This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I accept that the rich employ tax and business structure experts whose sole purpose is to legally minimise their client's taxation burden. This though is different, for two reasons. Firstly Trump is no longer just a "rich businessman". He is President of the USA. All the recent incumbents have released their returns. All were under audit at the time. None had huge debts, personally guaranteed other than Trump. He could easily have avoided this by simply releasing them. That he didn't gives the appearance he has something to hide. Which seems justified. Secondly is the scale. To have paid nothing at all for so long, and then very little for two years, isn't going to appear "smart" when so many are suffering. I certainly have mitigated my taxation, after taking expert advice, by postponing some, but have never "dodged" any. There are things revealed by the NYT which appear to be potentially illegal and certainly politically questionable. There are many on the centre left who are happy to be conservative over finances because it suits them. They always look to reduce or 'avoid' taxes that relate to them, but they hypocritically advocate for increased public spending by the state. They always look to increase their personal wealth and do better than the average....like every capitalist out there but when you listen to their commentary it's all about the downtrodden. It reminds me of the story of Jesus and the tax man. The difference is that Jesus rejected the tax man because he wouldn't match personal words with personal deeds.....The difference in today's society is that no one is there to hold hypocrites to account....So there's a huge class of people who behave like bourgeoisie bolsheviks and even celebrate that fact. They talk of principles yet the truth is that when it comes to themselves 'principles' are a virtue signal and a commodity. The reality is that, when it comes down to it they share more with those they criticise than they care to admit....with the difference being that the capitalists are much more honest than them. Edited by Stirlingsays (30 Sep 2020 10.04am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Nonsense. Exactly the same standards apply to who-ever might be involved. It just happens to be Trump who is right now but if a Democratic POTUS adopted these tactics then they would receive, and deserve, exactly the same criticism. The truth is, of course, that no other POTUS, be they Republican or Democrat, has even tried this kind of thing. Trump has taken the office of President to a new low. Any newspaper who is in possession of information which enables the voters to be aware of the truth about their choice for POTUS has a duty to reveal it, who-ever is involved.
As for the information itself, the truth or lies of what's presented is one thing. The timing of the release itself is political and hence deliberate election interference. And considering the huge play the Democrats have made upon interference it's yet another example of their pure one eyed hypocrisy. It's ok when they do it. As for Trump as a person....I don't really care that much. What I care about is how he runs the economy, his pushback against far left ideology and how which president in the office affects the UK with the EU. So, essentially you find yourself against the British parliament on that. As not only have the Democrats looked to interfere with the Brexit deal they have openly come out against the British in relation to the EU and trading. Whereas Trump is far more keen, both on Brexit and a trade deal. So, once again, I find you are against the national interest.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
Just seen the 'debate' and the moderator was just bullied by Trump and he let him get away with it. The challenger realised he was not going to get heard and traded blows. 'The worst US president in history' clearly true, look at how he has dragged the USA down. Just a loud-mouth bullying dictator. Trump isn't a nice person...accepted. However, he isn't a dictator. And I'll say this Steely....when it does come to 'bullying dictators', the left are where the real authoritarians are right now....not on the right. Biden is a weak and feeble man, and what stands behind him is a wrecking ball. You might like that...and in some ways it also suits my side. But a large part of me still doesn't enjoy looking into a potential abyss. I'm a tad conflicted in that way....Then again, if Trump wins it'll happen anyway so feck it. Edited by Stirlingsays (30 Sep 2020 11.28am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
As for the information itself, the truth or lies of what's presented is one thing. The timing of the release itself is political and hence deliberate election interference. And considering the huge play the Democrats have made upon interference it's yet another example of their pure one eyed hypocrisy. It's ok when they do it. As for Trump as a person....I don't really care that much. What I care about is how he runs the economy, his pushback against far left ideology and how which president in the office affects the UK with the EU. So, essentially you find yourself against the British parliament on that. As not only have the Democrats looked to interfere with the Brexit deal they have openly come out against the British in relation to trading. Whereas Trump is far more keen, both on Brexit and a trade deal. So, once again, I find you are against the national interest. Edited by Stirlingsays (30 Sep 2020 11.13am) If you believe that examining Trump's tax records is actually to do with tax then you are, once again, grasping the wrong end of the stick. It has nothing to do with tax per se. It has everything to do with honesty, integrity and character. The timing of the release is acknowledged as being political but that's only because it is framed by a huge political event. I support the motivation behind the timing which