. We can cope with a few more billion, but only if we manage things better. Population isn't the issue per se. It's how we manage and distribute our resources fairly and effectively. Our good friend Paul clearly agrees on that one. Your quotation suggests the usual political bias. The world population is not decreasing. It wont start to decrease significantly for around 100 years and only if current trends continue. The continuous import of labour force cannot keep pace with the demand that rapidly increasing population brings. Think about it for a second. Scientists are already talking about food rationing. Does that ring any alarm bells?
|
|
|
Originally posted by martin2412
We had the ideal opportunity to have a good cull a couple of years ago, but no, some eejit invented a vaccine. Harold Shipman tried his best
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Your quotation suggests the usual political bias. The world population is not decreasing. It wont start to decrease significantly for around 100 years and only if current trends continue. The continuous import of labour force cannot keep pace with the demand that rapidly increasing population brings. Think about it for a second. Scientists are already talking about food rationing. Does that ring any alarm bells? You're knickering yourself. Those quotes are from one interview with Ehrlich, where the majority of the discussion is along those lines. Not much political bias, unless you're suggesting your boy himself is in fact a lefty activist, or he didn't in fact say those things at all? Strange. I also never said the global population was decreasing now. I said according to the data (UN) the birth rate is decreasing and that based on that data projections show the population will peak around 2080-2100 (60-80 years) then start to decrease, globally. It's also worth pointing out that the UK population is expected to grow by about 10 million between now and 2100. Not 30m+. It only grew by around 3m in the last decade, use that for reference if you're intent on making up your own trends. You prefer to ignore the consensus and go for the highest figure you can get away with to fit your narrative. Amusingly you're also seemingly making your own conclusions that because population has increased by 10m in 30 years since 1993, it will do so exponentially into the future. That's not how you make considered projections – I'm not a statistician but even I know that's pretty dumb. So I'll say it for a third time – the issue appears not to be population size or growth based on todays projections and declining global birth rates. The issue is fair and even distribution of resources, efficiency (reduction of waste, which in some countries is near 50%, madness) and innovation about food production, water conservation and use, and so on. This would and should be aconsideration at 100million, 3billion, 8billion... thoughtless consumption is not and has never been the right answer. Food rationing would not need to be considered if we were smarter about how we consume and what we actually need to live comfortable lives, rather than out and out gluttony. To quote da bomb himself once again... 'The problem isn’t that there’s not enough to go around, says Ehrlich – the problem is that it’s not going around to everyone.' I think you have a pre-conceived narrative here, as per usual, and anything else regardless of truth or probability is dismissed as 'political' as it doesn't suit your narrative. As for 'ideological drones' – I'm literally quoting the guy who co-wrote da bomb and he's objectively countering his own work (quite rightly, as things have changed somewhat since the 1970s). I'm inclined to go with him and the community consensus more than your dated and dogmatic ramblings. if the projections consensus shifted to say the UK will be 30m larger by 2100 and the global population will hit 20bn, then I'd follow the science and change my view accordingly, and you'd be right. But it doesn't... and you're not. Clearly the ideological droning on this specific topic is yours, and yours alone. Edited by SW19 CPFC (23 Feb 2023 6.11pm)
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
You're knickering yourself. Those quotes are from one interview with Ehrlich, where the majority of the discussion is along those lines. Not much political bias, unless you're suggesting your boy himself is in fact a lefty activist, or he didn't in fact say those things at all? Strange. I also never said the global population was decreasing now. I said according to the data (UN) the birth rate is decreasing and that based on that data projections show the population will peak around 2080-2100 (60-80 years) then start to decrease, globally. It's also worth pointing out that the UK population is expected to grow by about 10 million between now and 2100. Not 30m+. It only grew by around 3m in the last decade, use that for reference if you're intent on making up your own trends. You prefer to ignore the consensus and go for the highest figure you can get away with to fit your narrative. Amusingly you're also seemingly making your own conclusions that because population has increased by 10m in 30 years since 1993, it will do so exponentially into the future. That's not how you make considered projections – I'm not a statistician but even I know that's pretty dumb. So I'll say it for a third time – the issue appears not to be population size or growth based on todays projections and declining global birth rates. The issue is fair and even distribution of resources, efficiency (reduction of waste, which in some countries is near 50%, madness) and innovation about food production, water conservation and use, and so on. This would and should be aconsideration at 100million, 3billion, 8billion... thoughtless consumption is not and has never been the right answer. Food rationing would not need to be considered if we were smarter about how we consume and what we actually need to live comfortable lives, rather than out and out gluttony. To quote da bomb himself once again... 'The problem isn’t that there’s not enough to go around, says Ehrlich – the problem is that it’s not going around to everyone.' I think you have a pre-conceived narrative here, as per usual, and anything else regardless of truth or probability is dismissed as 'political' as it doesn't suit your narrative. As for 'ideological drones' – I'm literally quoting the guy who co-wrote da bomb and he's objectively countering his own work (quite rightly, as things have changed somewhat since the 1970s). I'm inclined to go with him and the community consensus more than your dated and dogmatic ramblings. if the projections consensus shifted to say the UK will be 30m larger by 2100 and the global population will hit 20bn, then I'd follow the science and change my view accordingly, and you'd be right. But it doesn't... and you're not. Clearly the ideological droning on this specific topic is yours, and yours alone. Edited by SW19 CPFC (23 Feb 2023 6.11pm) Everybody knows there is not an even distribution of resources and that is good for the likes of us. If you think that reducing our share of the pot is a good idea then it explains your thinking very neatly. And I'd like an explanation of how our population will only rise by 10 million in 80 years when it has grow by 10 million in the last thirty because of immigration. That sounds like bulls*** to me, especially when the rate of immigration has been growing since the 1950s. Use your logic rather than looking it up on google.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Everybody knows there is not an even distribution of resources and that is good for the likes of us. If you think that reducing our share of the pot is a good idea then it explains your thinking very neatly. And I'd like an explanation of how our population will only rise by 10 million in 80 years when it has grow by 10 million in the last thirty because of immigration. That sounds like bulls*** to me, especially when the rate of immigration has been growing since the 1950s. Use your logic rather than looking it up on google.
'That is good for the likes of us' – it won't be when those resources run out, not because of population expansion, but because of inefficiency, misuse and gluttony. The amount of choice and cheap food we have is firstly unsustainable and secondly entirely unnecessary. Coupled with 50% wastage rate it's pretty obvious that the way we view and use resources such as food could be vastly improved, all without needing to 'give away our share of the pot' to the foreigns. In fact, you could probably do that just by reducing waste. We don't need to be able to buy light up gin bottles and 300 different types of sausages. Overconsumption needs to be viewed as borrowing from the future, rather than gratifying the rapacious wants of the now. 'And I'd like an explanation' – maybe look into statistical and mathematical best practice first, then the historical data, then the projected data, and then the hypotheses behind the reasoning for those projections. Neither of us are specialists in that area – so in a debate like this qualified, specialist research carries significantly more weight than hackneyed interpretations of statistics presented as fact, such as this doozy 'Our population grew 10 million over the last 30 years. Therefore I must conclude that it will grow by at least another 30 million over the next 80.' Now I'm no expert (hence why I'm referencing experts as the basis for my stance) but even to me that makes little sense, simply based on the amount of things it ignores, no1 being statistical best practice. But yeah sure, 'logic' etc. What's logical is the scientific/statistical consensus. What would also be logical is if that changed to project 30m growth instead of 10m due to well researched and proven challenge to the accepted thinking. Y'know, science Christ. I do hope you're not in education
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
My son lives near Clapham Junction, all the local supermarkets have plenty of everything Do go on
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
'That is good for the likes of us' – it won't be when those resources run out, not because of population expansion, but because of inefficiency, misuse and gluttony. The amount of choice and cheap food we have is firstly unsustainable and secondly entirely unnecessary. Coupled with 50% wastage rate it's pretty obvious that the way we view and use resources such as food could be vastly improved, all without needing to 'give away our share of the pot' to the foreigns. In fact, you could probably do that just by reducing waste. We don't need to be able to buy light up gin bottles and 300 different types of sausages. Overconsumption needs to be viewed as borrowing from the future, rather than gratifying the rapacious wants of the now. 'And I'd like an explanation' – maybe look into statistical and mathematical best practice first, then the historical data, then the projected data, and then the hypotheses behind the reasoning for those projections. Neither of us are specialists in that area – so in a debate like this qualified, specialist research carries significantly more weight than hackneyed interpretations of statistics presented as fact, such as this doozy 'Our population grew 10 million over the last 30 years. Therefore I must conclude that it will grow by at least another 30 million over the next 80.' Now I'm no expert (hence why I'm referencing experts as the basis for my stance) but even to me that makes little sense, simply based on the amount of things it ignores, no1 being statistical best practice. But yeah sure, 'logic' etc. What's logical is the scientific/statistical consensus. What would also be logical is if that changed to project 30m growth instead of 10m due to well researched and proven challenge to the accepted thinking. Y'know, science Christ. I do hope you're not in education We have agreed that too much food is wasted. Wheter that can be rectified significantly is another question. Food is only one resource. We haven't covered energy, water, minerals, metal and a host of others, all of which will become an issue. I would love to know why you or anybody thinks that a population of 95/100 million is unlikely by 2100. The current rate of population increase suggests a rise of 27.5 million, but the rate of immigration is going up. That suggests an acceleration of population increase and a rise in birthrate. Surely that is not too difficuly for you . What factors do you think will cause such a rapid reversal of this trend that projections of just 10 million are likely? What do the 'specialists' say? I'm keen to know. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (24 Feb 2023 1.16pm)
|
|
|
I can't find any turnips to cherish. I'll just have to make do with truffles.
|
|
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
My son lives near Clapham Junction, all the local supermarkets have plenty of everything My local co op seemed to have plenty as well. The cynic in me feels this could be the old ‘report the worst case’ it sells new and gets clicks. Almost like the financial crisis which appears strange with how busy the roads and shops are. Maybe it’s political to have a pop at the tories
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
My local co op seemed to have plenty as well. The cynic in me feels this could be the old ‘report the worst case’ it sells new and gets clicks. Almost like the financial crisis which appears strange with how busy the roads and shops are. Maybe it’s political to have a pop at the tories Plenty of everything here but, of course, as Maple would point out, I don’t live in the Metropolis
|
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Do go on I have no idea what that means
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance. |
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
I can't find any turnips to cherish. I'll just have to make do with truffles.
Where I live my beloved turnips and swedes are luxury goods only occasionally available in M and S
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Do go on The reason given in the supermarkets in the EU is that the Turkey/Syria earthquake has diminished supply. Plus something about Spain - drought in Southern Europe/Mediterranean. Couldn't get peppers or tomatoes (there was one sad pack of peppers and expensive tomatoes) yesterday. Also barely any chicken - much more expensive, and not many eggs. Bird flu and salmonella - almost a perfect storm with the Ukraine grain too.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.