This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by 7mins
Yes, but this shows my point about BLM (and the media to some extent) they called it murder, they couldn't care less if it was justifiable or not. The lads dad said "whites" are killing us, he had no idea it was a black police officer. It's the language of hate, it's not the currency that's needed right now. White people men and woman were pulled from their cars and beaten in Milwaukee. That plays right in to the hands of the far right. BLM are in the same conversation as the (current) KKK for me. an odd grouping. you may not like BLM but it's in response to a long list of racist activities against black americans, specifically from law enforcement. their tactics, at times, are unjustafiable. their goals are justifiable, though. the kkk is a group of racists who wear stupid outfits, for an unjustafiable purpose. not the same thing. not even close.
|
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Because America and American politics has for well over a decade hated facts. Its all about emotion and feeling. I'd stay clear of hyperbole such as comparing the Klan to BLM. That kind of hyperbole is Godwin's Law of argument (and lets not forget that the Klan exists today because of what it did in the past, and what its members still do and support). Acting on racism is never justified. Its the cycle of absurdity playing out, in which the stupid and the ignorant are pandered to. No number of wrongs make a right like attacking people indiscriminately. I get why people might target the police. But random white people, is just the same ignorant hate s**t you're supposed to be against.
Some of the chants heard at BLM marches make my blood run cold. They are without doubt a hateful ideology. I hope the UK doesn't follow suit, them silly nuggets that closed Heathrow are harmless, but these things could morph in to the hateful movement we're seeing in America.
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by 7mins
Some of the chants heard at BLM marches make my blood run cold. They are without doubt a hateful ideology. I hope the UK doesn't follow suit, them silly nuggets that closed Heathrow are harmless, but these things could morph in to the hateful movement we're seeing in America. But you can see just how inflammatory a statement like that is, given the history associated with the Klan - especially in an argument that's heavily influenced by arguments about race. Even when you say current KKK, people remember just exactly how cruel, brutal and influential the likes of the Klan used to be.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
But you can see just how inflammatory a statement like that is, given the history associated with the Klan - especially in an argument that's heavily influenced by arguments about race. Even when you say current KKK, people remember just exactly how cruel, brutal and influential the likes of the Klan used to be. It's only inflammatory if people purposely misread what I said. I have quite clearly said that the KKK of old were far far worse, if people disregard that to score points, it tells me their argument is weak. In Milwaukee, they were hunting for white people to beat up, this is what happens when BLM spreads their hateful message.
|
|
|
Originally posted by 7mins
It's only inflammatory if people purposely misread what I said. I have quite clearly said that the KKK of old were far far worse, if people disregard that to score points, it tells me their argument is weak. In Milwaukee, they were hunting for white people to beat up, this is what happens when BLM spreads their hateful message. It's worked its way over here as well. All those wannabe BLM cockroaches are jumping on the bandwagon of an American movement that has absolutely NOTHING to do with England. All lives matter. Regardless of your skin colour, religion, gender, sexuality or nationality. Edited by Alexi_the_Eagle (16 Aug 2016 10.21am)
"Look at that. Accident blackspot? These aren't accidents! They're throwing themselves into the road gladly! Throwing themselves into the road to escape all this hideousness!" |
|
|
Originally posted by 7mins
It's only inflammatory if people purposely misread what I said. I have quite clearly said that the KKK of old were far far worse, if people disregard that to score points, it tells me their argument is weak. In Milwaukee, they were hunting for white people to beat up, this is what happens when BLM spreads their hateful message. The most sensible common sense opinion I have ever read on here in regards to what is a tricky subject. You are of course correct in everything you have said thus far. But don't expect a straight answer from anyone of the liberal persuasion on here. According to them it's just a backlash from the nasty old colonial days (some 300 + Years ago). Facts are these there are more white people shot by Police in america than black people, and yet every time a black person gets shot we have riots as it wasnt his fault, nice young lad, promising sports person etc etc. Nothing to do with the fact he pointed a gun at an armed police officer. The levels of apologistic nonsense on these and other threads of a similar nature is beyond anything I would expect for intelligent, and reasoned human beings.
