This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Those who succeed in a system dictate what is and isn't a crime, especially in terms of regulating how they can retain a position of success. My "poverty of moral values" remark wasn't a snide remark about sections of society. It was about demonising the poor. Poverty doesn't make people criminals. Poverty of moral values does.
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by 7mins
My "poverty of moral values" remark wasn't a snide remark about sections of society. It was about demonising the poor. Poverty doesn't make people criminals. Poverty of moral values does. Sorry how does poverty of moral values occur and why is the majority of petty crime and gang crime correlated very strongly, in multiple sources, to poverty - as well as a number of other social phenomena such as substance abuse problems (note that whilst these occur in all groups, they disproportionately affect the poor). Are you specifically indicating that black people have somehow a higher poverty of moral values compared to white people in a similar situation. What are these moral values? If its poverty of moral values, doesn't that negate personal responsibility, given that a moral is inherent rather than learned.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Sorry how does poverty of moral values occur and why is the majority of petty crime and gang crime correlated very strongly, in multiple sources, to poverty - as well as a number of other social phenomena such as substance abuse problems (note that whilst these occur in all groups, they disproportionately affect the poor). Are you specifically indicating that black people have somehow a higher poverty of moral values compared to white people in a similar situation. What are these moral values? If its poverty of moral values, doesn't that negate personal responsibility, given that a moral is inherent rather than learned.
I have travelled through South America to some of the poorest villages, where the people have next to nothing, one village had only one phone in the local shop, and they let everyone use it.
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by 7mins
I disagree that morals are inherent rather than learned, I certainly consider my morals to come from my parents/siblings. Morals are inherent to the individual, ethics are socially constructed through learning and interaction. Originally posted by 7mins
I have travelled through South America to some of the poorest villages, where the people have next to nothing, one village had only one phone in the local shop, and they let everyone use it. Poverty doesn't equal crime. That kind of thinking is dangerous. Those countries don't correspond to the US directly though, as they're a different form of poverty - as the inequality is distanced and there isn't the same social value placed on wealth being success. Of course in many South American countries there is a history of criminality as a means of escaping poverty, both in the attraction of revolutionary movements and drug production - Especially in more developed urban areas. I'm not trying to say that poverty equals crime, but that is a major factor in aspects of criminality, and that's a reliable correlation. And for many in western poverty the opportunities to escape from poverty are increasingly fewer. Originally posted by 7mins
Criminality can breed in many different environments, personally I always terthink having two good parents helps. Even one 'good' parent makes a huge difference. But the problem of poverty impacts family and parents seriously. When you look at social phenomena such as addiction, gambling etc these have a of disproportionate effect on those in poverty because of the capacity to cope, and the attraction of escape. Poverty isn't just about being poor. You can be poor and not in poverty. Poverty is more a loop where in no matter what you do. My parents were poor, but they weren't in a position where they were broke and getting poorer on an unavoidable basis. Originally posted by 7mins
The number of young black people in America being brought up in single parent households is far higher than any other racial group. I think that's more or less true until you step outside of poor black families Originally posted by 7mins
I also think the gang culture doesn't help, seeing snoop dogg standing next to the Dallas police chief was incredible, that f***er is part of the problems Its a Catch-22. Snoop Dogg like many rappers escaped 'the cycle of poverty' by singing about the situations around him and that affected people he knew. The attraction of sports, music, celebrity and gangs are examples of success in the ghettos - Rappers become role models because they're successful, in a society were wealth defines success. The gangs were there long before people were 'spitting rhymes' about them. Its interesting how people focus on black gangs and rap music, in a way they absolutely don't when it comes to say the Mafia or general crime drama and movies. Listen to NWA, for example, and its not a glamourisation of gangs, what you see is the anger and the situation people, who's options in life are limited. Its the voice of disaffected, wasted youth. Originally posted by 7mins
Once criminal culture takes hold in a certain section of society it's difficult to eradicate, people become conditioned by their environment. I think the ehas to ultimately come from the black community. In part, that's true, but it cannot resolve the problem alone. These are people largely failed by the most underfunded parts of the US education system, with low employment prospects, large scale welfare dependency, poor housing. Gangs are as much a product and symptom of the problem, but they do perpetuate the problems as well. And its not a problem specific to the black community. Its been prevalent in Italian communities, Jewish and Irish Communities as well. Originally posted by 7mins
There are many things I admire about the black side of my family, but they don't see education as a main priority, I think that is something that could change. The Asian community are extremely family orientated and place huge importance on education. Education is certainly the single greatest effector in social mobility, probably more so than anything else. The problem is that education is very expensive in the US, and really not an option for many people. Its an odd phenomena of the poor, a general disdain for education that's proportionate to how poor you are. The problem of many of the big problem areas of the US, education is only a way out if you can get a scholarship. College and University are expensive and very distant, for someone who may have spent their entire life without travelling more than 20 miles.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Education is certainly the single greatest effector in social mobility, probably more so than anything else. The problem is that education is very expensive in the US, and really not an option for many people. Its an odd phenomena of the poor, a general disdain for education that's proportionate to how poor you are. The problem of many of the big problem areas of the US, education is only a way out if you can get a scholarship. College and University are expensive and very distant, for someone who may have spent their entire life without travelling more than 20 miles.
