You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic
November 16 2026 1.00am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Coronavirus (LOCKED)


Page 21 of 753 < 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 >
ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 16 Mar 20 10.37am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

I cough when I think about it and the first thing I did when I read your post was to cough

Check your temperature. Without being alarmist, you should self isolate for 7 days. Watch a couple of series' and read a few books. I recommend Silk Roads by Frankopan. That will definitely take you more than a week.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 16 Mar 20 10.51am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Yeah, it's almost as though people are so used to social liberalism that they are willing to let it kill them.

Kind of ironic.

I hate to say it, but when it comes to this stuff, I think the Chinese have the right approach.....You have to be illiberal if you are going to save a lot more people in the long run.

It was one region in China where it started on lockdown but I agree on the logic.

The British are just s*** at all this (geezer pr1ck openly coughing in a small co-op and then joking with the checkout young lad he was bellowing at he needs latex gloves) and the economy is set up so that people will take the risk because financial ruin is a possibility so we just have to look after ourselves.

Lockdown would take months, not weeks. It would batter people financially and the oldies who don’t go to work aren’t going to stay in anyway.

We all know how to reduce our risk.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (16 Mar 2020 10.52am)

 


COYP

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 16 Mar 20 11.44am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Loads of old people or over 70’s refusing to stay in, or (not get into contact with other people, which is what the advice should be). They don’t realise that:

1. Their immune system is low, no matter how fit they are.
2. They could get it and carry it because of 1. and pass it on.

The herd immunity idea is sounding like it’s flawed and not necessarily what the government are aiming for, which is slow it down, and slow the the spread and peak down so fewer people get it. It’s sounding a flawed idea to get it to be alright because the percentages of people who are dying from getting it whether fit or not means hundreds of thousands of deaths.

What’s also making me laugh is people wanting a complete lockdown but people here just won’t follow it.


I hear that the government seem to be modifying the advice today and suggesting that the over 70s won't need to "stay indoors" but to be sensible and avoid close contact with others. Which makes perfect sense. With warmer weather around the corner and knowing that fresh air and exercise will keep you healthy going for a walk must be good for you, and no danger to others, so long as you keep the recommended 2 metres distance. My dogs will be happy to know this too!

Building up "herd immunity" also seems sensible. If those young and fit enough to survive this get it, and then develop immunity, the numbers able to spread it reduce proportionately and so will the number infected at any one time. Thus the NHS can handle it over a longer time frame. If they get overwhelmed by a huge peak then the death rate will be higher. Unless I am missing something!

I am wondering if China will see a resurgence once they fully release the brakes because there is no "herd immunity" there and no vaccine yet.

I also wonder whether the global lockdowns we are seeing actually makes much sense. It's beginning to feel like shutting the stable door after the horse has bolted. If your country already has infections what's the point of stopping travel from another that has them, at the same or a similar level? Surely it's the internal systems to slow the spread and manage the way your health systems cope that really counts. I realise that many people won't want to travel at the moment unless they have to but blanket bans seem to be window dressing rather than of any practical effect.

The idea that globalisation has any responsibility for this, as made by another poster, is really quite ludicrous. Unless every country completely and permanently closed their borders such things as this virus are bound to spread. They might spread faster these days, but spread they always have. Knowing who is here won't stop that.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Stirlingsays Flag 16 Mar 20 12.02pm

I find it an apt metaphor for what social liberalism has done to society that the toilet roll now represents its most valued commodity.

If we had closed our borders when this started we simply wouldn't have the scale of the problem we have.

Also this reasoning that those who lock down are going to have a problem when people come out completely ignores that the warmer weather will knock down this virus far more effectively......I suspect that this is what they are planning for in countries that have locked down.

In my view, you are never going to get an effective level of 'herd immunity' to actually stop the old getting this.....life doesn't work like that....probably looks good on a spreadsheet but I suspect the reality is that it'll be the summer that knocks this down.

Then it's a race to a vaccine in time.


Edited by Stirlingsays (16 Mar 2020 12.03pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Matov Flag 16 Mar 20 12.13pm

Sorry but isolating is not about saving lives. It is all about spreading out the deaths so that come the winter, less people die of the second wave.

