You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are we boring and does it matter?
November 16 2026 2.28am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Are we boring and does it matter?


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 29 Nov 23 1.36pm

Look at the teams outside the top 4 or 5, i dont see anyone playing "entertaining" football, if Andersen, Guehi, Doucoure, Eze and Olise were all fit then we would be playing like we finished last season, all five of them would get into any team, Except maybe Man City, but we have had all 5 playing together 49 minutes all season, and you cant expect their standings to be nothing but average, get real FFS

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 29 Nov 23 1.45pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

I think perhaps the problem is that Vieira's first season gave us a glimpse of how well a small club like us can perform. More confident and braver in possession, playing with a more positive mindset, etc. In his second season he seemed to lose his courage of convictions and he and the team went into its shell. Thn Roy came in only needing a handful of points to secure safety, promptly got them against lesser opposition and we could relax and let our forward players have some fun.

Personally I don't think Roy changes his approach with the injuries, I just think when the creative players are out it shows his lack of tactics for the forward areas. Also, when you aren't scoring maybe you need to take a risk and play the £20m forward the club signed, or the athletic £10m signing from the Bundesliga. It might not work, but you can't argue there are no options, he's just not using them. Alternatively you change the shape, like going 3-5-2. I don't think we need to be boring, I just think we have a manager who doesn't care about performances, just results, which is fair enough if you just want to watch the Vidiprinter.

I Agree that RH could perhaps try other options when the tried and tested options are out - but he has given people like Franca, JRS and Ahamada time on the pitch, and they haven't impressed him.
My point really was that the gist of that statement was that we are simply treading water where in reality we've tried to push on, failed, then tried again and again failed. Long term, we're not actively out to stay mid table, but it's nice that that is our resting position.
What concerns me is that this cannot continue - RH cannot continue to be reemployed to steady the ship. We need to understand why those attempts failed.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 29 Nov 23 2.12pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Look at the teams outside the top 4 or 5, i dont see anyone playing "entertaining" football, if Andersen, Guehi, Doucoure, Eze and Olise were all fit then we would be playing like we finished last season, all five of them would get into any team, Except maybe Man City, but we have had all 5 playing together 49 minutes all season, and you cant expect their standings to be nothing but average, get real FFS

Agree with this. Problem atm is we aren’t boring enough at the wrong end of the pitch…

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 29 Nov 23 2.22pm

I have spoken to a supporter of a certain vintage who is unlikely to be mistaken for a sunbeam and could be filled under "Moaning Minnie".I am NOT in his league in terms of pessimism !

This chap bellowed that he would like the team to be relegated, citing that he has had enough of mid-table mediocrity and witnessing only a clutch of Home wins each season.He added that season-on-season he is devoid of any entertainment whatsoever and it would be nice if we actually emerged victorious in more games without of course being subjected to VAR.

Beetroot-gilled he continued that he is fed-up with the team "Treading water" in the PL season-on-season and it would be really nice to see us on the crest of a wave.

This gentleman is a fusty old eccentric.

Edited by Willo (29 Nov 2023 2.33pm)

 

taylors lovechild Flag 29 Nov 23 2.44pm

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

I Agree that RH could perhaps try other options when the tried and tested options are out - but he has given people like Franca, JRS and Ahamada time on the pitch, and they haven't impressed him.
My point really was that the gist of that statement was that we are simply treading water where in reality we've tried to push on, failed, then tried again and again failed. Long term, we're not actively out to stay mid table, but it's nice that that is our resting position.
What concerns me is that this cannot continue - RH cannot continue to be reemployed to steady the ship. We need to understand why those attempts failed.

Personally I struggle to see how a club our size pushes on in terms of finishing much higher up the table. Instead I'm more concerned about how do we retain a safe position in the PL but while playing a brand of football that doesn't send you into a coma. If Eze and Olise had been fit all season I probably wouldn't be so down about things and we'd probably have a few more points. Maybe I'm being hard on Roy. With Eze out I'd just like to see him stick Franca in from the start and try and lift the mood. He'll make mistakes, but he might at least add some flair and right now we could really do with that.

 

Den1923 Flag 29 Nov 23 2.48pm

from my viewpoint, success for me is the fact that we have been in the EPL for 11 seasons now and during that time we have enjoyed some of the best teams entertaining us and sometimes we win. Compare that with playing in Division 4 (we were founder members) or the old 3rd Division (South) and you would very much appreciate what we have today. The stadium is full and the club has a much higher profile than those dizzy days of yesteryear. There is no way I want to be relegated and therefore I can still dream that one day we may even finish in the top four and if we don't then providing we continue as we are, then we will still have the best teams and players coming to Selhurst for us all to enjoy!