I disagree, morals are not inherent.. We are never going to agree on that one. I consider myself to have by n large good morals, I believe I learnt these from my parents. None of my siblings have ever been in trouble with the police (apart from being punched by a Spanish copper). Other members of my extended family have fallen foul of the law... Obviously they feel the system is against them, but in all brutal honesty, one of them is a thief, his dad was offski pretty much straight away and his mum never worked and remained bitter at her life choices. I believe that led to this family member having bad morals. I don't believe America has serious trouble with Italian gangs, even the Hispanic gangs have a long way to go, before getting anywhere near the body count of the black gangs. I've never been a fan of... "What about..." Type arguments. You said my view of single parent black families is "more or less true". It is true... Look at the stats. There isn't a massive race problem with American police, when you look at the facts, none of the accusations stand up. Black people commit far far too much crime (especially violent crime) putting black people in prison hasn't worked, all it has done is make black people think they're being targeted (they're not, stats from DoJ, back this up) Now you get a few black people shot by cops, and it feeds in to this victim mentality. In my view, the black community needs to take responsibility for their actions. Michael Brown deserved to be shot, black witnesses backed the police officers account. The lady with the shotgun deserved to be shot, yet BLM described it as "a systematic attack on people of colour" all of this sounds like a deflection tactic... What would help (mainly) young black men best is if the black community admitted their problems. Forget about what the far right has to say... Just be honest. Sure it will sting for a bit, but just imagine the lives it will save, and the amount of young black men spending huge amounts of their lives in prison.
|
|
|
I think this will answer a few questions being asked and answers being given in this thread: [Link]
Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky. |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by 7mins
Thanks for the detailed reply. I will try to do it justice, but I'm currently posting from a foreign country on terrible internet connection. Well yes, but then what can he do about it. By himself, nothing, because that's what poverty is. Poverty and poor ethics and choices go hand in hand. Poverty isn't just about money, its about choices, influences, access to opportunities etc. Being poor is bad, but being impoverished is terrible. Originally posted by 7mins
I don't believe America has serious trouble with Italian gangs, even the Hispanic gangs have a long way to go, before getting anywhere near the body count of the black gangs. I've never been a fan of... "What about..." Type arguments. Well a large part of the drug and weapons black gangs are fighting over and with, will come from other organised crime gangs, or their affiliates. The Mafia ties back to Italy, are responsible for heroin trafficking into the black areas, for example. Originally posted by 7mins
There isn't a massive race problem with American police, when you look at the facts, none of the accusations stand up. There is a problem, but its not really the problem here. The problem in the US, is more about poor people, and a police forces funding, training and recruitment. The US criminal justice system is cruel in regards to the poorer members of socitety and black people get caught up in that. The difference, black America has a long history of having to fight for its rights, and as a result has an apparatus in place which gives it a voice, other groups in lower working class and underclasses simply don't have. BLM is important, not because the police are racist murder junkies, but that they are killing people in a manner that is unjustified in any reasonable sense, and that's part of a criminal justice system that is entirely cruel to those socio-economic demographics. If it wasn't for BLM no one would even be giving a s**t about these stories where police use of lethal force is entirely disproportionate to the situation and context.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by 7mins
Another black man shot, another riot. This guy had a stolen hand gun, and refused to put it down. Let's see the details of this emerge. BLM however don't need the details, they have already said "When will these unjustified murders stop?" Recycling the same flawed argument every time there's a killing doesn't make you any more right.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Recycling the same flawed argument every time there's a killing doesn't make you any more right. Explain my flawed argument?
