You are here: Home > Message Board > Gold Talk > Only A Five-Year Ban For Yorke Abuse?
November 19 2026 5.32pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Only A Five-Year Ban For Yorke Abuse?


Page 2 of 16 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Matt_Hep Flag Block B 24 Nov 04 6.02pm

Quote Jake d'Eagle at 24 Nov 2004 6:00pm


If I was having the same go at Earnshaw, would it racist ??


Only if you were commenting on his colour.

Everyone is so confused about racial issues, I don't think the government ever did anything to properly educate people. There are millions of misconceptions.

 

Jake d'Eagle Flag in the section labelled 'shirts', ... 24 Nov 04 6.06pm

so saying he's a black obnoxious welsh dwarf is unacceptable, but if I'm not making reference to his colour, that's OK ?

WHY ?

None of it (except the Welsh bit) is libellous, and black is a descriptive term, not a qualitative one.

Edited by Jake d'Eagle (24 Nov 2004 6:07pm)

 


Put a Glide in your Stride, and Dip in your Hip,
Come on over to the Mothership, baby

[Link] Transformation is Happening


robbo Flag Coventry 24 Nov 04 6.18pm

people are getting off the subject i think ..
nothing would have happened to him and like alot of others that do it every satiurday if it wasn't for the idiots in spain
if that makes scence

 


"GERTCHA"

[Link]

roffeyeagle Flag Freedman Wonderland 24 Nov 04 6.36pm

I know it's slightly off the subject, but had a black or Asian fan done the same to a white player do you think that any action would be taken? Just a thought.

 


'Happy being mediocre; if you've got no targets, you can't fail' - Mantra for life and Palace.

Feel free to check out the Expat Eagles Facebook Group [Link]

Viva la revolution!

deleted1 24 Nov 04 6.47pm

[redacted]

 

Pikester Flag Worthing 24 Nov 04 6.52pm

I'm with Jay on this one.
If someone black called me a White b****** I don't think I'd feel particularly hurt even if I was in the middle of Africa and a minority.

We've had all this with the 'Yid' thread with people asking is "Paddy" racist? What about (thieving) Scouser?

I think certain terms are way out of order such as the N-wprd because of all its connections with the Slave era. I've never really understood why P-A-K-I is particularly offensive as it's only an abbreviation of ****stani.

Also why is Racial assualt worse than a normal assault. Beating up someone because you don't like their colour or beating up someone because they spilt your pint still amounts to the same crime.

At the moment this is the media hot potato and the Sun especially is picking up on any Racist soccer issue with a vengeance.

People will always pick on someone for being different - it happens from our earliest days at school. Who had a girl who always stunk of pee in their class? Hands Up. Was calling her 'pee pants' worse than calling an Indian waiter "Oi Gupta!"

I think the Race Card is played when it's wanted and ignored when it's not. When the newspaper says "A Black Man was seen in the area" it's just reporting a fact. If I go to Palace and call Dwight Yorke a "Black c***" it's considered racist?? I would have thought being called a c*** was the worst bit of the sentence.

This always makes for a lively debate on here - but that's my two-penneth worth.

 


You fed me, you bred me, I'll remember your name.

madcap Flag #winning 24 Nov 04 7.12pm

Quote pikey_eagle at 24 Nov 2004 6:52pm

If I go to Palace and call Dwight Yorke a "Black c***" it's considered racist?? I would have thought being called a c*** was the worst bit of the sentence.

This always makes for a lively debate on here - but that's my two-penneth worth.


You make a good point BUT, calling a black person a black c*** is far worse than calling someone a c*** and can be seen as racist. If the word c*** is so bad, why not just call him a c***? Would you call a white person a white c***?

An indian friend of mine explained to me why he despises the word ****, the connotation associated with it today is completely different from what understand it to be.