The lack of a basic level of understanding about how viruses work is staggering. Nobody has a natural immunity to Covid-19. Therefore the only way to stop it is to prevent the spread is having 60% of the population to have had it and got better.

If anything those of us who are not in the at-risk groups should be deliberately infected with it. We should be socialising more, in optimum conditions for it to spread.

I would happily be infected today so that within 10 days I can get on with normal life.

OK, perhaps I am a bit of a lunatic but seriously, the only effective action is to ensure that most of us get it but spread out over the months to come. Not hide away from it now so that it can come back and bite us on the arse in November with a long winter ahead.

Catch Covid-19 now if you are under 70 and are not already having to visit the Doctor once a month.

Edited by Matov (16 Mar 2020 12.14pm)

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

Stirlingsays Flag 16 Mar 20 12.26pm

Originally posted by Matov

Sorry but isolating is not about saving lives. It is all about spreading out the deaths so that come the winter, less people die of the second wave.

The lack of a basic level of understanding about how viruses work is staggering. Nobody has a natural immunity to Covid-19. Therefore the only way to stop it is to prevent the spread is having 60% of the population to have had it and got better.

If anything those of us who are not in the at-risk groups should be deliberately infected with it. We should be socialising more, in optimum conditions for it to spread.

I would happily be infected today so that within 10 days I can get on with normal life.

OK, perhaps I am a bit of a lunatic but seriously, the only effective action is to ensure that most of us get it but spread out over the months to come. Not hide away from it now so that it can come back and bite us on the arse in November with a long winter ahead.

Catch Covid-19 now if you are under 70 and are not already having to visit the Doctor once a month.

Edited by Matov (16 Mar 2020 12.14pm)

I can't say I agree with you but I guess time is going to tell isn't it......By the end of summer the body bag numbers will tell us which approach was the most effective.

Whichever approach works better will no doubt become the blanket method by next winter....unless the vaccine race has been a giant and speedy success.

Edited by Stirlingsays (16 Mar 2020 12.28pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Matov Flag 16 Mar 20 12.34pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

I can't say I agree with you but I guess time is going to tell isn't it......By the end of summer the body bag numbers will tell us which approach was the most effective.

By the end of summer 2021, the amount of body bags will tell us who is right.

And that is the issue. This is a long term problem. Johnson is luckier than most politicians in that he is perhaps the most secure Western leader at the moment. 80 majority and a fixed-term Parliament act. He can afford to take the hit by not pandering to the hysteria.

Banking on a vaccine by November is irresponsible in the extreme. This wretched virus will kill. Nothing can prevent that as things stand. Better to take the wider term hit now as we go into the warmer months, with the NHS better able to cope, than delay it until the winter.

Yes, it seems heartless but emotions have to be taken out of this. We are essentially at war with this virus and I do not use that term lightly. This is an invader that wants to kill as many of us as possible. And it will, to a certain extent, succeed.

Now is the right time to fight it. To take it on the chin. Because if we don't then it comes back in November and the carnage will be even greater.


 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 16 Mar 20 12.46pm

Originally posted by Matov

Sorry but isolating is not about saving lives. It is all about spreading out the deaths so that come the winter, less people die of the second wave.

The lack of a basic level of understanding about how viruses work is staggering. Nobody has a natural immunity to Covid-19. Therefore the only way to stop it is to prevent the spread is having 60% of the population to have had it and got better.

If anything those of us who are not in the at-risk groups should be deliberately infected with it. We should be socialising more, in optimum conditions for it to spread.

I would happily be infected today so that within 10 days I can get on with normal life.

OK, perhaps I am a bit of a lunatic but seriously, the only effective action is to ensure that most of us get it but spread out over the months to come. Not hide away from it now so that it can come back and bite us on the arse in November with a long winter ahead.

Catch Covid-19 now if you are under 70 and are not already having to visit the Doctor once a month.

Edited by Matov (16 Mar 2020 12.14pm)

I do agree with you. The more the generally fit and healthy among us get it and recover the better. The most sensible thing would be if 25% of NHS staff all got it in stages during the next 8 weeks, took a couple of weeks off and we then had a full complement when the peak strikes. Couldn't be managed and no-one would accept it either.