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Recycling the same flawed argument every time there's a killing doesn't make you any more right. Tell me. Did you think OJ was innocent?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Tell me. Did you think OJ was innocent?
Ha. The facts are this dude had a long criminal record, had a illegal firearm and refused to put it down, he was given several warning
|
|
|
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Tell me. Did you think OJ was innocent?
Yes, but I am also pretty certain he also murdered his ex-wife and her lover. The law can be a odd thing at times. Definitely not guilty, but I am certain he did it.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by 7mins
Ha. The facts are this dude had a long criminal record, had a illegal firearm and refused to put it down, he was given several warning Facts, or the official line. This is why you need independent enquiries into such events, to establish the facts. I'm not saying either side is right, but there in lies the problem. The police aren't trusted, BLM seem to be more trusted than the police these days, even though I don't trust them as they're not an organisation with no official culpability (pretty much like many US Police Depts). The US in providing to provide proper regulate ons, requirements, training and oversight of its police forces are in a situation now where they aren't trusted, and probably will struggle to ever recover that trust. Its their own fault as well, because of the history of poor oversight, decades of closed ranks and political exploitation of enforcement by officials that have ended up dispropitionately targeting poor (and thus black) areas.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Facts, or the official line. This is why you need independent enquiries into such events, to establish the facts. I'm not saying either side is right, but there in lies the problem. The police aren't trusted, BLM seem to be more trusted than the police these days, even though I don't trust them as they're not an organisation with no official culpability (pretty much like many US Police Depts). The US in providing to provide proper regulate ons, requirements, training and oversight of its police forces are in a situation now where they aren't trusted, and probably will struggle to ever recover that trust. Its their own fault as well, because of the history of poor oversight, decades of closed ranks and political exploitation of enforcement by officials that have ended up dispropitionately targeting poor (and thus black) areas. It's facts, it's on camera. He runs, turns back pulls a gun out aims at police officer. BLM described at as murder. Father blamed white people. White people attacked Officer that shot him attacked.
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by 7mins
It's facts, it's on camera. He runs, turns back pulls a gun out aims at police officer. BLM described at as murder. Father blamed white people. White people attacked Officer that shot him attacked. Sounds like a justified shooting to me. Pointing a gun at anyone, is grounds for self defence anywhere in the world. Shame its come to this.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Sounds like a justified shooting to me. Pointing a gun at anyone, is grounds for self defence anywhere in the world. Shame its come to this. Yes, but this shows my point about BLM (and the media to some extent) they called it murder, they couldn't care less if it was justifiable or not. The lads dad said "whites" are killing us, he had no idea it was a black police officer. It's the language of hate, it's not the currency that's needed right now. White people men and woman were pulled from their cars and beaten in Milwaukee. That plays right in to the hands of the far right. BLM are in the same conversation as the (current) KKK for me.
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by 7mins
Yes, but this shows my point about BLM (and the media to some extent) they called it murder, they couldn't care less if it was justifiable or not. The lads dad said "whites" are killing us, he had no idea it was a black police officer. It's the language of hate, it's not the currency that's needed right now. White people men and woman were pulled from their cars and beaten in Milwaukee. That plays right in to the hands of the far right. BLM are in the same conversation as the (current) KKK for me. Because America and American politics has for well over a decade hated facts. Its all about emotion and feeling. I'd stay clear of hyperbole such as comparing the Klan to BLM. That kind of hyperbole is Godwin's Law of argument (and lets not forget that the Klan exists today because of what it did in the past, and what its members still do and support). Acting on racism is never justified. Its the cycle of absurdity playing out, in which the stupid and the ignorant are pandered to. No number of wrongs make a right like attacking people indiscriminately. I get why people might target the police. But random white people, is just the same ignorant hate s**t you're supposed to be against.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.