You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Facts
November 16 2026 3.01am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Facts


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 09 Apr 23 7.50pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

Mr Hodgson is coming to the end of his managerial time and PV is/was beginning.

Vieira’s been managing for 10 years now!!

 

derfes Flag upper norwood 09 Apr 23 7.54pm

Originally posted by monkey

Vieira’s been managing for 10 years now!!

if that is what 10 years of managerial experience gets you , no wonder parish wanted someone with at least 50.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 09 Apr 23 8.05pm

Originally posted by Painter

I dont think Parish will be asking Vieira to return and help out, like he has with Roy.

It's all about experience, why should Roy's time in football not be shared on the touchline with Viera.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 09 Apr 23 9.27pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

It's all about experience, why should Roy's time in football not be shared on the touchline with Viera.

Who is Viera?

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 09 Apr 23 10.11pm

There were too many things stacking up against Vieira statistically as well as results and performances in the end.

Too much was made of the difficult run of fixtures in one of the most open Premier League seasons.

The difference in the last two games has been stark and points heavily to overly prescriptive coaching in possession under PV.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 09 Apr 23 10.14pm

One other fact is that Roy has played people in their natural and therefore best positions whereas Vieira was constantly tinkering with square pegs in round holes so-to-speak.

 

Ali_Campbell Flag New Addington 09 Apr 23 10.22pm

The fixtures was tough for Viara, however 1 win in 15/16 games in a results business is always a concern. I was shocked to hear he got the boot, but no one can deny that in hindsight it was the right call. If we can all agree on one thing, the form in Eze alone because he was a bit part player under Viara.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 09 Apr 23 10.38pm

It was always dubious that Vieira got so much praise for adapting our style and integrating new players.

Another more realistic way of looking at it is that Vieira was afforded a transfer kitty that Roy only dreamed of which improved the potential of the team considerably. With that luxury, Vieira turned a team of mostly talented players into a disillusioned mess who couldn't even create a chance in the end.

Roy comes back, and he suddenly gets a team full of exciting players to do what they are capable of.

When you drop one of the most exciting players in the league to the bench when you can't win a game to save your life, you know it's time to go. Vieira has never been a successful coach, and he will be consigned to the same bin as Frank Lampard, Brian Robson and all the other quality players who didn't make good managers.

We have wasted this season.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (10 Apr 2023 4.03pm)

 

Oddball2021 Flag Adelaide 10 Apr 23 2.11am

oops

Edited by Oddball2021 (10 Apr 2023 2.20am)

 

Oddball2021 Flag Adelaide 10 Apr 23 2.20am


Edited by Oddball2021 (10 Apr 2023 4.51am)

 

Brasilian Eagle Flag Londres 10 Apr 23 5.07am

Originally posted by Painter

Who is Viera?

I don't know but perhaps we will meet again some sunny day!

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 11 Apr 23 8.35am

Originally posted by Ali_Campbell

The fixtures was tough for Viara, however 1 win in 15/16 games in a results business is always a concern. I was shocked to hear he got the boot, but no one can deny that in hindsight it was the right call. If we can all agree on one thing, the form in Eze alone because he was a bit part player under Viara.

..and Jeffrey Schlupp he's been fantastic.

 

Croydon-Trucker Flag 11 Apr 23 8.44am

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

1. Roy gets the best out of what he has, which is plenty.
2. PV gets the worst out of what he has, which was plenty
3. Their is no lack of investment, player wise. 130m spent.
4. Eze is a potential world class player, and has to have a free role
5. Roy will start next season as manager, if he wants too
6. We are staying up

Yes agree with everything there Lanzo, that and we are playing better as a team without Wilf, is it coincidence i dont know ! We scored 1 in the last 5 under PV and 7 in the last 2 under Roy. Eze is playing with a big fat smile on his face again . Its not a good advertisement for PV.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 11 Apr 23 8.47am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

It was always dubious that Vieira got so much praise for adapting our style and integrating new players.

Another more realistic way of looking at it is that Vieira was afforded a transfer kitty that Roy only dreamed of which improved the potential of the team considerably. With that luxury, Vieira turned a team of mostly talented players into a disillusioned mess who couldn't even create a chance in the end.

Roy comes back, and he suddenly gets a team full of exciting players to do what they are capable of.

When you drop one of the most exciting players in the league to the bench when you can't win a game to save your life, you know it's time to go. Vieira has never been a successful coach, and he will be consigned to the same bin as Frank Lampard, Brian Robson and all the other quality players who didn't make good managers.

We have wasted this season.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (10 Apr 2023 4.03pm)

But his first season was lovely. In hindsight I wish someone like Everton had bought out his contract over the summer.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 11 Apr 23 9.34am

I was pro-Vieira but ultimately results dictated that a change had to be made. And I agree, he didn't have the managerial experience to get the most of the resources available to him.

There's an open question as to whether he could have turned it around after we completed that tough run of fixtures, but clearly the majority of the ownership thought not.