"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Alexi_the_Eagle
It's worked its way over here as well. All those wannabe BLM cockroaches are jumping on the bandwagon of an American movement that has absolutely NOTHING to do with England. All lives matter. Regardless of your skin colour, religion, gender, sexuality or nationality. Edited by Alexi_the_Eagle (16 Aug 2016 10.21am) I think the point that's increasingly getting lost in the rhetoric and point scoring, is that the issue is that some lives matter more, as far as the state is concerned. Its a fairly true experience, that the police even in the UK, have a more 'heavy handed approach' to certain areas and groups in society, irrespective of the context of the situation. That this also includes a general application of more 'zero tolerance' approaches to poor, working class and ethnic minority groups, many of who are disproportionately targeted under things such as stop and search, regardless of the guidelines and rules regarding 'reasonable suspicion'. That's my experience, even as a white guy.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
I think the point that's increasingly getting lost in the rhetoric and point scoring, is that the issue is that some lives matter more, as far as the state is concerned. Its a fairly true experience, that the police even in the UK, have a more 'heavy handed approach' to certain areas and groups in society, irrespective of the context of the situation. That this also includes a general application of more 'zero tolerance' approaches to poor, working class and ethnic minority groups, many of who are disproportionately targeted under things such as stop and search, regardless of the guidelines and rules regarding 'reasonable suspicion'. That's my experience, even as a white guy. Possibly that's because the upper classes only blow their own heads off with a shotgun (when the financial crisis at the stately home gets too much), and the upper classes can afford to pay their dealer out of Granny's trust fund so don't have to mug old ladies for their pension money to pay for the habit.....
A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by becky
Possibly that's because the upper classes only blow their own heads off with a shotgun (when the financial crisis at the stately home gets too much), and the upper classes can afford to pay their dealer out of Granny's trust fund so don't have to mug old ladies for their pension money to pay for the habit..... Its usually more of a case they have the right friends to make sure the police are cordial and friendly, in their dealings with them. If you dawn raid some middle class c**t, the press will report the horrors and idignity of your treatment. If your working class or underclass, they'll package it for entertainment purposes. A lot of these problems are growing out of zero tolerance policing in the US being applied continually, rather than directed towards particular issues. An example can be found in Baltimore's poorer- white and black areas, where a zero tolerance anti-drug policy targeting 'corners' has expanded into becoming general policing approach to those areas, despite the successes garnered in moving gangs and dealers off of corners. You don't get that kind of approach dealing with dealers to the upper and middle classes, or even those who are provided the bulk supply and laundering the money.... The end result of continual zero tolerance policing is alienation of targeted communities, because it inevitably shifts from the target (where it might prove successful for the community) to the community in general. The middle and upper echelons of society will only see the stats, smile and pat themselves on the back. But in reality its self defeating, because it creates an unavoidable us and them situation. The war on drugs was lost 20 years ago. And yet in the US people are getting massive sentences for non-violent crimes, because they happen to live in poor areas. 55 years for 3 oz of Meth....
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Rubin
Divide and rule. The only effect BLM will have is white people becoming more racist towards black people. Legitimised by Obama and Clinton, and funded by George Soros, who's recent hacking has exposed and confirmed all his long suspected manipulation of world events. And white people. Division of class consciousness I think Marx called it, the reality being that poor whites, blacks and Hispanics have more in common, politically, than in conflict. A story as old as exploitation, keep them hating each other, and you never have to solve the problems.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by dannyh
The most sensible common sense opinion I have ever read on here in regards to what is a tricky subject. You are of course correct in everything you have said thus far. But don't expect a straight answer from anyone of the liberal persuasion on here. According to them it's just a backlash from the nasty old colonial days (some 300 + Years ago). Facts are these there are more white people shot by Police in america than black people, and yet every time a black person gets shot we have riots as it wasnt his fault, nice young lad, promising sports person etc etc. Nothing to do with the fact he pointed a gun at an armed police officer. The levels of apologistic nonsense on these and other threads of a similar nature is beyond anything I would expect for intelligent, and reasoned human beings. Sometimes, I feel that the liberal left are as much a danger on here. They seem to hold whites/police to a higher standard than blacks. If Zimmerman kills a black guy he is a prick (rightly so), we all condemn. Every 14hours a black man is killed by a fellow black man in Chicago.... No condemnation, is it that we expect that of blacks... They can't be helped, so why bother condemning them, they're a bunch of savages, would we expect any better?
|
|
|
Originally posted by 7mins
Sometimes, I feel that the liberal left are as much a danger on here. They seem to hold whites/police to a higher standard than blacks. If Zimmerman kills a black guy he is a prick (rightly so), we all condemn. Every 14hours a black man is killed by a fellow black man in Chicago.... No condemnation, is it that we expect that of blacks... They can't be helped, so why bother condemning them, they're a bunch of savages, would we expect any better? Spot on even Jamie the liberal flag bearer You Just can't win with people who do not, or will not see that the different races within the human race are not the same and that until those markedly different traits are excepted, by those who are effected by them, and the people themselves nothing will ever change.
