You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Alexander Sörloth
November 22 2026 8.03pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Alexander Sörloth


Page 22 of 32 < 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 >
Stirlingsays Flag 16 Sep 20 6.04pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

Eddie Newton has confirmed Sorloth has told him he doesn't want to play for Trans anymore. Well, there's the gratitude you get for finally being given a chance. Not "I want to leave but until I do I'll give you 100%". Nope, instead it's "A big club wants me so I'm off". Starting to think him and his Dad might be a couple of starstruck tw*ts.

Just give us 10m and pi$$ off.

I get the annoyance regarding any form of loyalty.

However, football clubs themselves only have significant loyalty to players who hold fiscal value for them. This is a business and while relationships obviously develop the bottom line is never far away from how long a footballer is at a club.

So as football is a short career the motivation for a player to not miss out on making as much money as possible is a strong one.

Back in the day when a player's wages were more related to the working man the loyalty aspect could play a larger role. Football had a far closer connection to the working class then. It would be more common for a first team player to see out his career with his first club...Cannon for us, Brooking for West Ham and so on.

Now top level football like the Premier league is more corporate and as such more impersonal. Proper money disconnects.

It's why your local lower league club will feel more grounded and connected to its area.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Spiderman Flag Horsham 16 Sep 20 6.42pm

We may have played a blinder 14m + add ons. 34m for Sorloth ffs

324E777C-5078-4E32-9268-7511091BDA4B.jpeg Attachment: 324E777C-5078-4E32-9268-7511091BDA4B.jpeg (91.13Kb)

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 16 Sep 20 6.44pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

I get the annoyance regarding any form of loyalty.

However, football clubs themselves only have significant loyalty to players who hold fiscal value for them. This is a business and while relationships obviously develop the bottom line is never far away from how long a footballer is at a club.

So as football is a short career the motivation for a player to not miss out on making as much money as possible is a strong one.

Back in the day when a player's wages were more related to the working man the loyalty aspect could play a larger role. Football had a far closer connection to the working class then. It would be more common for a first team player to see out his career with his first club...Cannon for us, Brooking for West Ham and so on.

Now top level football like the Premier league is more corporate and as such more impersonal. Proper money disconnects.

It's why your local lower league club will feel more grounded and connected to its area.


Good post Stirling. Also in those days loyalty would earn you a testimonial match which could be worth a significant sum and helped a player at the end of his career to move on into another sphere

 

sotac464 Flag Berkshire 16 Sep 20 6.54pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

Eddie Newton has confirmed Sorloth has told him he doesn't want to play for Trans anymore. Well, there's the gratitude you get for finally being given a chance. Not "I want to leave but until I do I'll give you 100%". Nope, instead it's "A big club wants me so I'm off". Starting to think him and his Dad might be a couple of starstruck tw*ts.

Just give us 10m and pi$$ off.

Why would that bother you? Ffs no club was interested in him when he bombed at Palace, Hes gone and made a name for himself, and performed, Trabs will earn out of this as well as Palace.

That's football, good luck to him, because personally I thought his career was over, apart from going back to Norway.

I wish him all the best, personal attack's on ex palace players, not warranted.

 


My equalibrium unbalanced me. Paul Draper Brighton 19/2/2018

lefty27 Flag ipswich 16 Sep 20 7.36pm

Anything we get is a bonus, we can all argue about if he had chances with us or not. He was s*** when he played, I remember fans of the club he came from laughing at us because we paid what we did, the truth is the only reason he is worth anything is because he scored 33 goals in Turkey. The Turks have increased his value so are due a cut.

 

deleted 25 Flag 16 Sep 20 7.48pm

Originally posted by Putitout


parish, and the club have been slagged on here time and time again for being to cautious , Taking to long checking every little detail of an in coming transfer.. caution seems to be the watchword. That behaviour doesn’t seem to fit the profile of someone who would agree to pay £9mill to retain his own player.

