This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
Thanks your answer, so basically Antifa depending on your definitions of nationalist and racist which are subjective terms. I would certainly not apply the tag fascist to the concerned citizens of Newquay Hammas would tick all the boxes.
Edited by HKOwen (29 Mar 2023 1.48pm) I'd tend to disagree that nationalism and racism are subjective terms. There might well be an attempt to paint them as such by L/R in the current discourse but they're both easily definable by rational individuals. Also as outlined above just because you're nationalist and racist doesn't make you a facist. If you believe in those things to extremes and support or act out violence in their name, then sure, that's the final piece of the facist puzzle. There are no doubt individuals or factions within most groups that are facist by definition, whether that's Antifa, EDL, BDP, The New Red Brigades, Hammas... As for Newquay, as a group they might not be, but who knows, there may be some individuals that could be tagged as such. Just like on this site.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
I'd tend to disagree that nationalism and racism are subjective terms. There might well be an attempt to paint them as such by L/R in the current discourse but they're both easily definable by rational individuals. Also as outlined above just because you're nationalist and racist doesn't make you a facist. If you believe in those things to extremes and support or act out violence in their name, then sure, that's the final piece of the facist puzzle. There are no doubt individuals or factions within most groups that are facist by definition, whether that's Antifa, EDL, BDP, The New Red Brigades, Hammas... As for Newquay, as a group they might not be, but who knows, there may be some individuals that could be tagged as such. Just like on this site. Who on this site would you tagg as Fascist?
|
|
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
Thanks your answer, so basically Antifa depending on your definitions of nationalist and racist which are subjective terms. I would certainly not apply the tag fascist to the concerned citizens of Newquay Hammas would tick all the boxes.
Edited by HKOwen (29 Mar 2023 1.48pm)
"Fascism is an ultranationalist, authoritarian political philosophy. It combines elements of nationalism, militarism, economic self-sufficiency, and totalitarianism. It does not permit disagreement and can use violence to suppress those who try to resist. It can hold a racist ideology." Tending towards something doesn't mean the journey is complete. Only that the journey has started and that warning bells must be sounded. I don't have detail on the individuals who comprised the two groups in Newquay, but some clearly thought some were demonstrating fascist tendencies whilst the other thought their opponents to be from the far-left. It's not such an unusual scenario! Edited by Wisbech Eagle (29 Mar 2023 3.54pm)
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
"Fascism is an ultranationalist, authoritarian political philosophy. It combines elements of nationalism, militarism, economic self-sufficiency, and totalitarianism. It does not permit disagreement and can use violence to suppress those who try to resist. It can hold a racist ideology." I don't have detail on the individuals who comprised the two groups in Newquay, but some clearly thought some were demonstrating fascist tendencies whilst the other thought their opponents to be from the far-left. It's not such an unusual scenario! Edited by Wisbech Eagle (29 Mar 2023 3.54pm) Sounds like Just Stop Oil.
|
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
I'd tend to disagree that nationalism and racism are subjective terms. There might well be an attempt to paint them as such by L/R in the current discourse but they're both easily definable by rational individuals. Also as outlined above just because you're nationalist and racist doesn't make you a facist. If you believe in those things to extremes and support or act out violence in their name, then sure, that's the final piece of the facist puzzle. There are no doubt individuals or factions within most groups that are facist by definition, whether that's Antifa, EDL, BDP, The New Red Brigades, Hammas... As for Newquay, as a group they might not be, but who knows, there may be some individuals that could be tagged as such. Just like on this site. So by your standard anyone who thinks nationalism and racism are subjective is irrational. You think there are users on here who encourage/participate in violence to achieve their political aims? Edited by HKOwen (29 Mar 2023 5.12pm)
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance. |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I'm not happy with what's happened here and what the direction of travel is. I'm just going to stop using the site as I can't be bothered with going through this again. I see that Durham University has recently discovered the Universe's largest Black Hole, 30 billions time the size of our Sun - perhaps they should call it Wisbech.