"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by 7mins
Sometimes, I feel that the liberal left are as much a danger on here. They seem to hold whites/police to a higher standard than blacks. If Zimmerman kills a black guy he is a prick (rightly so), we all condemn. Every 14hours a black man is killed by a fellow black man in Chicago.... No condemnation, is it that we expect that of blacks... They can't be helped, so why bother condemning them, they're a bunch of savages, would we expect any better? Well police should be held to a higher standard than the average citizen for fairly obvious reasons, and it would be absurd to hold police to the same standards as ordinary citizens. By default all professionals are held to a higher standard, that's the nature of being a professional, undergoing professional training etc. The issue with black on black violence isn't relevant, because the criminal justice and law enforcement system in place deal, often excessively, with this problem. But there is a massive problem in parts of the US with how the police operate, how they're managed, how their actions are reviewed and oversight. There is also a massive problem in the US with guns and the willing acceptance of the use of lethal force as an immediate resort or response. On white and black, and typically the poor. US Policing policies have increasingly created a 'us and them' situation in poor communities regarding the police, of which the BLM has become a focus (largely because the white poor don't have a civil rights movement in place to protect them) My issue with the whole mess in the US is that only some citizens are deemed responsible for their actions not all, and that with the police in the US, there is a problem that's escalated out of the failure to implement responsibility and clear, independent oversight that is responsible for people being killed unnecessarily and by unprofessional police behaviour.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Well police should be held to a higher standard than the average citizen for fairly obvious reasons, and it would be absurd to hold police to the same standards as ordinary citizens. By default all professionals are held to a higher standard, that's the nature of being a professional, undergoing professional training etc. When their ultimate line of defence is used against them i.e. Guns, then just how are they supposed to take the moral high ground when a firearm arm is used against them. They are human after all Jamie, and with all the training in the world only an idiot with a death wish wouldn't fire if being fired upon. Point being is someone is waving a gun at you, the kill or be killed question comes into play and regardless of my personal training I know what I would do. The issue with black on black violence isn't relevant, because the criminal justice and law enforcement system in place deal, often excessively, with this problem. It is relevant in as much white cop on black person shootings, falls into insignificance when compared to black on black gun crime and murder, so where's the movement/group to protest about that ? The racist word or oppression can't be applied so it gets no traction. But there is a massive problem in parts of the US with how the police operate, how they're managed, how their actions are reviewed and oversight. There is also a massive problem in the US with guns and the willing acceptance of the use of lethal force as an immediate resort or response. On white and black, and typically the poor. Jamie as I said earlier, if the entire population of a country is allowed by law to carry a gun, then is it any surprise the Police do to ? I do however agree that some of the more shall we say "remote" areas in the US where 50 percent of the town is called cleetus, and the other half Mary Jane, (and Where the film Deliverance is used as an instructional sex ed film) the policing is as basic as the people living there. I also agree that there should be a complete overhaul of the way policing is done in the US. US Policing policies have increasingly created a 'us and them' situation in poor communities regarding the police, of which the BLM has become a focus (largely because the white poor don't have a civil rights movement in place to protect them) They are police officers, they are not there to be children's entertainers and your best mate, they are there to uphold the law and protect people from those who would break it. IMO you always tend to find groups like the BLM are spawned out of hatred for ones own lot in life, and an incorrect assumption that you are owed what your neighbour has, well no, actually your not. Your entitled to what you work for, not what you steal. My issue with the whole mess in the US is that only some citizens are deemed responsible for their actions not all, and that with the police in the US, there is a problem that's escalated out of the failure to implement responsibility and clear, independent oversight that is responsible for people being killed unnecessarily and by unprofessional police behaviour. The issue is not with the officers. Again as I stated before if someone reaches for a gun in a country where Police officers are shot and killed everyday and you also have a gun, it's self preservation. Killings of any race by police officers in the US of any race will continue until the gun issue is solved. No gun = no shootings. Edited by dannyh (17 Aug 2016 10.06am)
"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by dannyh
When their ultimate line of defence is used against them i.e. Guns, then just how are they supposed to take the moral high ground when a firearm arm is used against them. They are human after all Jamie, and with all the training in the world only an idiot with a death wish wouldn't fire if being fired upon. Point being is someone is waving a gun at you, the kill or be killed question comes into play and regardless of my personal training I know what I would do Context is everything. Police officers put in a shoot or be shot situation, aren't the issue. Its police officers who are responding with force disproportionate to the situation they're in. Being fired on, of course they have to respond to the situation they find themselves in. Police officers have to be as accountable for the use of force, because the state permits the use of force to them. Without establishing independently that the use of force was justified, the system just breaks down. But that's different that shooting people who are restrained, or in a car who've informed you they have a carry permit and a gun. Also situations where you shoot a 12 year old kid with a toy gun, within seconds of getting out the car, rather than controlling the situation are the problem. Then of course there is the case of people who are not armed, being shot by police officers. Which is different to a British police response to a suspected firearm, which is to control the scene, and try to avoid engaging in a shoot out. The police are more accountable because its their job. If I'm s**t at my job, make stupid mistakes and so on, I get sacked. But that's not the case, by a long shot. The police close ranks, and politicians and DA's dependent on police union support in elections, tend to protect officers, rather than establish a reasonable truth of events. When you join the police, like any profession, you're putting yourself into a situation where you are expected to react as an expert. For a police officer, that means expecting to be put into dangerous situations, and to control them. It cannot and shouldn't be that you get carte blanche to the use of force. Originally posted by dannyh