Too cautious? I don't think so. Spending within your means is sensible, but writing off a player after 8 starts is from the same mold as sacking a manager after 4 games. Its reactionary. Palace are due to miss out on a striker that could have been what we have been looking for since Murray

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 16 Sep 20 9.18pm

Originally posted by Vincehair

Too cautious? I don't think so. Spending within your means is sensible, but writing off a player after 8 starts is from the same mold as sacking a manager after 4 games. Its reactionary. Palace are due to miss out on a striker that could have been what we have been looking for since Murray

This does have merit imo.
If fdb stayed we may play better than we do and still be in the top league.
If sorloth stayed we could have a 20 goal striker.
I suppose if your aunt had a pair she would be your uncle so it's all ifs buts and maybes.

I'll get me coat!

Edited by cryrst (16 Sep 2020 9.18pm)

 

thechaddyboy Flag Peterborough 16 Sep 20 9.27pm

Still baffled as to how they've managed to walk off with 20m for a player they don't own & other than part covering his wages they've laid out sod all. €34m is a hell of a deal if correct but how have we not got the Lion's share ?

 


Red & Blue since 73'

sprites Flag Auckland 16 Sep 20 9.33pm

I'm also just catching up on all this now.

Why can't we get him back again? Or do we just not want to...? If anyone's earned a second crack here, it's got to be him?

Sorry you're all probably sick of talking about it.

 

Ali_Campbell Flag New Addington 16 Sep 20 9.39pm

Originally posted by Vincehair

Too cautious? I don't think so. Spending within your means is sensible, but writing off a player after 8 starts is from the same mold as sacking a manager after 4 games. Its reactionary. Palace are due to miss out on a striker that could have been what we have been looking for since Murray

Did you watch any of those 8 starts?
Did you see any of the 19 games for Gent?

It is frustrating that he has gone away and done well. Did anyone think at the time he would be the next Glenn Murray. More Judy Murray the games I watched.

If we can some how make a tidy profit on a player that has managed 16 games for us and scored zero goals. I think the club should be congratulated.

Batshuayi’s record in a Roy team was 11 games, 6 goals. FYI

 

Jacey Flag 16 Sep 20 9.42pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

We may have played a blinder 14m + add ons. 34m for Sorloth ffs

What a blinder for the Turkish side who pay us the contractual price of £6m and pocket the huge balance.
They must have taken Palace as mugs to have arranged these terms!!

 

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 16 Sep 20 9.52pm

Two differen players

batsy will run away trying to fine the ball


Sorlorth was a No 9... different role. one role uncle roy is clueless about!
Bet Murray was pleased he didnt play under Roy, Glenn would have been stuck on the wing and told to defend!!


Originally posted by Ali_Campbell

Did you watch any of those 8 starts?
Did you see any of the 19 games for Gent?

It is frustrating that he has gone away and done well. Did anyone think at the time he would be the next Glenn Murray. More Judy Murray the games I watched.

If we can some how make a tidy profit on a player that has managed 16 games for us and scored zero goals. I think the club should be congratulated.

Batshuayi’s record in a Roy team was 11 games, 6 goals. FYI

 

Ali_Campbell Flag New Addington 16 Sep 20 10.14pm

Originally posted by A1969Eagle

Two differen players

batsy will run away trying to fine the ball


Sorlorth was a No 9... different role. one role uncle roy is clueless about!
Bet Murray was pleased he didnt play under Roy, Glenn would have been stuck on the wing and told to defend!!

Well bats enjoyed playing under Roy, that’s why he agreed to come back. Roy must be doing something right if he gets the best out of certain players and they are willing to play for him. I guess, Genk didn’t play to sorloths strengths either. 1 Trick pony if you ask me.