|
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
Sounds like Just Stop Oil. Much as I dislike that kind of direct action there is no way that those who resort to it can be legitimately described as fascist. Idiots, yes. Anti-democratic, yes. Counter-productive, yes. Fascist, no.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
So by your standard anyone who thinks nationalism and racism are subjective is irrational. You think there are users on here who encourage/participate in violence to achieve their political aims? Edited by HKOwen (29 Mar 2023 5.12pm) On the first point Maybe they are if you're looking through an ideological lens – people twist the definitions all the time on both sides of the debate. eg. the left crying racism at every opportunity and the right constantly denying any mention of it. That's applied subjectivity to definitions that aren't subjective. Much like making a statement that 'not all nationalists are racists.' But that doesn't mean that no nationalists are racists. Similarly facism is rather obviously not exclusive to the right. It's pretty obvious when something or someone is definably racist, for example, as the action or statements will neatly match the definitions. It only becomes subjective when, for example, someone who holds definable views (such as racism or nationalism for the sake of continuity) chooses not to be open about it. In that scenario you couldn't definitively say they were or were not, but you could hypothesise that they were based on those views being carefully leaked into conversation without going over the line. Dangerous game on both sides though, the accuser and the accused. The second point What one can do, though, is debate and give people a chance to respond accordingly. Otherwise the failure to do that makes those responsible start to look like the facist.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
On the first point Maybe they are if you're looking through an ideological lens – people twist the definitions all the time on both sides of the debate. eg. the left crying racism at every opportunity and the right constantly denying any mention of it. That's applied subjectivity to definitions that aren't subjective. Much like making a statement that 'not all nationalists are racists.' But that doesn't mean that no nationalists are racists. Similarly facism is rather obviously not exclusive to the right. It's pretty obvious when something or someone is definably racist, for example, as the action or statements will neatly match the definitions. It only becomes subjective when, for example, someone who holds definable views (such as racism or nationalism for the sake of continuity) chooses not to be open about it. In that scenario you couldn't definitively say they were or were not, but you could hypothesise that they were based on those views being carefully leaked into conversation without going over the line. Dangerous game on both sides though, the accuser and the accused. The second point What one can do, though, is debate and give people a chance to respond accordingly. Otherwise the failure to do that makes those responsible start to look like the facist. This is WE style wriggling, in court it would be called tailoring evidence. So when you say there are some on here that could be tagged as fascist what you meant was not that. Try owning what you post
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance. |
|
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
This is WE style wriggling, in court it would be called tailoring evidence. So when you say there are some on here that could be tagged as fascist what you meant was not that. Try owning what you post Disagree. I'll repeat the statement again and highlight the key words for you. 'There are no doubt individuals or factions within most groups that are facist by definition, whether that's Antifa, EDL, BDP, The New Red Brigades, Hammas...As for Newquay, as a group they might not be, but who knows, there may be some individuals that could be tagged as such. Just like on this site.' It's absolutely what I meant, and I don't think it's particularly controversial to extend the wider point to this site. It would be controversial and defamatory (not to mention highly personal and unnecessary) to start naming names or pointing fingers without definative evidence. As before, it would be unhelpful and defamatory. As I said, the closest I've seen is the 'kicking a migrant' post. It's also only tailoring evidence if it's aimed at someone. Neither of which apply here, as per my post that was clearly including a wide range of groups as examples and making the rather obvious point that if you get a large enough group of people, of which I'd suggest this site is one such group, there's going to be a few facists in there somewhere. Ironically through your responses you are in fact the one inadvertently narrowing it down. Care to reply to my response re. definitions? Or are you going to 'wriggle' your way out of that one via elaborate jazz handing. Edited by SW19 CPFC (29 Mar 2023 6.52pm)
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Much as I dislike that kind of direct action there is no way that those who resort to it can be legitimately described as fascist. Idiots, yes. Anti-democratic, yes. Counter-productive, yes. Fascist, no. What about the Rejoin EU Party? I understand they are keen to get into Poland.
|
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Similarly facism is rather obviously not exclusive to the right. It's pretty obvious when something or someone is definably racist, for example, as the action or statements will neatly match the definitions. Not sure what you are suggesting there. Are you saying for example that communists are fascists?