Apparently it remains unknown whether anyone can get reinfected or if the initial immunity dissipates. If it follows the expected pattern that won't be true and even if it doesn't partial immunity will remain, thus a re-infection will be milder than the first.

The body bag numbers by the end of the summer will tell us exactly that. What the number of deaths are by the end of this summer. A much better picture will be known by the end of summer 2021. By then we will know whether a vaccine has been yet found which works.

Edited by Wisbech Eagle (16 Mar 2020 2.42pm)

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

taylors lovechild Flag 16 Mar 20 12.49pm

What seems apparent is that as this is a new virus there are few certainties, with scientists generally saying it is too early to confirm whether warmer weather will get rid of it or slow it, or whether people will be immune once they've had it. I imagine these uncertainties must make it extremely hard to make decisions. If the UK did go down the herd immunity route and they got it wrong it could result in thousands of deaths that could possibly have been avoided. Whatever happens I hope that from the largest corporations to the man on the street people try and make decisions about more than just their own selfish interests, be it handing over profits to support health services to lending your neighbour a toilet roll.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 16 Mar 20 1.00pm

Hancock said, in an answer to a similar question, that it's hard to become reinfected once you've been through it.

But you hear different.....Still, I suspect that like most flu type illnesses the body develops antibodies.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Midlands Eagle Flag 16 Mar 20 1.02pm

Originally posted by Matov

Johnson is luckier than most politicians in that he is perhaps the most secure Western leader at the moment. 80 majority and a fixed-term Parliament act. He can afford to take the hit by not pandering to the hysteria.


Just think. If Corbyn's labour had won last year's General Election he would have had to govern from his front room and hold cabinet meetings over Skype

 

Matov Flag 16 Mar 20 1.02pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

What seems apparent is that as this is a new virus there are few certainties, with scientists generally saying it is too early to confirm whether warmer weather will get rid of it or slow it, or whether people will be immune once they've had it. I imagine these uncertainties must make it extremely hard to make decisions. If the UK did go down the herd immunity route and they got it wrong it could result in thousands of deaths that could possibly have been avoided.

Herd immunity is a thing. It is how humanity functions and copes with disease. COVID-19 is not actually that much of a ferocious virus. It kills pretty much how it is meant to i.e the old and infirm. In Darwinian terms, it actually serves a purpose.

Johnsons strategy, as advised by HMG's top scientists, is a perfectly rational one. Isolating at this stage is simply ludicrous for over 95% of us.

Really the advice should be for at risk groups to isolate immediately and for them to be supported in doing that whilst the rest of us just get on with everyday life and when we fall ill, tuck up in bed for a week or so.

But you need it to spread. That is the Elephant in the Room here that no politician really has the courage to admit to.

Lockdowns are the political version of panic buying loo-rolls. That need to be seen to do something, rather than just accepting that this is how life is.

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 16 Mar 20 1.09pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Just think. If Corbyn's labour had won last year's General Election he would have had to govern from his front room and hold cabinet meetings over Skype


At least he would govern though, think Boris was away on holiday for the start of the crisis, giving it 5 weeks head start on the rest of europe to spread ,10 years to plan such an episode on his partys hands, in boris we trust!

 

Stirlingsays Flag 16 Mar 20 1.11pm

Originally posted by Matov

Herd immunity is a thing. It is how humanity functions and copes with disease. COVID-19 is not actually that much of a ferocious virus. It kills pretty much how it is meant to i.e the old and infirm. In Darwinian terms, it actually serves a purpose.

Johnsons strategy, as advised by HMG's top scientists, is a perfectly rational one. Isolating at this stage is simply ludicrous for over 95% of us.

Really the advice should be for at risk groups to isolate immediately and for them to be supported in doing that whilst the rest of us just get on with everyday life and when we fall ill, tuck up in bed for a week or so.

But you need it to spread. That is the Elephant in the Room here that no politician really has the courage to admit to.

Lockdowns are the political version of panic buying loo-rolls. That need to be seen to do something, rather than just accepting that this is how life is.

So this 'herd immunity' how well did that work with smallpox then?.......measles and all of the rest of the viruses before vaccines for them?