To bring some perspective into this, Roy's appointment was not greeted with unanimous enthusiasm. I'm sure most people thought ( well, I did ) it was a return to the pragmatic grinding out of points performances that we had previously under him.

Instead we have had two performances of real attacking intent. And recovered from going behind in both games, demonstrating character from the players.

Roy knows the job is far from being completed as he said in his post match interview. Both Leicester and Leeds showed their own lack of character and confidence, and it was good to see a Palace team take full advantage.

As for next season, a bit like the Zaha situation, we need to prepare for life without Roy coming to the rescue. The recruitment was shambolic last time, let's hope we see an improvement this time around.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 11 Apr 23 11.12am

There's a serious amount of PV hate on this thread.
Regardless of transfers made, he gave us a great season last season. which you have to give him credit for.

He made us an exciting watch, and got them playing nice football. It all went wrong this season. I think thats down to losing CG and JimmyMac, and attempting to use different players to fill holes they were not suited for.

His greatest failing was sticking to his methods, rather than finding a system that suited our (remaining) players. 'Clueless' is A term I've read on here a fair bit. I think he was more Stubborn than Clueless.

I liked PV, but he was showing his failings, not just through the widely accepted run of 10 tough games but on those games before it, and those games like Villa which were games that we should have shown more. The chances created/shots on target stat was pretty damning in the end.
For all of his failings this year, please don't forget the good he did for us.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Uphill Flag Bedford 11 Apr 23 11.26am

Vieira was not clueless at all but where he failed was in an inability to motivate a good bunch of players.

Their morale was notably declining and when Leicester took the lead I doubt if he would have got them to recover, after all it was a close run thing in the end.

The benefit was to morale and self-belief particularly to Schlupp, Ayew and Eze.

Plus he recognised that playing Eze in a free role released his talents.

And above all, he got Jordan Ayew to smile - a rare achievement!

 


Man and boy Palace since my first game in 1948 sitting on my dad's shoulders

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 11 Apr 23 11.41am

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

There's a serious amount of PV hate on this thread.
Regardless of transfers made, he gave us a great season last season. which you have to give him credit for.

He made us an exciting watch, and got them playing nice football. It all went wrong this season. I think thats down to losing CG and JimmyMac, and attempting to use different players to fill holes they were not suited for.

His greatest failing was sticking to his methods, rather than finding a system that suited our (remaining) players. 'Clueless' is A term I've read on here a fair bit. I think he was more Stubborn than Clueless.

I liked PV, but he was showing his failings, not just through the widely accepted run of 10 tough games but on those games before it, and those games like Villa which were games that we should have shown more. The chances created/shots on target stat was pretty damning in the end.
For all of his failings this year, please don't forget the good he did for us.

Like what?

We got 4 more points than Roy did the previous season, but with better players.

We were briefly more entertaining, but the performances got slowly worse.
We had a tough run of games, but it was not the results that got him sacked, but rather the nature of our defeats. We were totally incapable of creating chances, never mind scoring.
There is no way that a chairman is going to look at that and take a risk on sticking with Vieira.

I wonder if the likes of Garth Crooks and Ian Wright would have criticised his sacking if he had been say Roy Hodgson.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (11 Apr 2023 11.42am)

 

Croydon-Trucker Flag 11 Apr 23 11.52am

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

There's a serious amount of PV hate on this thread.
Regardless of transfers made, he gave us a great season last season. which you have to give him credit for.

He made us an exciting watch, and got them playing nice football. It all went wrong this season. I think thats down to losing CG and JimmyMac, and attempting to use different players to fill holes they were not suited for.

His greatest failing was sticking to his methods, rather than finding a system that suited our (remaining) players. 'Clueless' is A term I've read on here a fair bit. I think he was more Stubborn than Clueless.

I liked PV, but he was showing his failings, not just through the widely accepted run of 10 tough games but on those games before it, and those games like Villa which were games that we should have shown more. The chances created/shots on target stat was pretty damning in the end.
For all of his failings this year, please don't forget the good he did for us.

I dont think there is any hate for him Badger, I think it more along the lines of he was just not up to the task . I quiet like him , he comes across as a nice guy , lets face it anyone that can kick Roy Keane is ok in my book . The stats dont lie though , I also think for such a tough player the softly softly approach didnt suit .

 

PatrickA Flag London 11 Apr 23 12.09pm

I don't recall much criticism of PV prior to the World Cup.
At that stage a top 10 finish looked realistic and we hoped for a Mcarthur return and possible additions in the January window.

However,the subsequent results were shocking and although we remained competitive we rarely looked like troubling the opposition let alone scoring goals.

The players have to take some responsibility for the decline of course, but PV showed little evidence of being able to turn it around.

By and large the same players have played in the last couple of games, although there have been enhanced roles for Eze and Edouard.
We're playing 10 yards further forward with nore confidence and Eze is now playing closer to Olise which has allowed them both to flourish.
When considering the upturn in form fair to factor in the poor opposition in the last two games, but I somehow doubt we had as many shots in games under PV even when playing well.
The new training regime is bearing dividends.

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Facts