 


All Football fans are scum and should be treated as such

Thank You, Goodnight, Much Love x

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 24 Nov 04 7.13pm

Quote Jay_Palace at 24 Nov 2004 5:44pm

Quote madcap at 24 Nov 2004 5:33pm

Quote Jay_Palace at 24 Nov 2004 5:22pm

Quote the despotic banana at 24 Nov 2004 5:16pm

Quote Jay_Palace at 24 Nov 2004 5:01pm

I've yet to be given a valid reason why racism should be treated as the mother and father of all insults.


People have been killed in their millions because of racial hatred. Does that not tell you something?


Yes it does, but in an entirely different context which is totally irrelevent to what i'm trying to argue.

Are you sugesting that making monkey noises at a black player is linked with people being killed in the past because of racial hatred?

Edited by Jay_Palace (24 Nov 2004 5:26pm)

No...making monkey noises at a black player is aimed at making someone feel sub-human as in the days of slavery which is totally unacceptable. Abuse about hair colour and height is totally different.

But why would it make you feel sub human?

The people who make these gestures and noises are morons who are so deluded that it's almost laughable, why their 'opinion' should bother anybody to the extent that it would make them feel sub human, is beyond me.

Obviously people should be stopped by all means from doing this, but we need to be careful where we draw the line. If we are to punish fans for abusing players, then it can't just for abuse directed at the colour of a player's skin.


Madcap said that monkey chanting is AIMED at making the person feel subhuman, not that it makes them feel subhuman. There's a difference.

When you consider the context of racism - slavery, genocide, the holocaust, colonialism - you should be able to see that racial abuse has another dimension when compared to abuse because of someone's hair colour or what they wear. Remember you can change your clothes, dye your hair or wear contacts instead of glasses. Skin colour is impossible to change.

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

deleted1 24 Nov 04 7.16pm

[redacted]

 

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 24 Nov 04 7.25pm

Quote redacted

Much less of a burden that slaves carried, and much less than many African countries are still carrying as a result of European imperialism.

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

deleted1 24 Nov 04 7.27pm

[redacted]

 

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 24 Nov 04 7.41pm

Quote pikey_eagle at 24 Nov 2004 6:52pm

I'm with Jay on this one.
If someone black called me a White b****** I don't think I'd feel particularly hurt even if I was in the middle of Africa and a minority.

Etc.

That is a fantastic post. Saved me the trouble of making the same points.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

jcreedy Flag 24 Nov 04 8.02pm

Quote Jay_Palace at 24 Nov 2004 5:01pm

I was heavily bullied when I was 8 for being very tall for my age, yet had I been racially abused, it would have been perceived as far more serious. Why?

I was also verbally and physically abused for being very tall and skinny for my age at school until I filled out a bit.
I've never understood why people felt it ok to call me lanky or say 'you're tall!' when they meet me, when I know they would take offence if I commented on how fat/short/bald/ugly/old/ginger/black/white they were. Being told that I'm tall doesn't really bother me, but gets tedious after hearing it for the last 15 years.

Edited by jcreedy (24 Nov 2004 8:03pm)

 


It was my dream to play for Palace and to make my debut. I've always played for the club so if I'm playing here, I wouldn't want to be anywhere else.

- John Bostock (Nov 2007)

matthau Flag South Croydon 24 Nov 04 8.25pm

what i find out of order is the fact that we openly accept temples being erected in the UK but if a small british, or generally white community would try to make a christian Church in Dehli theyd be strung up.

PCorrectness can somtimes go to far one way...

 

saxoneagle Flag Bromley 24 Nov 04 8.27pm

I have a white friend who was attacked by a group of black girls and some of the things they said to her were racist. When she reported it to the police they put it down as assualt and she questioned whether it should be "racially motivated assault" due to the comments that were made. She was told that they couldn't possibly call it racially motivated without evidence

Imagine the flipside - the Steven Lawrence's, the Damilola Taylor's... all whipped up into a media race-hate fuelled frenzy.

Why is one different to the other?

Racism is abhorrent in all forms, and in the main i agree with nearly everything Pikey said too.

 

saxoneagle Flag Bromley 24 Nov 04 8.29pm

Quote matthau at 24 Nov 2004 8:25pm

what i find out of order is the fact that we openly accept temples being erected in the UK but if a small british, or generally white community would try to make a christian Church in Dehli theyd be strung up.