Personally I think the Chinese have the best strategy....but as stated we will see.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

taylors lovechild Flag 16 Mar 20 1.12pm

Originally posted by Matov

Herd immunity is a thing. It is how humanity functions and copes with disease. COVID-19 is not actually that much of a ferocious virus. It kills pretty much how it is meant to i.e the old and infirm. In Darwinian terms, it actually serves a purpose.

Johnsons strategy, as advised by HMG's top scientists, is a perfectly rational one. Isolating at this stage is simply ludicrous for over 95% of us.

Really the advice should be for at risk groups to isolate immediately and for them to be supported in doing that whilst the rest of us just get on with everyday life and when we fall ill, tuck up in bed for a week or so.

But you need it to spread. That is the Elephant in the Room here that no politician really has the courage to admit to.

Lockdowns are the political version of panic buying loo-rolls. That need to be seen to do something, rather than just accepting that this is how life is.

I know what herd immunity is, I was simply stating that scientists seem reluctant to say whether this would work. Every time I think I know something an expert seems to contradict it, hence my saying how difficult it must be to make decisions. If the path was clear everyone would follow it; the varied responses suggests it is not a time of certainties.

 

mezzer Flag Main Stand, Block F, Row 20 seat 1... 16 Mar 20 1.15pm

I'm not sure that people are getting their head around the numbers (potentially) affected as yet.

It was forecast quite early on (when it was emerging from China) that 1.4 billion people could be affected. If you have a 2% mortality rate worldwide, that's 20 million (yes 20 million) deaths. We're at 6,500 and counting today.

We're nowhere near the end of this yet.

But, however scary that sounds, it still means that 98 out of every 100 people that catch it won't die. So is the economic depression that we're heading for, with all the residual bankruptcies, missed mortgage payments and mass unemployment that'll follow, actually worth the preventive measures being taken?

I don't know the answers and would hate to have to make the decisions, and being in an at risk category I'm not looking at it from the I'm alright Jack camp, but I do feel that when this is all over there'll be a lot of looking back and questions over whether it was all worth it.

 


Living down here does have some advantages. At least you can see them cry.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 16 Mar 20 1.18pm

Originally posted by Matov

Sorry but isolating is not about saving lives. It is all about spreading out the deaths so that come the winter, less people die of the second wave.

The lack of a basic level of understanding about how viruses work is staggering. Nobody has a natural immunity to Covid-19. Therefore the only way to stop it is to prevent the spread is having 60% of the population to have had it and got better.

If anything those of us who are not in the at-risk groups should be deliberately infected with it. We should be socialising more, in optimum conditions for it to spread.

I would happily be infected today so that within 10 days I can get on with normal life.

OK, perhaps I am a bit of a lunatic but seriously, the only effective action is to ensure that most of us get it but spread out over the months to come. Not hide away from it now so that it can come back and bite us on the arse in November with a long winter ahead.

Catch Covid-19 now if you are under 70 and are not already having to visit the Doctor once a month.

Edited by Matov (16 Mar 2020 12.14pm)

A medical specialist this morning said wanting to get it is as risky and stupid as you can get looking at the stats of how many get it and then die from it in all of the age groups. If everyone gets the strongest form of the virus there will be hundreds of thousand deaths.

 


COYP

mezzer Flag Main Stand, Block F, Row 20 seat 1... 16 Mar 20 1.20pm

Another thought. With the likelihood of major job losses and mortgage arrears on the horizon, wouldn't it be great to have something called PPI to protect ourselves?

Any lawyers out there who fancy a radio ad campaign along the lines of "Were you wrongly compensated for your PPI?'

Could make a fortune.

 


Living down here does have some advantages. At least you can see them cry.

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 16 Mar 20 1.26pm

We have a ready-made excuse for not doing any transfer business.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Mapletree Flag Croydon 16 Mar 20 1.42pm

Originally posted by mezzer

Another thought. With the likelihood of major job losses and mortgage arrears on the horizon, wouldn't it be great to have something called PPI to protect ourselves?

Any lawyers out there who fancy a radio ad campaign along the lines of "Were you wrongly compensated for your PPI?'

Could make a fortune.

Misconception

It was never designed to 'protect ourselves', only the lenders. Which is why it was a mis-sell.

 

Page 21 of 753 < 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic