You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Max Meyer thread
November 16 2026 5.54am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Max Meyer thread


Page 24 of 27 < 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 >
Helmet46 Flag Croydon 26 Dec 19 6.32pm

Originally posted by mattteo

What did you think of him today??

Problem is that he is really just 1 thing:attacking midfielder. He definitely isn't a right winger and can't really be an amazing central.midfielder.

He used to be a really good attacking midfielder in his youth in the Bundesliga, but then they pulled him down to central midfielder position and he lost his touch for goals or creating them.

He's been tried on several position since he arrived at Palace, but team doesn't really play with an attacking midfielder behind the main striker, so he's mostly forced on the wings. Shows touches of grandeur, but considering that he has the highest or second highest salary in the squad+ he could bring he club some money too if sold (I'd say he still has decent value in Germany and could bring in 10 million), would it be bad if he got sold in the winter?

I mean, with adequate replacement. A very similar attack minded player like Ryan Christie for example seems younger and in a much better mental and physical condition and would not cost more than 15 million, coming on a smaller salary than Meyer. What do you think? Would you still have patience with Max?

I don’t think it’s about us having patience with him, I think it’s about him having patience with us. He’s a decent player and, personally, I’d mould the team around him if, as expected, we lose Zaha.
You suggest we could get 10m for him and buy another for 15m. Appreciate he’s on a decent salary but if the difference in salaries is, say, £50k a week it would still take 2 years before it reached parity and we saw the benefit of selling him for £10m and bringing in someone untested at £15m.

Edited by Helmet46 (26 Dec 2019 6.36pm)

 

Painter Flag Croydon 26 Dec 19 6.33pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

Best attacking performance for many months. Not a coincidence that Max started. He's a genuine game changer for us. He gives us that bit of quality in midfield to help unlock defences.

His problem is that he cant sustain his performance for 90 mins, just fades away. That is Roys issue, so only uses as sub in second half or plays him when his options are reduced by injuries.

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 26 Dec 19 7.04pm

a lot of times he has seemed to run into dead ends, get a bit isolated and then run in a right handed circle into another dead end - he's doing this less now, and turning defence into attack with a pleasing regularity, Roy turned it round last season playing Luka deep and Schlupp and McArthur as sort of left and right inside forwards, Myer might suit our system best if he played in that slightly advanced narrow right side of midfield role that JimmyMac played last season.

 

merganser Flag 26 Dec 19 7.05pm

Quick feet and intelligent . We’ve not seen the best of him yet. He doesn’t have much bite when it comes to putting in a tackle.

 

mattteo Flag 26 Dec 19 7.47pm

Originally posted by Helmet46

I don’t think it’s about us having patience with him, I think it’s about him having patience with us. He’s a decent player and, personally, I’d mould the team around him if, as expected, we lose Zaha.
You suggest we could get 10m for him and buy another for 15m. Appreciate he’s on a decent salary but if the difference in salaries is, say, £50k a week it would still take 2 years before it reached parity and we saw the benefit of selling him for £10m and bringing in someone untested at £15m.

Edited by Helmet46 (26 Dec 2019 6.36pm)

Why would he have patience with us??

I can pretty much 100% say that a player like Ryan Christie who scores or assists in every match for Celtic (though a lower level, he's still young and will surely make it in the PL) would do more than Max. It's easy to do more than a player who has contributed no goals or assists and has hardly played 250 minutes this season. For 5 million? Yes, I'd make that exchange.

Team needs goals more than anything. Waiting for Meyer indefinitely or building the team around Meyer, Benteke, Wickham, Schlupp and even Townsend with his current form shows us that our attacking options are pretty horrible. In my humble opinion, we should be more demanding from out players. Saying that we could mold the team around him Meyer after a year and a half here in which he hasn't proven anything is fantasy. There's been plenty of time. Let's not simply accept mediocrity from players.

You have a chance- take it or move on.

Edited by mattteo (26 Dec 2019 7.50pm)

 

Robk Flag 26 Dec 19 7.54pm

A very talented player.. good passer of the ball nearly provided Ayew a goal in the first half... links up well with Wilf .. they are on the same wavelength..ok not a great tackler but there are others around to provide that.. I think we are better with him in the side!

 

Aray Flag South London 26 Dec 19 7.59pm

He looked unfit today. He needs game time if you ask me or sell and get yet another functional/box2box midfielder. Sigh

 

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 26 Dec 19 8.35pm

Originally posted by mattteo

Why would he have patience with us??

I can pretty much 100% say that a player like Ryan Christie who scores or assists in every match for Celtic (though a lower level, he's still young and will surely make it in the PL) would do more than Max. It's easy to do more than a player who has contributed no goals or assists and has hardly played 250 minutes this season. For 5 million? Yes, I'd make that exchange.

Team needs goals more than anything. Waiting for Meyer indefinitely or building the team around Meyer, Benteke, Wickham, Schlupp and even Townsend with his current form shows us that our attacking options are pretty horrible. In my humble opinion, we should be more demanding from out players. Saying that we could mold the team around him Meyer after a year and a half here in which he hasn't proven anything is fantasy. There's been plenty of time. Let's not simply accept mediocrity from players.

You have a chance- take it or move on.

Edited by mattteo (26 Dec 2019 7.50pm)

Meyer is an awful lot better than you give him credit for and I see no one suggesting building a team around Benteke. Meyer is a victim of our style of play. I’d rather he has a decent run playing to his strengths (which we have not done) than to draft a player in from Celtic. Christie is, incidentally, the same age (a few months older, than Max). It’s not Football Manager.


Edited by Helmet46 (26 Dec 2019 8.40pm)

 

mattteo Flag 26 Dec 19 8.53pm

Originally posted by Helmet46

Meyer is an awful lot better than you give him credit for and I see no one suggesting building a team around Benteke.

Edited by Helmet46 (26 Dec 2019 8.40pm)

He offers as much as Benteke in terms of goals, that's what I was saying.

Originally posted by Helmet46


Christie is, incidentally, the same age (a few months older, than Max).

Edited by Helmet46 (26 Dec 2019 8.40pm)

Point is that Christie has 17 goals and 13 assists in 32 matches this season and Celtic asks for a pretty moderate sum for him (actually small if you ask me, having seen him play) and Meyer has not had more than 2 goals and 3 assists in the last 3 years!!! At the same age

Originally posted by Helmet46


It’s not Football Manager.
Edited by Helmet46 (26 Dec 2019 8.40pm)

Is this supposed to be an insult coming from someone who actually is involved in players transfers in real life? No?? Then why do you talks about these things?!
Oh, sorry, I'm the only one who is a FM fan ))

Edited by mattteo (26 Dec 2019 8.54pm)

 

CPFCwetrust Flag Maidstone 26 Dec 19 9.03pm

I thought Meyer played well today... better passer of the ball, ran his arse off, looks to move the ball forward at more pace than some of the usual slow movement, he needs to tidy his finishing but I think he has the attributes (if given more game time) to be bloody good.

He works well if he's placed next to zaha in midfield. I see no point selling him as he is still young.

Edited by CPFCwetrust (26 Dec 2019 9.04pm)

 

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 26 Dec 19 9.07pm

Originally posted by mattteo

Is this supposed to be an insult coming from someone who actually is involved in players transfers in real life? No?? Then why do you talks about these things?!
Oh, sorry, I'm the only one who is a FM fan ))

Edited by mattteo (26 Dec 2019 8.54pm)

No, not an insult, an observation.
Interestingly enough, though, I am involved in football - not to that level but at semi-pro level, so I do like to think I have a little bit of an understanding. The trouble is, with the dough sloshing about at the top level of the game, its easy for fans to spend other people’s money - it’s harder to maximise what you have - to develop, grow and change.

Are you involved in football transfers in “real life” then? If so, I apologise as this is all about opinions. I would never, for example, claim to be 100% sure on anything in the game.


Edited by Helmet46 (26 Dec 2019 9.10pm)

 

mattteo Flag 26 Dec 19 9.16pm

Originally posted by Helmet46

No, not an insult, an observation.
Interestingly enough, though, I am involved in football - not to that level but at semi-pro level, so I do like to think I have a little bit of an understanding. The trouble is, with the dough sloshing about at the top level of the game, its easy for fans to spend other people’s money - it’s harder to maximise what you have - to develop, grow and change.

Are you involved in football transfers in “real life” then? If so, I apologise as this is all about opinions. I would never, for example, claim to be 100% sure on anything in the game.


Edited by Helmet46 (26 Dec 2019 9.10pm)


I am not, but as fans we discuss the topics about football teams way above our curent level. Everything is hypothetical. But I can surely say with 100% certainty that someone else would do better than a fellow who has contributed to 0. It just can't be any other way.

 

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 26 Dec 19 9.28pm

Originally posted by mattteo


I am not, but as fans we discuss the topics about football teams way above our curent level. Everything is hypothetical. But I can surely say with 100% certainty that someone else would do better than a fellow who has contributed to 0. It just can't be any other way.

I expect that’s exactly how Chelsea fans felt about Mo Salah.
Personally if I was Parish I would hang on to Meyer.
There are a number of players in front of him in the queue to go but, as I say, our current style of play doesn’t suit him. Now, it may be that you’re right but at this stage I wouldn’t take that chance - especially with a 72 year old manager in charge.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 26 Dec 19 9.40pm

He was ok today but not the game changer some have suggested. Roy taking him off for Wickham tipped the game in our favour IMO.

 

mattteo Flag 26 Dec 19 9.42pm

Originally posted by Helmet46


There are a number of players in front of him in the queue to go but, as I say, our current style of play doesn’t suit him. Now, it may be that you’re right but at this stage I wouldn’t take that chance - especially with a 72 year old manager in charge.

Normally, I wouldn't mind him in the squad as a backup, but reports have been saying that his salary is gigantic, so it's actually a question if something better can be done with the money.

Also, he's one of the few players who the club could sell to increase funds in the transfer window (others would be Zaha- who is very important and a starter-, PVA, Townsend and that's pretty much it). I've heard there are only 17 million available for the winter period. Just as an exercise of imagination, if the club sold Townsend for 15 (Newcastle always interested, he played well there), Meyer for 10 and Benteke for 10, that would give the club an extra 35 million to spend on 5-6 attacking players of 5-10 million each for the second half of the season, who together with Zaha and Jordan Ayew could provide the necessary goals.

If you know where to look, you can find players better than Benteke and even Meyer or Townsend.

 

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 26 Dec 19 9.49pm

Originally posted by mattteo

Normally, I wouldn't mind him in the squad as a backup, but reports have been saying that his salary is gigantic, so it's actually a question if something better can be done with the money.

Also, he's one of the few players who the club could sell to increase funds in the transfer window (others would be Zaha- who is very important and a starter-, PVA, Townsend and that's pretty much it). I've heard there are only 17 million available for the winter period. Just as an exercise of imagination, if the club sold Townsend for 15 (Newcastle always interested, he played well there), Meyer for 10 and Benteke for 10, that would give the club an extra 35 million to spend on 5-6 attacking players of 5-10 million each for the second half of the season, who together with Zaha and Jordan Ayew could provide the necessary goals.

If you know where to look, you can find players better than Benteke and even Meyer or Townsend.

Reidewald was one of those players. At the time (not now) it was said he was one of the best prospects from the Ajax academy and extremely highly rated. There is a risk with this strategy and we’ve gone full circle here. My initial point was if we sold Zaha and I stand by that as I suspect we would need to change our style of play. That is why I would not get rid of Meyer.

 

bifffabazz Flag Highworth, Wiltshire 27 Dec 19 8.03am

Would take Joniesta or Barry Bannan over Max in a heartbeat.

 


Spirit of 1974

Uphill Flag Bedford 27 Dec 19 8.47am

Originally posted by bifffabazz

Would take Joniesta or Barry Bannan over Max in a heartbeat.

Illustrates successive managers' disregard of ball holding midfielders. Also Michael Hughes and Ben Watson.
Williams and Meyer dismissed as 'too lightweight' or 'can't last 90 minutes' etc.

Kouayte and Milosevic are destroyers and contribute little attacking prowess.

Meyer is an artist and should be nurtured.

 


Man and boy Palace since my first game in 1948 sitting on my dad's shoulders

EddieMac Flag 27 Dec 19 9.11am

The Max Meyer fan club must have had their blinkers on again yesterday. The chap done little to nothing again yesterday. He had numerous chances to play a pass to put us through on goal but gave the ball away. (And don’t tell me his one pass to Ayew means he is worthy of a starting place. He is not fast enough or strong enough, can’t tackle and is certainly not good enough for this division. He will be no loss to us when he leaves.

Get your eyes open folks, he has been with us long enough now and contributed didddly.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 27 Dec 19 9.11am

He played, we won. So much so that we dominated and fully deserved to win. He adds much needed creativity to a hardworking, if somewhat uncreative midfield. It's all about getting the balance right.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (27 Dec 2019 9.16am)

 

Page 24 of 27 < 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Max Meyer thread