|
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Disagree. I'll repeat the statement again and highlight the key words for you. 'There are no doubt individuals or factions within most groups that are facist by definition, whether that's Antifa, EDL, BDP, The New Red Brigades, Hammas...As for Newquay, as a group they might not be, but who knows, there may be some individuals that could be tagged as such. Just like on this site.' It's absolutely what I meant, and I don't think it's particularly controversial to extend the wider point to this site. It would be controversial and defamatory (not to mention highly personal and unnecessary) to start naming names or pointing fingers without definative evidence. As before, it would be unhelpful and defamatory. As I said, the closest I've seen is the 'kicking a migrant' post. It's also only tailoring evidence if it's aimed at someone. Neither of which apply here, as per my post that was clearly including a wide range of groups as examples and making the rather obvious point that if you get a large enough group of people, of which I'd suggest this site is one such group, there's going to be a few facists in there somewhere. Ironically through your responses you are in fact the one inadvertently narrowing it down. Care to reply to my response re. definitions? Or are you going to 'wriggle' your way out of that one via elaborate jazz handing. Edited by SW19 CPFC (29 Mar 2023 6.52pm) I stand by my view and move on.
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance. |
|
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
I stand by my view and move on. Fair enough
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
Not sure what you are suggesting there. Are you saying for example that communists are fascists? Not are Can be. Main reasoning? Because communism is never really implemented properly, almost always abused and often ends up as facism in all but name. ‘Red fascism’ I believe is the term. Stalinism etc. Maybe it’s more ideologically accurate to say ‘fascist behaviours’ but radical nationalism, racism and violent support of those behaviours could be and are expressed by any group of people. Also not all lefties are communists, but plenty of extreme lefties exhibit fascist behaviour. Also, by definition, you can’t be a peaceful fascist.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Not are Can be. Main reasoning? Because communism is never really implemented properly, almost always abused and often ends up as facism in all but name. ‘Red fascism’ I believe is the term. Stalinism etc. Maybe it’s more ideologically accurate to say ‘fascist behaviours’ but radical nationalism, racism and violent support of those behaviours could be and are expressed by any group of people. Also not all lefties are communists, but plenty of extreme lefties exhibit fascist behaviour. Also, by definition, you can’t be a peaceful fascist. Of course communism has been implemented properly. It is nationalist, militarist, genocidal, totalitarian and is economically disastrous. The totalitarian method of government by the Communists was defined by Marx as the ‘Dictatorship of the proletariat’. According to Lenin, the dictatorship of the proletariat is a ‘persistent struggle—bloody and bloodless, violent and peaceful, military and economic, educational and administrative—against the forces and traditions of the old society’. If all right wing leaning people have some sort of Fascist aspects, it is just as true to say that all left wing people have some Communist characteristics.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
"Fascism is an ultranationalist, authoritarian political philosophy. It combines elements of nationalism, militarism, economic self-sufficiency, and totalitarianism. It does not permit disagreement and can use violence to suppress those who try to resist. It can hold a racist ideology." Tending towards something doesn't mean the journey is complete. Only that the journey has started and that warning bells must be sounded. I don't have detail on the individuals who comprised the two groups in Newquay, but some clearly thought some were demonstrating fascist tendencies whilst the other thought their opponents to be from the far-left. It's not such an unusual scenario! Edited by Wisbech Eagle (29 Mar 2023 3.54pm) The far left use this tactic constantly. The only 'fascism' that has any relevance is that employed by the self righteous Left. So now Trump is being charged in a laughably transparent attempt to undermine his electoral campaign. Jokers like you still claim to be on the side of the fair and good and claim to be 'conservative'. You make me sick.
|
|
|
I hear there was an indictment yesterday.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
The far left use this tactic constantly. The only 'fascism' that has any relevance is that employed by the self righteous Left. So now Trump is being charged in a laughably transparent attempt to undermine his electoral campaign. Jokers like you still claim to be on the side of the fair and good and claim to be 'conservative'. You make me sick. Even if that were true what has it got to with this? Any drift towards fascist behaviour is to be deplored. As many believe that Trump being charged will help energise his support base, rather than damage his re-election prospects, there is no reason to suppose that this has anything more than a DA keeping his word and following due process. The innocent have nothing to fear from the law, especially those who can afford to assemble the best lawyers to construct a defence. Indeed, knowing how Trump thinks and operates, portraying himself as a victim could easily be part of his play book to detract from his the much charges which seem likely to arrive later. Trump is no "conservative"! He is 100% a fraud, with no central core of beliefs. He deserves to be exposed.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.