This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Brentmiester_General
It doesn’t matter. We’re picking up points with him in the team. Weren’t with Hennesey in the side. Unless you love Hennessey above Palace then surely even you can see that we’re doing much better since Julian has been in goal for us. I’m not saying that it’s because of Julian, i’m Just saying that the team has stopped the rot and that we’re turning things around since he’s been in the team. Can you confirm or deny this please? What a stupid thing to say! Obviously we've picked up more points since he's been in the team as we had none before then. But it's not down to him. Try and understand simple maths - Hennessey faced 45 shots in 7 games and let in 17 goals; Speroni has faced 10 shots in 3 games and let in 4 goals. Hennessey has better stats (62% of shots saved c/w 60%) but faced a lot more shots (not his fault surely?) and consequently let in more goals. More valid surely as to why we've been doing better is that we've actually scored some goals, down to Zaha being back in the side and Puncheon not so.
|
|
|
Originally posted by jeeagles
One of my biggest criticism of Hennessey is that his distribution is terrible. Speroni's hasn't been great but at the end of the game yesterday he was getting the ball back up the pitch really quickly. If it wasn't for that urgency we wouldn't have scored. No - his kicking is accurate and normally finds the head of Benteke (when he's playing). Speroni does these awful kicks with backspin that just hang in the air and are easy pickings for defenders. Yes, Speroni started the move that led to the equalizer yesterday, but it was just a roll-out to a defender a few yards away, not exactly difficult.
|
|
| Brentmiester_General |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by cpj
What a stupid thing to say! Obviously we've picked up more points since he's been in the team as we had none before then. But it's not down to him. Try and understand simple maths - Hennessey faced 45 shots in 7 games and let in 17 goals; Speroni has faced 10 shots in 3 games and let in 4 goals. Hennessey has better stats (62% of shots saved c/w 60%) but faced a lot more shots (not his fault surely?) and consequently let in more goals. More valid surely as to why we've been doing better is that we've actually scored some goals, down to Zaha being back in the side and Puncheon not so. That’s all that matters in my book. No need to debate any further is there. You’re simply arguing to continue the argument but it’s over. Drop it and move on before you make yourself look even more silly.
"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ... |
|
|
Originally posted by PalacePhotoMan
The first goal was hit first time from about 8 yards out like a rocket. I was right behind it and it flew in. It might have hit a keeper and stayed out had it been hit straight at him. But it wasn't and although he got a hand to it, there's no way it was his fault it went in. If you have to blame anyone for this it was whoever left the over-lapping left back unmarked. The second goal was hit just under the crossbar from 20 yards. A 6' 7" keeper might have stopped it but I doubt it. Again, if you have to blame anyone, Luka lost the ball in midfield and then Dann failed to tackle the scorer and also allowed him to turn back onto his favoured left foot. Not every goal conceded is a goalkeeper's fault. Goals go in, no matter who the keeper is. Is there a West Ham thread blaming Hart for Wilf's goal? You are of course correct and had a great view. The first also took a deflection off Tomkins. Jules had little chance with either of the goals yesterday just as Wayne wasn't to blame for any of Bristol City's on Tuesday. Some seriously misguided rubbish being posted on here now.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cpj
The stats prove otherwise. Speroni is costing us points - we should have won yesterday. There was only one goalie that cost us the points yesterday and it wasn't Speroni.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Painter
There was only one goalie that cost us the points yesterday and it wasn't Speroni. Hart made 7 saves from 9 shots on target; Speroni made no saves from 2 on target. You're happy with that? If WH had been in goal would you still have been happy?
|
|
| Brentmiester_General |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by cpj
Hart made 7 saves from 9 shots on target; Speroni made no saves from 2 on target. You're happy with that? If WH had been in goal would you still have been happy? So he let in the same amount of goals as Hart. What’s your point?
"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ... |
|
|
Originally posted by cpj
Hart made 7 saves from 9 shots on target; Speroni made no saves from 2 on target. You're happy with that? If WH had been in goal would you still have been happy? If both rolled trough his legs obviously not. Hennessey let in 4 goals from 5 on target from championship Bristol City. Like I said earlier, if it's the keepers fault I'll call it. Against Bristol, IMO none of them were Wayne's fault. Yesterday they weren't Julian's IMO, so no I have no problem with that.