is no more election interference than any other politically motivated act. The Dems, along with many decent Republicans, have made a "huge play" over election interference by a foreign influences with malign intentions which lead to the possibility of a President being compromised as a consequence. The NYT expose is not interfering. It is potentially exposing interference. I DO care who holds the office of POTUS as they have a huge amount of influence which extends far beyond the shores of the USA. His running of the US economy (much of which is a myth anyway) is well down my list of importance. Foreign policy and international co-operation and leadership come much, much higher. Pushing back against "far-left ideology" is another myth as such ideology only exists in tiny pockets in the USA and has just been invented as a bogeyman to rail against. That there is a slow drift towards modern social democratic thinking is to be welcomed but it is a million miles away from being "far-left". Being out of step with the current British government, and their approach on Brexit and the USA, is something that every right minded citizen is duty bound to be. Thankfully once we have a Democratic POTUS and a majority in both Houses the tide will start to turn. We will have to slide down further before we start to climb back again but climb back we will.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
If you believe that examining Trump's tax records is actually to do with tax then you are, once again, grasping the wrong end of the stick. It has nothing to do with tax per se. It has everything to do with honesty, integrity and character. The timing of the release is acknowledged as being political but that's only because it is framed by a huge political event. I support the motivation behind the timing which is no more election interference than any other politically motivated act. Again, you are fine with this 'election interference' because it supports your aims, but you railed against the 'Russian' and whatever else interference because you view anything anti Trump as acceptable. I think that when it comes to honesty and integrity and character the point could well be made that if you are going to criticise it in Trump you aren't displaying it yourself if you support a 'by any means possible' attitude against him. And I'll make the point that the idea that a president is someone with these ideals is laughable. They are all liars and disingenuous because that's what climbing the political greasey pole demands. I think you hold up false ideals that don't apply and are myths in the modern political world. Instead, I would suggest to you that unethical behaviour is part and parcel of both sides...all sides of any political process in any country actually and that we should accept that this is the case. I'm not saying we should condone it but we should not pretend that because one side suits my political worldview that their sh1tty ethics isn't sh1tty. Just accept that if you are going to travel through a sewer you are going to deal in sh1t and don't pretend otherwise. Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
The Dems, along with many decent Republicans, have made a "huge play" over election interference by a foreign influences with malign intentions which lead to the possibility of a President being compromised as a consequence. The NYT expose is not interfering. It is potentially exposing interference. I DO care who holds the office of POTUS as they have a huge amount of influence which extends far beyond the shores of the USA. His running of the US economy (much of which is a myth anyway) is well down my list of importance. Foreign policy and international co-operation and leadership come much, much higher. Pushing back against "far-left ideology" is another myth as such ideology only exists in tiny pockets in the USA and has just been invented as a bogeyman to rail against. That there is a slow drift towards modern social democratic thinking is to be welcomed but it is a million miles away from being "far-left". Being out of step with the current British government, and their approach on Brexit and the USA, is something that every right minded citizen is duty bound to be. Thankfully once we have a Democratic POTUS and a majority in both Houses the tide will start to turn. We will have to slide down further before we start to climb back again but climb back we will. Man, if I answered all this point by point this post would take forever. So I'd say that I disagree with you on all of those paragraphs but I will concede that it was an interesting read that came across as an honest view. And I always appreciate honesty whether I agree with the view or not.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by The Dolphin
I love this discussion! Excellent post and I know we don't always agree. I think that willingness to disagree and accept that difference is what marks us apart from what we fear...which is what we see behind Biden. I accept the character flaws of Trump....the reality that he is a lying bully. However, we also see what the left are willing to condole and support and it's anti what most people want.....People want to be left alone to work hard and get on with their lives as much as possible without state or activist interference. They are going to get that far more with Trump.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Excellent post and I know we don't always agree. I think that willingness to disagree and accept that difference is what marks us apart from what we fear...which is what we see behind Biden. I accept the character flaws of Trump....the reality that he is a lying bully. However, we also see what the left are willing to condole and support and it's anti what most people want.....People want to be left alone to work hard and get on with their lives as much as possible without state or activist interference. They are going to get that far more with Trump.