It is relevant in as much white cop on black person shootings, falls into insignificance when compared to black on black gun crime and murder, so where's the movement/group to protest about that ? The racist word or oppression can't be applied so it gets no traction. Black on Black Gun Crime is enforced by the police, and those people who killed those police men, were all arrested and charged - They don't need protest groups - job was done, they're dead or going to prison. How would a protest be valid... Protest typically reflects social injustice, not support for existing status quo, and there is definitely social injustice when it comes to the US criminal justice system and the poor. You have a situation where people are pleading guilty because the entire system is stacked against the poor. Originally posted by dannyh
Jamie as I said earlier, if the entire population of a country is allowed by law to carry a gun, then is it any surprise the Police do to ? I do however agree that some of the more shall we say "remote" areas in the US where 50 percent of the town is called cleetus, and the other half Mary Jane, (and Where the film Deliverance is used as an instructional sex ed film) the policing is as basic as the people living there. I also agree that there should be a complete overhaul of the way policing is done in the US. Very few people in the US are legally allowed to carry a gun, and all of them require a specific permit. Policing and training has to be conducted to higher standards when you're talking about licensing agents of the state and law enforcement to utilise lethal force against citizens. The US funding of the police in most of these areas is poor, the selection processes based around need not capacity, and you have officers with little more than accadamy training, put into deal with situations where a British Police Officer would likely have had two years training, two to five years experience and specialist training to deal with. Originally posted by dannyh
They are police officers, they are not there to be children's entertainers and your best mate, they are there to uphold the law and protect people from those who would break it. IMO you always tend to find groups like the BLM are spawned out of hatred for ones own lot in life, and an incorrect assumption that you are owed what your neighbour has, well no, actually your not. Your entitled to what you work for, not what you steal. I think BLM reflects a general issue in the US, but its only BLM that's heard, because the Black Civil Rights Movement in the US is a powerful lobby group and that's how US politics works. Shout the loudest, spend the most representation. Plenty of examples of similar situations in which whites have been killed, by police, but no one cares because the white poor do not have a voice. Obviously the police have a job to do. But they also have a wider requirement, they're also responsible for the protection of suspects and their rights. Its a tighter line to walk than most people, but when you sign up to become a police officer that's the job. Not to protect and serve those you like, but everyone. Even the people breaking the law. Originally posted by dannyh
The issue is not with the officers. Again as I stated before if someone reaches for a gun in a country where Police officers are shot and killed everyday and you also have a gun, it's self preservation. Killings of any race by police officers in the US of any race will continue until the gun issue is solved. No gun = no shootings. Yeah, but what about those shot and killed who are unarmed, suspicion of being armed is usually enough, and that's a very vague area. I agree, if someone is going to pull a gun, or you know they are armed and look likely to pull a gun, you may have to shoot someone. No one doubts that. But this isn't about those cases, and it shouldn't be, its about those cases where 'shootings are justified and accepted' where the use of force in any reasonable sense isn't defendable - even when a gun is present. And there seems to have been a lot of these in the US, not just of black people, but the homeless, mentall ill and the poor (irrespective of race), because the US upholds a defence of 'aggressively targeting the poor with zero tolerance policing'
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
If social injustice feeds protest, would you support a White Lives Matter style protest directed at black people who commit far too much crime against them?
|
|
|
Originally posted by 7mins
If social injustice feeds protest, would you support a White Lives Matter style protest directed at black people who commit far too much crime against them? I might if I lived in South Africa or Zimbabwe. But generally I'm too lazy.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by 7mins
If social injustice feeds protest, would you support a White Lives Matter style protest directed at black people who commit far too much crime against them? No, because its selectively racist and the police are notably very effective at pursuing crime committed by black people (given the rates of incarceration and zero tolerance programs aimed at black crime). I don't see what you'd be protesting - There is no social injustice to white people in how US law enforcement pursue crime committed by black people. I don't support BLM either, I support the idea that the police must be accountable in a clear and just manner for their action, irrespective of the race, social class, gender or sexuality. However, I do realise that BLM highlight a very valid issue with the use of excessive force, lethal force and how they target the poor (of all racial hues) and how the justice system fails the poor in the US time and again, which showing preference to offenders of middle and upper class groups. Its not a race thing, its a class thing.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
I might if I lived in South Africa or Zimbabwe. But generally I'm too lazy. That's because as far as the state of SA and Zimbabwe go, White Lives Don't Matter (although in fairness neither do most black lives either...).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.