That's Life |
|
|
Originally posted by cpj
Hart made 7 saves from 9 shots on target; Speroni made no saves from 2 on target. You're happy with that? If WH had been in goal would you still have been happy? I am not having a go at either Palace keeper, just pointing out that Hart stopped us winning virtually on his own.
|
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by cpj
What a stupid thing to say! Obviously we've picked up more points since he's been in the team as we had none before then. But it's not down to him. Try and understand simple maths - Hennessey faced 45 shots in 7 games and let in 17 goals; Speroni has faced 10 shots in 3 games and let in 4 goals. Hennessey has better stats (62% of shots saved c/w 60%) but faced a lot more shots (not his fault surely?) and consequently let in more goals. More valid surely as to why we've been doing better is that we've actually scored some goals, down to Zaha being back in the side and Puncheon not so. Anyone who thinks it's valid to compare 62% of 45 with 60% of 10 needs to learn the meaning of the term "statistically significant", especially with reference to sample size.
============ |
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by cpj
Hart made 7 saves from 9 shots on target; Speroni made no saves from 2 on target. You're happy with that? If WH had been in goal would you still have been happy? And does everyone understand that how good the shots were has something to do with it? Yesterday three of the four goals came from unsaveable shots and the fourth was a penalty. Hart was lucky to stop a couple that ought to have been unsaveable. Proves nothing. It would be just as easy (and similarly invalid) to point at all the clean sheets Hennessey has kept for Wales, and the single goal they conceded against Ireland (which again everyone seems to think was 100% his fault), and then at the 2-2 draw between Scotland and England, and conclude that Hennessey is a better keeper than Hart.
============ |
|
| michaelpearce |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
Anyone who thinks it's valid to compare 62% of 45 with 60% of 10 needs to learn the meaning of the term "statistically significant", especially with reference to sample size. You cant write that makes it sound like you know what you are talking about
|
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by michaelpearce
You cant write that makes it sound like you know what you are talking about When we quote two statistics for comparison - in this case, % shots stopped by goalkeepers - and we want to show that one is "better" than the other, we can only make that assertion based on a certain level of confidence. The level of confidence is a function of the difference and the sample size; the sample size implies the standard deviation of the population sampled. The difference between the found values in standard deviations determines the level of confidence: two standard deviations, 97.5%; three, 99.75%, and so on. The sample size here is vanishingly small and the difference in the found values would give a level of confidence so low that no meaningful statement could be made. Add to that that no consideration has been given to the quality of the defences, the quality of the shots, the prevailing sightlines (cited in Spam's excuse for Wilf's goal), and so on, and it will be clear that any attempt to state that either keeper is better than the other based on these games alone is futile. Edited by chateauferret (29 Oct 2017 6.07pm)
============ |
|
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
And does everyone understand that how good the shots were has something to do with it? Yesterday three of the four goals came from unsaveable shots and the fourth was a penalty. Hart was lucky to stop a couple that ought to have been unsaveable. Proves nothing. It would be just as easy (and similarly invalid) to point at all the clean sheets Hennessey has kept for Wales, and the single goal they conceded against Ireland (which again everyone seems to think was 100% his fault), and then at the 2-2 draw between Scotland and England, and conclude that Hennessey is a better keeper than Hart.
They really don't. Most people I've spoken to down here blamed Williams for calling for the ball and then getting caught in possession.
'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more' |
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by johnno42000
They really don't. Most people I've spoken to down here blamed Williams for calling for the ball and then getting caught in possession. Well, that would be my view too, but there were quite a few on here saying that Hennessey shouldn't have listened to the idiot.
============ |
|
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
When we quote two statistics for comparison - in this case, % shots stopped by goalkeepers - and we want to show that one is "better" than the other, we can only make that assertion based on a certain level of confidence. The level of confidence is a function of the difference and the sample size; the sample size implies the standard deviation of the population sampled. The difference between the found values in standard deviations determines the level of confidence: two standard deviations, 97.5%; three, 99.75%, and so on. The sample size here is vanishingly small and the difference in the found values would give a level of confidence so low that no meaningful statement could be made. Add to that that no consideration has been given to the quality of the defences, the quality of the shots, the prevailing sightlines (cited in Spam's excuse for Wilf's goal), and so on, and it will be clear that any attempt to state that either keeper is better than the other based on these games alone is futile. Edited by chateauferret (29 Oct 2017 6.07pm) I've got A Level Maths thanks and know about sample sizes - unfortunately those games are all we have from this season to use. My point is that there's little between the keepers. It's certainly more valid to compare shot/save percentages even form a small sample than just say WH has concede more goals therefore is a worse keeper which seems to be Brent's argument.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.