 

the.universal 16 Sep 20 10.30pm

Originally posted by Vincehair

Too cautious? I don't think so. Spending within your means is sensible, but writing off a player after 8 starts is from the same mold as sacking a manager after 4 games. Its reactionary. Palace are due to miss out on a striker that could have been what we have been looking for since Murray

Drawing a parallel with the sacking of De Boer is not a strong case. You’ll find few, if any that think sacking him after 4 games and replacing with Roy was a bad move.

Same with Sorloth. I don’t think any player ‘deserves’ a chance. You have to earn each and every start until you’re established in the first team. Sorloth never did that and frankly was terrible for us. No goals, no assists, no effort, no physicality. I’d argue he was mismanaged, which was the club’s fault. He wasn’t ready for the prem and the pressure a big money move bought, but now he has really found his feet.

Good luck to him but he was total and utter crap for us. Sometimes things just don’t work out. Hopefully we’ll get some decent cash from the transfer.

 


Vive le Roy!

EddieMac Flag 16 Sep 20 10.41pm

Originally posted by lefty27

Anything we get is a bonus, we can all argue about if he had chances with us or not. He was s*** when he played, I remember fans of the club he came from laughing at us because we paid what we did, the truth is the only reason he is worth anything is because he scored 33 goals in Turkey. The Turks have increased his value so are due a cut.

Most sensible post of the day for me. Nail smack on the head.

 

EddieMac Flag 16 Sep 20 10.43pm

Originally posted by Ali_Campbell

Did you watch any of those 8 starts?
Did you see any of the 19 games for Gent?

It is frustrating that he has gone away and done well. Did anyone think at the time he would be the next Glenn Murray. More Judy Murray the games I watched.

If we can some how make a tidy profit on a player that has managed 16 games for us and scored zero goals. I think the club should be congratulated.

Batshuayi’s record in a Roy team was 11 games, 6 goals. FYI

I couldn’t believe my eyes when I watched him play for us. I thought we’d been stitched up.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 16 Sep 20 10.46pm

Originally posted by Jacey

What a blinder for the Turkish side who pay us the contractual price of £6m and pocket the huge balance.
They must have taken Palace as mugs to have arranged these terms!!

We get any ongoing bonuses ref goals and titles etc. Plus a sell on %. If sorloth does the biz and goes to a huge club then palace will get a bucket load more. If not we are still 5m in profit after paying for him. Not bad, a mark up of 50% from 20 games.

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 17 Sep 20 1.05am

If there was enough space the title of this thread would IMO better read

"Have a guess at the Sorloth deal terms and conditions and any money we might recoup after he leaves Trabanspor"


Everyone is entitled to have an opinion but no one across the CPFC platforms I have seen actually knows and
CPFC will never make public.

Personally I would like him in our squad but if not at least recoup some of his cost.

Good luck to him

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

sprites Flag Auckland 17 Sep 20 5.27am

Originally posted by EddieMac

I couldn’t believe my eyes when I watched him play for us. I thought we’d been stitched up.

See I never thought he was that bad. Certainly not that bad for the 9 minutes at the end of each game he was getting or something. I remember him rifling one in against Chelsea that was marginally disallowed, going on the odd promising run and holding the ball up quite well at times.

Edited by sprites (17 Sep 2020 5.28am)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 17 Sep 20 5.56am

Originally posted by sprites

See I never thought he was that bad. Certainly not that bad for the 9 minutes at the end of each game he was getting or something. I remember him rifling one in against Chelsea that was marginally disallowed, going on the odd promising run and holding the ball up quite well at times.

Edited by sprites (17 Sep 2020 5.28am)

Sörloth was never given a serious chance at Palace, his game time was mainly as sub.

The club must obviously have had a good look at him and it appears they saw nothing special compared to what they had.

Personally I view him as a forward type that Palace aren't set up for. We base our style around counter attacking and while Zaha is here nothing's changing....and that's not Sorloth's game.

I think in a team set up for his playing style he will continue to do well.

It is what it is.....Let's see what the club can get for him.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Page 22 of 32 < 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Alexander Sörloth