Exactly this trump aint a decent guy but at least he doesn't have the audacity to be a pure evil c*** in private and a virtue signaller in public (biden, Clinton, Obama, Bush) Lefties always take the unhinged war potential stance which is just ridiculous if they really cared about peace they wouldn't vote in the party responsible for most of the conflicts in recent memory and total destabilising of the middle East. Bush should never of got involved in the middle East but at least they went in and had the courtesy to try and resolve the issues after they had been with a possible future government installed. Obama on the other hand went around destroying all the potential governments got drone strike happy totally destabilised Libya and then washed his hands of the whole thing now we have non stop war over there. Trump destroyed Isis with minimal involvement and cooperation with allies in the middle east. Trumps war and peace record s***s all over the Democrats end of.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Cpfc1861
Exactly this trump aint a decent guy but at least he doesn't have the audacity to be a pure evil c*** in private and a virtue signaller in public (biden, Clinton, Obama, Bush) Lefties always take the unhinged war potential stance which is just ridiculous if they really cared about peace they wouldn't vote in the party responsible for most of the conflicts in recent memory and total destabilising of the middle East. Bush should never of got involved in the middle East but at least they went in and had the courtesy to try and resolve the issues after they had been with a possible future government installed. Obama on the other hand went around destroying all the potential governments got drone strike happy totally destabilised Libya and then washed his hands of the whole thing now we have non stop war over there. Trump destroyed Isis with minimal involvement and cooperation with allies in the middle east. Trumps war and peace record s***s all over the Democrats end of. It's true, the west made a total mess of Libya and walked away and just stopped talking about it. It's enough to convict people for what has happened there since....good intentions, and for the most part I believe that...but they are not enough of an excuse for what happened. Edited by Stirlingsays (30 Sep 2020 2.01pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
It's not election interference unless it's untrue! It's elector information if it's true. Is it true? It has all the appearance of being true. Many previous stories and established facts support it. If found to be untrue the consequences would be catastrophic for the NYT, whose fact-checkers, lawyers and editors would all be implemented. I don't see them taking such a risk. Trump's response also adds weight to the likelihood it's truth. If it was not then there is simply no impediment, audit or not, to him releasing them and proving they are untrue. That their release has been timed to produce the maximum opportunity to damage him is undoubtedly true. If you are convinced, as I am, that his removal is an imperative, then choosing that timing is a duty. So it may not be true? But you have chosen to believe it and anyone who disagrees with you are wrong/misinformed. Of course without actual proof it could be you that is wrong.... oh wait a minute you never are, apologies
|
|
|
|
|
|
Originally posted by matthau
Believing in a deep state is fair enough. It's almost impossible not to believe there is one which operates out of the US, and you can see how it is almost encouraged constitutionally, by having a Federal Reserve with such global financial authority, by having such a disproportionate military might in the world, by having a political set up which is so convoluted between state and national governance, and so dependent on large financial donations to operate. But to think Trump isn't part of that? Are you serious? The first thing the guy did when he got in was lower taxes for the rich. He has stopped federal investigations in to global financial money laundering happening through the super deregulated states like Arizona and Delaware. He was best mates with Epstein FFS! Support him if you believe in neoliberalism, or because you don't like immigrants, that's fine. But don't delude yourself that he is some kind of man of the people. If he touched your hand he'd probably feel the need to have a shower to cleanse himself. Edited by serial thriller (30 Sep 2020 3.22pm)
If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4 |
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
So it may not be true? But you have chosen to believe it and anyone who disagrees with you are wrong/misinformed. Of course without actual proof it could be you that is wrong.... oh wait a minute you never are, apologies As with many things you have to make a judgement on what is true. Mine is, based on the available evidence, that what the NYT has said is overwhelmingly likely to be substantially true.
Do you disagree?