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 29 Nov 23 3.01pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

Personally I struggle to see how a club our size pushes on in terms of finishing much higher up the table. Instead I'm more concerned about how do we retain a safe position in the PL but while playing a brand of football that doesn't send you into a coma. If Eze and Olise had been fit all season I probably wouldn't be so down about things and we'd probably have a few more points. Maybe I'm being hard on Roy. With Eze out I'd just like to see him stick Franca in from the start and try and lift the mood. He'll make mistakes, but he might at least add some flair and right now we could really do with that.

I dont think anyone would disagree with that ,after the recent run we could all do with a lift . £20M has got to buy something worth watching

 

Painter Flag Croydon 29 Nov 23 3.27pm

Originally posted by MrRobbo


On a side note, my best mate is a ManC fan, had a season ticket for about 20 years, but stopped going about 4 years ago. Why? Its boring when you win every week, and expect to be winning every game 4-0.

Its all relative.

This sums it up perfectly. Fans get bored, if the result is almost a forgone conclusion. It’s the jeopardy of the result is what keeps fan’s interest, the hope the team will get better.

So, if being financially reliant on an oil state and winning everything gets boring, is the hope of beating the odds financially and developing your own players boring as well?

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 29 Nov 23 3.53pm

When we go out of the cup in January, already out of the first one, and we're about 16th is when I start doing other things at the weekend. I get the occasional surprise on either Sky Sports News or MOTD. I followed far more closely when we were championship.
VAR another factor to endure that doesn't help.

A cup run and we'd take the crap league form, is my main point.

 


Red and Blue Army!

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 29 Nov 23 4.01pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

Personally I struggle to see how a club our size pushes on in terms of finishing much higher up the table. Instead I'm more concerned about how do we retain a safe position in the PL but while playing a brand of football that doesn't send you into a coma. If Eze and Olise had been fit all season I probably wouldn't be so down about things and we'd probably have a few more points. Maybe I'm being hard on Roy. With Eze out I'd just like to see him stick Franca in from the start and try and lift the mood. He'll make mistakes, but he might at least add some flair and right now we could really do with that.

I too would like to see Franca, but we should trust Roy that he's not ready, or he'll be in. He's only been in the country a few months, is very young and is coming back from injury. Give him time. Seem to think JRS is closer to the first team, but now Olise is back, not sure what position he'll play in.....

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 29 Nov 23 8.19pm

I've reached the stage where I find it all pointless particularly Man City, Chelsea, VAR, Saudi, adult obsession with boring sanitised youth football and academies, endless analysis and punditry and talk about money.

The game's at the point where it's literally eating itself.

The absolute worst is going to a live game and not being able to celebrate a goal which was always going to be the outcome of VAR whatever the great footballing brains thought.

I've not been to so many this season although I've kept my season ticket.

Mentions of Brighton being the model but I went last season with a friend and sat in the home end. We had to leave before the end because of the gridlock outside if you don't - so a s*** matchday experience and half the home end was empty despite a narrow win against their bitter rivals. Fvcking rubbish.

Edited by Rachid Rachid Rachid (29 Nov 2023 9.18pm)

 

Glazier#1 Flag 29 Nov 23 9.31pm

I'm enjoying every season.

There's always drama with Palace, it seems: we never seem to do the expected, or very rarely.

One time we'll lose to a team that never wins, then win completely out of the blue in a 'no-win' game. You just never know.

It's never dull, as far as I'm concerned.

 

martin2412 Flag Living The Dream 29 Nov 23 10.48pm

This is what will happen in our next home game against Bournemouth:

0-0 at half time.
Bournemouth score after running us ragged early in the second half.
Palace start playing now we're behind.
Edouard gets replaced by Mateta after 64 minutes.
Palace are awarded a penalty after VAR takes 6 minutes to assess a foul and then sends the ref to the screen.
Palace score.
Roy immediately takes off Schlupp and replaces him with Chris Richards to protect what we've got.
Reidewald come on in the 91st minute for Ayew, and Palace fall back, inviting Bournemouth to attack.
Theres 10 minutes of added time for us to defend.
Whistle goes, it's a draw.
Roy's delighted with a good point against a very good side.
Attendance 24,863.

Predictable ? Boring ? Ain't it just.

You can count the amount of home games I've missed on one hand over the last 15 years, but even I'm starting to think it's becoming a chore.

It needs shaking up.

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 29 Nov 23 11.31pm

Originally posted by Den1923

from my viewpoint, success for me is the fact that we have been in the EPL for 11 seasons now and during that time we have enjoyed some of the best teams entertaining us and sometimes we win. Compare that with playing in Division 4 (we were founder members) or the old 3rd Division (South) and you would very much appreciate what we have today. The stadium is full and the club has a much higher profile than those dizzy days of yesteryear. There is no way I want to be relegated and therefore I can still dream that one day we may even finish in the top four and if we don't then providing we continue as we are, then we will still have the best teams and players coming to Selhurst for us all to enjoy!