PCorrectness can somtimes go to far one way...

Well didn't i read on here that someone's firm is not having a Christmas Party this year to avoid offending the non-Christians? I think sometimes we forget that we are a Christian rooted country who openly accept other religions and cultures but that we should not forget our heritage either, as tainted as it may be.

 

tetley Flag Wimbledon 24 Nov 04 9.18pm

Quote Jay_Palace at 24 Nov 2004 4:43pm

Just to put a different slant on this discussion, but is having monkey noises/gestures directed at you any worse than being abused because of your height, hair colour, sexual orientation, nationality etc.

jay_palace, i used to think this myself, but there is something more important to consider beyond the veener of a persons skin colour. for instance, for evry black man there is a culture that streteches back thousands of years which they are proud of. many of them feel that their whlole tradition is being undermined when racially taunted.

as far as i'm aware, there is not (yet) a huge tradition of music, art etc running in the history of people of ginger hair. of course this may change in the future and then the ninja's might have a leg to stand on.

Edited by Penge Eagle (02 Dec 2004 12:55am)

 


It's not the fall that's important.....it's the landing

All Nature is but Art, unknown to thee;
All Chance, Direction, which thou canst not see;
All Discord, Harmony, not understood;
All partial Evil, universal Good

[Link]

rach_cpfc Flag South Croydon 24 Nov 04 10.52pm

Quote pikey_eagle at 24 Nov 2004 6:52pm

I'm with Jay on this one.
If someone black called me a White b****** I don't think I'd feel particularly hurt even if I was in the middle of Africa and a minority.

Etc.

But, you or I have no idea what that'd be like if we'd been in a minority group our whole lives, and suffered from racism all that time.

 


"....They will soar on wings like EAGLES; they will run and not grow
weary, they will walk and not be faint."

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 24 Nov 04 11.02pm

Quote matthau at 24 Nov 2004 8:25pm

what i find out of order is the fact that we openly accept temples being erected in the UK but if a small british, or generally white community would try to make a christian Church in Dehli theyd be strung up.

PCorrectness can somtimes go to far one way...


That is the biggest load of tosh I've ever read. There are Christian churches all over the world, in countries which are considered to be Muslim, Hindu, Sikh, Bhuddist or whatever. There are communities from all the main religions in almost every country on the globe. They may be small and largely ignored, but they exist, even in countries we consider as "belonging" to one religion or another.

Delhi is of course in India, which has large populations of Christians, Muslims etc 99.9% of whom live side by side with the majority Hindu community with no problems whatsoever.

For the record, India's population is (at a 2000 estimate) 1,014,003,817

The breakdown according to religion is: Hindu 80%, Muslim 14%, Christian 2.4%, Sikh 2%, Buddhist 0.7%, Jains 0.5%, other 0.4%

2.4% of a billion is (I think) 24 million. That's quite a lot of Christians, not many of whom will have been, as you put it, "strung up".

[Link]

Why don't people think about what they're saying before they spout such drivel?

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

ouzo Flag Rafina 25 Nov 04 12.25pm

On an individual level I can't see that there is any difference whether you abuse someone racially or for any other reason, such as height, weight etc. Verbal abuse is pretty meaningless as a one of comment from someone who does't know you.

The problem, however, isn't one of individual abuse but the systematic abuse that the black people have faced for centuaries. It isn't that long age the apartheid was abolished in South Africa. I am sure no one would accept that it is right to have segregation due to skin colour, such as white only beaches etc. In England we have never had to experience so severly these conditions and for myself, not being black, I can't fully imagine how bad it must be to be considered as a second class citizen just because of the colour of my skin.

The reason that racism in football is so strongly condemned is because it is probably the most well supported sport worldwide. Therefore the sport has to be seen to be removing this aspect from the game and showing to the world that there is no place for racism in any part of society.

 

Page 2 of 16 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Gold Talk > Only A Five-Year Ban For Yorke Abuse?