This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I don't go with all that.....I know that's what gets sold to us but I've lived through these times. Putin has been in power in Russia since the nineties. It was cozy with him for a while. It was all perfectly fine until the neo cons started their usual interference. I have Farage right about it and he has been saying this stuff for over ten years. I went through all these arguments earlier in the thread. If Russia had been about taking back eastern Europe then it would have had an army built up to do it. That wasn't the case at all. Now however, because this war has only gone one way Russia are doing exactly that. We need people with common sense to step back and negotiate otherwise we are all going to eventually pay the piper....including Russia. Edited by Stirlingsays (09 Feb 2023 8.21pm) Negotiate about what exactly? How much of Ukraine Putin can have? Your view point assumes that Putin has no desire to encroach into any other neighbouring countries. How can we be sure? Who really knows? As we stand now, I can't see how we can just let him take Ukraine and do nothing. That would go against the lessons of history. Whatever provocation Putin claims for the invasion, a military assault on a free country in mainland Europe resulting in many deaths and devastation was a step too far.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Negotiate about what exactly? How much of Ukraine Putin can have? Your view point assumes that Putin has no desire to encroach into any other neighbouring countries. How can we be sure? Who really knows? As we stand now, I can't see how we can just let him take Ukraine and do nothing. That would go against the lessons of history. Whatever provocation Putin claims for the invasion, a military assault on a free country in mainland Europe resulting in many deaths and devastation was a step too far. How can I be sure? If Putin had been serious about taking these areas back then why wasn't his army in a state ready to do it back last February? Second point....why am I meant to care exactly? What has Ukraine got to do with me? I'm not a globalist Hrolf and Ukraine isn't a Nato country. I don't cheer for Biden's or social liberalism's gay disco expansionism, what beef am I meant to have with Putin exactly? I think US interference in the Ukraine with that coup back in 2014 led to the civil war and after the Minsk agreements were broken this invasion. Why is my standard of living meant to suffer and risk of dying in a nuclear attack meant to go through the roof because of these things? Like I say, I'm with Farage and Orban in this area.....none of our business. I don't think Ukraine wouldn't have given a fart if anything had happened to us.....This is a proxy war between the US state department and Putin.....I agree that Putin is looking out for Russia's interests and the US want him gone. I would have kept out of it.....I learnt my neo con lessons. Edited by Stirlingsays (09 Feb 2023 9.38pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
How can I be sure? If Putin had been serious about taking these areas back then why wasn't his army in a state ready to do it back last February? Second point....why am I meant to care exactly? What has Ukraine got to do with me? I'm not a globalist Hrolf and Ukraine isn't a Nato country. I don't cheer for Biden's or social liberalism's gay disco expansionism, what beef am I meant to have with Putin exactly? I think US interference in the Ukraine with that coup back in 2014 led to the civil war and after the Minsk agreements were broken this invasion. Why is my standard of living and risk of dying in a nuclear attack meant to go through the roof because of these things? Like I say, I'm with Farage and Orban in this area.....none of our business. I don't think Ukraine wouldn't have given a fart if anything had happened to us.....This is a proxy war between the US state department and Putin.....I agree that Putin is looking out for Russia's interests and the US want him gone. I would have kept out of it.....I learnt my neo con lessons. Edited by Stirlingsays (09 Feb 2023 9.37pm) Was Poland our business before World War2? This is not about loving Ukrainians or hating Putin. It's not even about loving the good old USA. Obviously, no one wants WW3, but sitting on our hands might just increase the risk, not reduce it.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Was Poland our business before World War2? This is not about loving Ukrainians or hating Putin. It's not even about loving the good old USA. Obviously, no one wants WW3, but sitting on our hands might just increase the risk, not reduce it. We might agree on lots of stuff but I can't say we agree here Hrolf. WW2 was a disaster for Britain and another war that never needed to expand into a world wide conflict. We should have just let Hitler fight it out with Stalin. Edited by Stirlingsays (09 Feb 2023 10.06pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by stancummins
ive watched this blog over the last year with interest without getting involved, but i agree with a lot that Stirling says. Putin was wrong to invade in the first place no doubt about that ,but the major miscalculation he made was the fact that the West would stick together in supporting Ukraine.He gambled that the West would turn a blind eye like they did in 2014 with Crimea.The problem now is that the West cannot financially keep paying for the military shopping list that Ukraine keep coming up with, at some stage they are going to have to go back to the negotiating table no matter how unpalatable that will be for all sides. The fear some people have that this will embolden Putin are misplaced based on what has happened in Ukraine ,he will feel once bitten . Ultimately it suits certain western governments to keep this conflict going as a diversionary tactic like yesterday where PMs question time was cancelled , How can we say no to NHS workers pay rises while sending billions of pounds worth of military equipment to Ukraine Yes, we should look after our own before wasting billions on Ukraine, but we are where we are. What we need to do is consider why Putin invaded parts of Ukraine post Crimea in 2014. Was it something to do with the rumoured bio labs in Ukraine/ Bidens son many trips there, the EU banging on the door encouraging Ukraine to apply for EU membership? Ukraine was a mutual buffer between Russia and the EU ; it isn’t anymore.
hats off to palace, they were always gonna be louder, and hate to say it but they were impressive ALL bouncing and singing. |
|
|
Originally posted by stancummins
ive watched this blog over the last year with interest without getting involved, but i agree with a lot that Stirling says. Putin was wrong to invade in the first place no doubt about that ,but the major miscalculation he made was the fact that the West would stick together in supporting Ukraine.He gambled that the West would turn a blind eye like they did in 2014 with Crimea.The problem now is that the West cannot financially keep paying for the military shopping list that Ukraine keep coming up with, at some stage they are going to have to go back to the negotiating table no matter how unpalatable that will be for all sides. The fear some people have that this will embolden Putin are misplaced based on what has happened in Ukraine ,he will feel once bitten . Ultimately it suits certain western governments to keep this conflict going as a diversionary tactic like yesterday where PMs question time was cancelled , How can we say no to NHS workers pay rises while sending billions of pounds worth of military equipment to Ukraine Pretty much. The story being sold to us by the mainstream completely ignores the different options we have. Once again, it's group think on steroids and escalation after escalation. Unless we are going to fight Russia properly....which is nuts....then some kind of negotiation is inevitable. People have been sold a pup all through this thing.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Behind Enemy Lines
Yes, we should look after our own before wasting billions on Ukraine, but we are where we are. What we need to do is consider why Putin invaded parts of Ukraine post Crimea in 2014. Was it something to do with the rumoured bio labs in Ukraine/ Bidens son many trips there, the EU banging on the door encouraging Ukraine to apply for EU membership? Ukraine was a mutual buffer between Russia and the EU ; it isn’t anymore. That seems to be the idea of the last thirty years. Continually spend billions and in the US's case trillions none of us have and just ignore the ever increasing repayments.....that's the next administration/generation's problem.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
We might agree on lots of stuff but I can't say we agree here Hrolf. WW2 was a disaster for Britain and another war that never needed to expand into a world wide conflict. We should have just let Hitler fight it out with Stalin. Edited by Stirlingsays (09 Feb 2023 10.06pm) Unfortunately, we might have been occupied before Russia entered the war. The battle Of Britain was in 1940. Russia entered the war in 1941. I assume you are suggesting that Hitler would have ignored us if we hadn't declared war on Germany. I have considered that myself, but without fighting on several fronts, Germany might well have occupied all of Europe, especially if Japan had not attacked America. All supposition. Right now it is a guessing game, but I suspect that both sides know that unless their very existence is threatened, they won't press the red button. What would be the point? Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (09 Feb 2023 10.18pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Unfortunately, we might have been occupied before Russia entered the war. The battle Of Britain was in 1940. Russia entered the war in 1941. I assume you are suggesting that Hitler would have ignored us if we hadn't declared war on Germany. I have considered that myself, but without fighting on several fronts, Germany might well have occupied all of Europe, especially if Japan had not attacked America. All supposition. Right now it is a guessing game, but I suspect that both sides know that unless their very existence is threatened, they won't press the red button. What would be the point? Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (09 Feb 2023 10.18pm) Hitler wanted his war with communism, the pack with Russia was just a means to an end. I'm no fan of Hitler but let's not forget that we declared war over Poland...which was a dictatorship at the time and quite frankly was over access to enable him to later fight Russia. Hitler wasn't interested in occupying Europe, he offered Churchill terms to leave Europe and just fight Russia. I never knew any of this before I looked into it.....It's kind of annoying that so much of WW2 history is myth. I say this while acknowledging that Hitler was a fanatic and a mass murderer....just like Stalin was. My view is that they should have been left to fight it out. Even if Hitler had taken over western Europe (which wasn't his plan according to his book) then you can be sure we would still be European and no one would be cutting their t1ts off. But yeah, just to be clear, Hitler was awful, but then again so was uncle Joe Stalin and we sided with a guy who was just as fond of killing millions. Edited by Stirlingsays (09 Feb 2023 10.35pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Unfortunately, we might have been occupied before Russia entered the war. The battle Of Britain was in 1940. Russia entered the war in 1941. I assume you are suggesting that Hitler would have ignored us if we hadn't declared war on Germany. I have considered that myself, but without fighting on several fronts, Germany might well have occupied all of Europe, especially if Japan had not attacked America. All supposition. Right now it is a guessing game, but I suspect that both sides know that unless their very existence is threatened, they won't press the red button. What would be the point? Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (09 Feb 2023 10.18pm) That supposes that the people in charge give a feck about the general pleb in the street.....Mmmmm. Old men who only have a few years left in the tank are very fond of letting young men die for them.....Both Putin and Biden fit that criteria for me. No one is willing to lose face and this playing chicken is all part of that. The stakes are far too high Hrolf....even an accident would be beyond terrible. My position is that this isn't a hill worth dying on. I've come to believe that you should only fight wars that you yourself are willing to die in. This isn't the one for me. In fact the only wars that I consider we had any business fighting in during my lifetime were the Falklands and the Afghanistan war.....to get at Bin Laden rather than the madness of staying there. Everything else was either something for the UN, a bit fat lie for the agenda of others or not sufficiently our business. Edited by Stirlingsays (09 Feb 2023 11.38pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Daddyorc
I understand what Sterling and others say, but very much disagree. Just ask yourself what happens if the West stops providing weapons... Putin starts to wear down the Ukrainian troops, they no longer have sophisticated weapons and start to get mass demoralized. Putin has victories in Donbas and other regions. Does he stop there? No. Putin takes Kiev and shortly all of Ukraine. Installs puppet government and all democracy and freedoms are crushed. Does he stop there? No. Putin next goes into Moldova, with already a part breakaway Russian enclave. The west fails to respond and same outcome. Does he stop there? No. Putin attacks Latvia, Lithuania and Estonia. Even though they're nato Sterling isn't willing to die on that hill.. Georgia would likely be next. Welcome to 5 democratic nations being crushed.
There are a few reasons why I think this analysis deserves questions. Firstly, I again make the point that Russia before last year had not mobilised an army to do what you suggest.....not even close to it. Secondly, Putin has often criticised the Soviet union for how it was run. Thirdly...and probably the strongest point, Putin needs the support of China, Turkey and India and the other BRICs countries. Now, he can justify the Ukraine war....not that most people get told those arguments in the west....but he's made those arguments and been accepted there. However, the prospect of a expansionist war against non border countries would be much more difficult. Four, what you are suggesting would involve massive cost, take time and constant warfare. Putin can sell the Ukraine war to his people but even if he wanted to do this I'm not sure how he would sell it. I have to be honest, I don't think you can justify a war on 'what if'. I tell you what, if we negotiated a settlement with Putin in Ukraine and he then went and invaded another European country without any real cause I would support doing this. Let's not forget that Russia was negotiating with Ukraine on a settlement back in March and we and the States refused to let them come to an agreement.....Does that sound like Russia wanting war with four other countries? Otherwise I regard the arguments for continuing this war as very weak and it's not without cause that the mainstream media aren't allowing opposing arguments to be made.....because they are frankly frightened of just how much their justifications are built upon fears rather than reason. Edited by Stirlingsays (10 Feb 2023 10.01am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Hitler wanted his war with communism, the pack with Russia was just a means to an end. I'm no fan of Hitler but let's not forget that we declared war over Poland...which was a dictatorship at the time and quite frankly was over access to enable him to later fight Russia. Hitler wasn't interested in occupying Europe, he offered Churchill terms to leave Europe and just fight Russia. I never knew any of this before I looked into it.....It's kind of annoying that so much of WW2 history is myth. I say this while acknowledging that Hitler was a fanatic and a mass murderer....just like Stalin was. My view is that they should have been left to fight it out. Even if Hitler had taken over western Europe (which wasn't his plan according to his book) then you can be sure we would still be European and no one would be cutting their t1ts off. But yeah, just to be clear, Hitler was awful, but then again so was uncle Joe Stalin and we sided with a guy who was just as fond of killing millions. Edited by Stirlingsays (09 Feb 2023 10.35pm) And there lies the crux of the matter. Hitler could not be trusted with promises, as he proved early on. I wouldn't trust Putin with any promises either. Any agreement he made to leave other countries alone could be taken with a pinch of salt. Western leaders know this, and this is why we are taking an aggressive stance. This only ends when he goes.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
Russia did not mobilise a more powerful army as Putin had been convinced that the Ukranians would view its move as relatively neutral to them, not particularly bad and not worth fighting over. After all, as all Russians keep saying, Ukrainians are simply Russians that have been brainwashed into thinking they aren't. Russia believed one relatively strong push would be enough for the Ukrainian government to accept the inevitable. It was totally shocked by the actual reaction as, to be frank, was I. Rather weird logic by Putin. If Ukraine wanted to be part of Russia, they could have agreed that around a table without a shot being fired.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Daddyorc
I understand what Sterling and others say, but very much disagree. Just ask yourself what happens if the West stops providing weapons... Putin starts to wear down the Ukrainian troops, they no longer have sophisticated weapons and start to get mass demoralized. Putin has victories in Donbas and other regions. Does he stop there? No. Putin takes Kiev and shortly all of Ukraine. Installs puppet government and all democracy and freedoms are crushed. Puppet Government = unpopular and not really answerable to the people of their respective country. Macron in France Biden in the US the late Angela Merkel's political career Rishi Sunak the West is awash with unpopular puppets. Often childless puppets. Puppets that nobody voted for
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
There are a few reasons why I think this analysis deserves questions. Firstly, I again make the point that Russia before last year had not mobilised an army to do what you suggest.....not even close to it. Secondly, Putin has often criticised the Soviet union for how it was run. Thirdly...and probably the strongest point, Putin needs the support of China, Turkey and India and the other BRICs countries. Now, he can justify the Ukraine war....not that most people get told those arguments in the west....but he's made those arguments and been accepted there. However, the prospect of a expansionist war against non border countries would be much more difficult. Four, what you are suggesting would involve massive cost, take time and constant warfare. Putin can sell the Ukraine war to his people but even if he wanted to do this I'm not sure how he would sell it. I have to be honest, I don't think you can justify a war on 'what if'. I tell you what, if we negotiated a settlement with Putin in Ukraine and he then went and invaded another European country without any real cause I would support doing this. Let's not forget that Russia was negotiating with Ukraine on a settlement back in March and we and the States refused to let them come to an agreement.....Does that sound like Russia wanting war with four other countries? Otherwise I regard the arguments for continuing this war as very weak and it's not without cause that the mainstream media aren't allowing opposing arguments to be made.....because they are frankly frightened of just how much their justifications are built upon fears rather than reason. Edited by Stirlingsays (10 Feb 2023 10.01am) It's about gas*. Specically Nord Stream II. The US has fracked itself out of fuel dependence. It now wants to sell the excess to others, ie Europe. Russia's income is dependant on fuel sales (45% of national income). Nord Stream II was sabotaged. Putin did it... really? Cut his nose off to spite his face? Biden is on video stating he would stop the gas flow before the invasion. How is this not debated? * re Gulf war/oil
Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
And there lies the crux of the matter. Hitler could not be trusted with promises, as he proved early on. I wouldn't trust Putin with any promises either. Any agreement he made to leave other countries alone could be taken with a pinch of salt. Western leaders know this, and this is why we are taking an aggressive stance. This only ends when he goes. Which leader could? We will have to agree to disagree on basing our military involvement, economic downgrading and possible deaths upon 'what ifs'. Like my point earlier Hrolf, what you are essentially saying here is our state's position. But our state told us lies on Iraq, Libya and Syria just to name three recent wars....they fecked it up in all those countries. The media was full of commentary on all of those wars none of which ended up as the result or reality. None of these feckers are honest, Putin or Biden or Sunak or any of them. They all lie and paint themselves as the saints and their opposition as sinners. No, they are all pawns playing their own power games and selective morality is their calling card. Why would you ever echo their position and opinions now? Especially when this particular war affects us both economically and in risk of death. I think our leaders have taken us down several bad directions all of which are worsening our lives. But as they control the megaphone and there is no one effectively challenging them. The public just resorts to the 'go along to get along' that is effectively universal majority human behaviour. To quote: 'The whole system revolves around the idea that the majority can be made to believe anything so long as it is repeated loudly and often and it works.' (Edward Snowdon)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
Russia did not mobilise a more powerful army as Putin had been convinced that the Ukranians would view its move as relatively neutral to them, not particularly bad and not worth fighting over. After all, as all Russians keep saying, Ukrainians are simply Russians that have been brainwashed into thinking they aren't. Russia believed one relatively strong push would be enough for the Ukrainian government to accept the inevitable. It was totally shocked by the actual reaction as, to be frank, was I. Yep I agree. The point however was in answer to the suggestion that Putin wants to invade five European countries and that unless we fight him he's going to do just that. My counter point is that there is no evidence for that and in fact the state of the Russia army before this conflict strongly suggests that this ambition wasn't the case. However, instead of ending this war when we could have all we have seen is continual escalation so what happens from here is 'up in the air' as far as I can tell. Edited by Stirlingsays (11 Feb 2023 12.21am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.