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Again, you are fine with this 'election interference' because it supports your aims, but you railed against the 'Russian' and whatever else interference because you view anything anti Trump as acceptable.I think that when it comes to honesty and integrity and character the point could well be made that if you are going to criticise it in Trump you aren't displaying it yourself if you support a 'by any means possible' attitude against him.And I'll make the point that the idea that a president is someone with these ideals is laughable. They are all liars and disingenuous because that's what climbing the political greasey pole demands. I think you hold up false ideals that don't apply and are myths in the modern political world.Instead, I would suggest to you that unethical behaviour is part and parcel of both sides...all sides of any political process in any country actually and that we should accept that this is the case.I'm not saying we should condone it but we should not pretend that because one side suits my political worldview that their sh1tty ethics isn't sh1tty.Just accept that if you are going to travel through a sewer you are going to deal in sh1t and don't pretend otherwise.
Did you read what I wrote? You are confusing election interference from a foreign source, which is illegal in the USA, with straightforward local politics. Whether it involves Trump or not makes no difference to that fact. That I support the political efforts does not mean I would support foreign interference on behalf of Biden. I would not. That politics in the USA inhabits a dirty world which is no longer fit for purpose is undeniable. That some within it try to operate, as best they can, with integrity and honour is also undeniable. There are those, like Trump, for whom it is their natural environment and who see nothing wrong in corruption, lies or cruelty so long as it achieves results that suit them, and there are those who recognise the failings and would love to do something about them. They are not all the same. That's just a common myth spread by the corrupt to justify their corruption.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Did you read what I wrote? You are confusing election interference from a foreign source, which is illegal in the USA, with straightforward local politics. Whether it involves Trump or not makes no difference to that fact. That I support the political efforts does not mean I would support foreign interference on behalf of Biden. I would not. That politics in the USA inhabits a dirty world which is no longer fit for purpose is undeniable. That some within it try to operate, as best they can, with integrity and honour is also undeniable. There are those, like Trump, for whom it is their natural environment and who see nothing wrong in corruption, lies or cruelty so long as it achieves results that suit them, and there are those who recognise the failings and would love to do something about them. They are not all the same. That's just a common myth spread by the corrupt to justify their corruption. I'm not seeing the Democrats as an option to sort out the corruption in the system. My reaction to this is that the Democratic nominees are the careerist politicians who have served their time in the party and are now getting their pop at the top job. I personally feel that bigger people in the party, such as Hilary Clinton and Obama are still pulling the strings. They are now the politicians' politicians and raise the money both you and Stirling mention.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
I'm not seeing the Democrats as an option to sort out the corruption in the system. My reaction to this is that the Democratic nominees are the careerist politicians who have served their time in the party and are now getting their pop at the top job. I personally feel that bigger people in the party, such as Hilary Clinton and Obama are still pulling the strings. They are now the politicians' politicians and raise the money both you and Stirling mention. The Democrats on their own cannot sort things out. It will require good people from all sides led by a leader, who could come from anywhere, who commands respect and can heal the divisions. And there are good people on all sides. Not just too many in the GOP right now. Why Trump entered politics is something that no doubt has had people wondering about for a long time. I don't know but I am quite sure it isn't because he wanted to serve this country with humility and honour so as to make the people safer and happier. Much more likely to be down to personal vanity or the need to hide his corruption and ultimately be pardoned for it. Trump's not really a fly in the ointment. He is more of a cuckoo in the nest, throwing out all the homebred innocents whilst conning those who feed him. We hear a lot about Trump for two reasons. Firstly because he wants to be talked about and makes sure he is via twitter and controversy. Secondly because by doing things quite as badly as he does he automatically draws attention to himself.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by samprior
The debate last night was an utter embarrassment and unbelievably depressing. A country of however many million and that's the cream of the crop. There's really no choice - vote A for decrepit crook or vote B for decrepit crook. One decrepit crook wants to hold power another 4 years, in whatever way he can fix it. The other might be older but he is neither decrepit nor a crook. He is a career politician, who is a safe pair of hands and knows the system, knows who can be trusted to advise and hold supporting office. Most of all he isn't Trump. He is very likely just a stalking horse. A bridge to a better future under a younger progressive leadership.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.