No need to dream! We did that already.

[Link] (wiki)

Then, fill your boots with [Link]

Although that was before Premier League (NOT EPL btw).

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 30 Nov 23 10.10am

I think it matters significantly.

Exciting football lifts the crowd which, in turn, gives the team a boost. We're 16th in the Premier League home table this season so need an edge there somehow.

It also makes us more appealing to potential signings. If we want to sign the next Eze or Olise, I'd say they'll be far more likely to join a club who play attractive football rather than the current 35% possession stodge.

People keep on about how do we improve the team further. We all know our only option is to be brave, sell and reinvest.

You'll hate this but I think if we could get somewhere in the region of £110-120m in total for Eze and Guehi this summer, particularly given Eze's injury record, and can reinvest it in 4/5 young £20m players, then that is how we end up with a stronger overall team / squad.

It also sends a message to potential signings that if they join us, we won't block their path going forwards, making it more likely.

Of course this also requires a manager who isn't afraid to trust young players so, for the time being, is moot.

Edited by Canterbury Palace (30 Nov 2023 10.11am)

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

Croydon-Trucker Flag 30 Nov 23 10.28am

Originally posted by martin2412

This is what will happen in our next home game against Bournemouth:

0-0 at half time.
Bournemouth score after running us ragged early in the second half.
Palace start playing now we're behind.
Edouard gets replaced by Mateta after 64 minutes.
Palace are awarded a penalty after VAR takes 6 minutes to assess a foul and then sends the ref to the screen.
Palace score.
Roy immediately takes off Schlupp and replaces him with Chris Richards to protect what we've got.
Reidewald come on in the 91st minute for Ayew, and Palace fall back, inviting Bournemouth to attack.
Theres 10 minutes of added time for us to defend.
Whistle goes, it's a draw.
Roy's delighted with a good point against a very good side.
Attendance 24,863.

Predictable ? Boring ? Ain't it just.

You can count the amount of home games I've missed on one hand over the last 15 years, but even I'm starting to think it's becoming a chore.

It needs shaking up.

Wow , do you have next weeks Euro millions numbers by any chance

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 30 Nov 23 10.54am

My Chelsea supporting brother in law was slagging brentford off recently after they won 2-0 at the bridge. He was giving it the old park the bus and anti football bollocks. Without saying it, he was also having a little dig at us. So obviously I reminded him the likes of us and Brentford can’t compete with a billion pound in spending and have to compensate. If Brentford had gone all out attacking football and tried to be more entertaining even this average Chelsea team would’ve wiped the floor with them. I doubt Brentford fans came away from the bridge thinking blimey that was a boring performance

I also reminded him that Mourinho didn’t exactly play total football at Chelsea, but it was effective and they were winners, obviously Chelsea fans didn’t care because they were winning every week

So basically no one gives a monkeys about the style of play as long as you’re winning, we wiped the floor with Leeds up there last season, but at the time before the game we would’ve taken a dull 0-1 win.

We are boring a lot of the time under Roy and it can be frustrating when we watch the team sitting back and showing teams too much respect, but if we do get a result, do we care? Course we don’t, it’s only a problem if we’re boring, sit back and still end up losing

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 30 Nov 23 11.03am

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Look at the teams outside the top 4 or 5, i dont see anyone playing "entertaining" football, if Andersen, Guehi, Doucoure, Eze and Olise were all fit then we would be playing like we finished last season, all five of them would get into any team, Except maybe Man City, but we have had all 5 playing together 49 minutes all season, and you cant expect their standings to be nothing but average, get real FFS

not sure i agree. Newcastle and Brighton are 7th and 8th and both have been very entertaining this season.

When we drew 0.0 recently with both Forest and Fulham, both looked far more attack minded than we did and we were a little lucky to get a point from both games.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 30 Nov 23 11.33am

Originally posted by monkey

We are boring a lot of the time under Roy and it can be frustrating when we watch the team sitting back and showing teams too much respect, but if we do get a result, do we care? Course we don’t, it’s only a problem if we’re boring, sit back and still end up losing

In the final 18 months of Roy's last tenure even when we won it often didn't feel like it so dire was the football. Most people had had enough and so Roy left. Given on average we only win about a third of our games that problem is always likely to raise its ugly head.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 30 Nov 23 12.02pm

I could only get so far into the article before it asked to log in, so I can only go on what I read up to then.
What the article omitted to mention is that to make the league look genuinely competitive, it must have 20 teams in it, despite that is fixed in favour of Saudi billions and dodgy VAR referees.
17 teams are there to make up the numbers, with a little carrot dangling promising Euro competition if one is good.
Entertainment? What's that? It's all about survival by any means necessary to be part of the PL club. Roy knows the score.

 

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are we boring and does it matter?